In Jewish tradition and the Talmud, Jesus is not portrayed as the Messiah or a divine figure. Instead, references to him, often under the name Yeshu, are generally negative and polemical, reflecting the historical and theological divergence between Judaism and Christianity. These portrayals, which vary in different texts and historical periods, often accuse him of sorcery and leading Jews astray.
1. Rejection of Jesus as Messiah or Son of God ✝️
Judaism fundamentally rejects the Christian concept of Jesus as the Messiah, the Son of God, or a member of a divine Trinity. This rejection is rooted in several core tenets of Jewish theology:
Monotheism: The central pillar of Judaism is the absolute unity and singularity of God, as expressed in the Shema prayer: "Hear, O Israel, the LORD is our God, the LORD is one" (Deuteronomy 6:4). The idea of a divine Son of God or a Trinity is considered a violation of this fundamental principle and a form of idolatry.
Messianic Prophecies: Jewish tradition holds that the Messiah must fulfill specific prophecies. Jesus did not meet these criteria. The Messiah, according to Jewish texts, will:
Bring an end to all wars and usher in an era of universal peace, knowledge, and prosperity.
Gather all Jews from their exile back to the land of Israel.
Rebuild the Holy Temple in Jerusalem.
Be a descendant of King David on his father's side.
Since none of these events occurred during or after Jesus's lifetime, Judaism concludes that he was not the promised Messiah. The messianic age has not yet begun.
2. Portrayal in the Talmud 📜
The Talmud, a central text of rabbinic Judaism, contains a few passages that some scholars identify as references to Jesus. These are highly contested and debated, but they generally present a critical and derogatory view.
Yeshu the Sorcerer: One of the most famous passages, found in the tractates Sanhedrin and Sotah, claims that a man named Yeshu was executed on the eve of Passover for practicing sorcery and leading Israel astray. The passage states a herald went out for 40 days to find anyone who would speak in his defense, but none was found. This account likely serves as a polemical counter-narrative to the Christian Gospels, asserting that Jesus's miracles were not divine but a form of magic, and his death was a justifiable punishment under Jewish law.
Yeshu, the Disciple of Rabbi Joshua ben Perahiah: Another Talmudic story describes a disciple named Yeshu who was excommunicated by his teacher, Rabbi Joshua ben Perahiah. This story places Jesus's life a century earlier than historical accounts, which suggests it is a later fabrication intended to discredit Jesus and his followers. In the story, Yeshu misinterprets his rabbi's comments, falls into idolatry, and is ultimately rejected when he seeks forgiveness. This narrative portrays Jesus as a wayward student who failed to adhere to rabbinic teaching and was justly cast out.
The Ben Stada and Pandira Narrative: Some Talmudic passages refer to a figure named Ben Stada or Ben Pandira. The name "Pandira" is thought to be a corruption of the Greek name Panthera, which was a common Roman name. The narratives suggest that Jesus's mother, Mary, had an illicit affair with a Roman soldier named Panthera. This story, while not universally accepted by all Jewish scholars as referring to Jesus, was historically used to mock the Christian doctrine of the Virgin Birth.
3. Historical and Theological Context 🌍
The negative portrayal of Jesus in the Talmud is best understood within its historical context. The Talmud was compiled centuries after Jesus's life, during a period when the nascent Christian Church was growing and persecuting Jewish communities. The rabbis, facing increasing pressure and hostility, used these polemical narratives to:
Counter-Missionary Efforts: Provide arguments for why Jews should not convert to Christianity. The unflattering portrayals served to discredit Christian claims about Jesus's divinity and messianic status.
Define Jewish Identity: Delineate the boundaries between Judaism and the emerging Christian sect. By portraying Jesus as a heretic and a sorcerer, the rabbis solidified their rejection of Christianity and affirmed Jewish monotheism and law.
Address Internal Debates: Some scholars argue that these stories may have initially been internal Jewish debates about figures who were perceived as charismatic but heretical teachers, and were later applied to Jesus as a way of articulating rabbinic opposition to Christianity.
4. Modern Jewish Views of Jesus 🤔
Modern Judaism generally holds a different, though still non-messianic, view of Jesus. Most modern Jews do not see him as a figure of central importance to their faith.
A historical figure: Many Jewish scholars acknowledge Jesus as a historical figure, a Jewish preacher from the first century C.E. who was executed by the Roman authorities.
A failed Messiah: Some Jewish thinkers, like the medieval philosopher Maimonides, referred to Jesus as a "failed Messiah," arguing that while his intentions may have been messianic, his failure to bring about the predicted messianic age disqualified him. This view is often more nuanced and less hostile than the Talmudic portrayals.
A great ethical teacher: A small but growing number of Jewish thinkers see Jesus as an ethical teacher who upheld many Jewish values. This perspective, however, is not a mainstream view and does not include accepting his divinity or messianic claims.
In conclusion, the portrayal of Jesus in the Talmud and Judaism is complex and has evolved over time. While the Talmud contains a harsh, polemical depiction of Yeshu as a heretic and sorcerer, modern Jewish thought tends to view Jesus with less animosity, though always firmly as a historical figure who did not fulfill the criteria for being the Jewish Messiah.
====
==
==
No comments:
Post a Comment