Israel - Palestine, 60 years of violence (English Documentary)
이스라엘-팔레스타인, 60년간의 폭력
Investigations et Enquêtes
3.1M subscribers
---
3,053,444 views Oct 23, 2023 PALESTINE
In 1948, the creation of the State of Israel was proclaimed. Three years after Nazism, the Jews can settle on the land of their ancestors. But for the Arab populations installed there, it is the disaster.
0:00. in 1948, David Ben-Gourion proclaimed the creation of the State of Israel, marking the end of Nazism and the beginning of the Palestinians' disaster.
7:41. 1967 Six days war: the Arab rout
10:05 am In 1967, Israel won a flash victory against the Arab countries and extended its territory, thus changing its victim status to that of military power.
19:37. Palestinians resist the Israeli army during the Battle of Karameh in 1968, while bomb attacks and diversion of planes were perpetrated by Palestinian activists in the following years.
28:42. In September 1970, three planes were diverted by pirates from the Leed group and landed at an disused airport in the hands of the Palestinians in Zarka in Jordan, where 400 passengers are retained hostage, but are finally released after six days of negotiations .
38:58. The war of the Kippur and the visit of the Egyptian president Anouar El-Sadate in Israel mark a turning point in the Israeli-Arab conflict, but the Palestinians remain in a situation of refugees.
49:24. The documentary talks about the Palestinian intifada and the reaction of Israel.
1:05. The assassination of Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin is a blow for the already fragile peace process between Israel and Palestine.
1:09. The peace process between Israel and Palestine is disputed, the influence of radical Islam increases and Hamas is gaining importance.
1:20.The documentary presents the lives of several people in Israel and Palestine, who have experienced significant events and have different aspirations.
====
1948년에는 이스라엘 국가의 탄생이 선포되었습니다. 나치즘 이후 3년이 지나면 유대인들은 조상의 땅에 정착할 수 있습니다. 그러나 그곳에 정착한 아랍인들에게는 재앙이다.
0:00. 1948년 다비드 벤구리온(David Ben-Gourion)은 나치즘의 종말과 팔레스타인의 재앙의 시작을 알리는 이스라엘 국가의 창설을 선포했습니다.
7:41. 1967년 6일 전쟁: 아랍의 패배
10:5. 1967년 이스라엘은 아랍 국가들에게 대승을 거두고 영토를 확장하면서 군사력의 피해자 신분으로 바뀌었다.
19:37. 팔레스타인인들은 1968년 카라메 전투에서 이스라엘군에 저항했고, 이후 몇 년 동안 팔레스타인 활동가들은 폭탄 공격과 비행기 우회를 자행했습니다.
28:42. 1970년 9월, 3대의 비행기가 리드 그룹의 해적들에 의해 우회되어 요르단 자르카의 팔레스타인 손에 있는 사용하지 않는 공항에 착륙했고, 그곳에서 400명의 승객이 인질로 잡혀 있었지만 6일간의 협상 끝에 마침내 풀려났다.
38:58. 키푸르 전쟁과 아누아르 엘사다테 이집트 대통령의 이스라엘 방문은 이스라엘-아랍 갈등의 전환점이 되었지만 팔레스타인인들은 여전히 난민 상황에 처해 있다.
49:24. 다큐멘터리는 팔레스타인 인티파다와 이스라엘의 반응에 대해 이야기합니다.
1:05. 이스라엘 총리 이츠하크 라빈의 암살은 이미 취약한 이스라엘과 팔레스타인 간의 평화 프로세스에 타격을 입혔습니다.
1:09. 이스라엘과 팔레스타인 간의 평화 과정이 논쟁을 벌이고 있으며 급진 이슬람의 영향력이 증가하고 하마스의 중요성이 커지고 있습니다.
1:20.다큐멘터리는 중요한 사건을 경험하고 서로 다른 열망을 갖고 있는 이스라엘과 팔레스타인의 여러 사람들의 삶을 보여줍니다.
====
Transcript
0:03
May 14, 1948, in Tel Aviv David Ben-Gurion proclaims the creation of the State of Israel.
0:11
In accordance with the resolution United Nations, we proclaim the foundation of the Jewish State in the land of Israel.
0:21
The Jewish people finally have a country. Three years after the fall of Nazism and the massacre of 6 million of them,
0:29
Jews can settle on the land of their ancestors.
0:38
For Arabs who live on this same land of Palestine, that day is that of the Nakba, the catastrophe.
0:47
Fleeing the fights or chased out by the Zionist army, more than 700,000 Arabs leave the country.
0:53
They think that they only leave for a while. However, these refugees will soon to become a people in exile
1:02
who searches by all means to return to the country which he calls Palestine and others call Israel.
1:17
War.
1:24
Clandestine army.
1:32
Terrorism.
1:40
Popular revolt. And repression.
1:52
Suicide attack.
1:58
And retaliation, and sometimes all the same a hope for peace.
2:09
The fight for this land claimed by two peoples has continued unabated for 60 years.
2:17
A Palestinian teacher became a hijacker. A student from Cairo promoted to guerrilla commander.
2:27
A child from Gaza who grew up in a refugee camp.
2:33
But also the son of a pioneer of Israel, army reservist.
2:38
And a young director from Tel Aviv, plunged despite himself into the heart of the Intifada.
2:47
Using photos and home movies, this is how five destinies radically different
2:54
went through a tragedy of which we do not see the end.
3:17
1949 These are the borders of Israel. More than 700,000 Palestinians took refuge in neighboring countries.
3:25
In Liban, in Syria and in two parts of the old Palestine which remained Arab.
3:33
The West Bank annexed by Jordan and the Gaza Strip under Egyptian control.
3:47
Refugees are massed at the borders. They left in a hurry
3:52
and they wait to go home.
4:06
1967. Eighteen years later, the refugees are still there.
4:12
Concrete constructions have little by little replaced the makeshift tents, but the hope of a return in Palestine is still going strong.
4:27
Leila Khaled is a young 23-year-old teacher. She's a rebel, great admirer of Che Guevara.
4:34
In her diary she writes. The Zionists drove us from our homeland.
4:40
They live in my town because they are Jews and that they possess strength. But one day we the survivors of the desert,
4:48
we will have this power and we will take back Palestine.
4:56
Leila Khaled lived on the Mediterranean coast in Haifa, in the beautiful areas of the city.
5:04
At the creation of Israel, his family fled the fighting and took refuge in Lebanon.
5:14
Here she is with her brothers and sisters in front of the house. It's the smallest. She is four years old.
5:19
It was just before he left. Since then, she has been preparing for her return.
5:31
- I was doing embroidery on a canvas I did it all the time
5:37
to hang it in our house in Haifa.
5:43
It was an illusion, but I was convinced that we were going to liberate Palestine.
5:55
- In the 60s, Palestine by Leila Khaled has already changed. Israel is a country in full swing development, where we live in the West.
6:04
A new generation is born, who has neither known nor Nazism nor the exodus.
6:13
On the beaches of Tel Aviv or Eilat, we are far from concerns of the young Palestinian woman.
6:33
However, in this spring of 1967, Leïla Khaled has reason to believe it.
6:38
In Arab capitals, the crowd is white hot. Here in Egypt, the demonstrators shout death to the Jews.
6:50
President Gamal Abdel Nasser calls for the destruction of Israel.
6:55
He is supported by his Soviet ally and by the Arab world who doesn't want this new neighbor.
7:01
The war of reconquest seems imminent.
7:07
To the south, Egypt brings his border troops. In the west, the Jordanian army is on alert.
7:16
To the north is Syria who is preparing for war.
7:22
On Arab radios, Jews are warned in Hebrew. Disaster will befall you.
7:32
Israel will take everyone speed.
7:49
On June 5, 1967, at 7:45 a.m., Israeli Air Force takes off towards Cairo.
7:58
The pilots were not informed of their mission until the last moment. In a few minutes, the planes are in Egypt
8:10
The Israelis attacked first. The Egyptian air force is destroyed.
8:39
On the ground, Israeli tanks press the enemy troops on all borders Among the chariots, there is that of Commander Uri Hurvitz
8:47
of the 45th Brigade.
8:56
Uri is the son of a pioneer of Israel. His father fled Russia at the beginning of the century
9:02
to escape anti-Semitic massacres. With a group of Zionists,
9:07
he founded one of all first kibbutz in the country Kfar Giladi, near the Lebanese border.
9:15
Tents, a first farm, a second,
9:21
then a whole village on a lost hill.
9:27
Uri was born here. He grew up at the same time as the kibbutz. This piece of land is his whole life.
9:35
He is proud of what his parents built it. For him, this war is a question of survival.
9:46
- We were defending our house. We have no other place where to go in the world, no other.
9:52
What would be passed if they had won They would have all of us exterminated, and we knew that.
10:01
- Israeli troops don't just defend. They conquer new territories.
10:09
To the south, they invade Sinai and this little strip of land called Gaza
10:15
where are installed several Palestinian refugee camps. Among them is the Rafah camp.
10:26
Refugees are far from the mode of modern and western life in Tel Aviv. They live in another era.
10:34
There is no water in the houses. Nor electricity.
10:44
A few blocks from the main road lives little Abdel Salam Shehadeh, 5 and a half years, with his brothers and sisters.
10:54
His father experienced the exodus of 1948. He lived a little further north,
11:00
in a village that now belongs to the Israelis. That morning Abdel Salam is sleeping
11:08
when the first Israeli tanks enter the Rafah camp.
11:19
- I was woken up suddenly. There were people everywhere.
11:24
We heard the Jews entered the city.
11:31
It's the panic. Nobody really knows what's going on. On the main street,
11:36
I see lots of corpses.
11:43
For us, after 67, everything was going to change.
11:49
- In Jerusalem too, everything will change. The Israelis are invading the Arab part of the holy city.
11:57
A dream that they could not achieve in 1948 during the War of Independence.
12:05
After 2,000 years of exile, the Jews are again masters of the Temple Mount, the first holiest site in Judaism.
12:13
The Minister of Defense, Moshe Dayan, the man with the headband and the victorious general Yitzhak Rabin are at the foot of the Western Wall.
12:26
The news spreads like wildfire.
12:34
- I was in radio contact with my boss and a guy that I knew was in Jerusalem.
12:43
He called all units and he told us: “We conquered Jerusalem.”
12:52
I was there, sitting in my tank.
12:59
It did something to me when I heard that the Western Wall had been taken.
13:05
Even today, I feel unexplainable things.
13:10
- Yitzhak Rabin, the general victorious becomes a national hero.
13:15
In a few years, it will even be the head of the Israeli government. His triumph is absolute.
13:29
- The Israeli soldier is an excellent soldier.
13:38
He has the will to win. He knows why he's fighting.
13:44
He has the courage to fight and training to fight.
13:56
- In just six days, the Egyptian armies Jordanian and Syrian forces are defeated.
14:02
These images of Arab rout go around the world. Not only was Israel not destroyed,
14:08
but the Jewish state multiplies its surface area by four.
14:14
Soldiers of the Hebrew State planted their flag in Sinai, in Gaza, in the West Bank,
14:22
in East Jerusalem and the Golan.
14:32
In 1967, the world's outlook changed. Israel is no longer the small Hebrew state besieged, heir of the Holocaust.
14:44
Thus, in Paris, General de Gaulle launches this polemical definition of the Jewish people.
14:50
- A people of elites self-confident and dominant.
14:59
- The tone is set. Israel is no longer a victim. It has become a military power.
15:13
In neighboring countries, the Arab defeat is a surprise. Salah al Tamari is Palestinian, born in Bethlehem.
15:21
When the war begins, he studied in Cairo. He does not participate protests against Israel
15:27
because he is revising for his exams, but he listens to Egyptian radio which announces great Arab victories,
15:36
until the day he discovers the truth.
15:43
- I remember, I was coming back from university. When I arrived at my building,
15:51
there was a neighbor who listened to English radio he was the minister of Israeli Defense Moshe Dayan
15:59
who made a press conference in Jerusalem. That caught my attention.
16:06
I stopped to listen and he said We got there and we have no intention of leaving.
16:13
I realized that everything what we heard on Arabic radio was false.
16:20
The Israelis occupied the West Bank, the Israelis occupied Sinai
16:25
and Arab countries had lost the war.
16:32
I could no longer stand on my legs. I collapsed on the stairs. I was demoralized.
16:40
Completely destroyed.
16:46
- From then on Salah al Tamari has certainty. To fight Israel,
16:51
the Palestinians will not be able to rely only on themselves,
16:57
but they lack an army and a leader.
17:22
A training camp in Jordan. For several years now, a clandestine organization trains fighters, Fatah.
17:32
Its leader is called Yasser Arafat. He's an engineer. He was born in Egypt, but his father is from Gaza and his mother from Jerusalem.
17:43
Arafat never had confidence in Arab countries. He wants to create an independent Palestinian army.
17:53
He's still just a stranger who lives hidden in a cave with a few fighters.
18:01
Everything will change after the battle of Karameh.
18:11
Karameh is a camp refugees in Jordan, a few kilometers from the border.
18:18
Yasser Arafat maintains its headquarters there. From here, the fighters launch their guerrilla operations towards Israel.
18:28
Among them, there is Salah al Tamari, the former student from Cairo.
18:38
- At the time, there wasn't really chain of command.
18:44
We were a small group. There was in particular Arafat.
18:49
Every day we waited our turn to cross the border and participate to an operation in occupied territory,
18:56
which I have done several times. - March 18, 68,
19:03
an Israeli school bus explodes on a mine planted by Fatah. There are about thirty injured children and deaths.
19:11
For Israel, it's unbearable.
19:20
The retaliations are massive. An army of 6,500 soldiers must destroy Karameh and these 300 fedayins.
19:38
Against all odds, the Palestinians hold their position. Al Tamari is in charge of the resistance.
19:47
- What is important in Karameh it's that we, young guys, we decided to fight.
19:57
The objective was obviously not to destroy the Israeli army,
20:03
but to prove that we were real fighters, ready to die for their country.
20:11
We knew that each death would be replaced by hundreds
20:17
and perhaps thousands of volunteers. This is indeed what happened.
20:29
- After 15 hours of confrontation, Israeli armored vehicles enter Karameh.
20:36
The Palestinians are decimated. Half were killed. The others are prisoners or on the run.
20:45
For the first time since the Six Day War, Palestinians resisted Israel.
20:53
Hebrew soldiers are wounded, there are even deaths. The military defeat becomes a psychological victory
21:01
for the Palestinians.
21:08
In the eyes of the Arab world, the leader of the fighters is a hero. Yasser Arafat comes out of hiding.
21:15
He gives his first interviews to the international press.
21:23
- We will establish our own Palestinian state democratic and independent. A state in which,
21:29
everyone, all citizens, Christians, Jews, Muslims, will all live equal
21:36
in fraternity. - He takes the head of the PLO,
21:41
the Organization for the liberation of Palestine, which brings together all the wrestling movements.
21:46
At 40, with his dark glasses and his keffiyeh, he now embodies Palestinian resistance.
22:11
Meanwhile Leila Khaled, the young Palestinian teacher, trains in a military camp.
22:18
She is not in Yasser Arafat's Fatah. She joined the PFLP, a more radical branch of guerrilla warfare.
22:27
She is waiting for her first mission.
22:33
In 69, she was finally summoned what we ask of him is quite extraordinary.
22:42
- My boss asked me, are you ready to die? I said of course yes.
22:47
He told me, that's not the question. Are you ready to go to prison?
22:53
Of course, there are many of my comrades, of my brothers and sisters in Israeli prisons.
23:01
He told me, that's not the point either. Are you ready to hijack a plane?
23:07
I laughed. It was all new to me all this terminology.
23:13
I was joking and he asked me why are you laughing? I explained to him that I imagined myself running
23:20
with a plane on the back and everyone was chasing me. I didn't know what that meant.
23:25
He said to me, are you ready? I answered him that I was ready for anything.
23:33
I asked him am I going to go to Palestine? He replied, we'll see.
23:43
- August 29, 1969. A TWA Los Angeles flight Tel Aviv makes a stopover in Rome.
23:58
Leila Khaled boarded with an accomplice. Among the passengers, there should be Yitzhak Rabin,
24:05
the victorious general of the Six Day War.
24:14
- It was necessary to do something for the world the question arises. Who are these Palestinians?
24:27
It was clear that if we hijacked a plane with a personality like Rabin on board,
24:33
Israel could not ignore it. They would be obliged to exchange it for prisoners.
24:42
Unfortunately Rabin changed planes in Rome. - After takeoff, the two pirates burst into the cockpit.
24:53
The flight that was supposed to land in Tel Aviv is diverted to Syria. It flies over Israel.
25:02
For the first time, Leïla Khaled sees Haifa again, the town of his childhood.
25:09
- I asked the pilot to get off. He descended.
25:15
Military planes Israelis surrounded us. I said on the radio,
25:21
we are the Front People of Free Palestine. Repeat. The control tower guy said Popular Front Palestine.
25:29
I said, I don't understand you, say it clearly. He repeated it clearly, three times.
25:35
For me, it was a victory. It was the first time in our lives
25:41
that we heard in another language someone say free and Arab Palestine.
25:50
- A few minutes later, the plane lands in Syria. The passengers are evacuated.
25:59
The hijackers cause the device to explode. A spectacular gesture to challenge public opinion.
26:09
Leïla Khaled makes headlines, but she's not going to stop there.
26:16
- By hijacking this plane, we wanted to tell these people that there is a war here.
26:21
This is the reason for our action here in the Middle East. To tell them, don't come here.
26:27
- And you intend to continue the fight for your cause? - Yes.
26:45
- In the north of Israel, reservist Uri Hurvitz must leave again his kibbutz of Kfar-Guiladi.
26:54
This time, it's not to join your tank. The government recruited him to enhance security
27:01
on board planes. Uri imposes new controls at airports
27:08
and armed men on the flights from the Israeli company El Al.
27:15
Measures that will change everything.
27:23
September 6, 70, Amsterdam airport. The El Al flight heading from New York will take off.
27:32
Among the passengers, no one noticed Leila Khaled and his accomplice Patrick Arguello,
27:40
a South American activist.
27:45
Despite security measures, they got on board armed with pistols and grenades.
27:52
Leila went unnoticed. She had three operations cosmetic surgery so as not to be recognized.
28:03
What she doesn't know, that's what's on board several armed men.
28:10
- What happened, is that the Israelis started to shoot the minute we got up.
28:18
People were asked to remain calm. I ran to the cockpit. Patrick was behind me, it was shooting everywhere.
28:30
- When the plane lands in London, Patrick Arguello is dead. Leila Khaled is immediately imprisoned,
28:41
but not for long.
28:47
A few thousand kilometers away three other planes were hijacked by pirates from Leïla Khaled's group.
28:56
They landed at an abandoned airport in the hands of the Palestinians in Zarqa, Jordan.
29:07
This is an unprecedented operation. Four hundred American passengers, English and Swiss are held hostage.
29:17
The fedayeen want to exchange them against prisoners and Leila Khaled is part of the conditions.
29:25
- Our demands and our conditions are very clear. And we won't come back above,
29:31
whatever happens. These conditions are the Liberation by comrade Leïla Khaled
29:38
and the return of the martyr's body and their evacuation to a safe place in exchange for British hostages.
29:46
- In Israel, the Prime Minister Golda Meir demands the greatest firmness.
29:52
She doesn't want the English free Leïla Khaled. - What are these people going to do
29:58
when will they be released? This young woman will she come home
30:03
to the convent ? Is she going to get married? and raise your children?
30:08
Is she going to go back to teaching? She announces it herself.
30:13
She's going to start again. At least try to start again. I don't know with which plane this time.
30:22
- After six days of negotiation, the hostages are released.
30:27
They are still all surprised by their adventure. Most had never heard about Palestine.
30:37
In exchange, the hijackers obtain the release of prisoners.
30:43
Once again, in front of cameras around the world,
30:50
they blow up planes.
31:05
Leila Khaled is extradited to Egypt where bad news awaits him.
31:14
The Egyptians cry the death of their president Gamal Abdel Nasser.
31:19
The man who claimed destroy Israel in 1967.
31:24
Leila lost one of her heroes, but other events
31:30
even more serious occurred in a neighboring country.
31:52
Plane explosion in Zarqa caused fury of King Hussein of Jordan.
31:58
For some time now, the king no longer supports these Palestinians who believe themselves in his country as at home.
32:06
Their militia controls entire neighborhoods of the capital Amman.
32:13
Some of their leaders even call openly to overthrow the king.
32:18
Hussein knows he is in danger. The explosion of the planes is the pretext he was waiting for.
32:33
On September 17, he launched his troops to attack refugee camps. Thousands of deaths,
32:39
a carnage of which there are almost no images and that the Palestinians will call
32:45
Black September.
32:51
Once again, Salah al Tamari is at the heart of the fighting.
32:59
- It was more painful that Karameh and the Six Day War When we fight against Israelis expect everything.
33:06
They occupied our land, they are our enemies. This is Jordan, they are our brothers.
33:15
We are part of the same people, of the same nation, of the same culture.
33:20
Unfortunately it happened and we paid a high price.
33:27
- A new exodus begins.
33:34
Palestinian fighters and their families are driven out of the country. They flee Jordan towards Lebanon.
33:44
This is where Yasser Arafat and his troops now intend to lead the fight.
33:50
The head of the PLO will be able to count on the support of Karameh's commander.
33:56
Salah al Tamari accompanies him to Beirut.
34:04
Leïla Khaled also goes to Lebanon. She takes care of the education in training camps.
34:12
These two diversions made her a star,
34:17
but the time of hostage taking that end well is over.
34:37
September 1972, Munich Olympic Games. Something is happening in the Israeli pavilion.
34:46
On the balcony, hooded men. A Palestinian commando took the Israeli delegation hostage.
34:54
It's called Black September in memory of the Jordanian massacre.
35:03
It's a global event. Never the Palestinians have not been so publicized.
35:10
The operation ends in tragedy. The German police attack.
35:21
The hostage takers performed the eleven athletes before being shot or arrested.
35:26
Bloody terrorism is only just beginning.
35:43
It's in this climate who was born Yariv Horowitz in Tel Aviv, Israel.
35:50
His mother is a pacifist, left-wing activist. His father is rather liberal
35:59
and yet, even if at home, Yariv hears about happiness and peace between peoples,
36:05
the general atmosphere of the country is heavy.
36:15
- When we were children we were very afraid of the Arabs because of terrorist attacks on TV and in the newspapers.
36:24
Many stories were rumors about what the Arabs were doing It's like that that we grew up here. In fear.
36:34
- At the beginning of the 70s, terrorism is not the only threat.
36:41
Little Yariv has other reasons to be afraid.
36:57
October 6, 73,
37:03
it is 2 p.m. when the sound the alarm sirens in Israel.
37:13
We are in the middle of the Yom Kippur fast, the Jewish festival of Great Atonement.
37:22
- One of my first memories, these are the sirens of Yom Kippur in 73.
37:27
I was two years old. I remember it because from the shock of my mother running with the pram.
37:35
I do not know if I remember it or if she told me about it, but it's somewhere in my memories
37:44
- This time, it's a new war. Egypt and Syria attack. Arab neighbors want to recover lost territories
37:51
during the Six Day War.
38:00
In Gaza, in the Rafah refugee camp, very close to the old Egyptian border,
38:06
little Abdel Salam has grown up.
38:13
He is now 11 years old. He goes to school established by the United Nations.
38:19
That day he listened his favorite show on the radio.
38:25
- The radio started to broadcast the national anthems. We understood what was happening something abnormal.
38:32
We learned that the Egyptians had invaded Sinai.
38:39
I remember the mayor who asked us to go up to the roof
38:45
to check if the bullets were Egyptian or Israeli.
38:54
- The Israelis are caught off guard. Six years after the triumph of the Six Day War,
38:59
the country is threatened. Reservist Uri Hurvitz, the man from the kibbutz
39:07
went on a mission abroad. When he hears the news, he rushes onto the first plane.
39:16
- When the Yom Kippur War broke out, I was in Canada.
39:22
I immediately returned to Israel. There is no other country in the world, neither in France nor in Italy,
39:28
nor even in the United States, where people come back to fight. Young people,
39:34
everywhere, as I did, letting go of everything.
39:44
- The Yom Kippur War is not just one further conflict between Jews and Arabs. It's a global crisis,
39:50
because Arab countries have a new weapon, oil. They refuse to sell their production to the friends of Israel.
39:58
In America, in Europe, the price of gasoline is soaring.
40:04
The oil shock will shake up the global economy for years.
40:15
After 15 days combat and heavy losses, Israel still won the war,
40:21
but the country has shown its fragility. Making peace becomes a necessity.
40:28
His main opponent is ready.
40:45
On November 19, 1977, the unthinkable happens.
40:52
Anwar el-Sadat, the Egyptian president goes to Jerusalem
40:58
Never an Arab leader had not come to the Jewish State.
41:06
Uri Hurvitz is at the foot of the device. He who is so proud to be Israeli, he is impressed by the composure of the Egyptian president.
41:16
- When he got out of the plane, he greeted everyone, he shook hands, said hello.
41:24
Then he went to see General Motta Gur.
41:31
Sadat told him, you didn't think I was going to come? Here I am, and we replied, welcome!
41:41
It took a lot of courage to come. He did it.
41:51
Several years later, Sadat will pay for it with his life. He will be murdered by a radical Islamist,
41:57
but for now it is a triumph in the Israeli parliament. - Let's decide one thing together.
42:03
We have to get there. Eye to eye between us and you.
42:09
We must continue so that even an old lady like me, live long enough to see the day when...
42:15
- It's true that I've always said that. - You always treated me old lady Mr. President.
42:22
- All smiles, he jokes with former Prime Minister Golda Meir. Finally, Mr. President,
42:29
from from a grandmother to a grandfather... Let me give you this little gift
42:35
for your new baby girl. And I thank you for the gift you gave me. [Arab spoken audio]
42:45
- At the same time, 200 kilometers away, in Lebanon, Yasser Arafat harangues his troops.
42:53
For his own, it is not good news. An Arab country makes a pact with the enemy
42:58
and the fate of the Palestinians takes a back seat.
43:10
- It was a dark day for all of us. Because
43:16
It was the first time that someone was raping our pact against Israel.
43:27
Here is a people who occupies our country, who expelled us by force.
43:35
Nevertheless, an Arab leader will negotiate with them,
43:40
at our cost.
43:48
- A year later, Egypt and Israel sign peace at Camp David in the United States.
43:57
In exchange, the troops Israelis evacuate Sinai that they occupy since the Six Day War.
44:07
For the first time, the Jewish state is at peace with a neighbor.
44:19
In the refugee camps, Nothing has changed. Here in Lebanon, we are in the third generation.
44:29
The Palestinians arrived in 48 had children, grandchildren
44:34
who have no nationality. They are just refugees.
44:41
From their birth, we teach them that they are not at home and that one day they are going to return to Palestine.
44:49
[Arab spoken audio] - Palestine.
44:54
The return. Jihad.
44:59
- They know everything about Jerusalem. From Palestinian history and its symbols.
45:16
Refugees are supervised and trained by PLO troops. Since his exile from Jordan,
45:22
Yasser Arafat made Lebanon its new headquarters. He feels at home here.
45:33
He built up a real army which multiplies the attacks in the north of Israel.
45:42
The reaction of the Jewish state won't be long.
46:06
In 1982 Israel prepares to an intervention in Lebanon, called Peace in Galilee.
46:17
Yariv is now 11 years old. He is proud to see his big brother going to the front.
46:24
- I was proud to the idea that my brother go serve my country and defend it.
46:31
He was leaving to help us survive, him too was happy to leave.
46:36
When he came back, that was another story. - Beirut, the capital of Lebanon.
46:47
The Israelis besiege the city.
46:53
Operation Peace in Galilee turned into war.
47:00
Originally, the troops were only to advance only 40 kilometers to secure the border,
47:09
but the Israeli generals want to put an end to the PLO. They pushed as far as Beirut.
47:20
Weeks of street battles, face-to-face among civilians,
47:26
in the streets of the capital.
47:36
After 70 days of fighting, the Palestinians are crushed. Fighters are evacuated from Beirut thanks to international intervention,
47:45
and in particular that of a French contingent.
47:54
This time Salah al Tamari will not leave, he is taken prisoner.
48:00
He will be released a year later during an exchange against Israeli soldiers.
48:12
As for Leïla Khaled, she is in one of the trucks driving towards the port. She is pregnant and she just got married.
48:22
- It was very hard for us. In the truck leaving for the port,
48:27
I was crying the whole time. Because I felt that it was a new exodus
48:33
far from our homeland.
48:40
- After Jordan, Lebanon, the Palestinians return to the road of exile.
48:56
Yasser Arafat sets sail for Tunisia with 4,000 fighters.
49:03
Their family stays there and a new drama awaits them.
49:18
A few days after the departure of the combatants, in the camps refugees from Sabra and Chatila,
49:26
hundreds of women and Palestinian children are massacred.
49:32
The men of a Christian militia came to avenge the assassination of their leader, the new Lebanese president.
49:38
Carnage!
49:45
The Israeli army was there. She let it happen.
49:56
In Israel, 400,000 people scandalized take to the streets.
50:01
This is the biggest event of the country's history.
50:07
Yariv is in the crowd with his parents.
50:12
- It was gigantic. There were a lot of people. There was a lot of anger,
50:20
and people were ashamed. I think they wanted to show the world that they were not responsible for that
50:28
and they were against this war operation in Lebanon.
50:34
- Israelis are confused. They can't stand the idea that their army could have made a mistake.
50:42
They believed themselves to be victims. They find themselves aggressors and they will soon discover
50:48
that the revolt is brewing at their doorstep.
51:08
The Gaza Strip in 1987.
51:14
Little Abdel Salam became a computer scientist. He just turned 26 and he married his neighbor.
51:27
Life in Gaza reminds us that of Arab cities from Jordan or Egypt
51:33
with one difference. It is a territory occupied since the Six Day War 20 years ago.
51:40
The patrols of Israeli soldiers are daily. Abdel Salam can no longer stand them.
51:48
- We have lived in this camp forever we see patrols all the time.
51:54
It's like a wall between you and your life, you and your freedom.
52:00
These soldiers are an obstacle to your hopes, to your dreams, and you can't leave.
52:19
- On December 8, 1987, everything changed. Residents take to the streets
52:25
throw stones on Israeli soldiers.
52:32
A trivial accident car started it all. This is the start of the Intifada.
52:38
An Arabic word meaning uprising.
52:44
Abdel Salam has a camera. He films and sometimes, like the others, he throws stones.
52:54
- It's the first time that people picked up stones to throw them away. I did it too.
53:03
I put my camera down and I threw stones, at least five or six.
53:14
It had become obvious. We had to throw stones.
53:31
The reason is very simple. It's to tell them What are you doing here ? Your language is different.
53:40
You have a uniform difficult to accept. You behave badly towards me.
53:46
You close the door. You close the window.
53:54
No more busy. The message is very clear.
54:02
Faced with stone throwers, Yitzhak Rabin, the overall winner of 1967.
54:08
He is Minister of Defense. Like the others, Rabin is taken by surprise.
54:15
He is convinced that it is a revolt with no future. He chooses firmness.
54:24
He recommends to his soldiers to be more aggressive. He even expressly asks them
54:31
to beat the stone throwers when they are caught in the act.
54:55
Far from the tumult, in Tel Aviv, Yariv Horowitz has become a teenager.
55:00
He takes advantage of his last moments of tranquility. At 18, like any Israeli citizen,
55:06
he must do his three years of military service. In the midst of the Intifada, he was sent in the occupied territories.
55:18
As it is part of the army cinema, propaganda films are ordered from him.
55:30
- One day they sent me with the paratroopers to make a film. to boost the morale of the troops.
55:39
They were at the end of their military service it must have made them a memory of the last days.
55:47
It was meant to be a very happy and very funny film.
55:52
- The interviews are going to get out of hand. In front of him, the soldiers confess.
55:57
They say they are disoriented by this funny war that they become bullies.
56:06
- They told me what they were doing. They were frustrated with chasing children
56:11
who threw stones at them without catching them. How they caught them even before they threw stones.
56:27
- We take to the street. We see a group of 5 teenagers drinking tea and quietly playing backgammon.
56:34
We pass, we overturn their table and we start hitting them.
56:40
We knew that as soon as we passed, they would have called us fags and Israeli bastards.
56:45
That they would throw stones at us. So we typed them first because afterwards we wouldn't have caught up with them.
56:54
- When I showed the film to my bosses, they were shocked.
57:00
Because no one imagined that. From our point of view, the Israeli army was the most moral of all.
57:11
Morality was its basis. We are Jews. We survived the Holocaust, we must be very moral.
57:19
When I came home, they discovered reality. Kids aged 18-19,
57:24
and I too was 19 years old, who had completely lost their minds.
57:31
- Yariv's film is an electric shock which goes back to the top of the State.
57:36
The Israeli parliament forbidden to the same soldier to stay more than three months in occupied territory,
57:44
but every day of Intifada, the gap between Arabs and Jews deepens a little more.
58:06
September 13, 1993, in Washington, the White House.
58:11
After six years of stone war, finally an immense hope.
58:19
Yasser Arafat was surprised by the Intifada. To avoid being overwhelmed, he must regain the initiative.
58:28
In front of him, the new Prime Minister is Yitzhak Rabin. He understood his mistake.
58:34
The Intifada is not a flash in the pan, you have to negotiate.
58:39
Between them, there is Bill Clinton's America which plays a decisive role.
58:46
The first Gulf War in Iraq has left its mark. Since 91, the Americans are convinced
58:52
that must be pacified this region as quickly as possible.
58:58
Everything is not settled, but peace is on the way.
59:04
After months of secret negotiations in Oslo, Norway, they will sign an agreement which provides for Palestinian autonomy.
59:13
Israelis commit to withdraw their troops from Gaza and the West Bank. Ultimately,
59:18
these territories could become a Palestinian state.
59:27
The whole world is waiting for the event. The handshake between yesterday's mortal enemies is not self-evident.
59:44
- When I was watching television, I saw the images bleeding.
59:50
I saw the blood of the martyrs, all those who died in combat.
59:56
When Arafat shook Rabin's hand, I hated him at that moment.
1:00:08
- For us, when we see the image of Yasser Arafat, it is necessarily accompanied by blood.
1:00:13
When we see him shake Rabin's hand, we have very mixed feelings.
1:00:20
I remember Arafat arriving to shake Rabin's hand. This was a big question in Israel to know whether to shake his hand
1:00:29
and the break before let Rabin hold out his hand. He's like that and then he says to himself,
1:00:34
come on, let's go.
1:00:46
- The time for peace has come. We will have fought you,
1:00:52
you, the Palestinians. We tell you today,
1:00:57
high and loud. Enough blood and tears.
1:01:05
Enough !
1:01:19
- Some months later, thanks to the Oslo Accords, Yasser Arafat, the leader of the fighters, returns to Palestine for the first time.
1:01:29
He makes a triumphant entry into Gaza. He will soon be the first president of the Palestinian Authority.
1:01:39
Abdel Salam now has four children. He became a cameraman in a press agency.
1:01:45
It's an unforgettable day.
1:01:51
- Since my childhood, I saw Arafat on TV. He was our hero, the very symbol of our resistance.
1:02:03
I believed in that day, when Arafat entered Gaza. I felt very strong things.
1:02:11
I made pictures of faces happy people.
1:02:26
We tell ourselves that peace can succeed. I'm very optimistic at this point.
1:02:37
In the euphoria of the negotiations, a few exiles are allowed to return.
1:02:47
Salah al-Tamari, the commander of Karameh. For the first time since the 1967 war,
1:02:55
he can return in his town of Bethlehem.
1:03:04
The case of Leïla Khaled is more complicated. Israel does not want of a former terrorist.
1:03:10
She gets exceptional authorization to travel to the occupied territories.
1:03:23
- As soon as I saw the Israeli flag, it was terrible for me.
1:03:28
This is the first thing that I saw while crossing the border.
1:03:36
I wanted to see mine.
1:03:51
I went there and my people received me.
1:03:57
I would never have dreamed of such a thing. It was as if I knew everyone,
1:04:04
even though I didn't know anyone.
1:04:11
- Leila Khaled goes to Gaza to participate at the Palestinian National Congress.
1:04:17
Abdel Salam is there. He films his interview. - Will you go to Haifa?
1:04:23
I do not think so. I'm not allowed to go there.
1:04:29
- When we see a woman like Leila Khaled who hijacked a plane, and we see it there,
1:04:38
we say to ourselves that maybe maybe this is the beginning of peace.
1:04:43
That the Israelis will make concessions. That the Palestinians will make concessions.
1:04:48
That we are at the beginning of a new era. That's not what happened.
1:05:11
November 4, 1995, the place of the Kings of Israel in Tel Aviv is packed with people.
1:05:19
The biggest demonstration from Sabra and Shatila. It's a rally for peace.
1:05:25
Side by side, the Israeli and Palestinian flag.
1:05:31
On the podium, Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin is moved. He didn't expect such a crowd.
1:05:38
Since shaking Arafat's hand, part of the Israelis accuses him of treason.
1:05:47
- We will not only sing peace, we are going to do it too.
1:06:01
Sing the song of peace.
1:06:08
- The few words of this song will be these last words.
1:06:14
A few seconds later, he leaves the platform. A Jewish extremist shoots him three times in the back.
1:06:32
His supporters are appalled. In the eyes of the world, Rabin embodied hope.
1:06:41
Even the American president hides his distress poorly.
1:06:47
- Yitzhak Rabin was my partner and my friend.
1:06:52
I admired him and I loved him very much.
1:06:58
Because words cannot express what I feel, I will simply say
1:07:05
goodbye my brother. Goodbye My friend.
1:07:25
On the kibbutz of Kfar-Guiladi, the emotion is considerable. Uri Hurvitz is 68 years old.
1:07:32
He is having a peaceful retirement when he hears the news. He knew the Prime Minister well.
1:07:40
Rabin had come several times on the kibbutz to participate in ceremonies
1:07:52
- It was horrible.
1:07:57
I don't know how to express my feeling on this wild animal that killed him.
1:08:07
I was really bad, not just me, all of Israel.
1:08:14
We lost a leader. He was truly a great leader.
1:08:25
- The assassination of Rabin is a hard blow for a peace process already in a bad way.
1:08:32
These successors did not not always the same certainties. Some like Ariel Sharon
1:08:38
even openly declare that the Oslo Accords are the largest disaster never happened to Israel.
1:08:50
More and more Jewish settlers settle in the occupied territories.
1:08:56
They want to make it impossible the creation of a Palestinian state and they say it openly.
1:09:05
- This is our country, this is not Palestine or the Palestinian state. It's Israel. It is the Holy Land of the Jews.
1:09:11
I am Jewish and we have the right to live in a Jewish state, and stay wherever you want.
1:09:18
On the Palestinian side too, the peace process has serious adversaries. Yasser Arafat is increasingly contested.
1:09:27
For a while now, radical Islam from Iran gains influence throughout the Middle East.
1:09:34
Arafat is overtaken by extremist religious movements who refuse negotiation with Israel.
1:09:43
Most important among them is Hamas.
1:09:51
This party has become essential by getting involved in social life and in schools.
1:09:58
Little by little, fundamentalism settles among the Palestinians.
1:10:10
- I remember my sister who had modern clothes, dresses, short skirts.
1:10:19
Now women are all the same, in black.
1:10:37
- On both sides, tension rises.
1:10:44
Everything is ready for a new explosion.
1:11:14
Fall 2000, on the Esplanade des Mosques in Jerusalem,
1:11:29
a new Intifada begins.
1:11:43
This one has nothing left of a spontaneous revolt. Very quickly, she turns into a real war.
1:11:52
Guns have replaced stones.
1:11:59
Street fighting cause hundreds of deaths.
1:12:15
The suicide attack is the new Palestinian weapon. Suicide bombers who claim to be Hamas or Islamic Jihad
1:12:22
get blown up in the streets of Jerusalem and Tel Aviv.
1:12:33
Everytime, the same panic scenes and the same images of carnage.
1:12:46
Yariv Horowitz, the young Israeli who filmed the Intifada became a director.
1:12:52
He lives in the neighborhood fashionable in Tel Aviv. He is afraid to leave his house.
1:13:05
We were afraid all the time. It was twice a week, three times per week.
1:13:11
We never knew. There was an attack two minutes from here.
1:13:19
It was everywhere. It was depressing. Really depressing.
1:13:27
With each attack, Israel responds with violence.
1:13:37
Entire neighborhoods are bombed in the occupied territories.
1:13:47
When Israel launches an operation reprisals on the Rafah camp, Abdel Salam is filming.
1:13:55
He sees his childhood neighborhood disappear before his eyes.
1:14:04
Here he is in a t-shirt orange with his camera. That day, he narrowly escapes death.
1:14:15
- The Israelis destroyed everything. I couldn't even anymore reach my neighborhood.
1:14:22
All my friends, my primary school destroyed.
1:14:27
School is terrible. We have lots of memories. We can't find anything anymore.
1:14:43
It's like my story is dead because someone came and killed my dream.
1:14:50
It was like that in Rafah. I couldn't believe it.
1:14:56
- Yasser Arafat, the old Palestinian leader, is nothing more than a shadow.
1:15:01
Hamas does not recognize its authority Israelis do not don't want to talk to him anymore.
1:15:09
He is ill. At the end of October 2004, it is evacuated to France to be hospitalized.
1:15:27
Al Tamari, the commander of Karameh, remembers their last dinner.
1:15:38
- I had dinner with him a day before let him leave for Paris.
1:15:43
It was Ramadan. I was the only one to share this meal with him.
1:15:55
He was really very weak, and when he left, I knew I would never see him again.
1:16:08
Arafat never lacked courage. He followed through with his ideas
1:16:14
and if our movement of resistance survived, it's thanks to him personally.
1:16:21
It was someone who could make peace with the Israelis.
1:16:42
With the death of Arafat, the Palestinians have lost their leader.
1:16:55
Disappointed with the process of peace and by Fatah, they turn massively towards Hamas which wins the elections.
1:17:04
For Europe and America, Hamas in power is unacceptable, even after a democratic victory.
1:17:12
They cut their subsidies to Palestine.
1:17:18
The situation is getting worse. Fatah and Hamas get into a war fratricide between Palestinians.
1:17:33
It's mostly in Gaza that the world's attention is focused on. In 2005 Israel get rid of this territory.
1:17:42
Army withdraws from Gaza for the first time since 67.
1:17:49
Even the Jewish settlers furious must leave.
1:17:57
They are forced to abandon their home. Their protection is too expensive.
1:18:02
Israel no longer wants Gaza.
1:18:11
Palestinians celebrate the departure of the Hebrew soldiers.
1:18:17
However, these images are illusory,
1:18:23
because Israel remains in control from all borders and therefore the region's economy.
1:18:35
In 2007, when Hamas takes power. Israel imposes a total blockade of the territory.
1:18:43
The Gaza Strip is nothing more than a huge prison.
1:18:54
Since then, every week, Hamas sends rockets to Israel and Israel responds with air raids on Gaza.
1:19:11
On December 27, 2008, the planes of the Jewish state bombs Gaza.
1:19:17
After a six-month truce, the conflict starts again more violent than ever.
1:19:23
This time it is a large-scale operation, a new war. Israel wants to end it definitely with rocket fire
1:19:31
and with Hamas. Hebrew chariots invest the Gaza Strip
1:19:40
like in 1967.
1:19:47
In 60 years of violence, peace has not made much progress. Like this wall built by the Hebrew State.
1:19:59
A wall of more than 700 kilometers which will soon wind around the entire West Bank, sometimes crossing villages.
1:20:13
A security barrier to protect themselves from suicide attacks, say the Israelis.
1:20:19
A wall of shame to make life impossible, say the Palestinians.
1:20:37
Today Uri Hurvitz is 82 years old. The pioneer's son who fought all the wars
1:20:44
still has the same confidence in his country. He is faithful to his kibbutz of Kfar-Guiladi.
1:20:53
Whatever happens, he intends to end his life there.
1:21:01
At 37 Yariv Horowitz no longer the little Israeli who was afraid of attacks.
1:21:06
He is a prominent director in Tel Aviv. He returned to the soldiers which he had filmed during the Intifada.
1:21:16
He made a film about it the dismay of a generation.
1:21:25
Salah al Tamari is 65 years old. The Cairo Student became commander in Karameh
1:21:32
is now governor of Bethlehem, the city where he was born.
1:21:39
A city disfigured by the wall.
1:21:45
Abdel Salam Shehadeh spent his 46 years in Gaza. The little boy who saw the tanks arrive in 1967
1:21:54
became boss of a press agency. He lives cut off from the world by the Israeli blockade.
1:22:06
As for Leïla Khaled, she lives in Jordan. The young teacher Palestinian refugee
1:22:13
become a hijacker is now 64 years old. She still lives in hope
1:22:20
to return to Haifa one day, the town of his childhood.
====================================================================================================================
6,332 Comments
@steveromeocars
6 months ago
Magnificent report. This report should be shown in the official media. But we all know that the truth is not shown on the public screen...
1K
Reply
42 replies
@abyfaye4610
6 months ago (edited)
The more I look, the more my rage rises. Hypocrites of the first order. How can we hope for peace without justice and equity?
753
Reply
31 replies
@WisMohadi
5 days ago
Thank you for the video. Adding to the knowledge of long history..... greetings brotherhood
4
Reply
1 reply
@Abdoumalien
7 months ago
Full support for the Palestinian people who have suffered for decades, they are an oppressed people 🇵🇸🇵🇸
823
Reply
116 replies
@ALAINMAXI
6 months ago (edited)
Beautiful work of memory, on this endless conflict written in blood, pain, and tears.
466
Reply
16 replies
@milagroskloostra5063
1 month ago
It's not 60 years of violence, don't forget that this already started more than 100 years ago...
37
Reply
7 replies
@heliharonoja2508
3 weeks ago (edited)
There are lot of important details left out in this document. I was hoping more about two state solution proposals around the years and little bit of history about the Judea Samaria region before state of Israel and fights from 1920's
41
Reply
6 replies
@smittenbesotted9918
7 days ago
Why not start from the peace treaties of 1919 and 1920 when the League of Nations granted the Jews their ancestral lands and the Arabs the rest of the Middle East? Why start 60 years ago when history goes back a little longer?
5
Reply
@Quran24.
5 months ago
They received guests, but they themselves were left without a home 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 ️
733
Reply
35 replies
@Prometheus444
6 months ago
They did not leave their land but were forcibly displaced. Lots of errors
347
Reply
26 replies
@alexandreturgeon9831
1 month ago
I feel sympathy for both Palestinians and Israelis, it’s very understandable that they fear each other; lot of good people on both sides, but extremists on both side make the peace very difficult… hopefully one day they will learn to live side by side with safety and equal rights
13
Reply
@onlylexus
3 weeks ago
This documentary is highly inaccurate, names and dates are wrong, so are the names given to nations that didn't even exist at that time. Broadly it is ok, but it should be re checked.
30
Reply
2 replies
@erosfastoche8341
6 months ago
My God, what courage in the face of hopes followed by despair with this dream of being able to one day live in peace in Palestine anchored in our bodies and hearts.
295
Reply
5 replies
@Alena0757
6 months ago
Awesome movie! I watched and cried! My soul was torn with grief along with the unfortunate Palestinians deprived of their homeland and freedom! Many thanks to the creators for their honesty, for the truth, for the same feelings as mine. I feel the same pain for Palestine with you (Philestine, that’s more correct), although it is not spoken about openly. 🇯🇴🇯🇴🇯🇴! Thank you! Novosibirsk. Russia.
281
Reply
72 replies
@Franc_Hendz
3 weeks ago
Very informative documentary for those of us who like to listen to history
4
Reply
@louisevintsos4346
1 month ago
Very interesting and fairly fair, but incomplete. Who allowed the creation of Israel? Who favored the creation of Hamas?
5
Reply
@angolanprince
5 months ago
Excellent documentary. I hope that the Palestinian people achieve their freedom and regain their lands, in the name of G-d.
405
Reply
8 replies
@ismaeldia8756
6 months ago
Support for the victims of these dirty wars
148
Reply
3 replies
@lanceroberthough1275
1 month ago
So much is left out. 4 nations attacked Israel in 1948.
10
Reply
@user-rs9fd5td2c
1 month ago
you left aside the single most important thing - in 1948, 1 day after Ben-Gurions statement, the arabs attacked Israel with 4 armies: Egypt, Syria, Iraq and Jordan. They told the arabs that lived here to fall back into the west bank so the armies could carry on. The arab armies lost the war and the people were left in the west bank with no help from Jordan that held that land. this is the origin of the Palestinians.
Israel accepted the 2 state solution that the UN offerd in 1947 and the arabs tried to destroy a 1 day old country.
23
Reply
5 replies
@ylmazemine4527
5 months ago
Seventy years of torture is something that has never been seen anywhere. Seventy years continuously. This must now be reversed and they must be held accountable. This world is not a place of calculation, but a place of tasting. Even pain and cruelty must have a dose in the conscience, otherwise there must be a price.
155
Reply
7 replies
@jeanpaulsilve5564
6 months ago
Blood and tears for so long
107
Reply
3 replies
@akbarunissasyed6948
2 weeks ago
Allahas Greatest Palestinen Freedom People's Always FREE PALESTINE PEOPLE'S INSHALLAHA 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
2
Reply
@mujionoz8487
8 days ago
Thank you for allowing us to hear and see pieces of the story and the documents
1
Reply
@moniquemwimba9450
6 months ago
Quality documentary; very good work which gives us an overview of this endless conflict. Thank you so much...
117
Reply
2 replies
@emmamabandza7604
6 months ago
Thank you for this interesting and very good quality documentary.
263
Reply
2 replies
@DovidShaw
1 month ago
This story misses out the fact that the Arab High Command sent messages to cities and town that had radio that the Muslim Arabs should leave as the surrounding nations were coming in to push the Jews into the sea. So they left due to the command or request of the Arab High Command. This is often missed out of such documentaries.
4
Reply
@balice806
9 days ago
What year was this documentary made?
1
Reply
@ha-fi-da
4 months ago
Bravo for this factual, objective report and giving a voice to people on both sides! Well done again
57
Reply
4 replies
@kirikou306
5 months ago
Thank you for this serious and detailed documentary. I learned a lot from him.
66
Reply
@amalnina650
1 month ago
Istrael which attacks a people who have absolutely nothing to do with them before the eyes of the world with incredible impunity and hypocrisy!! Shame on the world for allowing this injusticeglory to the Palestinian people who suffer🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
20
Reply
1 reply
@benebikwo2000
3 weeks ago
Warriors of the State of Israel, people of the Sovereign Eternal Covenant
3
Reply
1 reply
@abousaria603
6 months ago
I like this sentence from the show ''the bottom of the cards'': the end of the exile of the Israeli people marks the beginning of the exile of the Palestinian people. She explains a lot
84
Reply
3 replies
@pascalrivalan2876
6 months ago
Total support for the Palestinian people, their cause is just...
225
Reply
9 replies
@user-tz1nl9sb8v
13 days ago (edited)
Israel won all the wars because of GODS love for them and his promise to Abraham. God's angels were helping them and still are.
8
Reply
2 replies
@user-fq2mv3lj2s
1 month ago (edited)
Unbelievable how you distorted and twisted the facts (whilst ignoring other crucial facts) pretending to be objective
This is literally the definition of mind engineering.
37
Reply
6 replies
@Merak1976
6 months ago
Magnificent report with true impartiality, it's a change from BFM and CNEWS...
95
Reply
@ahvigier
4 months ago
Excellent documentary, the result of a real effort at objectivity. Very rare on the subject, too rare.
41
Reply
@vr6594
1 month ago
Always the innocent who pay is really shameful when everyone should live in peace.
1
Reply
@NinaMymy
1 month ago (edited)
May God’s peace, mercy, and blessings be upon you. Have a blessed Friday, Lord of the worlds, God willing, and do not think that those who were killed in the cause of God are dead, rather they are alive with their Lord and provided for. “God Almighty has spoken the truth.” Amen, Lord of the worlds. God is sufficient for us. There is no god but He. In Him we trust, and He is the Lord of the Great Throne. !!! God is sufficient for us, there is no god but Him in Him we put our trust, and He is the Lord of the Great Throne!!! God is sufficient for us, there is no god but Him in Him we put our trust, and He is the Lord of the Great Throne!!! God is sufficient for us, there is no god but Him in Him we put our trust, and He is capable of all things!!! God is sufficient for us, there is no god but Him in Him we put our trust, and He is capable of all things!!! God is sufficient for us, there is no god but Him in Him we put our trust, and He is capable of all things!!! Glory and eternity to our righteous martyrs, victory, our luck, and God does not break His promise, God willing,🇩🇿🇩🇿🇩🇿🇩🇿🇩🇿
1
Reply
@user-ev2rj7ud8n
5 months ago
Excellent document. For my part, I have always been both delighted and surprised that a State was formed on a confessional basis. Our education teaches us - I hope - to distinguish between identities: civil (and therefore - a priori secular for us -), personal, family, and confessions: Christian (Catholic, Orthodox (of various rites and belonging to various patriarchates), Protestants and evangelicals), Jews... of various denominations, or other spiritualizing families from the distant East. Let's imagine for a moment that ALL Christians live in the Vatican?... A "Jewish" state was felt to be necessary (as a reminder, the idea went back, in the minds of the English, well before the last world war! From the 19th century in any case), but the idea is unique, isn't it? With us, you can be French, German, Italian, Spanish, etc. AND... of Jewish, Christian, Muslim and other CONFESSION. This mixture of genres appeals to me and above all... the idea of a "Jewish reduction" scandalizes me! Because it would be like saying: these “people” cannot integrate or be integrated anywhere or by anyone... they therefore need an “enclosure”! I find this scandalous. I had a number of comrades of various faiths, notably Jewish. Between us kids, it was never a problem!
29
Reply
8 replies
@vincentchastel2025
6 months ago
Excellent documentary, clear and objective.
82
Reply
2 replies
@tabularasa9104
1 month ago
It will serve us all to remember these words: As we sow so shall we reap.
2
Reply
@anarchist3551
6 months ago
From The River To The Sea
Palestine Will Be Free!🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
203
Reply
16 replies
@belgomikebelgomke8959
6 months ago
I understand the problem much better, thank you for this documentary.
118
Reply
27 replies
@tehilarosenbaum2299
7 days ago
You are presenting this like there were no Jewish community's prior to 1948 what an misleading video essay. This is unfortunate .
8
Reply
@visionzo
11 days ago
PALESTINE will be free from the river to the sea🇵🇸🇵🇸
1
Reply
@Merbleue56
3 months ago
Well done Palestinians, you are great. Long live Palestine.
278
Reply
14 replies
@lallamimi676
6 months ago
Justice is near. The price to pay is extremely painful. But alongside the difficulty lies the ease
69
Reply
3 replies
@edbloom2327
3 weeks ago
Jews have considered this area their holy land since 1300 years before Christ. In 1948 there was a two-state solution - Palestine and Israel. It was acceptable to Israel, not Palestine. Arab nations attacked Israel. Israel won this war. They've made peace with some neighbors, but still are being attacked from many nations.
2
Reply
@annietyger5894
12 days ago
Palestine 🇵🇸 WILL VICTORY 🇵🇸 free
1
Reply
@sarahgawdan2215
6 months ago
Sad…I cry…helpless my heart is with you
88
Reply
4 replies
@VpourVictoire
6 months ago
60 years of brutality and injustice
207
Reply
9 replies
@Andhbhakt000
3 weeks ago
We support Palestine..love from India
1
Reply
@martineyourte8691
5 months ago
thank you for this report which allowed us to understand the reason for this endless conflict, and to do it impartially, it makes a change in the media! peace for palestine
70
Reply
2 replies
@abe4524
7 months ago
Waaow what a story, we don't talk about that on TV or at school
33
Reply
3 replies
@user-pl9hj1hd6d
1 day ago
Takbir allahu akbar for the independence of Palestine...
Reply
@brendal.b7968
13 days ago (edited)
Very well done, but your pronouciation of Yitzhak Rabin's name I found very distracting. It's pronounced Rahbeen.
3
Reply
@user-fm7nv6xp4b
6 months ago
It's scary to watch. How could this be allowed to happen?
54
Reply
6 replies
@marieb.6769
6 months ago
Very good historical reminder, especially for the generation from the 80s onwards. Many wonder how we got there and do not understand the origins of the conflict, since we don't talk about it at school, apart from after the war. and the creation of Israel. In view of current events, a documentary on the history of the conflict, which sheds light on both sides, was essential. Whatever position one takes, it is above all essential to know and understand. This documentary sticks to the facts and attempts to remain objective by looking at both sides over the decades.
171
Reply
14 replies
@alexfranklin1479
5 days ago
60 yrs violence for what ,?. Both have the right to live in their respective places peacefully. War will not yield anything but animosity only
1
Reply
@user-pl9hj1hd6d
1 day ago
Independent Palestine 2024, fight for an independent Palestine....
Reply
@user-op6sb2cv8i
5 months ago
All praise belongs to the Almighty One Greatest Gracious Merciful Allah Lord of the Worlds
28
Reply
@gregorychandeze6860
6 months ago
Unfortunately it has been going on for over 70 years.and each time it rises to a crescendo and unfortunately it is always the civilians who are massacred. And this will continue until there are no courageous leaders to find a compromise acceptable to both peoples.
35
Reply
6 replies
@at6479
2 weeks ago
Free, free, free Palestine 🇸🇩!
1
Reply
@maapaa2010
1 month ago (edited)
I support freedom and peace.
That's why I support Palenstine.
It was never not a state, only it was invaded and reppressed by an evil regime.
I hope the people of that region whom many have a common ancestry can live in peace.
1
Reply
@gaetanodallacqua6249
6 months ago
Really informative documentary
111
Reply
3 replies
@doloresmatias146
6 months ago
What would we say about France if tomorrow others came to invade our territory? They settle down and occupy our country by decreeing to be at home??? Let's put ourselves in everyone's place, let's be fair and good! Let's stop wars and advocate PEACE!! Every life matters
43
Reply
11 replies
@kathyrobbert1940
1 day ago
Interesting documentary, bringing understanding to the viewers. They left out the biggest detail (unless I missed it): the United Nations voted to give Israel a nation after World War II. It’s dishonest not to include this in the video since the re-creation of the Israeli state was recognized and approved by many nations. This changes the whole assumption presented in this video, which is (according to them) that Israel is the perpetrator. Still the interviews were informative.
Reply
@CristinaCiccarelli-uu3ln
3 weeks ago
There is no denying the existence of a people and their origins, land and rights.️
Reply
@christianhumblot5630
6 months ago
Thank you for your documentary which allows us to understand the origin of this endless conflict.
100
Reply
5 replies
@user-zp1jt4ff5u
5 months ago
You don't have to be a Muslim to be honest in your dealings with Palestinians!
130
Reply
9 replies
@bmt3727
1 month ago
Long live Palestine 🇵🇸
2
Reply
@jeanbon5282
2 weeks ago
Long live Anwar El-Sadat! Long live Israel!
1
Reply
@colettedeParis
6 months ago
Just the title is already misinformation. Either you tell it like it is, or you don't. This story has been going on for over 75 years. It's pure and simple occupation in a region filled with (oh well... gas and oil).
16
Reply
1 reply
@anonymousanonymous165
6 months ago (edited)
The thing that moved me the most, despite knowing the profile of this man, was Rabin's death. We can really see the desire for peace on their faces. Too bad for both peoples but extremism won that day
26
Reply
2 replies
@MarcusWestloe
3 weeks ago
One-sided documentary, never have thought media would fall so low. Very sad indeed
1
Reply
@trinitymatrix9719
3 weeks ago (edited)
Nobody knows what geocide is unless they experienced ottman empire geocide against jews and christians, armenian genocide or holocaust
29
Reply
4 replies
@nolimitcityid
5 months ago
Thank you for the Indonesian subtitles, a very good documentary video. This is the 1st on YouTube.
24
Reply
1 reply
@YakubovAbdurahmonkhoja
3 months ago
This nation of Israel is not worthy of humanity, it is worse than an animal that does not live in peace.
141
Reply
7 replies
@aliamokrane56
1 month ago
Long live Palestine and the Palestinian people.
1
Reply
@user-pl9hj1hd6d
1 day ago
Rise up my fighters for an independent Palestine...
Reply
@hichammouaddib7762
7 months ago
Thanks for the report . Very good quality
113
Reply
2 replies
@jmotivation22
7 months ago
Let's not forget to pray for the situation to calm down️️
82
Reply
10 replies
@YoutubeHashMedico
1 month ago
Mark my words this decade will change everything ,free Palestine
1
Reply
@aureliopereiradelima9111
1 day ago
AURÉLIO-SOROCABA-SP-..A COSTUME THAT HAS NO END, RIGHT?..COMMENTING ABOUT HAMAS SEEMS TO BE HIDDEN. WHAT IS THE REASON FOR PALESTINIANS TO BE SUBJECTED AND LET THEMSELVES STAY IN THE HAMAS COLLECTION?...HONESTY SEEMS NOT TO BE THE PURPOSE OF THIS VIDEO
1
Reply
@jacquesfridez1658
6 months ago
For me it's been going on for 76 years and I'm starting to get anxious that these poor Palestinians will find their Country, Peace, Joy of Living.my wish is that all people come together and punish the guilty, which Lonu is incapable of doing
48
Reply
3 replies
6 months ago
Thank you for this quality, enlightening and objective report. May peace return to all!
22
Reply
1 reply
@user-pl9hj1hd6d
1 day ago
Free Palestine, for the sake of our children and grandchildren, unite the whole world to support Palestine....... Freedom...... Go away from the Israeli colonialists...
Reply
@rayjc1539
1 month ago
Enough of wars, like grow up, this what life for, come on now️️️️
2
Reply
1 reply
@metalstrider2221
6 months ago
excellent reporting and allow a better understanding of the story
66
Reply
1 reply
@juniaguimaraes3489
6 months ago
Very well prepared and timely. Thinking about PEACE after so much blood and tears is as necessary as it is utopian. Unfortunately!!!
20
Reply
3 replies
@user-wr3ps4wm2v
9 days ago
It is where the 12 sons of Jacob grazed for thousands of years......they are the 12 tribes of Israel, then they built JERUSALEM,,,,,,,, and Jewish history continued
Reply
@rabiachairi25
1 month ago
He and his brother El Haq FREE PALESTINE
1
Reply
@nanahasanah4457
6 months ago (edited)
Thank you for the video, I have come to understand about the conflict between Israel and Palestine, if the previous prime minister had not died there might have been peace there, the Palestinian people were sad and hurt, they were forced to leave the house they had been occupying, that's why there was resistance, maybe there should have been there a long time ago better communication in society, better information so that there is no hatred between the two parties, because the war destroyed both countries and only created bad memories between the two countries...now it is getting worse as if human life has no meaning.
8
Reply
4 replies
@tigerjo123
6 months ago
Palestine must be returned to the Palestinians. European Jews must return home to Europe and other countries from which they came. Most Israelis have dual nationality! Only Jews of Palestinian origin and those who legally purchased their homes and land before World War II should remain and cohabit with Muslim and Christian Palestinians in a multi-religious Palestine. Peace and long life to the country of Palestine and its citizens! ️
27
Reply
1 reply
@okaytosmile
1 month ago
Free Palestine from the river to the sea Palestine will be free
1
Reply
@ehabbob5111
8 days ago
I am a Coptic Egyptian but I love Isreal a lot
Reply
6 months ago
A real history lesson, I remember many of the episodes of this film, history has always interested me since my lessons in primary school until now.
29
Reply
5 replies
@Elena-gm5qo
6 months ago
Спасибо за работу
27
Reply
2 replies
@emparriera2946
1 month ago
both parties lose. It is impossible for these very different cultures and religions to coexist on the same territory.
1
Reply
@txitxarro2
2 days ago
A JEWISH POINT OF VIEW.. BUT VERY FAR FROM THE TRUTH
Reply
@user-dw3zu7dl9j
5 months ago
Look at what is right and greedy, open your eyes and hearts. Zionists are indeed cruel and cruel when they ask for their hearts to be given protection, but instead take them away. Remember heroes and fighters for truth will never die
9
Reply
@ericst-laurent8161
7 months ago
This whole story is making me nauseous. I have the feeling that one day this will end in a catastrophe for the entire planet.
45
Reply
11 replies
@ons900
2 weeks ago
FREE FREE PALESTINE LET THE WHOLE WORLD KNOW THE TRUTH 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
Reply
@user-kn8pr4zm6u
5 months ago
I am for peace without hatred and love for each other will prevail
14
Reply
1 reply
@elizabethgoode4050
5 months ago
High quality, non-partisan documentary which well summarizes the history of this terrible fratricidal struggle
33
Reply
3 replies
@martinmaidenbaum5159
2 weeks ago
A one sided description of the facts. I do not wish to go into details. The truth is self evident. Arab propaganda can not distort the truth, not now or ever!! Israel is here to stay!! Live with it!!
1
Reply
@user-kg7fx2bx3b
1 month ago
Palestinian 🇵🇸 is always for Palestinian
1
Reply
@elsaturner606
1 month ago
.....you don't blow up a school bus :-( Very good documentary, thank you
Reply
@rivaldoherera97
5 months ago (edited)
From birth until now I have grown up. Thank God, I have sided with Palestine, and since I was little I have hated Israel. Free Palestine 🇵🇸 Hasbunallah wanikmal deputy..🇵🇸🇮🇩
80
Reply
5 replies
@user-py9nw7dk2g
2 weeks ago
GOD JESUS BLESS ISRAEL 🇮🇱 FOREVER
4
Reply
@siamosolonoi1659
6 months ago
I can't, and I don't want to be a "bearer", because on both sides we can see that neither really wants peace. The Palestinians because they saw themselves expropriated of their lands, without a referendum, only by decision of England. And the Jews, a people chased, persecuted, after the Shoah want a place to feel safe. Except that, once there, much more financially comfortable, with a well-trained and over-armed army, they say: We 1,400 AJC, we lived here, and god, HM promised us this land, because next to the Sinai, etc . And towards the end of the report, when I hear the girl say: We Jews have all the rights, and the right to live wherever we want!! that’s part of it. So, given the girl's age, I tell myself that peace is not for next Tuesday...
16
Reply
2 replies
@elsinoredevera3713
3 weeks ago
If it's happen before? what hamas did are their goaLs till now so israel has the right to depend and to dismantle capability to create terror in which nazi done for history. Why are those protesting in different country knows this? What hamas did and not condemn them used Palestinian as covered
1
Reply
@user-zz7vt1mv4o
11 days ago
Infinite sadness, man vs man, pain
Reply
@yusufyusyf5666
5 months ago
Thank you very much for supporting Palestine and for the truth, kind person
36
Reply
2 replies
@Heriawans
5 months ago
Palestine will be free🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
7
Reply
@eliasdejesusmunguiaramirez9227
13 hours ago
God Bless the Palestinians, the problem is not in their people, it is in their leaders, they must surrender their hearts before the true God, our God, God of Abraham, God of Isaac and God of Jacob. God is our father, and we are Brothers, through our Lord Jesus Christ, God Bless you!! Peace to Israel!!
====================
Try dog food with a difference
lyka.com.au
Order now
Sponsored 1 of 2 ·
0:19
lyka.com.au
5
0:00 / 0:19
Israel - Palestine, 60 years of violence (English Documentary)
Investigations et Enquêtes
3.1M subscribers
Subscribe
27K
Share
3,053,444 views Oct 23, 2023 PALESTINE
In 1948, the creation of the State of Israel was proclaimed. Three years after Nazism, the Jews can settle on the land of their ancestors. But for the Arab populations installed there, it is the disaster.
0:00 in 1948, David Ben-Gourion proclaimed the creation of the State of Israel, marking the end of Nazism and the beginning of the Palestinians' disaster.
7:41 1967 Six days war: the Arab rout
10:05 am In 1967, Israel won a flash victory against the Arab countries and extended its territory, thus changing its victim status to that of military power.
19:37 Palestinians resist the Israeli army during the Battle of Karameh in 1968, while bomb attacks and diversion of planes were perpetrated by Palestinian activists in the following years.
28:42 In September 1970, three planes were diverted by pirates from the Leed group and landed at an disused airport in the hands of the Palestinians in Zarka in Jordan, where 400 passengers are retained hostage, but are finally released after six days of negotiations .
38:58 The war of the Kippur and the visit of the Egyptian president Anouar El-Sadate in Israel mark a turning point in the Israeli-Arab conflict, but the Palestinians remain in a situation of refugees.
49:24 The documentary talks about the Palestinian intifada and the reaction of Israel.
1:05:11 The assassination of Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin is a blow for the already fragile peace process between Israel and Palestine.
1:09:26 The peace process between Israel and Palestine is disputed, the influence of radical Islam increases and Hamas is gaining importance.
1:20:45 The documentary presents the lives of several people in Israel and Palestine, who have experienced significant events and have different aspirations.
Follow us on the networks:
Facebook:
/ investigations in
Chapters
View all
Transcript
Follow along using the transcript.
Show transcript
Investigations et Enquêtes
3.1M subscribers
Videos
About
Facebook
Instagram
Police Action
Action Replay
DAM - Auto / Moto
216
Le Monde
by Investigations et Enquêtes
Try dog food with a difference
Sponsored
lyka.com.au
Order now
Scotch Whisky Investment
Investment-Grade At Half The Wholesale Price
Sponsored
Whiskey Wealth Club
Learn more
14:04
Now playing
Meet Lily Greenberg Call, First Jewish Biden Appointee to Publicly Resign over Gaza
Democracy Now!
116K views 2 days ago
New
23:53
Now playing
How Israeli Apartheid Destroyed My Hometown
AJ+
7.1M views 1 year ago
1:11:13
Now playing
Iraq - When France says no to America
Investigations et Enquêtes
127K views 2 days ago
New
29:46
Now playing
EXCLUSIVE: ICC prosecutor seeks arrest warrants against Sinwar and Netanyahu for war crimes
CNN
434K views 3 days ago
New
25:04
Now playing
In Gaza now, it’s worse than ethnic cleansing | Centre Stage
Al Jazeera English
318K views 2 months ago
2:20:46
Now playing
The Soldiers of November: from training to Operation Barkhane
Investigations et Enquêtes
1.3M views 5 months ago
14:09
Now playing
Full interview: Tapper talks to Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu after ICC seeks arrest warrant
CNN
332K views 2 days ago
New
1:24:43
Now playing
John Mearsheimer: What’s Behind Biden’s Blank Check Support for Israel? | Endgame #179 (Luminaries)
Gita Wirjawan
707K views 2 months ago
56:32
Now playing
The Libyan powder keg: threat at the gates of Europe | Documentary with English subtitles
Investigations et Enquêtes
5.3M views 1 year ago
1:43:55
Now playing
The Great Misinterpretation: How Palestinians View Israel - Haviv Rettig Gur
Shalem College - המרכז האקדמי שלם
381K views 2 months ago
1:45:40
Now playing
Mohamed Merah, route of a killer
Investigations et Enquêtes
4.5M views 3 years ago
21:08
Now playing
Palestine : La peste blonde - L’Effet Papillon
Butterfly Effect
3.1M views 6 years ago
47:13
Now playing
Six days that changed the Middle East: The '67 Arab-Israeli War | Featured Documentary
Al Jazeera English
4.8M views 11 months ago
57:05
Now playing
Syria: Jihad Squadrons (english documentary)
Investigations and Investigations
7M views 4 months ago
9:40
Now playing
Top U.S. & World Headlines — May 23, 2024
Democracy Now!
149K views 19 hours ago
New
21:15
Now playing
Is a two-state solution for Israel and Palestine possible? | Start Here
Al Jazeera English
751K views 1 month ago
54:36
Now playing
I infiltrated Daesh in France
Investigations and Investigations
3.2M views 4 months ago
19:50
Now playing
“A Watershed Event”: ICC Charges Against Netanyahu First Time Court Has Gone After Western Leader
Democracy Now!
225K views 2 days ago
New
51:28
Now playing
The Final Days of Jim Morrison | Full documentary in English
imineo Documentaries
971K views 1 month ago
1:24:16
Now playing
The West Bank's Unseen Conflict: Palestinians Documenting Israeli Violence | Palestine Documentary
Java Discover | Free Global Documentaries & Clips
275K views 3 months ago
Show more
6,332 Comments
Sejin Lifeforce
Add a comment...
@steveromeocars
6 months ago
Magnificent report. This report should be shown in the official media. But we all know that the truth is not shown on the public screen...
1K
Reply
42 replies
@abyfaye4610
6 months ago (edited)
The more I look, the more my rage rises. Hypocrites of the first order. How can we hope for peace without justice and equity?
753
Reply
31 replies
@WisMohadi
5 days ago
Thank you for the video. Adding to the knowledge of long history..... greetings brotherhood
4
Reply
1 reply
@Abdoumalien
7 months ago
Full support for the Palestinian people who have suffered for decades, they are an oppressed people 🇵🇸🇵🇸
823
Reply
116 replies
@ALAINMAXI
6 months ago (edited)
Beautiful work of memory, on this endless conflict written in blood, pain, and tears.
466
Reply
16 replies
@milagroskloostra5063
1 month ago
It's not 60 years of violence, don't forget that this already started more than 100 years ago...
37
Reply
7 replies
@heliharonoja2508
3 weeks ago (edited)
There are lot of important details left out in this document. I was hoping more about two state solution proposals around the years and little bit of history about the Judea Samaria region before state of Israel and fights from 1920's
41
Reply
6 replies
@smittenbesotted9918
7 days ago
Why not start from the peace treaties of 1919 and 1920 when the League of Nations granted the Jews their ancestral lands and the Arabs the rest of the Middle East? Why start 60 years ago when history goes back a little longer?
5
Reply
@Quran24.
5 months ago
They received guests, but they themselves were left without a home 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 🇵🇸 ️
733
Reply
35 replies
@Prometheus444
6 months ago
They did not leave their land but were forcibly displaced. Lots of errors
347
Reply
26 replies
@alexandreturgeon9831
1 month ago
I feel sympathy for both Palestinians and Israelis, it’s very understandable that they fear each other; lot of good people on both sides, but extremists on both side make the peace very difficult… hopefully one day they will learn to live side by side with safety and equal rights
13
Reply
@onlylexus
3 weeks ago
This documentary is highly inaccurate, names and dates are wrong, so are the names given to nations that didn't even exist at that time. Broadly it is ok, but it should be re checked.
30
Reply
2 replies
@erosfastoche8341
6 months ago
My God, what courage in the face of hopes followed by despair with this dream of being able to one day live in peace in Palestine anchored in our bodies and hearts.
295
Reply
5 replies
@Alena0757
6 months ago
Awesome movie! I watched and cried! My soul was torn with grief along with the unfortunate Palestinians deprived of their homeland and freedom! Many thanks to the creators for their honesty, for the truth, for the same feelings as mine. I feel the same pain for Palestine with you (Philestine, that’s more correct), although it is not spoken about openly. 🇯🇴🇯🇴🇯🇴! Thank you! Novosibirsk. Russia.
281
Reply
72 replies
@Franc_Hendz
3 weeks ago
Very informative documentary for those of us who like to listen to history
4
Reply
@louisevintsos4346
1 month ago
Very interesting and fairly fair, but incomplete. Who allowed the creation of Israel? Who favored the creation of Hamas?
5
Reply
@angolanprince
5 months ago
Excellent documentary. I hope that the Palestinian people achieve their freedom and regain their lands, in the name of G-d.
405
Reply
8 replies
@ismaeldia8756
6 months ago
Support for the victims of these dirty wars
148
Reply
3 replies
@lanceroberthough1275
1 month ago
So much is left out. 4 nations attacked Israel in 1948.
10
Reply
@user-rs9fd5td2c
1 month ago
you left aside the single most important thing - in 1948, 1 day after Ben-Gurions statement, the arabs attacked Israel with 4 armies: Egypt, Syria, Iraq and Jordan. They told the arabs that lived here to fall back into the west bank so the armies could carry on. The arab armies lost the war and the people were left in the west bank with no help from Jordan that held that land. this is the origin of the Palestinians.
Israel accepted the 2 state solution that the UN offerd in 1947 and the arabs tried to destroy a 1 day old country.
23
Reply
5 replies
@ylmazemine4527
5 months ago
Seventy years of torture is something that has never been seen anywhere. Seventy years continuously. This must now be reversed and they must be held accountable. This world is not a place of calculation, but a place of tasting. Even pain and cruelty must have a dose in the conscience, otherwise there must be a price.
155
Reply
7 replies
@jeanpaulsilve5564
6 months ago
Blood and tears for so long
107
Reply
3 replies
@akbarunissasyed6948
2 weeks ago
Allahas Greatest Palestinen Freedom People's Always FREE PALESTINE PEOPLE'S INSHALLAHA 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
2
Reply
@mujionoz8487
8 days ago
Thank you for allowing us to hear and see pieces of the story and the documents
1
Reply
@moniquemwimba9450
6 months ago
Quality documentary; very good work which gives us an overview of this endless conflict. Thank you so much...
117
Reply
2 replies
@emmamabandza7604
6 months ago
Thank you for this interesting and very good quality documentary.
263
Reply
2 replies
@DovidShaw
1 month ago
This story misses out the fact that the Arab High Command sent messages to cities and town that had radio that the Muslim Arabs should leave as the surrounding nations were coming in to push the Jews into the sea. So they left due to the command or request of the Arab High Command. This is often missed out of such documentaries.
4
Reply
@balice806
9 days ago
What year was this documentary made?
1
Reply
@ha-fi-da
4 months ago
Bravo for this factual, objective report and giving a voice to people on both sides! Well done again
57
Reply
4 replies
@kirikou306
5 months ago
Thank you for this serious and detailed documentary. I learned a lot from him.
66
Reply
@amalnina650
1 month ago
Istrael which attacks a people who have absolutely nothing to do with them before the eyes of the world with incredible impunity and hypocrisy!! Shame on the world for allowing this injusticeglory to the Palestinian people who suffer🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
20
Reply
1 reply
@benebikwo2000
3 weeks ago
Warriors of the State of Israel, people of the Sovereign Eternal Covenant
3
Reply
1 reply
@abousaria603
6 months ago
I like this sentence from the show ''the bottom of the cards'': the end of the exile of the Israeli people marks the beginning of the exile of the Palestinian people. She explains a lot
84
Reply
3 replies
@pascalrivalan2876
6 months ago
Total support for the Palestinian people, their cause is just...
225
Reply
9 replies
@user-tz1nl9sb8v
13 days ago (edited)
Israel won all the wars because of GODS love for them and his promise to Abraham. God's angels were helping them and still are.
8
Reply
2 replies
@user-fq2mv3lj2s
1 month ago (edited)
Unbelievable how you distorted and twisted the facts (whilst ignoring other crucial facts) pretending to be objective
This is literally the definition of mind engineering.
37
Reply
6 replies
@Merak1976
6 months ago
Magnificent report with true impartiality, it's a change from BFM and CNEWS...
95
Reply
@ahvigier
4 months ago
Excellent documentary, the result of a real effort at objectivity. Very rare on the subject, too rare.
41
Reply
@vr6594
1 month ago
Always the innocent who pay is really shameful when everyone should live in peace.
1
Reply
@NinaMymy
1 month ago (edited)
May God’s peace, mercy, and blessings be upon you. Have a blessed Friday, Lord of the worlds, God willing, and do not think that those who were killed in the cause of God are dead, rather they are alive with their Lord and provided for. “God Almighty has spoken the truth.” Amen, Lord of the worlds. God is sufficient for us. There is no god but He. In Him we trust, and He is the Lord of the Great Throne. !!! God is sufficient for us, there is no god but Him in Him we put our trust, and He is the Lord of the Great Throne!!! God is sufficient for us, there is no god but Him in Him we put our trust, and He is the Lord of the Great Throne!!! God is sufficient for us, there is no god but Him in Him we put our trust, and He is capable of all things!!! God is sufficient for us, there is no god but Him in Him we put our trust, and He is capable of all things!!! God is sufficient for us, there is no god but Him in Him we put our trust, and He is capable of all things!!! Glory and eternity to our righteous martyrs, victory, our luck, and God does not break His promise, God willing,🇩🇿🇩🇿🇩🇿🇩🇿🇩🇿
1
Reply
@user-ev2rj7ud8n
5 months ago
Excellent document. For my part, I have always been both delighted and surprised that a State was formed on a confessional basis. Our education teaches us - I hope - to distinguish between identities: civil (and therefore - a priori secular for us -), personal, family, and confessions: Christian (Catholic, Orthodox (of various rites and belonging to various patriarchates), Protestants and evangelicals), Jews... of various denominations, or other spiritualizing families from the distant East. Let's imagine for a moment that ALL Christians live in the Vatican?... A "Jewish" state was felt to be necessary (as a reminder, the idea went back, in the minds of the English, well before the last world war! From the 19th century in any case), but the idea is unique, isn't it? With us, you can be French, German, Italian, Spanish, etc. AND... of Jewish, Christian, Muslim and other CONFESSION. This mixture of genres appeals to me and above all... the idea of a "Jewish reduction" scandalizes me! Because it would be like saying: these “people” cannot integrate or be integrated anywhere or by anyone... they therefore need an “enclosure”! I find this scandalous. I had a number of comrades of various faiths, notably Jewish. Between us kids, it was never a problem!
29
Reply
8 replies
@vincentchastel2025
6 months ago
Excellent documentary, clear and objective.
82
Reply
2 replies
@tabularasa9104
1 month ago
It will serve us all to remember these words: As we sow so shall we reap.
2
Reply
@anarchist3551
6 months ago
From The River To The Sea
Palestine Will Be Free!🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
203
Reply
16 replies
@belgomikebelgomke8959
6 months ago
I understand the problem much better, thank you for this documentary.
118
Reply
27 replies
@tehilarosenbaum2299
7 days ago
You are presenting this like there were no Jewish community's prior to 1948 what an misleading video essay. This is unfortunate .
8
Reply
@visionzo
11 days ago
PALESTINE will be free from the river to the sea🇵🇸🇵🇸
1
Reply
@Merbleue56
3 months ago
Well done Palestinians, you are great. Long live Palestine.
278
Reply
14 replies
@lallamimi676
6 months ago
Justice is near. The price to pay is extremely painful. But alongside the difficulty lies the ease
69
Reply
3 replies
@edbloom2327
3 weeks ago
Jews have considered this area their holy land since 1300 years before Christ. In 1948 there was a two-state solution - Palestine and Israel. It was acceptable to Israel, not Palestine. Arab nations attacked Israel. Israel won this war. They've made peace with some neighbors, but still are being attacked from many nations.
2
Reply
@annietyger5894
12 days ago
Palestine 🇵🇸 WILL VICTORY 🇵🇸 free
1
Reply
@sarahgawdan2215
6 months ago
Sad…I cry…helpless my heart is with you
88
Reply
4 replies
@VpourVictoire
6 months ago
60 years of brutality and injustice
207
Reply
9 replies
@Andhbhakt000
3 weeks ago
We support Palestine..love from India
1
Reply
@martineyourte8691
5 months ago
thank you for this report which allowed us to understand the reason for this endless conflict, and to do it impartially, it makes a change in the media! peace for palestine
70
Reply
2 replies
@abe4524
7 months ago
Waaow what a story, we don't talk about that on TV or at school
33
Reply
3 replies
@user-pl9hj1hd6d
1 day ago
Takbir allahu akbar for the independence of Palestine...
Reply
@brendal.b7968
13 days ago (edited)
Very well done, but your pronouciation of Yitzhak Rabin's name I found very distracting. It's pronounced Rahbeen.
3
Reply
@user-fm7nv6xp4b
6 months ago
It's scary to watch. How could this be allowed to happen?
54
Reply
6 replies
@marieb.6769
6 months ago
Very good historical reminder, especially for the generation from the 80s onwards. Many wonder how we got there and do not understand the origins of the conflict, since we don't talk about it at school, apart from after the war. and the creation of Israel. In view of current events, a documentary on the history of the conflict, which sheds light on both sides, was essential. Whatever position one takes, it is above all essential to know and understand. This documentary sticks to the facts and attempts to remain objective by looking at both sides over the decades.
171
Reply
14 replies
@alexfranklin1479
5 days ago
60 yrs violence for what ,?. Both have the right to live in their respective places peacefully. War will not yield anything but animosity only
1
Reply
@user-pl9hj1hd6d
1 day ago
Independent Palestine 2024, fight for an independent Palestine....
Reply
@user-op6sb2cv8i
5 months ago
All praise belongs to the Almighty One Greatest Gracious Merciful Allah Lord of the Worlds
28
Reply
@gregorychandeze6860
6 months ago
Unfortunately it has been going on for over 70 years.and each time it rises to a crescendo and unfortunately it is always the civilians who are massacred. And this will continue until there are no courageous leaders to find a compromise acceptable to both peoples.
35
Reply
6 replies
@at6479
2 weeks ago
Free, free, free Palestine 🇸🇩!
1
Reply
@maapaa2010
1 month ago (edited)
I support freedom and peace.
That's why I support Palenstine.
It was never not a state, only it was invaded and reppressed by an evil regime.
I hope the people of that region whom many have a common ancestry can live in peace.
1
Reply
@gaetanodallacqua6249
6 months ago
Really informative documentary
111
Reply
3 replies
@doloresmatias146
6 months ago
What would we say about France if tomorrow others came to invade our territory? They settle down and occupy our country by decreeing to be at home??? Let's put ourselves in everyone's place, let's be fair and good! Let's stop wars and advocate PEACE!! Every life matters
43
Reply
11 replies
@kathyrobbert1940
1 day ago
Interesting documentary, bringing understanding to the viewers. They left out the biggest detail (unless I missed it): the United Nations voted to give Israel a nation after World War II. It’s dishonest not to include this in the video since the re-creation of the Israeli state was recognized and approved by many nations. This changes the whole assumption presented in this video, which is (according to them) that Israel is the perpetrator. Still the interviews were informative.
Reply
@CristinaCiccarelli-uu3ln
3 weeks ago
There is no denying the existence of a people and their origins, land and rights.️
Reply
@christianhumblot5630
6 months ago
Thank you for your documentary which allows us to understand the origin of this endless conflict.
100
Reply
5 replies
@user-zp1jt4ff5u
5 months ago
You don't have to be a Muslim to be honest in your dealings with Palestinians!
130
Reply
9 replies
@bmt3727
1 month ago
Long live Palestine 🇵🇸
2
Reply
@jeanbon5282
2 weeks ago
Long live Anwar El-Sadat! Long live Israel!
1
Reply
@colettedeParis
6 months ago
Just the title is already misinformation. Either you tell it like it is, or you don't. This story has been going on for over 75 years. It's pure and simple occupation in a region filled with (oh well... gas and oil).
16
Reply
1 reply
@anonymousanonymous165
6 months ago (edited)
The thing that moved me the most, despite knowing the profile of this man, was Rabin's death. We can really see the desire for peace on their faces. Too bad for both peoples but extremism won that day
26
Reply
2 replies
@MarcusWestloe
3 weeks ago
One-sided documentary, never have thought media would fall so low. Very sad indeed
1
Reply
@trinitymatrix9719
3 weeks ago (edited)
Nobody knows what geocide is unless they experienced ottman empire geocide against jews and christians, armenian genocide or holocaust
29
Reply
4 replies
@nolimitcityid
5 months ago
Thank you for the Indonesian subtitles, a very good documentary video. This is the 1st on YouTube.
24
Reply
1 reply
@YakubovAbdurahmonkhoja
3 months ago
This nation of Israel is not worthy of humanity, it is worse than an animal that does not live in peace.
141
Reply
7 replies
@aliamokrane56
1 month ago
Long live Palestine and the Palestinian people.
1
Reply
@user-pl9hj1hd6d
1 day ago
Rise up my fighters for an independent Palestine...
Reply
@hichammouaddib7762
7 months ago
Thanks for the report . Very good quality
113
Reply
2 replies
@jmotivation22
7 months ago
Let's not forget to pray for the situation to calm down️️
82
Reply
10 replies
@YoutubeHashMedico
1 month ago
Mark my words this decade will change everything ,free Palestine
1
Reply
@aureliopereiradelima9111
1 day ago
AURÉLIO-SOROCABA-SP-..A COSTUME THAT HAS NO END, RIGHT?..COMMENTING ABOUT HAMAS SEEMS TO BE HIDDEN. WHAT IS THE REASON FOR PALESTINIANS TO BE SUBJECTED AND LET THEMSELVES STAY IN THE HAMAS COLLECTION?...HONESTY SEEMS NOT TO BE THE PURPOSE OF THIS VIDEO
1
Reply
@jacquesfridez1658
6 months ago
For me it's been going on for 76 years and I'm starting to get anxious that these poor Palestinians will find their Country, Peace, Joy of Living.my wish is that all people come together and punish the guilty, which Lonu is incapable of doing
48
Reply
3 replies
6 months ago
Thank you for this quality, enlightening and objective report. May peace return to all!
22
Reply
1 reply
@user-pl9hj1hd6d
1 day ago
Free Palestine, for the sake of our children and grandchildren, unite the whole world to support Palestine....... Freedom...... Go away from the Israeli colonialists...
Reply
@rayjc1539
1 month ago
Enough of wars, like grow up, this what life for, come on now️️️️
2
Reply
1 reply
@metalstrider2221
6 months ago
excellent reporting and allow a better understanding of the story
66
Reply
1 reply
@juniaguimaraes3489
6 months ago
Very well prepared and timely. Thinking about PEACE after so much blood and tears is as necessary as it is utopian. Unfortunately!!!
20
Reply
3 replies
@user-wr3ps4wm2v
9 days ago
It is where the 12 sons of Jacob grazed for thousands of years......they are the 12 tribes of Israel, then they built JERUSALEM,,,,,,,, and Jewish history continued
Reply
@rabiachairi25
1 month ago
He and his brother El Haq FREE PALESTINE
1
Reply
@nanahasanah4457
6 months ago (edited)
Thank you for the video, I have come to understand about the conflict between Israel and Palestine, if the previous prime minister had not died there might have been peace there, the Palestinian people were sad and hurt, they were forced to leave the house they had been occupying, that's why there was resistance, maybe there should have been there a long time ago better communication in society, better information so that there is no hatred between the two parties, because the war destroyed both countries and only created bad memories between the two countries...now it is getting worse as if human life has no meaning.
8
Reply
4 replies
@tigerjo123
6 months ago
Palestine must be returned to the Palestinians. European Jews must return home to Europe and other countries from which they came. Most Israelis have dual nationality! Only Jews of Palestinian origin and those who legally purchased their homes and land before World War II should remain and cohabit with Muslim and Christian Palestinians in a multi-religious Palestine. Peace and long life to the country of Palestine and its citizens! ️
27
Reply
1 reply
@okaytosmile
1 month ago
Free Palestine from the river to the sea Palestine will be free
1
Reply
@ehabbob5111
8 days ago
I am a Coptic Egyptian but I love Isreal a lot
Reply
6 months ago
A real history lesson, I remember many of the episodes of this film, history has always interested me since my lessons in primary school until now.
29
Reply
5 replies
@Elena-gm5qo
6 months ago
Спасибо за работу
27
Reply
2 replies
@emparriera2946
1 month ago
both parties lose. It is impossible for these very different cultures and religions to coexist on the same territory.
1
Reply
@txitxarro2
2 days ago
A JEWISH POINT OF VIEW.. BUT VERY FAR FROM THE TRUTH
Reply
@user-dw3zu7dl9j
5 months ago
Look at what is right and greedy, open your eyes and hearts. Zionists are indeed cruel and cruel when they ask for their hearts to be given protection, but instead take them away. Remember heroes and fighters for truth will never die
9
Reply
@ericst-laurent8161
7 months ago
This whole story is making me nauseous. I have the feeling that one day this will end in a catastrophe for the entire planet.
45
Reply
11 replies
@ons900
2 weeks ago
FREE FREE PALESTINE LET THE WHOLE WORLD KNOW THE TRUTH 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
Reply
@user-kn8pr4zm6u
5 months ago
I am for peace without hatred and love for each other will prevail
14
Reply
1 reply
@elizabethgoode4050
5 months ago
High quality, non-partisan documentary which well summarizes the history of this terrible fratricidal struggle
33
Reply
3 replies
@martinmaidenbaum5159
2 weeks ago
A one sided description of the facts. I do not wish to go into details. The truth is self evident. Arab propaganda can not distort the truth, not now or ever!! Israel is here to stay!! Live with it!!
1
Reply
@user-kg7fx2bx3b
1 month ago
Palestinian 🇵🇸 is always for Palestinian
1
Reply
@elsaturner606
1 month ago
.....you don't blow up a school bus :-( Very good documentary, thank you
Reply
@rivaldoherera97
5 months ago (edited)
From birth until now I have grown up. Thank God, I have sided with Palestine, and since I was little I have hated Israel. Free Palestine 🇵🇸 Hasbunallah wanikmal deputy..🇵🇸🇮🇩
80
Reply
5 replies
@user-py9nw7dk2g
2 weeks ago
GOD JESUS BLESS ISRAEL 🇮🇱 FOREVER
4
Reply
@siamosolonoi1659
6 months ago
I can't, and I don't want to be a "bearer", because on both sides we can see that neither really wants peace. The Palestinians because they saw themselves expropriated of their lands, without a referendum, only by decision of England. And the Jews, a people chased, persecuted, after the Shoah want a place to feel safe. Except that, once there, much more financially comfortable, with a well-trained and over-armed army, they say: We 1,400 AJC, we lived here, and god, HM promised us this land, because next to the Sinai, etc . And towards the end of the report, when I hear the girl say: We Jews have all the rights, and the right to live wherever we want!! that’s part of it. So, given the girl's age, I tell myself that peace is not for next Tuesday...
16
Reply
2 replies
@elsinoredevera3713
3 weeks ago
If it's happen before? what hamas did are their goaLs till now so israel has the right to depend and to dismantle capability to create terror in which nazi done for history. Why are those protesting in different country knows this? What hamas did and not condemn them used Palestinian as covered
1
Reply
@user-zz7vt1mv4o
11 days ago
Infinite sadness, man vs man, pain
Reply
@yusufyusyf5666
5 months ago
Thank you very much for supporting Palestine and for the truth, kind person
36
Reply
2 replies
@Heriawans
5 months ago
Palestine will be free🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
7
Reply
@eliasdejesusmunguiaramirez9227
13 hours ago
God Bless the Palestinians, the problem is not in their people, it is in their leaders, they must surrender their hearts before the true God, our God, God of Abraham, God of Isaac and God of Jacob. God is our father, and we are Brothers, through our Lord Jesus Christ, God Bless you!! Peace to Israel!!
Reply
@theofficialmascot
1 month ago
Israel was 12 tribes, not a land. It all a lie.
4
Reply
2 replies
@christalafella9642
6 months ago (edited)
One of the best French documentaries that I have seen with particular attention. Objectivity and transparency of the eternal Israeli-Palestinian conflict. The two great political figures for the restoration of peace have disappeared, died without realizing their dreams of the mythical establishment of peace. Everything is changing and getting worse. Currently we are in an impasse which only leads to hatred and the massacre of the population of Gaza due to the intransigence of the two belligerents, who each claim the exclusivity of these holy territories for both parties. The history of this conflict demonstrates the weaknesses and strengths of these antagonists. Gaza is burning and innocent Palestinians scapegoated are dying in outrage. The balance of power is unbalanced and the law of the strongest will be established to the detriment of the other. The history of this conflict is imprinted in the oppressed hearts of the Palestinian people like a bleeding red tattoo, revenge makes them more and more blind. Charismatic leaders do not exist to guide these lost people in their own story of survival and dignity. The blindness of not recognizing the mistakes committed in the past by both parties makes this conflict inevitable. What outcome, what hope of survival can we imagine????Is the myth of peace so sought after possible to come true???? ?
27
Reply
4 replies
@RechercheDusavoir-cl7oh
6 months ago
I congratulate you on this visual document, we learned a lot about the facts between the two countries...
32
Reply
1 reply
@patriciatewhetu6808
8 days ago
11 years old and being sent up to find out if it was an Egyptian or Israeli Bullet is so profound to me, i didn't even know there was a difference and the fact an 11 yr old even knows the difference
Reply
@fatimabendrif9122
1 month ago
The ugliest thing a person can be exposed to is betrayal by those you welcomed and opened your door to
Now I ask for forgiveness from King Hussein Allah
Have mercy on him
1
Reply
@netizenyangbaik2847
6 months ago
Currently, I have seen how Israeli atrocities against civilians in Gaza... Just imagine in ancient times, information was not as easy to obtain as it is now.
57
Reply
2 replies
@balthazarjoe8698
6 months ago
an outstanding report. which will perhaps open the eyes of all people who speak without knowing, and who explain without understanding anything about what is happening in the Middle East
8
Reply
1 reply
@Sipaling467
1 month ago
It was a shame that the Arab leaders formed a coalition with England rather than the Ottoman Empire, where the Ottomans had guarded them for hundreds of years.
Reply
@Sopramalagasy
3 weeks ago
Thank you for this report which explains this war well
Reply
@sofiasatari3689
6 months ago
Free free Palestine free free Palestine 🇵🇸
113
Reply
4 replies
@osmanyuvinipaguadazavala6396
3 weeks ago
How many people support violence that sadly has everyone plummeting into the abyss is very terrifying what these nations practice they are reaping what they sow everything by reusing and rejecting the Lord Jesus Christ
Reply
@rogermccormick5248
1 month ago
I will stand with the Constitution and I will not be moved.
Reply
@hubertmwika3690
6 months ago
Thank you for this very high quality documentary in impeccable narration.
35
Reply
1 reply
@nicolasquiles9770
7 months ago
Despite all the misfortunes that befall the Palestinian people, the television news only pity Israel and never the Palestinians!! It's shameful
36
Reply
2 replies
@cagdaskose9429
9 days ago
Long live Free palestine.
1
Reply
@Falestinelibre
1 month ago
Long live the resistance Palestine 🇵🇸 free insha'Allah
4
Reply
@fathimuthu...
6 months ago
Our Lord, give us good in this world and good in the Hereafter, and protect us from the torment of Hellfire Palestine 🇵🇸 Amen
79
Reply
3 replies
@user-vq1ys6rc7v
5 months ago (edited)
Can't see this.. Too heartbreaking watch this.
You are great human, Palestinians.
So patient, very good heart, I even can't describe how strong your people are.
Mercì bèaoucup for uploading this video.
57
Reply
7 replies
@LuisHernandez-or2kd
3 weeks ago
That's my birthday, I'm from Panama, I'm going to Israel xr k. They are people of God.
Reply
@user-gl9cj2jy8h
1 month ago
In my opinion, Israel, from the time of their ancestors, was very sad, they were slaves of ancient Egypt until the second world war, many of them were killed, millions of people, so now they have risen, from sheep to strong lions, they are trying to seize the land of their ancestors, that's why can survive until now because of the intervention of the creator, imagine they were squeezed by the Arab countries but were still able to survive, hopefully the war in the Middle East will end quickly and not take any more lives. How beautiful it is that this world is peaceful and prosperous, gradually this world will be destroyed because the actions of humans themselves
Reply
@AmiAsh-bk6rg
6 months ago
This is how the Americans survived the Indians, the same thing with the hands of America how the Palestinians are slowly surviving.
26
Reply
4 replies
@user-lr5hr3wy3f
6 months ago
No matter what happens, children should not suffer! Nowhere and Never!!!!!
15
Reply
1 reply
@Sempervida288
1 month ago
YOU ARE️ IN THE RIGHT SIDE OF HISTORY ️🇵🇸
3
Reply
@EmakMilenia2120
1 month ago (edited)
since 1982 following the Palestinian struggle from Hebrew colonialism, Palestine has nothing to do with the Holocaust, the Palestinian people should not be victims of Jewish immigrants. Before the arrival of Jewish immigrants, they were peaceful and worshiped according to their religion. Peace to Palestine.
Reply
@angesolis1515
6 months ago
thank you for this excellent documentary! I'm going to broadcast it.
16
Reply
1 reply
@ZsbAlbarwani
4 months ago
Free Palestine 🇵🇸 ️️🇵🇸
6
Reply
@knottybogeye6387
1 month ago
Free Palestine.
3
Reply
@Nebillle
9 days ago
It's incredible how Israel took away Palestine's land.
1
Reply
@pa7447
2 months ago (edited)
Huh there were 8 million people starved to death in their own country Ireland 1847-1850. Read about it....by the British government which as you should know is the queen.
46
Reply
8 replies
@mohamedhammad7672
3 months ago
Only one hero, the PALESTINIAN PEOPLE!!! 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
5
Reply
@irinapazmino4313
4 days ago
"I will bless to those who bless you and corse to those who corse you"
Reply
@user-wj3ij9dy9o
6 days ago
Inshallah Palestine will be freedom country ameen summa ameen
Reply
@andrewdeen1
5 months ago
thank you for the upload. are these subs translated from the french subtitle file using AI, is that what these subtitles are? or just translated using youtubes translation?
34
Reply
2 replies
@hayderlafta4214
5 months ago
The film did not address many of the facts that the Palestinian people suffered from.🇮🇶️🇵🇸
25
Reply
4 replies
@belledenuit57
2 weeks ago
Following the Declaration of the Establishment of the State of Israel on 14 May 1948, the Arab League decided to intervene on behalf of Palestinian Arabs, marching their forces into former British Palestine, beginning the main phase of the 1948 Arab–Israeli War.
1
Reply
@tradetonik5169
6 months ago
When we move in with others without being invited, we are generally never welcome,
21
Reply
3 replies
@chilijohny354
6 months ago
Hello, very good report!
On the other hand, it was first released on the channel about 2-3 weeks ago and I started watching it, then the video was deleted from Youtube, before being published again now. Was there a problem the first time?
51
Reply
6 replies
@josephsanchez262
4 days ago
Currently the problem is properly being delt with by IDF hero’s to us real Americans and civilized people around the world
Reply
@frontbattles8090
1 month ago
"complete documentation in German" - Not a single German word.
2
Reply
@anonymousanonymous165
6 months ago (edited)
Very objective film to understand the escalation of violence until today, not everything is so simple when trust is broken and everyone's life is fueled and punctuated by killings with ups and downs...
39
Reply
5 replies
@joellelecomte8763
6 months ago
Support for the Palestinians
11
Reply
1 reply
@mariafigueroa8598
1 month ago
God is with his people ISRAEL GOD BLEES THERE IS NO PLESTINA IN ISRAEL, THEN IS FOR ALL ISREALITES.
Reply
@MC-uj4gd
1 month ago
Finally have a country on somebody’s land.
Reply
@moniquedelaney7958
6 months ago
Support for all people who want peace, Palestinians and Israelis.
15
Reply
@user-ff6wm6my9r
6 months ago
Free Palestine. فلسطين حرة
155
Reply
9 replies
@gracianomendoza8671
1 month ago
There was no Palestinian land ever since. Just wondering why Egypt, Syria or Jordan offer a piece of their land to be a Palestinian country. All they had to do I guess was apply for it with the UN, just like what the Israelites did.
1
Reply
@annabelegan8097
1 month ago
I have been going on 'free Palestine ' marches since the 1970's. The oppression and murder must stop. 🇵🇸 from 🇬🇧
3
Reply
No comments:
Post a Comment