2026-07-23

On Xi Jinping How Xi's Marxist Nationalism is Shaping China and the World : Rudd: Amazon.com.au: Books

On Xi Jinping How Xi's Marxist Nationalism is Shaping China and the World : Rudd: Amazon.com.au: Books




On Xi Jinping How Xi's Marxist Nationalism is Shaping China and the World
by Rudd (Author) Format: Hardcover
4.5 4.5 out of 5 stars (68)

An authoritative account of Xi Jinping's worldview and how it drives Chinese behaviour both domestically and on the world stage. In his new book, On Xi Jinping, former Australian Prime Minister Kevin Rudd provides an authoritative account of the ideological worldview driving Chinese behaviour both domestically and on the world stage--that of President Xi Jinping, who now hold near-total control over the Chinese Communist Party and is now, in effect, president-for-life. Rudd argues that Xi's worldview differs significantly from those of the leaders who preceded him, and that this ideological shift is reflected in the real world of Chinese policy and behaviour. Focusing on China's domestic politics, political economy, and foreign policy, Rudd characterises Xi Jinping's ideological framing of the world as "Marxist-Leninist nationalism." According to Rudd, Xi's notion of Leninism has taken the party and Chinese politics further to the left in comparison to his predecessors. Also, his Marxism has also taken Chinese economic thinking to the left-in a more decisively more statist direction and away from the historical dynamism of the private sector. However, Chinese nationalism under Xi has moved further to the right- towards a much, harder-edged, foreign policy vision of China and a new determination to change the international status quo. Xi's worldview is an integrated one, where his national ideological vision for China's future is ultimately inseparable from his view on China's position in the region and the world. These changes in worldview are also reflected in Xi's broader rehabilitation of the concept of "struggle" as a legitimate concept for the conduct of both Chinese domestic and foreign policy--a struggle that need not necessarily always be peaceful. Finally, Xi's ideological worldview also exhibits a new level of nationalist self-confidence about China's future--derived from China's historical and civilizational strengths but reinforced by his Marxist-Leninist concept of historical determinism and the belief that the tides of history are now on firmly China's side. A powerful analysis of the worldview of arguably the most consequential world leader of our era, this will be essential reading for anyone interested in how Xi is transforming both China and the international order, and, most importantly, why?
Read less
===

==
Review
"Rudd's book helps to better understand a man who is likely to shape China and world politics for a long time to come. Xi takes ideology very seriously. We should do the same." -- Angela Köckritz, Books for the Winter 2024, Table Media
""[An] incisive new book... adds a wealth of context to what animates Xi's grim determination." -- James Kynge, Financial Times
"Essential reading... For British readers, Rudd's book may take work: it's serious scholarship. But it's worth it to make clear that Xi's ideological framework is essential to any assessment of the threat from China...Rudd's warning has never been more timely: "We ignore Xi's clarity of ideological purpose at our peril."" -- Tom Tugendhat, Daily Telegraph
"magnificent...the book is a clarion call for free and open countries to wake up." -- Charles Parton, Spectator
"[A] monumental new take on Xi... [Rudd] understands the system [in China] in ways few of his peers can claim to... [He] is particularly good at showing how the strangely heterodox mixture of ideas from Marx, Mao and, in recent years, Confucius seen in China's domestic politics relate to the outside world." -- Kerry Brown, Times Literary Supplement
"A book of singular importance...It's distinctive, and therefore intensely valuable, and a classically Rudd enterprise because it involved reading, analysing and putting into Chinese and communist context every significant thing Xi has ever said or written." -- Greg Sheridan, The Australian
"Kevin Rudd shows how taking Xi's ideology seriously helps us to better understand Chinese politics and to make policies that reduce the likelihood of conflict." -- Neil Thomas, Australian Book Review
"[Xi Jinping's] worldview is superbly analysed in Kevin Rudd's new book...which should be read by specialists, the public and incoming Trump officials alike." -- Michael Pezzullo, The Strategist
"an essential read" -- Gunjan Singh, Business Standard
"A highly impressive tome - scholarly, authoritative, and surprisingly lucid for such a dense endeavour." -- Sang-Hwa Lee, The Article
"Xi Jinping is one of the most important, but most unknowable leaders of the modern world. Kevin Rudd uses meticulous readings of Chinese sources and deep knowledge of Beijing politics to interpret Xi's thinking in a fascinating and revealing way that is both deeply scholarly and informed by Rudd's own understanding of leadership." -- Rana Mitter, ST Lee Chair in US-Asia Relations, Harvard Kennedy School
"Public servant, prime minister, diplomat, scholar--Kevin Rudd's resume is also a stellar CV for the elite caste of scholar-bureaucrats that managed the Chinese empire for over a millennium. On Xi Jinping focusses the experience of a political practitioner engaged with China since his teenage years to analyse Xi Jinpingâs Party Empire and its global ambitions. Rudd also attempts the seemingly impossible by offering words of guidance and hope in this darkling age." -- Geremie R. BarmÃ(c), editor of the China Heritage
"Understanding Xi Jinping's worldview and what it means for China and us, is more crucial now than ever. Rudd's superb analysis provides the reader with a comprehensive guide to Xi's thinking on domestic policy and global affairs. Rudd takes Xi's words seriously and teases out the consequences: a politics and economics that has moved to the left and a foreign policy that has turned to a form of rightist nationalism. Rudd encapsulates these processes with the phrase 'Marist-Leninist Nationalism.' This work is essential reading for anyone interested in understanding where China has come from, where it is heading and the consequences for all of us." -- Anthony J. Saich, Daewoo Professor of International Affairs, Harvard Kennedy School
"How has Xi Jinping's 'Marxist-Nationalism' shaped China and its relations with the world? No one is better placed than Kevin Rudd to answer these questions, and he does so convincingly in these illuminating pages. This is an essential book for everyone interested in the future of China." -- Joseph S. Nye, Author of A Life in the American Century
"In this book, Kevin Rudd provides all who care about peace a huge service. Drawing on his extraordinary knowledge of China and the Chinese system, Rudd reveals a side of Xi Jinping only comprehensible through his extensive ideological writings--giving us all unique insights into a man upon whom much of the future depends and helping scholars and policymakers alike better understand Xiâs motives and anticipate his actions. A remarkable read!" -- Meghan L. O'Sullivan, Director of the Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs and Jeane Kirpatrick Professor of the Practice of International Affairs, Harvard University's Kennedy School of Government
"Understanding Xi Jinping, his plans for China, and how they will affect the world, is the central challenge for the United States and policymakers everywhere. As a foreign policy practitioner, a scholar, a Chinese language speaker, and a former world leader himself, Kevin Rudd is uniquely well placed to answer the question of what Xi Jinping actually believes. He does so brilliantly by drawing on Chinese primary sources, in-depth research, and a lifetime of experience dealing with China's leadership." -- Stephen J. Hadley, National Security Advisor to President George W. Bush
"A very insightful analysis on Chinese politics, economics, and foreign policy under Xi Jinping's leadership, focusing on the critical role of ideology... a very well written and organised book." -- John West, Australian Outlook
"Best books of 2024: Politics "both entertaining and scholarly" -- Gideon Rachman, Financial Times
"The blend of Marxism and nationalism under Xi's leadership is not just reshaping China-it's a strategy that's impacting geopolitics worldwide." -- S&G Consulting Firm
"On Xi Jinping is a remarkable feat of research, which delivers a clear, compelling argument as to what Xi really believes, and how he plans to remake China and the world." -- Katie Stallard, New Statesman
"The book is an unusual production: a self consciously academic book written by a high-profile practitioner." -- Ian Hall, International Affairs
"Elegantly written" -- Elizabeth Economy, Foreign Affairs
"One of the seminal books on Xi Jinping ... it's essential in terms of understanding the background of Xi and where he comes from and his ideology." -- Erin Olander, The China Global South Project
"Rudd's On Xi Jinping contributes to a growing body of literature that takes ideology seriously in understanding contemporary China." -- Alfred L. Chan, The China Quarterly
Review
"Rudd's book helps to better understand a man who is likely to shape China and world politics for a long time to come. Xi takes ideology very seriously. We should do the same." -- Angela Köckritz, Books for the Winter 2024, Table Media ""[An] incisive new book... adds a wealth of context to what animates Xi's grim determination." -- James Kynge, Financial Times "Essential reading... For British readers, Rudd's book may take work: it's serious scholarship. But it's worth it to make clear that Xi's ideological framework is essential to any assessment of the threat from China...Rudd's warning has never been more timely:"We ignore Xi's clarity of ideological purpose at our peril."" -- Tom Tugendhat, Daily Telegraph "magnificent...the book is a clarion call for free and open countries to wake up." -- Charles Parton, Spectator "[A] monumental new take on Xi... [Rudd] understands the system [in China] in ways few of his peers can claim to... [He] is particularly good at showing how the strangely heterodox mixture of ideas from Marx, Mao and, in recent years, Confucius seen in China's domestic politics relate to the outside world." -- Kerry Brown, Times Literary Supplement "A book of singular importance...It's distinctive, and therefore intensely valuable, and a classically Rudd enterprise because it involved reading, analysing and putting into Chinese and communist context every significant thing Xi has ever said or written." -- Greg Sheridan, The Australian "Kevin Rudd shows how taking Xi's ideology seriously helps us to better understand Chinese politics and to make policies that reduce the likelihood of conflict." -- Neil Thomas , Australian Book Review "[Xi Jinping's] worldview is superbly analysed in Kevin Rudd's new book...which should be read by specialists, the public and incoming Trump officials alike." -- Michael Pezzullo , The Strategist "an essential read" -- Gunjan Singh, Business Standard "A highly impressive tome - scholarly, authoritative, and surprisingly lucid for such a dense endeavour." -- Sang-Hwa Lee, The Article "Xi Jinping is one of the most important, but most unknowable leaders of the modern world. Kevin Rudd uses meticulous readings of Chinese sources and deep knowledge of Beijing politics to interpret Xi's thinking in a fascinating and revealing way that is both deeply scholarly and informed by Rudd's own understanding of leadership." -- Rana Mitter, ST Lee Chair in US-Asia Relations, Harvard Kennedy School "Public servant, prime minister, diplomat, scholar--Kevin Rudd's resume is also a stellar CV for the elite caste of scholar-bureaucrats that managed the Chinese empire for over a millennium. On Xi Jinping focusses the experience of a political practitioner engaged with China since his teenage years to analyse Xi Jinpingâs Party Empire and its global ambitions. Rudd also attempts the seemingly impossible by offering words of guidance and hope in this darkling age." -- Geremie R. Barmé, editor of the China Heritage "Understanding Xi Jinping's worldview and what it means for China and us, is more crucial now than ever. Rudd's superb analysis provides the reader with a comprehensive guide to Xi's thinking on domestic policy and global affairs. Rudd takes Xi's words seriously and teases out the consequences: a politics and economics that has moved to the left and a foreign policy that has turned to a form of rightist nationalism. Rudd encapsulates these processes with the phrase 'Marist-Leninist Nationalism.' This work is essential reading for anyone interested in understanding where China has come from, where it is heading and the consequences for all of us." -- Anthony J. Saich, Daewoo Professor of International Affairs, Harvard Kennedy School "How has Xi Jinping's 'Marxist-Nationalism' shaped China and its relations with the world? No one is better placed than Kevin Rudd to answer these questions, and he does so convincingly in these illuminating pages. This is an essential book for everyone interested in the future of China." -- Joseph S. Nye, Author of A Life in the American Century "In this book, Kevin Rudd provides all who care about peace a huge service. Drawing on his extraordinary knowledge of China and the Chinese system, Rudd reveals a side of Xi Jinping only comprehensible through his extensive ideological writings--giving us all unique insights into a man upon whom much of the future depends and helping scholars and policymakers alike better understand Xiâs motives and anticipate his actions. A remarkable read!" -- Meghan L. O'Sullivan, Director of the Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs and Jeane Kirpatrick Professor of the Practice of International Affairs, Harvard University's Kennedy School of Government "Understanding Xi Jinping, his plans for China, and how they will affect the world, is the central challenge for the United States and policymakers everywhere. As a foreign policy practitioner, a scholar, a Chinese language speaker, and a former world leader himself, Kevin Rudd is uniquely well placed to answer the question of what Xi Jinping actually believes. He does so brilliantly by drawing on Chinese primary sources, in-depth research, and a lifetime of experience dealing with China's leadership." -- Stephen J. Hadley, National Security Advisor to President George W. Bush "A very insightful analysis on Chinese politics, economics, and foreign policy under Xi Jinping's leadership, focusing on the critical role of ideology... a very well written and organised book." -- John West, Australian Outlook "Best books of 2024: Politics "both entertaining and scholarly" -- Gideon Rachman, Financial Times "The blend of Marxism and nationalism under Xi's leadership is not just reshaping China-it's a strategy that's impacting geopolitics worldwide." -- S&G Consulting Firm "On Xi Jinping is a remarkable feat of research, which delivers a clear, compelling argument as to what Xi really believes, and how he plans to remake China and the world." -- Katie Stallard, New Statesman "The book is an unusual production: a self consciously academic book written by a high-profile practitioner." -- Ian Hall, International Affairs "Elegantly written" -- Elizabeth Economy, Foreign Affairs "One of the seminal books on Xi Jinping ... it's essential in terms of understanding the background of Xi and where he comes from and his ideology." -- Erin Olander, The China Global South Project "Rudd's On Xi Jinping contributes to a growing body of literature that takes ideology seriously in understanding contemporary China." -- Alfred L. Chan, The China Quarterly
Read more

Top
About this item
Similar
From the Brand
From the Author
Questions
Reviews
On Xi Jinping How Xi's Marxist Nationalism is Shaping China and the World
On Xi Jinping How Xi's Marxist Nationalism is Shaping China and the World
Product details
Publisher ‏ : ‎ Oxford University Press USA
Publication date ‏ : ‎ 19 December 2024
Language ‏ : ‎ English
Print length ‏ : ‎ 400 pages
ISBN-10 ‏ : ‎ 019776603X
ISBN-13 ‏ : ‎ 978-0197766033
Item weight ‏ : ‎ 1.04 kg
Dimensions ‏ : ‎ 16.41 x 4.19 x 24.08 cm
Best Sellers Rank: 2,612 in Books (See Top 100 in Books)
1 in Nationalism
1 in Fascism
1 in Asian Politics
Customer Reviews: 4.5 4.5 out of 5 stars   (68)
==
From Australia

PaulM
5.0 out of 5 stars Effort Required
Reviewed in Australia on 19 July 2026
Format: KindleVerified Purchase
Reading Rudd’s book can sometimes feel like trudging through mud, but the effort is worth it in getting a better, or perhaps different, Western understanding of what makes China tick, especially under the guiding hand of Xi Jinping. The one concern, despite Rudd’s credentials and apparent expertise, is how far an outsider can really penetrate an opaque system to the very heart of its leadership. His efforts may be likened to reverse-engineering. Accordingly, his book may or may not reflect what actually happens on the inside. Irrespective, a useful read even if all we have is a detailed view from the outside.
Helpful
Report

Inclusivity
5.0 out of 5 stars Worth reading, even if selectively.
Reviewed in Australia on 6 December 2025
Format: HardcoverVerified Purchase
Not a fan of Rudd, at all, but this book is very good. No great revelations, but it does increase one's understanding of what we can see happening. A surprisingly good read.
One person found this helpful
Helpful
Report
From other countries

CarlosCC
5.0 out of 5 stars Muy recomendable
Reviewed in Spain on 21 March 2025
Format: HardcoverVerified Purchase
Un libro que todos aquellos que estén interesados en la geopolítica y sientan interés en ver hacia donde podría ir el mundo en los próximos años, deben leer, puesto que la evolución de la política china nos afectará a todos. El libro está muy bien documentado y Kevin Rudd demuestra ser un experto en la materia. Creo que lo más interesante de este libro es que analizando el pensamiento de Xi Jinping y cómo ha ido evolucionando la política interna y exterior de China desde que llegó al poder, permite predecir como podría seguir esa evolución.
Report
Translate review to English

Denis Timko
5.0 out of 5 stars Collision course
Reviewed in the United States on 22 November 2024
Format: HardcoverVerified Purchase
An exhaustively researched analysis of Xi Jinping and his impact on not only China, but the world itself. A serious book that needs to be read and used as a framework for gaining some insights into how , going forward, China is likely to behave and what to look for as clues about the direction China is taking on the key issues of today. There’s a lot going on. If the US has any real hope of continuing to prosper and provide a safe and secure environment for its citizens it’s important its citizens educate themselves about who they’re dealing with. This book is a great place to start or improve one’s knowledge and awareness of what’s coming down the road. Read it carefully and reflect on what it says.
Report

FRANCISCO XAVIER GONZALEZ GARZA
5.0 out of 5 stars Enigmático.
Reviewed in Mexico on 12 March 2026
Format: HardcoverVerified Purchase
Very interesting...
Report

Niall O'Connor
5.0 out of 5 stars On Contradiction
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 18 April 2025
Format: HardcoverVerified Purchase
An extremely timely and well written introduction to the Xi, for which Rudd has to be warmly congraulated. Nonetheless, I am personally not convinced as regards the conclusions/predictions that Rudd comes to in the book.

Mao’s On Contradiction is clear that contradictions, whether in society or politics, are inherently unpredictable and can never be fully dissected or broken down into simple terms. As Mao puts it, contradictions exist within contradictions, and their resolution is contingent on how these contradictions unfold over time. This process is far from deterministic, meaning that the outcome of any contradiction—whether in politics, economics, or ideology—cannot be known in advance. This is consistent with Badiou's notion of the Event, which suggests that historical developments and political shifts often emerge unexpectedly, defined by radical breaks from the existing order, rather than by gradual, predictable trajectories.

In this light, Rudd’s predictions about Xi’s future actions become problematic. Rudd attempts to forecast China’s trajectory based on a linear interpretation of Xi's Marxist-Leninist ideology, presupposing a level of predictability that contradicts the very dialectical foundations upon which Xi’s ideology rests. By predicting Xi’s moves based on ideological purity or supposed shifts, Rudd overlooks the contingent, evolving nature of Xi's approach.

Xi's own embrace of Marxist-Leninist dialectical thinking involves recognizing that contradictions are fluid, and their resolution is not preordained but determined by dynamic, contingent factors. Xi has famously articulated Marxism-Leninism as the Party’s weapon of thought, suggesting a flexible approach to contradictions that is highly attuned to changing conditions. The strategic decisions Xi makes are contingent upon the evolving dynamics of both internal Chinese politics and the global geopolitical environment. This makes Xi’s political approach inherently unpredictable and marks a clear departure from Rudd’s linear predictions.

For instance, Xi’s handling of China’s relationship with the U.S. during the trade war cannot be fully understood by simply mapping it onto a set of predictive models based on his Marxist-Leninist ideology. Xi’s decisions are, at their core, contingent on unfolding contradictions—domestic and international—and cannot be reduced to an ideological template that predicts a specific course of action. Predictions about Xi’s future behavior that don’t account for this contingent, dialectical unfolding of contradictions miss the core philosophical underpinnings of his thought.

Rudd’s tendency to make specific predictions about Xi’s future moves, particularly in terms of foreign policy and economic strategy, becomes a non-sequitur when viewed through the lens of dialectical materialism. If contradictions are inherently unpredictable, then to claim that Xi will pursue specific strategies based on an ideological framework risks reducing Marxist-Leninist dialectics to a rigid, deterministic system. In reality, the outcome of contradictions is contingent upon historical moments and unforeseen developments—just as Badiou’s Event emphasizes the radical unpredictability of historical shifts.

The dialectical method employed by Xi—echoing Mao’s conception of contradictions—would lead us to understand that Xi’s actions are not the result of inevitable ideological progression but rather the product of a contingent unfolding. Any attempt to predict Xi’s actions with certainty, as Rudd does, neglects the fluidity of the contradictions in play, the potential for radical shifts, and the unpredictable nature of the political landscape. Therefore, Rudd’s predictions about Xi’s trajectory can be seen as a philosophical misstep, given the inherent contingency and unpredictability at the heart of Xi's dialectical Marxist-Leninist framework.

Rudd’s thesis falls short because it misunderstands the dialectical nature of Xi’s Marxist-Leninism, reducing it to a deterministic framework that allows for specific predictions about future actions. However, as Mao’s On Contradiction and Badiou's notion of the Event make clear, contradictions and their resolution are inherently contingent, unpredictable, and subject to radical breaks rather than gradual developments. This makes Rudd’s predictions about Xi’s future policy moves not just problematic, but a philosophical non-sequitur, given the dialectical and contingent nature of Marxist-Leninist thought as embraced by Xi. Understanding Xi’s leadership requires more than ideological analysis or predictive forecasting; it demands an appreciation of the unpredictability of political decisions and the contingent nature of the contradictions that define both Chinese domestic politics and global geopolitics.
Report

Mauricio
5.0 out of 5 stars Must read to understand China
Reviewed in Belgium on 20 June 2026
Format: HardcoverVerified Purchase
In depth amazing analysis of Xi and his grab on the other world power.
Report

Laetitia Strauch-Bonart
5.0 out of 5 stars Le livre pour comprendre Xi
Reviewed in France on 10 February 2025
Format: KindleVerified Purchase
Un ouvrage impressionnant par son exhaustivité et sa fluidité.
Report
Translate review to English

RoW
5.0 out of 5 stars Great read
Reviewed in the Netherlands on 3 July 2026
Format: HardcoverVerified Purchase
Great read
Report

Alexander Zabezhinsky
5.0 out of 5 stars The best book to understand modern China
Reviewed in the United States on 28 October 2024
Format: HardcoverVerified Purchase
The most in-depth book on politics, economics and governance in China. Presents quite clearly the change that has happened and continues to happen in China under the leadership of Xi. Few people in the West know and understand China as deeply as Kevin Rudd. I am personally in the world of investments and the book clearly sets out for me the concept regarding investments in China.
Report

A. Menon
4.0 out of 5 stars A perspective on Xi Xinping's domestic move to the left
Reviewed in the United States on 25 March 2025
Format: KindleVerified Purchase
On Xi Jinping is Kevin Rudd's second book on China and its leadership's priorities in the last few years. This work is an extension of his Doctoral Thesis he recently submitted on the study of Xi Jinping and his ideological priorities of expanding Marxist-Leninism within the Party while also moving China to the right on a foreign policy agenda. It is a very thorough work surveying the public works of Xi as well as inclusive of diplomatic commentary on the change of nature in diplomatic encounters with China. It is largely a work of academic political science and so is quite dry to read at times. Overall the book contains a thorough message that China's ideological move to the left is both substantial and will be persistent under Xi with all moves away from this direction ultimately being tactical. It also contains the message that China's international ambitions will continue to grow as its domestic strength has and its belief in its own wisdom for global governance norms will be on display to a greater and more forceful degree than the past.

On Xi Jinping is an expansive book covering most aspects of Xi Jinping thought and how it influences governance through 16 chapters. The author begins with a historical overview of what he is discussing and what the terminology definitions are. There is a long legacy of Marxist intellectual infrastructure which is used by the party to frame its policy initiatives as well as the framework for analyzing history. The author thus discusses dialectic materialism and the role of contradictions for framing the Party's world view and in particular Xi Jinping's views on the current challenges China faces as a function of its past decisions. The longer cycles of history are thus more deeply embedded in Xi's ideology than the business cycle focus of much of the West at the expense of coherent long term strategy. One novel quote which the author clears up as an effective mis-quote is that by Zhou Enlai when asked about the French Revolution with the response being we need more time to assess in which Zhou was apparently assuming the query was about recent French protests rather than the French Revolution. The author moves in to how China's world view started to measurably change under Xi with increased clampdowns domestically followed by more abrasive behavior externally. These were a distinct shifts marked a break from the operating model under Deng and inherited by Hu and Jiang Zemin. Domestically the increased materialism and inequality inducing growth that was introduced in the reform periods was deemed to have gone too far and relying on the Marxist historical analysis framework was leading to new contradictions which needed to be addressed. Xi in particular felt that the party's credibility was deeply at risk by the rising corruption within the party and the growing inequality in society. The response to this was a dramatic anti-corruption and rectification agenda that continues to this day.

These beliefs about the causes of China's growing domestic incoherence with the original governing philosophy of the party led to a significant re-orientation of priorities to embedding the state back into the economy more aggressively and containing the animal spirits of the private sector. The book details all that went into this and at some level Xi tried to address much of the concerns that are prevalent everywhere but with little concern or regret for all of the unintended consequences of trying to re-engineer the political economy. This is deemed to be a necessary evil and as such is a core message of the book, the actions being taken are ideological over practical and the beliefs of Xi are driven by ideology rather than results. Of course the leadership pays attention to results but only to adjust tactically and there is an acknowledgement that the adjustment will be painful but inescapable. This is the main takeaway but it is also not particularly insightful as it is where the consensus is and has been for 2 years now.

The author moves on to the move to the right on promotion of nationalism and projection of power abroad. This is another multi year and multi-faceted agenda to increase the role of China in governing world affairs. Here the author argues that China under Xi is trying to re-orient the global governance structure away from US centric and towards one where China's wisdom is deferred to and it's interests are not contested. The author includes personal discussions with diplomats on their real world analysis of the changing diplomatic exchanges with China and the increased abrasiveness of them.

Overall there are several different weaved aspects of how Xi's governing philosophy is affecting how China interacts with itself and with the world that are to the left from the Deng era domestically and to the right globally with the rise of nationalism. This is deeply strategic under Xi and tactical deviations are merely to manage a path but the ideologically determined strategic goals will not waver under Xi. After many years of managing mini-crisis with partial resolutions being the norm, most people see this as obvious now and those hoping for any dramatic shift back to greater market involvement and westernization are dismissed easily. As such this book is largely just summarizing from a political philosophy perspective why the agenda has been set as it has and how to interpret it. From that lens it is an informative read.
Report

ML
4.0 out of 5 stars In-Depth Review of Xi Jinping Ideology and Policies But Repetitive
Reviewed in the United States on 13 May 2025
Format: KindleVerified Purchase
I really enjoyed the first half or so of this book, up through his interviews with anonymous ex ambassadors and officials from countries outside China. The best parts of this book are the excerpts from Xi’s many speeches and papers. After the ambassador recap, however, the narrative became largely repetitive of themes, analysis, and conclusions that had been well established in the preceding chapters. I took a star off my rating for this, but would still recommend the book.
Report
To see more,  search o
==

==

==

==

The Souls of China: The Return of Religion After Mao : Johnson, Ian: Amazon.com.au: Books

The Souls of China: The Return of Religion After Mao : Johnson, Ian: Amazon.com.au: Books




Read sample


Follow the author

Ian JohnsonIan Johnson
Follow



The Souls of China: The Return of Religion After Mao
by Ian Johnson (Author) Format: Paperback
4.5 4.5 out of 5 stars (143)

The human story of the vast changes now transforming China, with religion sweeping up millions of people in ways which are a profound threat to the Communist Party.

In no society on Earth was there such a ferocious attempt to eradicate all trace of religion as in modern China. But now, following a century of violent antireligious campaigns, China is awash with new temples, churches, and mosques - as well as cults, sects, and politicians trying to harness religion for their own ends. Driving this explosion of faith is uncertainty - over what it means to be Chinese, and how to live an ethical life in a country that discarded traditional morality and is still searching for new guideposts.

The Souls of China is the result of some fifteen years of studying and travelling around China. The message of Ian Johnson's extraordinary book is that China is now experiencing a 'Great Awakening' on a vast scale. Everywhere long-suppressed religions are rebuilding, often in new forms, and reshaping the values and behaviours of entire communities.
===

Review

A lively and fascinating book by a veteran chronicler of grassroots China... a humane portrait of Chinese society that reveals more about everyday life in China than any political text — Amy Hawkins, The Guardian

Ian Johnson has long been a resourceful and bracing guide to the biggest national transformation of modern history. In
The Souls of China he masterfully opens up a little explored realm: how the quest for religion and spirituality drives hundreds of millions of Chinese — Pankaj Mishra

Johnson succeeds in having produced a nuanced group portrait of Chinese citizens striving for non-material answers in an era of frenetic materialism. — Julia Lovell, Guardian

Extraordinarily rich and intimate... This vividly written, deeply researched book will be the primary work about religious faith in China for years to come. — Leslie T. Chang

This entrancing and engaging book challenges the modern assumption that religion is a thing of the past — Karen Armstrong

Ian Johnson
breaks new ground with a brilliant approach, mixing theoretical explorations with real life vignettes from a convincing insider-outsider-combined perspective, making them commenting each other, illuminating in the same way as through the traditional Chinese criticism paradigm of 'I commentate the six classics which commentate me.' The Souls of China is a must read for an understanding of China — Qiu Xiaolong, author of The Inspector Chen Novels

The great Chinese writer Lu Xun once wrote that when many men pass along the same way, a new road is made.
The Souls of China shows us how the Chinese people, some with heroic steps and others with hesitant ones, are making a new road for Chinese religion in the twenty-first century. The reappearance and flourishing of religion is perhaps the most surprising aspect of the dramatic changes in China in recent decades. With great sensitivity Ian Johnson guides us on a tour of the rituals, festivals, and above all some of the remarkable characters who make up this new Chinese religious world. This is a beautiful, moving and insightful book — Michael Szonyi, author of Cold War Island

The Souls of China is a rich, informative, and timely book, which explores a major aspect of Chinese life. Ian Johnson carries erudition lightly and describes the people and events with deep insights and personal involvement. Section by section, the writing shows long-term dedication and meticulous research. At heart this is also a personal book, full of feelings and exuberance. It's a tremendous accomplishment — Ha Jin

His tripartite masterpiece Wild Grass and his newest book, The Souls of China, are the most remarkable works to come from a western author in the past two decades. — Liao Yiwu, exiled Chinese author of God is Red: The Secret Story of How Christianity Survived and Flourished in Communist China

Through interviews conducted with a wide variety of practitioners, Johnson paints a vivid picture of the diversity of Chinese religious life....He provides a fascinating account of how traditional activities recovered after enduring severe repression during China's Cultural Revolution (1966-76). An excellent work that is highly recommended for readers interested in Chinese culture or religion — Library Journal

About the Author

Ian Johnson is a Pulitzer Prize winning correspondent for The New York Times and The New York Review of Books. He has spent about half of the past thirty years in China, first as a student and then as a correspondent. He is also an advising editor for The Journal of Asian Studies and teaches on religion in China. He is the author of two other books that also focus on the intersection of politics and religion: Wild Grass: Three Stories of Change in China, and A Mosque in Munich: Nazis, the CIA, and the Rise of the Muslim Brotherhood in the West. He splits his time between Beijing and Berlin.

Product details

  • ASIN ‏ : ‎ B01MRVTUYR
  • Publisher ‏ : ‎ Penguin
  • Accessibility ‏ : ‎ Learn more

From other countries

Jean Shen
5.0 out of 5 stars A very important book, a China classic that is key to understanding this superpower today
Reviewed in the United States on 12 June 2017
Verified Purchase
A masterpiece of reportage by one of the best reporters of China today.

Ian Johnson tackles the issue at the heart of present-day Chinese society: its lost moral compass. This is, at base, a defining characteristic of Chinese society which is still dealing with the long legacy of the Cultural Revolution and decades of this political culture. Ostensibly about religion, this book goes much deeper -- really into what makes China tick.

The China he describes with great detail, unique empathy derived from his speaking Chinese, his cultural affinity, and real immersion in the laobaixing / regular Chinese people's lives, is one locals will recognise and acknowledge is accurate. He goes deep into documenting how different groups of Chinese now are searching for a pathway out of this moral malaise, offering a heartening portrait of how China might change in time to come. This search for values will define the next chapter of life in and the behaviour of this super power. Johnson is a solid and warm, empathetic guide who takes us to meet the characters he got to know over years of reporting in pockets of China that even many of us who live here might not have encountered.

Reading this book is key to really understanding China -- its society, political life, foreign policy behaviour. It really does offer a window into this complex country's soul.

The depth of his reporting, the lyricism in his writing are unparalleled among China-based English language writers today. Very few really have invested as much time -- and emotion -- in understanding China from the very grassroots.

I can't recommend this important book highly enough. I think it will prove to be a classic in China reporting, as was Johnson's previous book Wild Grass. The book and its writing feel understated in many ways, but it really is very valuable in making sense of what China is and where it's going.

It will also be of broader interest to non-China watchers -- for those interested in religion, sociology, politics -- for it is a portrait of a society grasping with massive transformation, being lost and trying to find new ways forward.
Report

Alex
5.0 out of 5 stars recomendado
Reviewed in Spain on 23 February 2025
Format: PaperbackVerified Purchase
Buena lectura, para procesar con calma si no se tiene el background necesario. Aunque se me hace neceario contrastar con otros puntos de vista.
Report
Translate review to English

Amazon Customer
5.0 out of 5 stars Fantastic insight
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 15 July 2021
Format: KindleVerified Purchase
Fantastically detailed, humble and compassionate insight into beliefs and practices in modern China. Brilliantly written, thoroughly researched, thoughtful and engaging.
Report

dragonworks
5.0 out of 5 stars GREAT BOOK
Reviewed in Canada on 10 November 2023
Verified Purchase
It's been a long time since I've read something this well written. It felt like a documentary in my head. Full of colour, noise, laughter, tears, emotion and pragmatism. Gave me joy, made me think. I feel I, too, know all these people he met. I cannot praise it too highly.
Report

Philip Fang
5.0 out of 5 stars A Must-Read Masterpiece on Contemporary Chinese Culture and Its Ordinary People
Reviewed in the United States on 22 June 2017
Format: HardcoverVerified Purchase
As a busy academic, I hardly read a book word by word. Ian Johnson’s The Souls of China, however, is one of those books that I’m willing to read so closely. This book will help you better understand – even challenge your old knowledge on – what “religion” is, what China is, and how contemporary faith is practiced by ordinary Chinese people.

The topic of the book – religion – is heavy, but the book itself is easy to read. Johnson strategically chooses three groups of ordinary people to tell a consistent story – the spiritual revival after Mao – that is big enough to reflect the “soul(s)” of contemporary China. Many readers might have read much about Chinese “Culture” (with a capitalized C), but very few books in the market do a good job detailing how Chinese “Culture” is perceived and practiced in everyday life and thus become Chinese cultures that really matter for most ordinary people. In his sophisticated writing, Johnson presents us Chinese religious beliefs through the Ni family in Beijing that makes an annual pilgrimage to a Buddhist temple that worships Our Lady of the Azure Clouds, the Li family in Shanxi that practices a form of family-based Daoism and folk religion, and a group of Protestant Christians in a house church in Chengdu led by a charismatic preacher Wang Yi. These stories Johnson brilliantly narrates in the book are so intriguing that I sometimes thought I was interacting with these people directly.

Johnson shows his wisdom from the mundane details of ordinary people’s everyday lives. He is humble and respects every person in this book, which is part of the reason why this book is so original, so special and so touching. By showing that ordinary people in China can understand “infinitely more,” Johnson allows them to speak, in their own words, about how they actively seek faith to transform and fulfill their lives on their own, instead of being led, aimlessly, by the vague slogans of the Party and the radical changes brought by modernity and globalization.

As a Chinese scholar in the West, I have been trained to criticize other colleagues’ works. But The Souls of China is so insightful that I have to drop my weapons and give it my highest compliments. I have to admit that I’ve learned a lot about my country and my people from this book. A good journalist is also a lay sociologist; Johnson is too good to be an ethnographer, as he can always easily fit into Chinese communities and provide his readers the best observations.

No matter how much you know about China – from a knowledgeable scholar of China Studies to a lay reader who is recently planning your first trip to China – you will find this book original, enjoyable, informative, intriguing, smart, and sometimes “as surprising as cold water running through your back.”
Report

Dilly Doe
5.0 out of 5 stars Engaging book that mixes personal perspectives from worshipers with history, politics, spirituality
Reviewed in Canada on 19 March 2019
Format: HardcoverVerified Purchase
Great book for all those interested in religion in China. I think this would be an especially good book for young foreign born Chinese or children of the Chinese diaspora that want to learn more about the religion of their ancestors and the modern landscape of religion in China today. A bit more geographically diverse coverage would be appreciated though since the book mostly focuses on people and religion n the North and very little in the South, but otherwise it is very engaging.
Report

Peter Donald
3.0 out of 5 stars a fascinating insight into religions in China
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 15 August 2025
Verified Purchase
Nicely written, but quite hard work to read
Report

Amazon Customer
4.0 out of 5 stars Great
Reviewed in the United States on 16 May 2017
Format: HardcoverVerified Purchase
Great Book
Report

M. L. Asselin
5.0 out of 5 stars A Solid, Engaging Book on the State of Religion in China Today
Reviewed in the United States on 20 November 2017
Format: HardcoverVerified Purchase
We’ve seen several academic books about religion in contemporary China in recent years, but this look at Chinese religious practice by the American journalist Ian Johnson is both well researched and highly accessible. Like other books by journalists living in China, “Souls of China” features first-hand accounts that bring a kind of intimacy and immediacy that the general reader finds engaging. In Johnson’s book, these passages are not ends in themselves, but serve to illustrate Johnson’s thesis about the state of religion in China today. When he joins in on a Buddhist pilgrimage or a Protestant Christmas Eve service, Johnson reveals a society hungry for meaning beyond that which a free market and Communist ideology can provide. “I know there’s something bigger than us that guides us,” says one of his subjects (p. 174).

Johnson says that the aspirations of the people in his book can be summarized by the word “Tian” or “Heaven.” By this he means that they seek justice and respect, and a well-ordered society. The author goes on to say that this yearning for justice, order, and meaning may help transform Chinese society, perhaps not in the way that Buddhism and Taoism transformed Taiwan into a democracy, but that in the long-term will influence China to embrace shared universal values and morality. President Xi, who has demonstrated a willingness to be heavy-handed in his control of Chinese society, at the same time seems comfortable with a certain level of religious practice, so long as the religion being practiced has Chinese characteristics and is overseen by one of the state bodies regulating religion (p. 356). In general, this means that Christianity, and especially Catholicism, have not fared well against the state apparatus. Nonetheless, the tolerance for some things religious has given all religious expressions a little more latitude than they may have had before.

When it comes to Western-derived religions, Johnson devotes most of his space to Protestant sects; Protestantism, because it is decentralized and isn’t tied to a foreign base of influence, is thriving relative to the state-controlled Catholic Church, with its suspicious Vatican ties. It’s unfortunate there isn’t more on Catholicism given the rich history of the Catholic Church in China. (Johnson subsequently wrote about the Catholic Church in China in the Jesuit periodical, America, October 2, 2017.) You won’t find much about Islam in “Souls of China,” either.

That being said, I truly enjoyed reading this book. Johnson is a fine stylist, his research is solid, and his understanding of Chinese culture refined. His explanation of the rise of religion in China today is very convincing. Moreover, his candor and respectfulness in dealing with his subjects makes this a very humane work, one that makes you care about the people he describes. In short, this is one of the best overall non-academic books on contemporary China and Chinese culture available in English.
Report

Chinese learner
5.0 out of 5 stars Critically important work
Reviewed in the United States on 6 July 2017
Format: HardcoverVerified Purchase
I have been following Ian Johnson's work on China for several years and have always been impressed with his insights into not only Chinese society but also to Chinese as individuals. "Souls" is a critically important work for China watchers - and for anyone is trying to understand the world's oldest and most populous civilization. It chronicles in a very personal way the reemergence of traditional Chinese values in the context of the country's breakneck pace of economic development. The well recognized "spiritual vacuum" created by China's economic rise is being filled by individual, and communal, searches for deeper meaning in life. Johnson describes well how these searches are leading to both renewal of traditional practices of Buddhist, and Daoism and legitimate growth of Christian, especially evangelical, communities. He also brings his years of living in China and extensive personal contacts to a critical view of how the Chinese government's religious policy.

"Souls" was well worth the full price I paid for the hardback; something I have never done before with Amazon.
Report

Charlene Fu
5.0 out of 5 stars Brilliantly researched, reported, structured and written
Reviewed in the United States on 10 January 2019
Format: HardcoverVerified Purchase
This book was brilliantly done. I was in absolute awe of the reporting that went into it. As a former Associated Press foreign correspondent whose time in Beijing overlapped with the author's, I know better than most readers what is involved in gathering that much first-hand material for a book of such breadth and depth and insight. AND, on top of that, the structure of the book was a stroke of genius, and the writing was captivating and engaging. I read it the summer it first came out and was too busy at the time to write a review. I recently purchased the book as Christmas presents for my mom and a friend, and decided it was time to add a review, especially because one of the main characters -- the Christian house church pastor Wang Yi -- and his church have just in recent months come under incredible persecution. The response of this pastor and his congregation has been so inspiring, and reading this book helps to explain why and how they are able to remain steadfast in their faith. I could not recommend this book more highly.
Report

Gordo
5.0 out of 5 stars A Behind-the-Scenes Look at Religion in China
Reviewed in the United States on 25 June 2017
Format: HardcoverVerified Purchase
This is a fascinating book. Johnson takes the reader "behind the scenes" of the practice of religion in China, following individuals and groups as they live out their faith lives. He gains privileged access to Buddhists, Christians, Daoists, and practitioners of folk religion, watches them worship, and allows them to speak for themselves throughout the book. While weaving their stories together, he also paints a broader picture of the state of religion in China and the government's approach to religion over recent years. He also looks at phenomena that western observers may not know a lot about: Qigong, Falun Gong and Eastern Lightning. While not a history book per se, it captures the present moment of religion in China. The only critique I had was the lack of focus on Islam and Catholicism. It is written in a similar style to other "China books" by authors like Peter Hessler and Evan Osnos - if you've enjoyed those books, you'll enjoy this book too.
Report

Frederick Holmes, M.D.
5.0 out of 5 stars Very thoughtful review of China's five officially acknowledged religions: ...
Reviewed in the United States on 5 August 2017
Format: HardcoverVerified Purchase
Very thoughtful review of China's five officially acknowledged religions: Buddhism, Daoism, Protestantism, Catholicism, and Islam. The focus is largely on the return of these faiths in China since the death of Mao Tse Tung in 1976. Along with Confucianism Mao abolished all five in the 1950s. Johnson's main argument is that after Mao's death the Chinese government allowed religion to flourish - though cautiously - because its people needed systems that provided a moral foundation for their lives. Daoism gets the most coverage because it is the oldest religion in China and is uniquely Chinese. Protestantism - divided between the government's officially managed churches and the tolerated independent churches - is growing rapidly. Catholicism lags behind in growth because the government is wary of a faith with a strong foreign allegiance. Ian Johnson writes with authority because he has lived in China and is fluent in the Chinese language.
Report

Charles
5.0 out of 5 stars a well-written and well-searched high-quality book
Reviewed in the United States on 8 May 2017
Verified Purchase
as a Chinese, when i first picked up his book, i was amazed by his approach. the book started with the lunar calendar, i was carious about what this book is about, isn't it about all forms of religions in China? kept on reading it, you will gradually find all connection. this, I believe, is a smart move, and a nice approach. it would, to certain degrees, wisely explain those folk religions which have been regarded as superstition from 1949. as a Chinese, Ian used lots of poems, ancient books, some of them, the Chinese people would be familiar. all the translation are precise. i think, more importantly, this book would enlighten people to have better understanding of China, not only about its people, its politics, its society and the ongoing events, but more in depth. however, Ian is slightly optimistic... it is a great book about contemporary China, worthy of buying and reading, if the readers want to know more.
Report

William Nee
5.0 out of 5 stars Excellent book that captures dramatic social changes in China
Reviewed in the United States on 29 December 2017
Format: HardcoverVerified Purchase
China watchers can easily get tired of books and articles that rehash top line macro trends about China’s contested economic data, dismal demographic trends, unfettered consumerism, and the worrying orientation of the Communist Party. In this sense, veteran journalist Ian Johnson’s “The Souls of China” - a book about the resurgence of religion in China - is refreshingly different.

With an eye akin to a well trained anthropologist, but the pen of an engaging novelist, Johnson profiles a warm family of folk religion pilgrims in Beijing, a diligent family carrying on traditional Daoist funeral services in Shanxi, a vibrant congregation of Protestants in Chengdu, and various Buddhist and qigong masters.

Johnson writes with clear empathy for his subjects, who in their drive for justice, their striving for community building, and desire for spiritual growth, help give even the most jaded some newfound reasons for hope.
Report

Russell O. Redman
5.0 out of 5 stars Faith is alive and struggling in China.
Reviewed in the United States on 25 August 2019
Verified Purchase
Officially, the People's Republic of China is an atheist state. Under Mao, that atheism was enforced with all the power of the state. Monasteries were bulldozed or converted into factories, monks and priests were forced to recant, and religious literature was burned. After Mao, however, the deep need of the people for purpose in their lives led to a reawakening of religion. This books looks at contemporary Chinese faith through the lives of the people who practice it. It focuses on Daoism, Buddhism, and Christianity, to understand how these religions have survived the challenges of modern life, and why some of them are flourishing.
Report

lynnette wright
5.0 out of 5 stars but he delivers a great deal more than a snapshot or series of snapshots
Reviewed in the United States on 30 March 2018
Format: HardcoverVerified Purchase
A sort of Canterbury Tales meets the New York Times. Ian Johnson is a journalist, to be sure, but he delivers a great deal more than a snapshot or series of snapshots. The book is filled with humor, compassion, insight and honesty. Johnson's voice is masterfully consistent and never became the story. I did not begin the book with a comprehensive China orientation but was engaged and captivated from the start. The book was far more personal and compelling than any stale academic exercise in cultural anthropology. This is a timely must read for those who seek context. I look forward to Johnson's next.
Report

Yun Rou
5.0 out of 5 stars a genuine masterwork
Reviewed in the United States on 3 May 2017
Format: HardcoverVerified Purchase
I am going to keep this review short for fear of gushing over the writer's masterful prose, grit and clarity both, and the broad conceptual umbrella he spreads over developments in China that would take a smorgasbord of academic essays to cover. Suffice to say Mr. Johnson has both the breadth of intellect to see what's going on in macro terms and the compassionate humanity and insight to make his observations personal, tangible, and memorable. Despite my voracious appetite for books about Chinese culture, history, and philosophy, I can't say I've ever read a better one. If you want to understand rarely covered but real and important undercurrents in China today, buy this book and devour it.
Report

ward serrill
5.0 out of 5 stars Fascinating Book!
Reviewed in the United States on 29 August 2022
Format: HardcoverVerified Purchase
Ian Johnson's account of the contemporary spiritual soul of China is absolutely fascinating. Written from a talented journalist's eye for story and character, it is a captivating and illuminating journey into a China little known or understood outside the country.
Report

Carol R.
5.0 out of 5 stars Helped me understand my experience in China
Reviewed in the United States on 28 December 2017
Format: HardcoverVerified Purchase
In May 2017, my husband and I went to China to visit churches where his grandparents served as missionaries in the 1920s and 1930s. After we returned, a friend tipped us off about this book. As I read it, I had a lot of "aha" moments - "Yes, I remember seeing that;" and "so that's why ..." The writing and insights are superb, but for me this was also a personally illuminating and delightful read that helped me understand my experience better.
Report

C. M. Clarke
5.0 out of 5 stars A badly needed objective look at the state of religion in China today
Reviewed in the United States on 24 September 2017
Format: HardcoverVerified Purchase
Johnson has written a fascinating and much needed book on the state of religion and its plight in today's China. Most people think of "communist" China, but China has more Muslims than Saudi Arabia, one of the largest Christian communities in the world, and a vast, enduring, and intricate array of native and "Asian" religions. Johnson contributes mightily to describing this vital part of Chinese life.
Report

Alberto Buzzola
5.0 out of 5 stars What does religion really mean to the people of China.
Reviewed in the United States on 7 August 2023
Format: HardcoverVerified Purchase
A must read if you want to understand what religion really means to Chinese people.
Report

rgmississippi
5.0 out of 5 stars What a wonderful book
Reviewed in the United States on 28 June 2020
Verified Purchase
Its many vignettes, running down three story lines, compose an image rather than a theme.
When you come to the end, and especially the reburial in Chapter 29, you understand more about our Chinese neighbors than you would have imagined. Quite wonderful.
Report

Retired Shipbuilder
5.0 out of 5 stars Really slow reporting
Reviewed in the United States on 29 January 2019
Verified Purchase
Someone from my church teaches in China. With the coming of the societal grading for each individual, I decided to do some research. Another reviewer characterized the book as "slow reporting". It seems to be a perfect technique, but understanding a completely different society is way beyond my ability, but this book helps.
Report

Julie S.
5.0 out of 5 stars Excellent treatment and presentation of status of religion in post-Mao ...
Reviewed in the United States on 1 September 2017
Format: HardcoverVerified Purchase
Excellent treatment and presentation of status of religion in post-Mao China. Johnson deftly weaves a lot of history into his narrative about China's search for "core values" since the destructiveness of the Cultural Revolution.
Report

GBaker
5.0 out of 5 stars A Must Read for China Scholars
Reviewed in the United States on 2 August 2017
Format: HardcoverVerified Purchase
Very well researched and insightful into what is happening to "the souls of China." Serious students of today's China need to read and understand the dynamics that the author has reported.
Report

Hailey Dumeny
5.0 out of 5 stars Arrived on time!
Reviewed in the United States on 7 November 2021
Verified Purchase
Perfect book for college students arrived on time!
Report

BillinBoston
5.0 out of 5 stars Deep insights, wonderfully written
Reviewed in the United States on 17 January 2018
Verified Purchase
Ian Johnson combines deep personal experience with the religious groups he discusses, knowledge of history, a broad understanding of contemporary China, and wonderful writing to produce a magnificent book.
Report

Amazon Customer
1.0 out of 5 stars A deep analysis of Chinese cultural, political and religious interplay, perhaps but awfully written and rambling all the way.
Reviewed in the United States on 30 January 2020
Verified Purchase
The author apparently is an China expert with many years of studying the people and society but his effort to convey the current interplay between the old and the new and the religious and cultural scene under a godless communist system is not successful, at least not to most readers. It is so boringly told that few can muster two chapters. I muscled through the whole book hoping some revealing and inspiring passages will eventually appeared but was disappointed. Should have quit after chapter three.
Report

Roxie's mom
5.0 out of 5 stars Inclusive and penetrating
Reviewed in the United States on 6 August 2017
Verified Purchase
Extensively researched. The intimate insights gathered in conversations with various characters lightened and brightened this book.
Report

Gail Pellett
5.0 out of 5 stars The search for meaning and identity
Reviewed in the United States on 5 August 2017
Verified Purchase
Essential to understanding the space that many Chinese are seeking to find identity, meaning, truth and morality.
Report

Samuel Gregg Smyrl
5.0 out of 5 stars Five Stars
Reviewed in the United States on 5 May 2017
Format: HardcoverVerified Purchase
Well written. Gave me a lot of information about the current Faith experience in China
Report

Rev. Luther C. Pierce
5.0 out of 5 stars Five Stars
Reviewed in the United States on 8 September 2017
Format: HardcoverVerified Purchase
An important study as we interact with China in our world
Report

Yue Seong Swee
5.0 out of 5 stars Getting back the souls ...
Reviewed in the United States on 19 July 2017
Verified Purchase
A great insight to what's happening in China.
Report

Amazon Customer
5.0 out of 5 stars Five Stars
Reviewed in the United States on 31 August 2017
Verified Purchase
Fantastic book, meticulous reportage, wonderful detail.
Report

Michael L. Friedmann
5.0 out of 5 stars Great and valuable book on an important subject.
Reviewed in the United States on 31 August 2017
Format: HardcoverVerified Purchase
Compelling, important book.
Report

Douglas W. Holmes
5.0 out of 5 stars Five Stars
Reviewed in the United States on 27 June 2017
Format: HardcoverVerified Purchase
thought provoking
Report
To see m





일본의 맑스주의 역사학 マルクス主義という経験: 1930-40年代日本の歴史学>

일본의 맑스주의 역사학  マルクス主義という経験: 1930-40年代日本の歴史学>

2008년 4월에 출간된 《마르크스주의라는 경험: 1930~40년대 일본의 역사학(マルクス主義という経験: 1930-40年代日本の歴史学)》이라는 역사학 학술서입니다.
📚 도서 기본 정보
  • 엮은이: 이소마에 준이치(磯前順一) 및 해리 D. 하루투니안(Harry D. Harootunian) 공동 편집
  • 출판사: 아오키 서점(青木書店)
  • 출간일: 2008년 4월 1일
  • 페이지 수: 376페이지
🔍 주요 내용 및 특징
  • 핵심 주제: 1930년대부터 1940년대까지 마르크스주의가 일본의 역사 서술 및 역사학 연구에 미친 영향과 흔적을 추적합니다.
  • 학술적 가치: 국가 중심의 역사관(내셔널 히스트리)을 넘어서려 했던 당대 마르크스주의 역사학의 가능성을 재조명합니다.
  • 구성 내용: 전후 역사학의 기원, 국체의 기원과 마르크스주의 역사학, 종교·문화론과의 관계, 식민지 시기 조선의 마르크스주의 사학(백남운의 《조선사회경제사》 등)을 다룬 다채로운 논문들이 수록되어 있습니다.
===

<マルクス主義という経験: 1930-40年代日本の歴史学> (마르크스주의라는 경험: 1930~40년대 일본의 역사학)에 대한 요약 및 평론을 작성한다.

1. 책의 기본 정보 및 배경

이 책은 1930년대부터 1940년대에 이르는 전간기 및 태평양 전쟁기 일본 역사학계에서 마르크스주의 사상이 어떻게 수용되고, 변용되며, 학문적·지적 자산으로 정착했는지를 다룬 연구서이다. 1930년대 일본은 치안유지법의 강화와 국가주의 사상의 폭주로 인해 좌익 운동과 마르크스주의에 대한 탄압이 극에 달했던 시기이다. 많은 지식인이 전향(轉向)을 강요받았으며, 표면적으로 마르크스주의 정치 운동은 완전히 궤멸한 것처럼 보였다.

그러나 본 서는 정치 운동으로서의 마르크스주의가 탄압받은 이후에도, 지적 방법론이자 역사 인식의 틀로서의 '마르크스주의'가 일본 근대 역사학의 형성 과정에 얼마나 깊은 흔적을 남겼는가에 주목한다. 마르크스주의는 단지 파기되어야 할 과격 사상이 아니라, 일본 지식인들이 자국의 역사와 사회 구조를 과학적으로 분석하기 위해 통과해야만 했던 결정적 '경험'이었다는 점을 역사학사(歷史學史)적 관점에서 입증하고자 한다.

2. 핵심 내용 요약

(1) 일본 자본주의 논쟁과 역사학의 방법론적 확립

1920년대 후반부터 1930년대 초반까지 전개된 '일본 자본주의 논쟁'은 강좌파(講座派)와 노농파(勞農派)의 대립을 축으로 진행되었다. 이 논쟁은 단순한 정치적 노선 투쟁을 넘어, 일본 역사를 보는 실증적· theoretical 한 분석 틀을 제공했다. 강좌파의 <일본자본주의발달사강좌>는 메이지 유신의 성격, 봉건적 잔재의 평가, 자본주의 발전 단계 등을 역사적 사료와 경제 통계를 바탕으로 입증하려 했다.

이 과정에서 마르크스주의 유물사관은 근대 일본 역사학에 '구조적 분석'과 '발전 단계론'이라는 과학적 방법론을 이식했다. 이전의 전통적 사학이 국왕 중심의 편년체나 단순한 사료 고증에 머물렀다면, 마르크스주의라는 경험을 거치면서 경제적 기반, 계급 관계, 생산력과 생산 관계의 모순이라는 거시적 틀로 역사를 해석하는 체계가 갖추어졌다.

(2) 탄압, 전향, 그리고 학문적 우회

1930년대 중반 이후 파시즘의 압박이 거세지면서 다수의 마르크스주의 역사학자들은 체포되거나 학계에서 축출되었다. 그러나 이들은 학문적 탐구를 완전히 포기하지 않았다. 직접적인 정치적·혁명적 발언이 불가능해진 상황에서, 이들은 '실증 사학'이나 '고대·중세사 연구', 혹은 '아시아 지역 연구'로 연구의 중심을 우회시켰다.

예를 들어, 미우라 히로유키나 하니 고로, 와타나베 요시미치 등은 정치적 탄압을 피하기 위해 사료 고증에 더욱 철저를 기하면서도, 그 내부에는 유물사관적 문제의식을 은밀히 유지했다. 이러한 '실증으로의 우회'는 역설적으로 마르크스주의 사학이 감상적 혁명론에서 벗어나 고도의 사료 критические 분석 기법을 확보하는 계기가 되었다.

(3) 전시 체제와 마르크스주의의 변용

태평양 전쟁기(1941~1945) 동안 일본 국가주의는 '대동아공영권' 사상을 정당화하기 위해 역사학을 동원했다. 흥미로운 점은 일부 마르크스주의 역사학자들이 제시했던 근대화론이나 아시아 침체론적 시각이 전시 체제의 동아시아 역사 재편 논리와 묘하게 교차했다는 사실이다.

마르크스주의적 발전 단계론은 서구 중심의 역사 발전을 모델로 삼았기에, 아시아의 '전제주의'나 '정체성(停滯性)'을 극복해야 할 대상으로 보았다. 일제 당국은 이러한 시각을 아시아 침략과 근대화 지원이라는 미명으로 변용시켰다. 이 책은 마르크스주의 지식인들이 전시 체제에 협력하거나 편승하게 되는 복잡한 비극적 메커니즘과 사상적 굴곡을 치밀하게 추적한다.

(4) 전후 사학(戰後史學)으로의 연속성

1945년 패전 이후 일본 학계에서 폭발적으로 일어난 '전후 사학'의 부흥은 갑작스러운 기적이 아니었다. 이시모다 쇼를 비롯한 전후 대표 사학자들의 역사의식은 이미 1930~40년대의 엄혹한 시기 동안 마르크스주의적 문제의식을 단련하고 실증 연구를 축적한 결과물이었다.

패전 후 민주주의 역사학의 성립은 1930-40년대라는 지하의 용광로에서 마르크스주의라는 방법론이 실증사학과 결합하며 다져진 지적 기초가 있었기에 가능했다. 즉, 전쟁 기간은 단절의 시대가 아니라, 전후 마르크스주의 사학이 만개하기 위한 지하 축적기였다.

3. 평론: 지적 유산으로서의 '경험'이 지닌 의미

이 책은 1930-40년대 일본 역사학을 단순한 '파시즘에 대한屈服'이나 '수난의 역사'라는 이분법적 구도로 바라보지 않는다. 대신 마르크스주의를 하나의 '지적 경험(Intellectual Experience)'으로 재conceptualize 한다.

첫째, 지성사의 복원력이 돋보인다. 이 책은 정치적 탄압이라는 외적 규제 속에서도 지식인들이 어떻게 사상적 정체성을 유지하고, 변용하며, 학문적 형태로 가공해 냈는지를 정교하게 밝혀낸다. 마르크스주의가 비단 정치 정당의 교리가 아니라, 역사학이라는 학문 분과 내부에서 어떻게 방법론적 자산으로 흡수되었는가를 추적한 점은 사상사 연구로서 매우 높은 평가를 받을 만하다.

둘째, 역사의 연속성과 모순성을 직시한다. 전시 체제기 지식인들의 행적을 단순히 '협력자'와 '저항자'로 나누는 도식적 평가를 넘어선다. 마르크스주의의 근대주의적 시각이 어떻게 식민지 지배 논리나 대동아공영권의 대의와 접점을 가질 수 있었는지 보여줌으로써, 진보적 사상이 가질 수 있는 내적 한계와 모순을 날카롭게 지적한다.

셋째, 전후 일본 사회를 이해하는 열쇠를 제공한다. 전후 일본의 학계와 지성계가 왜 그토록 오랫동안 마르크스주의적 담론에 깊이 매료되었는가에 대한 근본적인 답을 준다. 그것은 패전 후 외부에서 이식된 사조가 아니라, 1930-40년대의 암흑기 속에서 일본 역사학자들이 자국 역사를 해석하기 위해 피흘리며 다듬어낸 '자가 발전적 지적 도구'였기 때문이다.

결론적으로, <マルクス主義という経験: 1930-40年代日本の歴史学>은 사상적 탄압이라는 극단적 조건 속에서 지식이 어떻게 살아남고 변용되는가를 보여주는 뛰어난 역사학사 연구이다. 마르크스주의라는 사조가 20세기 일본 근대 지성사에서 지닌 정당한 위치를 재조명하고, 학문과 정치, 그리고 시대적 광기 사이에서 고민했던 지식인들의 복잡한 궤적을 서술한 수작이다.



===




이 책은 단일 저자의 저술이 아니라, 이소마에 준이치(磯前順一)와 해리 D. 하루투니언(Harry D. Harootunian)이 엮은 공동 연구서다. 2008년 아오키서점에서 출간되었으며, 376쪽 분량으로 1930~40년대 일본의 마르크스주의 역사학이 전후 역사학의 형성에 끼친 영향을 재검토한다. 
==
<마르크스주의라는 경험: 1930~40년대 일본의 역사학> 요약 평론

이소마에 준이치·해리 D. 하루투니언 편

1. 문제의식: 마르크스주의는 단순한 이론이 아니었다

<마르크스주의라는 경험>은 1930~40년대 일본의 역사학자들이 마르크스주의를 어떻게 받아들이고, 변형하며, 때로는 포기하거나 은폐했는지를 살펴보는 연구서다. 책의 핵심은 마르크스주의 역사학을 이미 실패한 정치이론이나 낡은 역사발전 단계론으로 평가하는 데 있지 않다. 오히려 마르크스주의가 당시 일본 지식인들에게 어떤 역사적·정치적·윤리적 경험이었는지를 묻는다.

여기서 ‘경험’이라는 말이 중요하다. 마르크스주의는 일본 역사학자들이 외부에서 수입한 완성된 교리만이 아니었다. 그것은 천황제 국가, 자본주의, 식민지 지배, 농촌 공동체, 전쟁과 파시즘을 설명하기 위해 부딪히고 씨름했던 사유의 현장이었다. 이 경험을 거치면서 일본의 역사학은 국가의 공식 서사인 황국사관과 대결할 수 있었고, 동시에 마르크스주의 자체의 경직성과 유럽중심주의에도 직면했다.

책은 전후 일본 역사학이 1945년 패전과 함께 갑자기 시작된 것이 아니라고 주장한다. 전후 민주주의 역사학의 주요 문제의식과 방법은 이미 1930~40년대의 억압된 지적 작업 속에서 형성되었다. 그러나 전후 역사학은 자신의 기원을 패전 이후의 민주화에서만 찾으면서 전쟁 전 마르크스주의 경험을 부분적으로 망각했다. 이 책은 바로 그 ‘기원과 망각’을 복원하려 한다.

2. 국체의 기원과 마르크스주의 역사학

제1부는 일본의 국체, 즉 천황 중심 국가질서의 기원을 마르크스주의 역사학자들이 어떻게 해석했는지를 다룬다. 중심 자료 가운데 하나는 와타나베 요시미치와 하야카와 지로 등이 참여해 1936~37년에 간행한 <일본역사교정>(日本歴史教程)이다.

일본 국가의 공식 역사학은 천황제를 태고부터 이어져 온 자연적이고 신성한 질서로 설명했다. 이에 비해 마르크스주의 역사학은 천황제와 국가를 특정한 생산관계와 계급관계 속에서 형성된 역사적 제도로 파악했다. 이는 천황제를 초역사적 실체가 아니라 발생하고 변화하며 소멸할 수 있는 대상으로 만드는 급진적 전환이었다.

그러나 마르크스주의자들도 문제를 안고 있었다. 유럽의 고대 노예제, 중세 봉건제, 근대 자본주의라는 발전단계를 일본사에 기계적으로 적용할 경우 일본의 역사적 특수성을 설명하기 어려웠다. 이에 일부 연구자들은 마르크스의 ‘아시아적 생산양식’과 농촌 공동체론을 활용해 일본 고대사와 국가형성을 새롭게 설명하려 했다.

하야카와 지로의 연구는 고고학과 마르크스주의를 결합했다. 선사시대를 단순한 유물 배열이 아니라 생산력, 공동체, 계급분화가 전개되는 역사적 과정으로 이해하려 했다. 이러한 시도는 일본 민족과 천황국가가 원래부터 하나였다는 국체론에 대한 비판이었다.

제1부에는 식민지 조선의 백남운도 포함된다. 백남운은 <조선사회경제사>에서 조선사를 정체된 특수사회로 보는 일본 식민사학에 맞서, 조선에도 보편적인 사회발전 과정이 존재했다고 주장했다. 이는 조선의 역사적 주체성을 회복하는 작업이었다. 동시에 유럽에서 만들어진 발전단계론을 조선사에 적용했다는 한계도 있었다.

백남운의 사례는 마르크스주의의 양면성을 보여준다. 마르크스주의는 제국주의와 식민주의를 비판하는 보편적 언어를 제공했지만, 그 보편성이 서구의 역사경험을 기준으로 삼았다는 점에서 또 다른 중심주의를 낳을 수 있었다.

3. 종교와 사상을 역사화하다

제2부는 마르크스주의가 종교와 일본사상 연구에 가져온 변화를 살핀다. 당시 일본 국가주의는 신도와 천황숭배를 정치적 종교로 만들고, 이를 민족의 영원한 정신으로 제시했다. 마르크스주의자들은 종교를 초월적 진리로 받아들이지 않고, 사회관계와 물질생활 속에서 발생한 역사적 현상으로 분석하려 했다.

종교의 기원을 노동, 생산, 공동체, 자연에 대한 인간의 두려움과 연결해 설명하는 작업은 국가신도의 신성성을 해체하는 효과를 가졌다. 종교는 영원한 본질이 아니라 인간이 특정한 사회적 조건 속에서 만들어낸 상징체계가 되었다.

그러나 종교를 지배계급의 이데올로기나 허위의식으로만 설명하는 방식은 충분하지 않았다. 종교에는 억압을 정당화하는 기능뿐 아니라, 고통받는 사람들이 현실을 견디고 공동체를 구성하며 다른 세계를 꿈꾸게 하는 기능도 있기 때문이다.

일본사상사 연구에서도 비슷한 문제가 나타났다. 마르크스주의 역사학은 사상을 위대한 개인의 정신적 업적으로만 보는 관념론에서 벗어나게 했다. 사상은 사회구조, 계급관계, 정치적 갈등 속에서 형성된 것으로 이해되었다. 하지만 사상을 경제구조의 단순한 반영으로 환원하면 사상과 문화가 지닌 자율성, 모순, 상징적 힘을 설명하기 어려워졌다.

이 책은 1930년대 일본의 마르크스주의자들이 이런 한계를 완전히 해결했다고 주장하지 않는다. 다만 그들이 경제결정론을 넘어 종교와 문화, 의식과 주체의 문제로 나아가려 했다는 사실을 중요하게 평가한다.

4. 문화론적 마르크스주의와 역사 의식

책에서 가장 중요한 부분은 제3부 ‘문화론적 마르크스주의와 역사 의식’이다. 여기서는 하니 고로, 이시모다 쇼, 이에나가 사부로, 마루야마 마사오 등 전후 일본 역사학과 사상사를 대표한 인물들의 전쟁 전·전쟁 중 작업을 분석한다.

하니 고로에게 역사는 과거 사실을 객관적으로 재현하는 작업만이 아니었다. 역사가는 현재의 위기와 요구를 통해 과거를 선택하고 재구성한다. 역사는 현재를 비판하고 다른 미래를 상상하기 위한 알레고리가 된다. 이런 관점은 역사학의 정치성을 드러내지만, 현재의 목적에 따라 과거를 지나치게 도구화할 위험도 가진다.

이에나가와 마루야마의 사상사 연구에서는 ‘부정성’이 중요한 의미를 지닌다. 전쟁과 국가주의가 모든 차이와 비판을 억압하던 시기에 이들은 일본사 안에서 국가질서에 완전히 통합되지 않는 사상과 주체의 가능성을 찾았다. 이 작업은 패전 후 민주주의 사상사와 전쟁책임론의 기초가 되었다.

이시모다 쇼의 <중세적 세계의 형성>은 이 책 전체의 핵심 사례라고 할 수 있다. 이시모다는 전쟁 중에 일본 중세사회를 연구하면서 봉건제의 형성과 민중의 역사적 역할을 분석했다. 그는 제국 일본의 현재를 직접 비판하기 어려운 상황에서 중세사의 서술을 통해 국가와 권력의 형성, 지배와 저항의 문제를 우회적으로 제기했다.

전후 일본의 역사학은 이시모다의 연구를 민주적·민중적 역사학의 출발점으로 높이 평가했다. 그러나 이 책은 그를 영웅으로 단순화하지 않는다. 그의 연구 역시 일본이라는 국민국가의 단위를 전제로 했으며, 식민지와 제국의 문제를 충분히 포함하지 못했다.

5. 마르크스주의와 국민국가 역사

이 책의 중요한 주제는 마르크스주의 역사학이 국민국가 중심의 역사를 넘어설 수 있었는가 하는 문제다. 마르크스주의는 계급, 생산관계, 세계자본주의를 강조함으로써 민족과 국가를 영원한 단위로 보는 역사관에 도전했다. 일본사도 고립된 민족의 역사가 아니라 동아시아와 세계 자본주의의 관계 속에서 분석할 수 있게 되었다.

그러나 실제 마르크스주의 역사학은 흔히 ‘일본은 어떻게 봉건제를 극복하고 근대 국민국가가 되었는가’라는 질문에 집중했다. 천황제와 제국주의를 비판하면서도 일본 국민국가를 역사의 기본 주체로 삼는 모순이 있었다.

식민지 조선의 백남운을 일본 역사학과 함께 다룬 것은 이런 문제를 드러내기 위한 것이다. 일본의 마르크스주의 역사학을 일본 열도 내부의 지적 전통으로만 설명해서는 안 된다. 제국 일본의 지적 공간에는 조선인, 중국인, 대만인 연구자들도 있었으며, 식민지 경험은 마르크스주의가 지닌 해방 가능성과 한계를 동시에 보여주었다.

6. 전후 역사학의 기원과 망각

책의 서론은 전후 역사학이 자신의 전전·전중기 기원을 망각했다고 지적한다. 패전 이후 일본 역사학계는 천황제와 군국주의를 비판하고 민중을 역사의 주체로 내세웠다. 이 과정에서 마르크스주의 역사학은 큰 영향력을 행사했다.

그러나 전후 역사학은 종종 전쟁 전과 전쟁 후를 단절된 시기로 나누었다. 전쟁 전은 파시즘과 억압의 시기, 전쟁 후는 민주주의와 과학적 역사학의 시기로 묘사되었다. 이런 구분은 전후 역사학자들의 사상과 방법이 이미 전쟁 전·전쟁 중에 형성되었다는 사실을 가렸다.

또한 전후 마르크스주의 역사학이 ‘과학성’을 강조하면서 자신의 역사적·정치적 조건을 숨긴 점도 비판 대상이 된다. 역사학자가 현재의 정치와 욕망으로부터 독립해 객관적 법칙만을 발견한다는 주장은 역사서술 자체가 하나의 실천이라는 사실을 은폐한다.

이 책이 사용하는 ‘포이에시스’는 역사를 단순히 발견하는 것이 아니라 만들어낸다는 뜻에 가깝다. 역사가는 없는 사실을 조작하는 사람이 아니라, 무수한 과거의 사실 가운데 어떤 것을 선택하고 연결하며 의미를 부여하는 사람이다. 역사학은 언제나 현재의 요구와 관계한다.

7. 책의 성과

이 책의 가장 큰 성과는 일본 마르크스주의 역사학을 교리의 옳고 그름으로 평가하지 않는다는 점이다. 공산당 노선에 충실했는가, 발전단계론이 정확했는가를 따지기보다 마르크스주의가 구체적인 역사적 상황 속에서 어떤 사유와 실천을 가능하게 했는지를 묻는다.

둘째, 전후 역사학의 기원을 1945년 이후로 한정하지 않는다. 전쟁 전과 전쟁 후를 단순히 단절시키지 않고, 억압과 검열 속에서 형성된 문제의식이 패전 후 어떻게 계승되거나 변형되었는지를 보여준다.

셋째, 경제사 중심의 마르크스주의 이해를 넘어 종교, 문화, 사상, 역사 의식의 문제를 다룬다. 마르크스주의를 생산양식과 계급구조에 관한 이론으로만 보지 않고, 인간이 역사적 시간을 경험하고 현재를 비판하는 방법으로 이해한다.

넷째, 일본사 내부에 머물지 않고 식민지 조선의 역사학을 포함함으로써 일본 제국의 지적 공간을 드러낸다. 마르크스주의가 제국주의를 비판하는 언어였지만 동시에 유럽중심적 보편사와 국민국가의 틀에서 벗어나지 못했다는 모순도 지적한다.

8. 한계와 비판

이 책은 여러 연구자의 전문 논문을 모은 책이므로 일반 독자에게는 상당히 어렵다. 연구자마다 문제의식과 이론적 언어가 다르고, 전체를 관통하는 하나의 서사가 항상 분명한 것은 아니다. 특히 포이에시스, 알레고리, 부정성, 역사주의 같은 철학적 개념에 익숙하지 않으면 논지를 따라가기 쉽지 않다.

또한 책이 다루는 인물들이 주로 지식인과 역사학자라는 점도 한계다. 마르크스주의가 노동운동, 농민운동, 식민지의 대중, 여성운동 속에서 어떻게 경험되었는지는 상대적으로 부족하다. ‘마르크스주의라는 경험’이라는 제목에 비해 실제 분석은 전문 역사학자들의 지적 경험에 집중되어 있다.

여성 역사학자와 젠더 문제도 거의 중심에 놓이지 않는다. 계급과 국가, 민족의 문제를 비판하면서도 가족제도, 가부장제, 성별 분업이 역사학의 형성에 어떤 영향을 주었는지는 충분히 검토하지 않는다.

마지막으로 마르크스주의가 일본 제국주의에 저항하는 힘이었음은 분명하지만, 일부 마르크스주의자들이 전쟁기에 전향하거나 국가주의적 논리에 접근했던 과정도 더 깊이 다룰 필요가 있다. 억압에 굴복했다는 설명만으로는 전향의 복잡한 사상적 구조를 충분히 설명할 수 없다.

9. 한국 독자에게 갖는 의미

이 책은 한국 역사학을 이해하는 데도 중요하다. 한국의 전후 역사학 역시 식민사관을 극복하고 민족의 주체성을 회복하려는 과정에서 마르크스주의와 민족주의의 영향을 함께 받았다. 백남운의 사회경제사학은 식민지 조선이 정체된 사회가 아니라 독자적인 역사발전 과정을 지녔다고 주장했다는 점에서 해방적 의미를 가졌다.

그러나 한국에서도 마르크스주의 역사학은 민족국가 중심의 역사서술과 결합했다. 계급과 생산관계를 강조하면서도 역사의 주체를 ‘민족’으로 설정한 경우가 많았다. 그 결과 여성, 지역, 소수자, 재일조선인, 이주민, 식민지 내부의 차이는 주변화되기 쉬웠다.

이 책은 한국의 민족주의 역사학과 민중사학에도 같은 질문을 던지게 한다. 지배국가의 역사에 맞서 민족과 민중을 복원하는 일은 필요했지만, 민족과 민중을 단일한 주체로 상상하는 순간 새로운 배제가 생기지 않았는가. 국가 중심의 보수 역사학을 비판하면서도 또 다른 국민국가의 서사를 만든 것은 아닌가.

10. 종합 평가

<마르크스주의라는 경험>은 마르크스주의 역사학을 복권하려는 책도 아니고, 그것을 시대착오적 이론으로 폐기하려는 책도 아니다. 이 책은 마르크스주의를 하나의 역사적 경험으로 다시 읽는다. 그것은 천황제와 자본주의, 식민주의에 대항하는 비판의 언어였으며, 역사에 변혁 가능성을 부여한 사유였다. 동시에 발전단계론, 경제결정론, 유럽중심주의, 국민국가 중심주의라는 한계를 지녔다.

이 책이 오늘날에도 의미 있는 까닭은 마르크스주의의 정답을 되찾아 주기 때문이 아니다. 오히려 어떤 이론도 역사 밖에 존재하지 않으며, 비판이론조차 특정한 시대의 욕망과 한계를 지닌다는 사실을 일깨우기 때문이다.

마르크스주의 역사학이 남긴 가장 중요한 유산은 모든 역사가 필연적인 결과가 아니라는 인식이다. 천황제도, 자본주의도, 제국도 영원한 질서가 아니라 역사적으로 만들어진 것이다. 만들어진 것은 변화할 수 있다. 이 단순하지만 급진적인 인식이 1930~40년대 일본의 억압된 시대에 마르크스주의가 제공한 가장 중요한 ‘경험’이었다.

한 문장으로 평가하면, 이 책은 <전후 일본 역사학이 탄생한 장소를 1945년 이후가 아니라, 전쟁과 억압 속에서도 다른 역사를 상상하려 했던 1930~40년대의 미완성된 사유에서 찾는 연구서>라고 할 수 있다.
:::

책의 실제 구성은 서론 <전후 역사학의 기원과 그 망각>과 세 부분—<국체의 기원과 마르크스주의 역사학>, <마르크스주의와 종교·문화론>, <문화론적 마르크스주의와 역사 의식>—으로 이루어진다. 

===