Book of the dayShort stories
The Accusation by Bandi review – forbidden stories from inside North Korea
Written in secret between 1989 and 1995 and smuggled out of the country in 2013, these short works offer powerful insights into a world behind walls
Hamhŭng, North Korea … Bandi’s characters take in a wide range of locales and social classes. Photograph: AlamyRO Kwon
Sat 11 Mar 2017 18.30 AEDT
139
17
This collection has an extraordinary origin story. Bandi, meaning “firefly”, is the pseudonym for a North Korean who has worked, and might still work, as part of the nation’s official writers’ association. In public, Bandi contributed to government-authorised periodicals; in secret, from 1989 to 1995, he wrote stories and poems criticising the state – itself a heroic act in a land where the slightest political dissidence is enough to get you killed. When a close relative told him she planned to leave North Korea, he asked her to take along what had become a 750-page manuscript. She promised, instead, to send for it once she’d escaped. En route, she was picked up by Chinese soldiers; she bribed her way out, made it to South Korea, and enlisted the help of a human rights worker, Do Hee-yun, in retrieving Bandi’s writing. Eventually, in 2013, Do recruited a Chinese friend to smuggle out Bandi’s manuscript while visiting North Korean relatives.
The seven stories in The Accusation were selected from this clandestine manuscript, billed as the first of its kind: defectors have published books in the larger world, but not North Korean residents. Initially published in South Korea, the collection has now been translated into English by Deborah Smith, who with Han Kang won the 2016 Man Booker international prize for the translation of The Vegetarian. In Bandi’s stories, each of which is based on a factual situation, the characters are from a wide range of locales and social classes, from collective farm labourers to the Pyongyang elite. Some of them are relatively powerful, others unable to even obtain a travel permit to visit a dying parent; the accidents of birth determine much of their luck. In North Korea, people are organised into classes according to familial histories of loyalty to the Communist party. To be able to claim a father who died fighting in the Korean war, for instance, is a godsend; to have a relative who has defected to the South is the opposite.
Advertisement
But all the characters in The Accusation inhabit North Korea, and in these stories, as in life, no citizen is safe from the threat of political ruin. It’s a place where, following Kim Il‑sung’s death in 1994, Bandi’s characters leave flowers at altars built in the dictator’s memory “once before each mealtime, morning, noon, and night” because they know the visits are secretly being tallied. With Pyongyang soon stripped bare of flowers, the would-be mourners are forced to find the requisite floral tributes in the mountains. The ground is treacherous, slick with monsoon rains; some of them die in landslides. Still, they persist in trying to find more flowers, afraid that if they don’t, they’ll be charged with antirevolutionary crimes. In another story, a single parent works so hard on a soybean farm that he goes long stretches at a time without seeing his children; nonetheless, when his crop fails, he is indicted for antirevolutionary crimes. A party stalwart’s small son cries at the sight of giant posters depicting Stalin’s and Kim Il-sung’s faces. She tries to prevent his crying, but to little avail: the posters are ubiquitous, and she and her husband are judged guilty of, once again, antirevolutionary crimes.
The Accusation reads like powerful emotion felt right now, in a condition of ongoing crisis
In story after story, industrious North Koreans, “innocent people whose lives consisted of doing as they were told”, accidentally run afoul of the state and lose their last political illusions. They then get jailed, escape, die, or go mad, but the real culmination of each story occurs in that instant of revelation, when they realise that, despite everything they have always been told, the state is malign. It’s like living in an evil garden, one character says: they are slaves ruled by a demon, secluded from the rest of the world by high walls. The overall structures of Bandi’s stories are almost identical – perhaps too identical, one might think, except that the repetitiveness of their trajectories seems all too accurately to reflect the fates of real-life North Koreans. Bandi’s prose style is rough, jagged with exclamation marks and anguished rhetorical questions: this, too, could be said to fit the exigencies of his book. If poetry, as Wordsworth said, can be glossed as powerful emotion recollected in tranquillity, The Accusation reads like powerful emotion felt right now, in a condition of ongoing crisis.
In the book’s afterword, it is pointed out that, in lieu of trying to escape, Bandi chose to dispatch his manuscript, an “entreaty to shine a spotlight on North Korea’s oppressive regime”. In 2015, the human rights worker, Do Hee-yun, said he hadn’t heard from Bandi in months. He expressed concern that the author’s identity had been discovered, which would have led to death, or worse. “People write books and sing songs claiming that love is this or that,” one of Bandi’s characters says. “But to me, love was indistinguishable from sympathy.” In its scope and courage, The Accusation is an act of great love.
• RO Kwon’s novel Heroics will be published by Riverhead. The Accusation by Bandi is published by Serpent’s Tail. To order a copy for £12.74 (RRP £14.99) go to bookshop.theguardian.com or call 0330 333 6846. Free UK p&p over £10, online orders only. Phone orders min. p&p of £1.99.
Topics
Short stories
Book of the day
Fiction
Poetry
reviews
Reuse this content
Advertisement
Most viewed
Priti Patel hits out at 'dreadful' Black Lives Matter protests
LiveUK coronavirus live: 1 in 80 in England had Covid last week; R-value below 1 for first time since July
Dramatic discovery links Stonehenge to its original site – in Wales
Trump's case of coronavirus was far worse than he admitted, report says
LiveCoronavirus live: France recommends single vaccine dose for those who had Covid; Germany shut parts of land border
Book of the day
No One Is Talking About This by Patricia Lockwood review – life in the Twittersphere
7h ago
Consent by Vanessa Springora review – a memoir of lost adolescence
1d ago
The Changing of the Guard by Simon Akam review – the truth about the British army
2d ago
Cowboy Graves by Roberto Bolaño review – more mysteries and enigmas
3d ago
10
No One Is Talking About This by Patricia Lockwood review – richly tragicomic debut novel
4d ago
24
Asylum Road by Olivia Sudjic review – inside the mind of a survivor
6d ago
The Hidden Spring by Mark Solms review – the riddle of consciousness solved?
5 Feb 2021
Fake Accounts by Lauren Oyler review – internet secrets and lies
4 Feb 2021
comments (17)Sign in or create your Guardian account to join the discussion.
Sort byOldest
Per page100
Display threadsCollapsed
TheSentinel
11 Mar 2017 19:05
1
If you go to Pyongyang you have to try the beer, it's delicious, and a perfect complement to the very spicy KimChi they have there.
Report
Makidadi
11 Mar 2017 19:46
3
I look forward to reading this. May I recommend Adam Johnson's Pullitzer Pprize-winning novel, The Orphan Master 's Son? I have been using it as a course novel with grade eleven students for the past few years and find it thoroughly readable and thought provoking. Most of my students like it and feel that it opens their eyes to a part of the world that they had very little prior exposure to.
Report
InhaleLit
Makidadi
12 Mar 2017 6:16
1
I read the Orphan Master's Son a month or so ago and am still thinking about it. A gripping, fabulous read that I recommend without reservation to anyone interested in this part of the world, especially now where "truth" is subject to so much manipulation and fabrication. I just bought this book from Book Depository and am looking forward to seeing how it validates Johnson's work. Have not read How I Became a North Korean, although it is on my TBR.
Report
Borisinmunich
Makidadi
18 Mar 2017 8:15
1
The Orphan Master's son is a work of fiction, much of it sheer fantasy. I wouldn't use it as a text to open students' eyes to North Korea, unless you want them to start telling people 'authoritatively' that old people get slaughtered in Wonsan or goats graze on Pyongyang rooftops, all of which they now know because they 'studied it in class'. It's one thing to read it as a novel, but to use it to 'educate' people on any aspect of North Korea turns it into a tool of disinformation, which I don't think is its intention.
Report
Makidadi
Borisinmunich
18 Mar 2017 12:05
- 0
Of course I teach it as a work of fiction. I acknowledge that the central issue is whether readers are willing to accept the increasinglingly outlandish coincidences that occur in the second half of the novel. I also mention that the atrocities described in this work of fiction are likely much less drast
No comments:
Post a Comment