2025-05-08

Carl Stephenson (historian) - Wikipedia Mediaeval Feudalism

Carl Stephenson (historian) - Wikipedia

손민석
  · 
C.스티븐슨의 <봉건제란 무엇인가>(원제 : 중세봉건제)는 서문에 이 책은 얼핏 보기에는 별 내용이 없는, 그저 그런 입문서처럼 보이지만 나중에 공부를 많이 하고 나서 다시 보면 꼭 필요한 내용만 담겨 있는 책이라는 걸 새삼스레 깨닫게 된다. 이런 내용이 있다. 근데 정말 신기하게도 이 책의 독자들은 봉건제를 공부하다보면 그 경험을 하게 된다. 스티븐슨의 설명은 지나치게 단조로워 보이고 내용도 평이하여 딱히 큰 인상을 남기지 않는데, 마르크 블로크 등의 탁월한 연구자들의 다양한 견해를 접하고 나서 다시 보면 그 내용의 평이함이 적확함으로, 단순함이 핵심으로 바뀌어 보인다. 역시 튜닝의 끝은 순정인가. 사회경제사적인 측면이 배제된, 주종관계를 주로 다루는 이 단순한 저작이 다양한 배경지식을 갖고 읽으면 핵심을 짚는 걸로 보이니 참 신기하다.


Carl Stephenson (historian)

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Carl Stephenson (1886–1954) at the time of his death was regarded as one of America's foremost medieval scholars.[1] He was a student of Charles Gross and Charles Homer Haskins at Harvard University (graduated 1914[2]), later studied with Henri Pirenne at the University of Ghent (1924–25[2]) and had close scholarly ties with other well-known medievalists of the first half of the 20th century. He taught mainly at the University of Wisconsin–Madison and Cornell University Department of History (1931–1941).

Primarily focused on documentary evidence, he was opposed to easy theorizing and glib generalizations.[1] Carl Stephenson did his best work on those institutions found in medieval Europe between the Loire and the Rhine.[1] Since he was writing far removed from western Europe and its acrimonious academic feuding, he dispassionately demolished much of the prejudiced nationalistic writing devoted to praising or damning Germanic or Latin institutions.[1] His greatest joy came from demonstrating that a tax, a commune, or seignorialism and feudalism were not peculiar to one area but were common to all western Europe.

For fifteen years Carl Stephenson regularly published articles in the leading historical journals of America, England, Belgium, and France and established himself as an authority on taxation, representative assemblies, and the origin of urban institutions. His most mature work,[1] Borough and Town, appeared in 1933; here he combined his research with scholarly methods developed on the Continent to show that the English borough was not an insular peculiarity but that it was like its continental counterpart in origin and constitution. He then turned his attention to seignorial and feudal institutions, work resulting in further articles including his 1942 classic essay Mediaeval Feudalism which has remained in print into the 21st century. His book, Medieval History: Europe from the Fourth to the Sixteenth Century, was for decades one of the most widely used textbooks in the field.[2] He co-edited Sources of English Constitutional History with his Cornell colleague Frederick Marcham;[3] the work is still considered a monumental achievement.

Notes

[edit]
  1. Jump up to:a b c d e Carl Stephenson, Mediaeval Feudalism (1942). See "Introduction" by Bryce D. Lyon in the Great Seal Books edition first published in 1956 by Cornell University Press
  2. Jump up to:a b c "Medievalists at Cornell" Archived 2007-07-15 at the Wayback Machine
  3. ^ Stephenson, Carl and Frederick G. Marcham, eds: Sources of English Constitutional History (2nd ed. 1990)
[edit]
===

===
https://archive.org/details/in.ernet.dli.2015.59885/page/n7/mode/2up
===

Kindle
from $5.99
Audiobook
$0.00with membership trial

Paperback
$6.81

Other Used and New from $2.19


Mediaeval Feudalism Kindle Edition
by Carl Stephenson (Author) Format: Kindle Edition
4.6 4.6 out of 5 stars (16)
3.8 on Goodreads
143 ratings

This is the reprint of the first single-volume work in English to treat of the principles of feudalism. It gives a clear and concise account of the origin, growth, and decay of the feudal system. Special attention is paid to the principles of feudal tenure, chivalry, the military life of the nobility, and the workings of feudal government, as illustrated by actual cases.

The book has enjoyed a distinguished career and has been received enthusiastically by historians...
"Really a little masterpiece."—Carl Becker
"Such a book as this has long been needed."—Richard A. Newhall
"I believe it to be the best treatment of the subject, within a limited scope, that is in existence."—James F. Baldwin

This digital edition of "Mediaeval Feudalism" was meticulously scanned and thoroughly proofread by the expert team at Babel Books and has been specifically formatted and skillfully edited to ensure optimal readability on various digital devices.

Read less

From the Back Cover
This book gives a clear and concise account of the origin, growth, and decay of the feudal system.
About the Author


Carl Stephenson, regarded as one of America's foremost medievalists at the time of his death in 1954, had a long and significant scholarly career. A student of Charles Gross and Charles Homer Haskins at Harvard, he later studied with the renowned Henri Pirenne of Belgium. Most of his teaching was done at the University of Wisconsin and Cornell University. His other books include Borough and Town (1933) and Medieval History: Europe from the Fourth to the Sixteenth Century (1935).

Top
About this itemQuestionsReviewsSimilar

Product details
ASIN ‏ : ‎ B0CGXVHY7H
Publication date ‏ : ‎ August 29, 2023
L
Print length ‏ : ‎ 82 pages

#2,099 in Radical Political Thought
Customer Reviews:
4.6 4.6 out of 5 stars (16)

Amazon Customer

2.0 out of 5 stars Two StarsReviewed in the United States on July 23, 2017
Verified Purchase
Stephen Balbach


4.0 out of 5 stars Mediavel FeudalismReviewed in the United States on November 17, 2007


Carl Stephenson (1886-1954) was an early to mid-20th century American Medievalist, a student of Charles Homer Haskins (America's "first medievalist"). This little gem was written in 1942 before the more fashionable works on Feudalism by Bloch, Ganshof, Reynolds and Brown. It is a solid and easily digested foundation written in a delightfully simple down to earth style. Even if some of the perspectives have been questioned or expanded by later works, this still provides a necessary and accessible foundation. As the opening paragraph of the 1956 edition says:

[START QUOTE]

SINCE its first printing in 1942 the late Carl Stephenson's 'Mediaeval Feudalism' has enjoyed a distinguished career. Eminent historians of America and Europe have reviewed it with high praise in the most respected historical journals. To the college freshman it has been a "vade mecum" in the awesome task of mastering such complicated feudal principles as subinfeudation and liege homage. The omniscient graduate student has at first reading whisked through it with disdain, casting it aside for the imaginative hypotheses of a Marc Bloch or for the impressive tomes of German historians, only to come meekly back to it to obtain his bearings and a sense of proportion. Seasoned scholars and teachers have read the book with discrimination, realizing that behind each page stood years of research and thought devoted to the study of feudalism in mediaeval Europe; they in turn have recommended it to their students.

[END QUOTE]

Another book by Stephenson, Medieval History: Europe from the Fourth to the Sixteenth Century, was for decades one of the most widely used textbooks in the field. He is probably best known for Borough and Town: A Study of Urban Origins in England (1933). Stephenson was working in an age rife with prejudiced nationalism among European scholars; as an outsider he helped show the commonality of medieval institutions and move the discussion beyond 19th and early 20th century nationalistic concerns.

Read less

10 people found this helpful


HelpfulReport

No comments: