Israel Loyalists Embedded In U.S. Government Pushed U.S. Into Iraq War
by Alison Weir
Publication date 2021-10-19
Topics Israel, Lobby, Dual Citizenship, Iraq, War, Zionists
Collection opensource
The disastrous Iraq war cost multitudes of lives, trillions of dollars, destabilized the Middle East, and led to the rise of ISIS. It’s essential to learn why the U.S. launched such a catastrophic war if we are to avoid such calamities in the future…
As many have said: ‘Those who do not learn history are doomed to repeat it’…
The invasion of Iraq was promoted by an interconnected network of Israel loyalists known as “neoconservatives” who were operating at all levels of the U.S. government, and who used their positions to promote policies on behalf of Israel. (Now they’re doing it again against Iran…)
Israeli media report on this openly – e.g. an Israeli journalist in a major Israeli newspaper reported in 2003: “The war in Iraq was conceived by 25 neoconservative intellectuals, most of them Jewish, who are pushing President Bush to change the course of history…”
Some members of this network had been part of a 1996 study group working for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu that had recommended “shaping [Israel’s] regional environment” by damaging and destabilizing countries such as Iraq, Iran, and Syria.
Below are three articles that name this network of pro-Israel U.S. officials and describe their activities – which include allegations of spying for Israel.
===
Israel loyalists embedded in U.S. government pushed
U.S. into Iraq War
https://israelpalestinenews.org/israel-loyalists-embedded-in-u-s-government-pushed-us-into-irag-war/
October 19, 2021 2 ,
3
Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon with Douglas Feith, U.S. Under Secretary
of Defense, one of many U.S. officials with long records of activism on
behalf of Israel and of promoting policies sometimes at odds with U.S.
interests. Feith’s study featured a portrait of Theodor Herzl, the “the
spiritual father of Israel”. Feith was investigated for allegedly providing
classified material to an Israeli diplomat. He’s one of several members of
the neocon network accused of being spies for Israel.
The disastrous Iraq war cost multitudes of lives, trillions of dollars,
destabilized the Middle East, and led to the rise of ISIS. It’s essential to
learn why the U.S. launched such a catastrophic war if we are to avoid
such calamities in the future... As many have said: ‘Those who do not
learn history are doomed to repeat it’...
The invasion of Iraq was promoted by an interconnected network of
Israel loyalists known as “neoconservatives” who were operating at
all levels of the U.S. government, and who used their positions to
promote policies on behalf of Israel. (Now they’re doing it again
against Iran...)
Israeli media report on this openly - e.g. an Israeli journalist in a
major Israeli newspaper reported in 2003: “The war in Iraq was
conceived by 25 neoconservative intellectuals, most of them Jewish,
who are pushing President Bush to change the course of history...”
Some members of this network had been part of a 1996 study
group working for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu that
had recommended “shaping [Israel’s] regional environment” by
damaging and destabilizing countries such as Iraq, Iran, and Syria.
Below are three articles that name this network of pro-Israel U.S.
officials and describe their activities - which include allegations of
spying for Israel.
Photos have been added by IAK and include some of their offspring,
who are now also embedded in U.S. institutions...
A Rose By Another Other Name
The Bush Administration’s Dual Loyalties
by KATHLEEN and BILL CHRISTISON, CounterPunch, December 13, 2002
-reposted on If Americans Knew; photos added. (The Christisons were
former CIA analysts - bios below.)
Since the long-forgotten days when the State Department’s Middle East
policy was run by a group of so-called Arabists, U.S. policy on Israel and the
Arab world has increasingly become the purview of officials well known for
tilting toward Israel. From the 1920s roughly to 1990, Arabists, who had a
personal history and an educational background in the Arab world and
were accused by supporters of Israel of being totally biased toward Arab
interests, held sway at the State Department and, despite having limited
power in the policymaking circles of any administration, helped maintain
some semblance of U.S. balance by keeping policy from tipping over totally
toward Israel. But Arabists have been steadily replaced by their exact
opposites, what some observers are calling Israelists, and policymaking
circles throughout government now no longer even make a pretense of
exhibiting balance between Israeli and Arab, particularly Palestinian,
interests.
In the Clinton administration, the three most senior State Department
officials dealing with the Palestinian-Israeli peace process were all
partisans of Israel to one degree or another. All had lived at least for brief
periods in Israel and maintained ties with Israel while in office,
occasionally vacationing there. One of these officials had worked both as a
pro-Israel lobbyist and as director of a pro-Israel think tank in Washington
before taking a position in the Clinton administration from which he helped
make policy on Palestinian-Israeli issues. Another has headed the pro-Israel
think tank since leaving government.
The link between active promoters of Israeli interests and policymaking
circles is stronger by several orders of magnitude in the Bush
administration, which is peppered with people who have long records of
activism on behalf of Israel in the United States, of policy advocacy in Israel,
and of promoting an agenda for Israel often at odds with existing U.S.
policy. These people, who can fairly be called Israeli loyalists, are now at all
levels of government, from desk officers at the Defense Department to the
deputy secretary level at both State and Defense, as well as on the National
Security Council staff and in the vice president’s office.
Dual loyalties
We still tiptoe around putting a name to this phenomenon. We write
articles about the neo-conservatives’ agenda on U.S.-Israeli relations and
imply that in the neo-con universe there is little light between the two
countries. We talk openly about the Israeli bias in the U.S. media. We make
wry jokes about Congress being “Israeli-occupied territory.” Jason Vest
in The Nation magazine reported forthrightly that some of the think tanks
that hold sway over Bush administration thinking see no difference
between U.S. and Israeli national security interests. But we never
pronounce the particular words that best describe the real meaning of
those observations and wry remarks. It's time, however, that we say the
words out loud and deal with what they really signify.
Dual loyalties. The issue we are dealing with in the Bush administration is
dual loyalties-the double allegiance of those myriad officials at high and
middle levels who cannot distinguish U.S. interests from Israeli interests,
who baldly promote the supposed identity of interests between the United
States and Israel, who spent their early careers giving policy advice to right-
wing Israeli governments and now give the identical advice to a right-wing
U.S. government, and who, one suspects, are so wrapped up in their
concern for the fate of Israel that they honestly do not know whether their
own passion about advancing the U.S. imperium is motivated primarily by
America-first patriotism or is governed first and foremost by a desire to
secure Israel’s safety and predominance in the Middle East through the
advancement of the U.S. imperium.
“Dual loyalties” has always been one of those red flags posted around the
subject of Israel and the Arab-Israeli conflict, something that induces
horrified gasps and rapid heartbeats because of its implication of Jewish
disloyalty to the United States and the common assumption that anyone
who would speak such a canard is ipso facto an anti-Semite. (We have a
Jewish friend who is not bothered by the term in the least, who believes
that U.S. and Israeli interests should be identical and sees it as perfectly
natural for American Jews to feel as much loyalty to Israel as they do to the
United States. But this is clearly not the usual reaction when the subject of
dual loyalties arises.)
Although much has been written about the neo-cons who dot the Bush
administration, the treatment of the their ties to Israel has generally been
very gingerly. Although much has come to light recently about the fact that
ridding Iraq both of its leader and of its weapons inventory has been on the
neo-con agenda since long before there was a Bush administration, little
has been said about the link between this goal and the neo-cons’ overriding
desire to provide greater security for Israel. But an examination of the cast
of characters in Bush administration policymaking circles reveals a
startlingly pervasive network of pro-Israel activists, and an examination of
the neo-cons’ voluminous written record shows that Israel comes up
constantly as a neo-con reference point, always mentioned with the United
States as the beneficiary of a recommended policy, always linked with the
United States when national interests are at issue.
The Begats
First to the cast of characters. Beneath cabinet level, the list of pro-Israel
neo-cons who are either policy functionaries themselves or advise
policymakers from perches just on the edges of government reads like the
old biblical “begats.” Deputy Secretary of Defense Paul Wolfowitz leads the
pack. He was a protégé of Richard Perle, who heads the prominent
Pentagon advisory body, the Defense Policy Board. Many of today’s neo-
cons, including Perle, are the intellectual progeny of the late Senator Henry
“Scoop” Jackson, a strong defense hawk and one of Israel's most strident
congressional supporters in the 1970s.
The Next Tier
Wolfowitz in turn is the mentor of Lewis “Scooter” Libby, now Vice
President Cheney's chief of staff who was first a student of Wolfowitz and
later a subordinate during the 1980s in both the State and the Defense
Departments.* Another Perle protégé is Douglas Feith, who is currently
undersecretary of defense for policy, the department's number-three man,
and has worked closely with Perle both as a lobbyist for Turkey and in co-
authoring strategy papers for right-wing Israeli governments [more
info here and here.] Assistant Secretaries Peter Rodman and Dov
Zackheim, old hands from the Reagan administration when the neo-cons
first flourished, fill out the subcabinet ranks at Defense. At lower levels, the
Israel and the Syria/Lebanon desk officers at Defense are imports from
the Washington Institute for Near East Policy, a think tank spun off from
the pro-Israel lobby organization, AIPAC.
State Department
Neo-cons have not made many inroads at the State Department, except
for John Bolton, an American Enterprise Institute hawk and Israeli
proponent who is said to have been forced on a reluctant Colin Powell as
undersecretary for arms control. Bolton’s special assistant is David
Wurmser, who wrote and/or co-authored with Perle and Feith at least two
strategy papers for Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu in 1996. Wurmser’s
wife, Meyrav Wurmser, is a co-founder of the media-watch
website MEMRI (Middle East Media Research Institute), which is run by
retired Israeli military and intelligence officers and specializes in
translating and widely circulating Arab media and statements by Arab
leaders. A recent investigation by the Guardian of London found that
MEMRP’s translations are skewed by being highly selective. Although it
inevitably translates and circulates the most extreme of Arab statements, it
ignores moderate Arab commentary and extremist Hebrew
statements. [more here]
Vice President’s office
In the vice president’s office, Cheney has established his own personal
national security staff, run by aides known to be very pro-Israel. The
deputy director of the staff, John Hannah, is a former fellow of the Israeli-
oriented Washington Institute. On the National Security Council staff, the
newly appointed director of Middle East affairs is Elliott Abrams, who
came to prominence after pleading guilty to withholding information from
Congress during the Iran-contra scandal (and was pardoned by President
Bush the elder) and who has long been a vocal proponent of right-wing
Israeli positions. Putting him in a key policymaking position on the
Palestinian-Israeli conflict is like entrusting the henhouse to a fox. [More
info here]
Information arena
Pro-Israel activists with close links to the administration are also busy in
the information arena inside and outside government. The head of Radio
Liberty, a Cold War propaganda holdover now converted to service in the
“war on terror,” is Thomas Dine, who was the very active head of AIPAC
throughout most ofthe Reagan and the Bush-41 administrations. Elsewhere
on the periphery, William Kristol, son of neo-con originals Irving
Kristol and Gertrude Himmelfarb, is closely linked to the administration’s
pro-Israel coterie and serves as its cheerleader through the Rupert
Murdoch-owned magazine that he edits, The Weekly Standard. Some of
Bush’s speechwriters - including David Frum, who coined the term “axis of
evil” for Bush’s state-of-the-union address but was forced to resign when his
wife publicly bragged about his linguistic prowess - have come from The
Weekly Standard. [Also see this.] Frank Gaffney, another Jackson and Perle
protege and Reagan administration defense official, puts his pro-Israel oar
in from his think tank, the Center for Security Policy, and through
frequent media appearances and regular columns in the Washington
Times.
The incestuous nature of the proliferating boards and think tanks, whose
membership lists are more or less identical and totally interchangeable, is
frighteningly insidious. Several scholars at the American Enterprise
Institute, including former Reagan UN ambassador and long-time supporter
of the Israeli right wing Jeane Kirkpatrick, make their pro-Israel views
known vocally from the sidelines and occupy positions on other boards.
Probably the most important organization, in terms of its influence on Bush
administration policy formulation, is the Jewish Institute for National
Security Affairs (JINSA). Formed after the 1973 Arab-Israeli war
specifically to bring Israel's security concerns to the attention of U.S.
policymakers and concentrating also on broad defense issues, the
extremely hawkish, right-wing JINSA has always had a high-powered board
able to place its members inside conservative U.S. administrations. Cheney,
Bolton, and Feith were members until they entered the Bush
administration. Several lower level JINSA functionaries are now working in
the Defense Department. Perle is still a member, as are Kirkpatrick, former
CIA director and leading Iraq-war hawk James Woolsey, and old-time rabid
pro-Israel types like Eugene Rostow and Michael Ledeen.
Both JINSA and Gaffney’s Center for Security Policy are heavily
underwritten by Irving Moskowitz, a right-wing American Zionist,
California business magnate (his money comes from bingo parlors), and
JINSA board member who has lavishly financed the establishment of
several religious settlements in Arab East Jerusalem.
By Their Own Testimony
Paul Wolfowitz
Most of the neo-cons now in government have left a long paper trail giving
clear evidence of their fervently right-wing pro-Israel, and fervently anti-
Palestinian, sentiments. Whether being pro-Israel, even pro right-wing
Israel, constitutes having dual loyalties that is, a desire to further Israel's
interests that equals or exceeds the desire to further U.S. interests is
obviously not easy to determine, but the record gives some clues.
Wolfowitz himself has been circumspect in public, writing primarily about
broader strategic issues rather than about Israel specifically or even the
Middle East, but it is clear that at bottom Israel is a major interest and may
be the principal reason for his near obsession with the effort, of which he is
the primary spearhead, to dump Saddam Hussein, remake the Iraqi
government in an American image, and then further redraw the Middle
East map by accomplishing the same goals in Syria, Iran, and perhaps other
countries. Profiles of Wolfowitz paint him as having two distinct aspects:
one obessively bent on advancing U.S. dominance throughout the world,
ruthless and uncompromising, seriously prepared to “end states,” as he
once put it, that support terrorism in any way, a velociraptor in the words
of one former colleague cited in the Economist; the other a softer aspect,
which shows him to be a soft-spoken political moralist, an ardent democrat,
even a bleeding heart on social issues, and desirous for purely moral and
humanitarian reasons of modernizing and democratizing the Islamic
world.
But his interest in Israel always crops up. Even profiles that downplay his
attachment to Israel nonetheless always mention the influence the
Holocaust, in which several of his family perished, has had on his thinking.
One source inside the administration has described him frankly as “over-
the-top crazy when it comes to Israel.” Although this probably accurately
describes most of the rest of the neo-con coterie, and Wolfowitz is guilty at
least by association, he is actually more complex and nuanced than this. A
recent New York Times Magazine profile by the Times‘ Bill Keller cites critics
who say that “Israel exercises a powerful gravitational pull on the man”
and notes that as a teenager Wolfowitz lived in Israel during his
mathematician father’s sabbatical semester there. His sister is married to
an Israeli. Keller even somewhat reluctantly acknowledges the accuracy of
one characterization of Wolfowitz as “Israel-centric.” But Keller goes
through considerable contortions to shun what he calls “the offensive
suggestion of dual loyalty” and in the process makes one wonder if he is
protesting too much. Keller concludes that Wolfowitz is less animated by
the security of Israel than by the promise of a more moderate Islam. He
cites as evidence Wolfowitz's admiration for Egyptian President Anwar
Sadat for making peace with Israel and also draws on a former Wolfowitz
subordinate who says that “as a moral man, he might have found Israel the
heart of the Middle East story. But as a policy maker, Turkey and the gulf
and Egypt didn't loom any less large for him.”
These remarks are revealing. Anyone not so fearful of broaching the issue
of dual loyalties might at least have raised the suggestion that Wolfowitz's
real concern may indeed be to ensure Israel's security. Otherwise, why do
his overriding interests seem to be reinventing Anwar Sadats throughout
the Middle East by transforming the Arab and Muslim worlds and thereby
making life safer for Israel, and a passion for fighting a pre-emptive war
against Iraq when there are critical areas totally apart from the Middle
East and myriad other broad strategic issues that any deputy secretary of
defense should be thinking about just as much? His current interest in
Turkey, which is shared by the other neo-cons, some of whom have served
as lobbyists for Turkey, seems also to be directed at securing Israel’s place
in the region; there seems little reason for particular interest in this
moderate Islamic, non-Arab country, other than that it is a moderate
Islamic but non-Arab neighbor of Israel.
Furthermore, the notion suggested by the Wolfowitz subordinate that any
moral man would obviously look to Israel as the “heart ofthe Middle East
story” is itself an Israel-centered idea: the assumption that Israel is a moral
state, always pursuing moral policies, and that any moral person would
naturally attach himself to Israel automatically presumes that thereisan
identity of interests between the United States and Israel; only those who
assume such a complete coincidence of interests accept the notion that
Israel is, across the board, a moral state.
Clean Break paper
Others among the neo-con policymakers have been more direct and open in
expressing their pro-Israel views. Douglas Feith has been the most prolific
of the group, with a two-decade-long record of policy papers, many co-
authored with Perle, propounding a strongly anti-Palestinian, pro-Likud
view. He views the Palestinians as not constituting a legitimate national
group, believes that the West Bank and Gaza belong to Israel by right, and
has long advocated that the U.S. abandon any mediating effort altogether
and particularly foreswear the land-for-peace formula.
In 1996, Feith, Perle, and both David and Meyrav Wurmser were among the
authors of a policy paper issued by an Israeli think tank and written for
newly elected Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu that urged Israel to make a
“clean break” from pursuit ofthe peace process, particularly its land-for-
peace aspects, which the authors regarded as a prescription for Israel's
annihilation. Arabs must rather accept a “peace-for-peace” formula through
unconditional acceptance of Israel’s rights, including its territorial rights in
the occupied territories. The paper advocated that Israel “engage every
possible energy on rebuilding Zionism” by disengaging from economic and
political dependence on the U.S. while maintaining a more “mature,” self-
reliant partnership with the U.S. not focused “narrowly on territorial
disputes.” Greater self-reliance would, these freelance policymakers told
Netanyahu, give Israel “greater freedom of action and remove a significant
lever of pressure [i.e., U.S. pressure] used against it in the past.”
The paper advocated, even as far back as 1996, containment of the threat
against Israel by working closely with guess who? Turkey, as well as with
Jordan, apparently regarded as the only reliably moderate Arab regime.
Jordan had become attractive for these strategists because it was at the time
working with opposition elements in Iraq to reestablish a Hashemite
monarchy there that would have been allied by blood lines and political
leanings to the Hashemite throne in Jordan. The paper’s authors saw the
principal threat to Israel coming, we should not be surprised to discover
now, from Iraq and Syria and advised that focusing on the removal of
Saddam Hussein would kill two birds with one stone by also thwarting
Syria’s regional ambitions. In what amounts to a prelude to the neo-cons’
principal policy thrust in the Bush administration, the paper spoke frankly
of Israel’s interest in overturning the Iraqi leadership and replacing it with
a malleable monarchy. Referring to Saddam Hussein’s ouster as “an
important Israeli strategic objective,” the paper observed that “Iraq’s future
could affect the strategic balance in the Middle East profoundly” meaning
give Israel unquestioned predominance in the region. The authors urged
therefore that Israel support the Hashemites in their “efforts to redefine
Iraq.”
In a much longer policy document written at about the same time for the
same Israeli think tank, David Wurmser repeatedly linked the U.S. and
Israel when talking about national interests in the Middle
East [archived here, also see this]. The “battle to dominate and define Iraq,”
he wrote “is, by extension, the battle to dominate the balance of power in
the Levant over the long run,” and “the United States and Israel” can fight
this battle together. Repeated references to U.S. and Israeli strategic policy,
pitted against a “Saudi-Iraqi-Syrian-Iranian-PLO axis,” and to strategic
moves that establish a balance of power in which the United States and
Israel are ascendant, in alliance with Turkey and Jordan, betray a thought
process that cannot separate U.S. from Israeli interests.
Perle gave further impetus to this thrust when six years later, in September
2002, he gave a briefing for Pentagon officials that included a slide
depicting a recommended strategic goal for the U.S. in the Middle East: all
of Palestine as Israel, Jordan as Palestine, and Iraq as the Hashemite
kingdom. Secretary of Defense Rumsfeld seems to have taken this aboard,
since he spoke at about the same time of the West Bank and Gaza as the “so-
called occupied territories” effectively turning all of Palestine into Israel.
Elliot Abrams
Elliott Abrams is another unabashed supporter of the Israeli right, now
bringing his links with Israel into the service of U.S. policymaking on
Palestinian-Israeli issues. The neo-con community is crowing about
Abrams’ appointment as Middle East director on the NSC staff (where this
Iran-contra criminal has already been working since mid-2001, badly
miscast as the director for, of all things, democracy and human rights). The
Weekly Standard‘sFred Barnes has hailed his appointment as a decisive
move that neatly cocks a snook at the pro-Palestinian wimps at the State
Department. Accurately characterizing Abrams as “more pro-Israel, less
solicitous of Palestinians” than the State Department and strongly opposed
to the Palestinian-Israeli peace process, Barnes gloats that the Abrams
triumph signals that the White House will not cede control of Middle East
policy to Colin Powell and the “foreign service bureaucrats.” Abrams comes
to the post after a year in which it had effectively been left vacant. His
predecessor, Zalmay Khalilzad, has been serving concurrently as Bush’s
personal representative to Afghanistan since the fall of the Taliban and has
devoted little time to the NSC job, but several attempts to appoint a
successor early this year were vetoed by neo-con hawks who felt the
appointees were not devoted enough to Israel.
Although Abrams has no particular Middle East expertise, he has managed
to insert himself in the Middle East debate repeatedly over the years. He
has a family interest in propounding a pro-Israel view; he is the son-in-law
of Norman Podhoretz, one of the original neo-cons and a long-time
strident supporter of right-wing Israeli causes as editor of Commentary
magazine, and Midge Decter, a frequent right-wing commentator. Abrams
has written a good deal on the Palestinian-Israeli conflict, opposing U.S.
mediation and any effort to press for Israeli concessions. In an article
published in advance of the 2000 elections, he propounded a rationale for a
U.S. missile defense system, and a foreign policy agenda in general, geared
almost entirely toward ensuring Israel’s security. “It is a simple fact,” he
wrote, that the possession of missiles and weapons of mass destruction by
Iraq and Iran vastly increases Israel’s vulnerability, and this threat would
be greatly diminished if the U.S. provided a missile shield and brought
about the demise of Saddam Hussein. He concluded with a wholehearted
assertion of the identity of U.S. and Israeli interests: “The next decade will
present enormous opportunities to advance American interests in the
Middle East [by] boldly asserting our support of our friends” - that is, of
course, Israel. Many of the fundamental negotiating issues critical to Israel,
he said, are also critical to U.S. policy in the region and “require the United
States to defend its interests and allies” rather than giving in to Palestinian
demands.
Neo-cons in the Henhouse
The neo-con strategy papers halfa dozen years ago were dotted with
concepts like “redefining Iraq,” “redrawing the map of the Middle East,”
“nurturing alternatives to Arafat,” all of which have in recent months
become familiar parts of the Bush administration’s diplomatic lingo.
Objectives laid out in these papers as important strategic goals for Israel -
including the ouster of Saddam Hussein, the strategic transformation of the
entire Middle East, the death of the Palestinian-Israeli peace process,
regime change wherever the U.S. and Israel don’t happen to like the
existing government, the abandonment of any effort to forge a
comprehensive Arab-Israeli peace or even a narrower Palestinian-Israeli
peace have now become, under the guidance of this group of pro-Israel
neo-cons, important strategic goals for the United States. The enthusiasm
with which senior administration officials like Bush himself, Cheney, and
Rumsfeld have adopted strategic themes originally defined for Israel’s
guidance and did so in many cases well before September 11 and the so-
called war on terror testifies to the persuasiveness of a neo-con philosophy
focused narrowly on Israel and the pervasiveness of the network
throughout policymaking councils.
Does all this add up to dual loyalties to Israel and the United States? Many
would still contend indignantly that it does not, and that it is anti-Semitic to
suggest such a thing. In fact, zealous advocacy of Israel’s causes may be just
that zealotry, an emotional connection to Israel that still leaves room for
primary loyalty to the United States and affection for Israel is not in any
case a sentiment limited to Jews. But passion and emotion and, as George
Washington wisely advised, a passionate attachment to any country have
no place in foreign policy formulation, and it is mere hair-splitting to
suggest that a passionate attachment to another country is not loyalty to
that country. Zealotry clouds judgment, and emotion should never be the
basis for policymaking.
Zealotry can lead to extreme actions to sustain policies, as is apparently
occurring in the Rumsfeld-Wolfowitz-Feith Defense Department. People
knowledgeable of the intelligence community have said, according to a
recent article in The American Prospect [archived here], that the CIA is
under tremendous pressure to produce intelligence more supportive of war
with Iraq - as one former CIA official put it, “to support policies that have
already been adopted.” Key Defense Department officials, including Feith,
are said to be attempting to make the case for pre-emptive war by
producing their own unverified intelligence [see this 3-part series by
Pentagon insider]. Wolfowitz betrayed his lack of concern for real evidence
when, in answer to a recent question about where the evidence is for Iraq’s
possession of weapons of mass destruction, he replied, “It’s like the judge
said about pornography. I can’t define it, but I will know it when I see it.”
Zealotry can also lead to a myopic focus on the wrong issues in a conflict or
crisis, as is occurring among all Bush policymakers with regard to the
Palestinian-Israeli conflict. The administration’s obsessive focus on
deposing Yasir Arafat, a policy suggested by the neo-cons years before Bush
came to office, is a dodge and a diversion that merely perpetuates the
conflict by failing to address its real roots. Advocates of this policy fail or
refuse to see that, however unappealing the Palestinian leadership, it is not
the cause of the conflict, and “regime change” among the Palestinians will
do nothing to end the violence. The administration’s utter refusal to engage
in any mediation process that might produce a stable, equitable peace, also
a neo-con strategy based on the paranoid belief that any peace involving
territorial compromise will spell the annihilation of Israel, will also merely
prolong the violence. Zealotry produces blindness: the zealous effort to
pursue Israel's right-wing agenda has blinded the dual loyalists in the
administration to the true face of Israel as occupier, to any concern for
justice or equity and any consideration that interests other than Israel’s are
involved, and indeed to any pragmatic consideration that continued
unquestioning accommodation of Israel, far from bringing an end to
violence, will actually lead to its tragic escalation and to increased
terrorism against both the United States and Israel.
What does it matter, in the end, if these men split their loyalties between
the United States and Israel? Apart from the evidence of the policy
distortions that arise from zealotry, one need only ask whether it can be
mere coincidence that those in the Bush administration who most strongly
promote “regime change” in Iraq are also those who most strongly support
the policies of the Israeli right wing. And would it bother most Americans to
know that the United States is planning a war against Iraq for the benefit of
Israel? Can it be mere coincidence, for example, that Vice President Cheney,
now the leading senior-level proponent of war with Iraq, repudiated just
this option for all the right reasons in the immediate aftermath of the Gulf
War in 1991? He was defense secretary at the time, and in an interview
with the New York Times on April 13, 1991, he said:
“Ifyou're going to go in and try to topple Saddam Hussein, you have
to go to Baghdad. Once you've got Baghdad, it’s not clear what you
will do with it. It's not clear what kind of government you would put
in place of the one that's currently there now. Is it going to be a Shia
regime, a Sunni regime or a Kurdish regime? Or one that tilts toward
the Ba'athists, or one that tilts toward the Islamic fundamentalists.
How much credibility is that government going to have if it's set up by
the United States military when it's there? How long does the United
States military have to stay to protect the people that sign on for the
government, and what happens to it once we leave?”
Since Cheney clearly changed his mind between 1991 and today, is it not
legitimate to ask why, and whether Israel might have a greater influence
over U.S. foreign policy now than it had in 1991? After all, notwithstanding
his wisdom in rejecting an expansion of the war on Iraq a decade ago,
Cheney was just as interested in promoting U.S. imperialism and was at that
same moment in the early 1990s outlining a plan for world domination by
the United States, one that did not include conquering Iraq at any point
along the way. The only new ingredient in the mix today that is inducing
Cheney to begin the march to U.S. world domination by conquering
Iraq is the presence in the Bush-Cheney administration of a bevy of
aggressive right-wing neo-con hawks who have long backed the Jewish
fundamentalists of Israel's own right wing and who have been
advocating some move on Iraq for at least the last half dozen years?
The suggestion that the war with Iraq is being planned at Israel’s behest, or
at the instigation of policymakers whose main motivation is trying to create
a secure environment for Israel, is strong. Many Israeli analysts believe
this. The Israeli commentator Akiva Eldar recently observed frankly in
a Ha’aretz column that Perle, Feith, and their fellow strategists “are walking
a fine line between their loyalty to American governments and Israeli
interests.” The suggestion of dual loyalties is not a verboten subject in the
Israeli press, as it is in the United States. Peace activist Uri Avnery, who
knows Israeli Prime Minister Sharon well, has written that Sharon has long
planned grandiose schemes for restructuring the Middle East and that “the
winds blowing now in Washington remind me of Sharon. Ihave absolutely
no proof that the Bushies got their ideas from him . But the style is the
same.”
The dual loyalists in the Bush administration have given added impetus to
the growth of a messianic strain of Christian fundamentalism that has
allied itself with Israel in preparation for the so-called End of Days. These
crazed fundamentalists see Israel's domination over all of Palestine as a
necessary step toward fulfillment of the biblical Millennium, consider any
Israeli relinquishment of territory in Palestine as a sacrilege, and view
warfare between Jews and Arabs as a divinely ordained prelude to
Armageddon. [To see how this novel interpretation of the Bible took hold,
see this.] These right-wing Christian extremists [in some cases led by Jewish
Israel partisans] have a profound influence on Bush and his administration,
with the result that the Jewish fundamentalists working for the
perpetuation of Israel's domination in Palestine and the Christian
fundamentalists working for the Millennium strengthen and reinforce each
other’s policies in administration councils. The Armageddon that Christian
Zionists seem to be actively promoting and that Israeli loyalists inside the
administration have tactically allied themselves with raises the horrifying
but very real prospect of an apocalyptic Christian-Islamic war. The neo-
cons seem unconcerned, and Bush’s occasional pro forma remonstrations
against blaming all Islam for the sins of Islamic extremists do nothing to
make this prospect less likely.
These two strains of Jewish and Christian fundamentalism have dovetailed
into an agenda for a vast imperial project to restructure the Middle East, all
further reinforced by the happy coincidence of great oil resources up for
grabs and a president and vice president heavily invested in oil. All of these
factors the dual loyalties of an extensive network of policymakers allied
with Israel, the influence of a fanatical wing of Christian fundamentalists,
and oil probably factor in more or less equally to the administration’s
calculations on the Palestinian-Israeli situation and on war with Iraq. But
the most critical factor directing U.S. policymaking is the group of Israeli
loyalists: neither Christian fundamentalist support for Israel nor oil
calculations would carry the weight in administration councils that they do
without the pivotal input of those loyalists, who clearly know how to play to
the Christian fanatics and undoubtedly also know that their own and
Israel's bread is buttered by the oil interests of people like Bush and Cheney.
This is where loyalty to Israel by government officials colors and influences
U.S. policymaking in ways that are extremely dangerous.
Too Many Smoking Guns to Ignore:
Israel, American Jews and the War on Iraq
BY BILL CHRISTISON - KATHLEEN CHRISTISON, CounterPunch, January
25, 2003
— reposted on If Americans Knew
Most of the vociferously pro-Israeli neo-conservative policymakers in the
Bush administration make no effort to hide the fact that at least part of
their intention in promoting war against Iraq (and later perhaps against
Syria, Iran, Hezbollah, and the Palestinians) is to guarantee Israel's security
by eliminating its greatest military threats, forging a regional balance of
power overwhelmingly in Israel's favor, and in general creating a more
friendly atmosphere for Israel in the Middle East. Yet, despite the neo-cons'
own openness, a great many of those on the left who oppose going to war
with Iraq and oppose the neo-conservative doctrines ofthe Bush
administration nonetheless utterly reject any suggestion that Israel is
pushing the United States into war, or is cooperating with the U.S., or even
hopes to benefit by such a war. Anyone who has the temerity to suggest any
Israeli instigation of, or even involvement in, Bush administration war
planning is inevitably labeled somewhere along the way as an anti-Semite.
Just whisper the word “domination” anywhere in the vicinity of the word
“Israel,” as in “U.S.-Israeli domination of the Middle East” or “the U.S. drive
to assure global domination and guarantee security for Israel,” and some
leftist who otherwise opposes going to war against Iraq will trot out charges
of promoting the Protocols of the Elders of Zion, the old czarist forgery that
asserted a Jewish plan for world domination.
This is tiresome, to put it mildly. So it’s useful to put forth the evidence for
the assertion of Israeli complicity in Bush administration planning for war
with Iraq, which is voluminous, as the following recitation will show. Much
of what is presented below could be classified as circumstantial, but much
is from the mouths of the horses themselves, either the neo-con planners or
Israeli government officials, and much of it is evidence that, even if Israel is
not actively pushing for war, many Israelis expect to benefit from it, and
this despite their fear that a war will bring down on Israel a shower of Iraqi
missiles.
The evidence below is listed chronologically, except for two items grouped
separately at the end. Although deletions have been made for the sake of
brevity, and emphasis has been added to occasional phrases and sentences,
no editorial narrative has been added. The evidence speaks for itself.
“Benjamin Netanyahu's government comes in with a new set of ideas.
While there are those who will counsel continuity, Israel has the
opportunity to make a clean break; it can forge a peace process and
strategy based on an entirely new intellectual foundation, one that
restores strategic initiative.To secure the nation's streets and borders
in the immediate future, Israel can [among other steps] work closely
with Turkey and Jordan to contain, destabilize, and roll-back some of
its most dangerous threats. This implies a clean break from the
slogan, ‘comprehensive peace” to a traditional concept of strategy
based on balance of power. Israel can shape its strategic
environment, in cooperation with Turkey and Jordan, by weakening,
containing, and even rolling back Syria. This effort can focus on
removing Saddam Hussein from power in Iraq, an important Israeli
strategic objective in its own right, as a means of foiling Syria's
regional ambitions. Jordan has challenged Syria's regional ambitions
recently by suggesting the restoration of the Hashemites in Iraq..Since
Iraq's future could affect the strategic balance in the Middle East
profoundly, it would be understandable that Israel has an interest in
supporting the Hashemites in their efforts to redefine Iraq. Israel's
new agenda can signal a clean break by abandoning a policy
whichallowed strategic retreat, by reestablishing the principle of
preemption, rather than retaliation alone and by ceasing to absorb
blows to the nation without response. Israel's new strategic agenda
can shape the regional environment in ways that grant Israel the
room to refocus its energies back to where they are most needed: to
rejuvenate its national idea.Ultimately, Israel can do more than
simply manage the Arab-Israeli conflict though war. No amount of
weapons or victories will grant Israel the peace it seeks. When Israel
is on a sound economic footing, and is free, powerful, and healthy
internally, it will no longer simply manage the Arab-Israeli conflict; it
will transcend it. As a senior Iraqi opposition leader said recently:
Israel must rejuvenate and revitalize its moral and intellectual
leadership. It is an important, if not the most important, element in
the history of the Middle East.’ Israel-proud, wealthy, solid, and
strong-would be the basis of a truly new and peaceful Middle East.”
“A Clean Break: A New Strategy for Securing the Realm,” policy paper
written for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, mid-1996,
under the auspices of an Israeli think tank, the Institute for Advanced
Strategic and Political Studies. Authors included Richard Perle,
Douglas Feith, and David Wurmser, now all policymakers in or policy
advisers to the Bush administration
“Iraq's future will profoundly affect the strategic balance in the
Middle East. The battle to dominate and define Iraq is, by extension,
the battle to dominate the balance of power in the Levant over the
long run.Iraq tried to take over its neighbor, Kuwait, a catastrophic
mistake that has accelerated Iraq's descent into internal chaos. This
chaos has created a vacuum in an area geostrategically central, and
rich with human and natural resources. The vacuum tempts Iraq's
neighbors to intervene, especially Syria, which is also driven to
control the region.Iraq's chaos and Syria's efforts simultaneously
provide opportunities for the Jordanian monarchy. Jordan is best
suited to manage the tribal politics that will define the Levant in the
wake of failed secular-Arab nationalism.IfJordan wins, then Syria
would be isolated and surrounded by a new pro-western Jordanian-
Israeli-Iraqi-Turkish bloc.It would be prudent for the United States
and Israel to abandon the quest for comprehensive peace,” including
its land for peace’ provision with Syria, since it locks the United
States into futile attempts to prop-up local tyrants and the unnatural
states underneath them. Instead, the United States and Israel can use
this competition over Iraq to improve the regional balance of power
in favor of regional friends like Jordan.”
“Coping with Crumbling States: A Western and Israeli Balance of
Power Strategy for the Levant,” policy paper written for an Israeli
think tank, the Institute for Advanced Strategic and Political Studies,
December 1996, by David Wurmser, now a State Department official
in the Bush administration
“In the [occupied] territories, the Arab world, and in Israel, Bush's
support for Sharon is being credited to the pro-Israel lobby, meaning
Jewish money and the Christian right.[In April 2002] state
department professionals convinced Bush that it was important to
quell the violence in the territories before assaulting Iraq. The U.S.
military supported that view, emphasizing the critical importance of
the ground bases in Saudi Arabia and Egypt, for the success of the
mission. But according to a well-placed American source, the weather
vane turned. Vice President Dick Cheney, Defense Secretary Donald
Rumsfeld, and Rumsfeld’s deputy, Paul Wolfowitz, asked Bush what
kind of coalition-shmoalition he needed to win the war in
Afghanistan. They calmed his concerns by saying there’s no chance
the situation in the territories will shake the regimes of Mubarak in
Egypt and the Abdullahs in Jordan and Saudi Arabia.Last Saturday
[April 20], the president convened his advisors in Camp David, for
another discussion of the crisis in the territories and Iraq. They
decided to sit on the fence.”
Israeli commentator Akiva Eldar, Ha'aretz, April 26, 2002
“It echoes the hawks in the Bush administration, but Israel has its
own agenda in backing a US attack on Iraq. As Egypt and other Arab
allies issue vehement warnings to dissuade Washington, Israel’s fear
is that the US will back off. Ifthe Americans do not do this now,’ said
Israeli Deputy Defense Minister and Labor Party member Weizman
Shiry on Wednesday, ‘it will be harder to do it in the future. In a year
or two, Saddam Hussein will be further along in developing weapons
of mass destruction. It is a world interest, but especially an American
interest to attack Iraq. And as deputy defense minister, I can tell you
that the United States will receive any assistance it needs from Israel,’
he added. Viewed through the eyes of Israel’s hawkish leaders,
however, a US strike is not about Iraq only. Decisionmakers believe it
will strengthen Israel’s hand on the Palestinian front and throughout
the region. Deputy Interior Minister Gideon Ezra suggested this week
that a US attack on Iraq will help Israel impose a new order, sans
Arafat, in the Palestinian territories. The more aggressive the attack
is, the more it will help Israel against the Palestinians. The
understanding would be that what is good to do in Iraq, is also good
for here,’ said Ezra. He said a US strike would “undoubtedly deal a
psychological blow” to the Palestinians.Yuval Steinitz, a Likud party
member of the Knesset's Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee, says
he sees another advantage for Israel. The installation of a pro-
American government in Iraq would help Israel vis-a-vis another
enemy: Syria. After Iraq is taken by US troops and we see a new
regime installed as in Afghanistan, and Iraqi bases become American
bases, it will be very easy to pressure Syria to stop supporting
terrorist organizations like Hizbullah and Islamic Jihad, to allow the
Lebanese army to dismantle Hizbullah, and maybe to put an end to
the Syrian occupation in Lebanon,’ he says. “If this happens we will
really see a new Middle East. It might be enough not to invade Syria
but just to have an American or UN blockade so that no one can ship
weapons to it,’ Steinitz adds.Mr. Ezra predicts a US strike would
“calm down the entire region’ by eliminating ‘the extremism of
Saddam.”
Ben Lynfield, Christian Science Monitor, August 30, 2002
“As the Bush administration debates going to war against Iraq, its
most hawkish members are pushing a sweeping vision for the Middle
East that sees the overthrow of President Saddam Hussein of Iraq as
merely a first step in the region’s transformation. The argument for
reshaping the political landscape in the Mideast has been pushed for
years by some Washington think tanks and in hawkish circles. It is
now being considered as a possible US policy with the ascent of key
hard-liners in the administration, from Paul Wolfowitz and Douglas
Feith in the Pentagon to John Hannah and Lewis Libby on the vice
president’s staff and John Bolton in the State Department, analysts
and officials say. Iraq, the hawks argue, is just the first piece of the
puzzle. After an ouster of Hussein, they say, the United States will
have more leverage to act against Syria and Iran, will be in a better
position to resolve the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, and will be able to
rely less on Saudi oil. The thinking does not represent official US
policy. But increasingly the argument has served as a justification for
a military attack against Iraq, and elements of the strategy have
emerged in speeches by administration officials, most prominently
Vice President Dick Cheney.A powerful corollary of the strategy is
that a pro-US Iraq would make the region safer for Israel and, indeed,
its staunchest proponents are ardent supporters of the Israeli right-
wing. Administration officials, meanwhile, have increasingly argued
that the onset of an Iraq allied to the US would give the
administration more sway in bringing about a settlement to the
Israeli-Palestinian conflict, though Cheney and others have offered
few details on precisely how.In its broadest terms, the advocates
argue that a democratic Iraq would unleash similar change
elsewhere in the Arab world.’Everyone will flip out, starting with the
Saudis,’ said Meyrav Wurmser, director of the Center for Middle East
Policy at the Hudson Institute in Washington [and another author of
the 1996 policy paper written for Israel, above]. Tt will send shock
waves throughout the Arab world. Look, we already are pushing for
democracy in the Palestinian Authority, though not with a huge
amount of success, and we need a little bit more of a heavy-handed
approach,’ she said. ‘But ifwe can get a democracy in the Palestinian
Authority, democracy in Iraq, get the Egyptians to improve their
human rights and open up their system, it will be a spectacular
change. After a war with Iraq, then you really shape the region.”
John Donnelly and Anthony Shadid, Boston Globe, September 10, 2002
“Slowly, President Bush’s war plan against Iraq is emerging from the
thick fog. At first it looked like a collection of hazy slogans, but
gradually it is becoming clear that it has definite, if hidden, aims.The
war plan of the Bushies makes sense only if the US leadership is ready
(more than that, is actually longing) for the occupation of Iraq in
order to remain there for many, many years.But in the eyes of Bush
and his advisers, this is a very worthwhile investment that would
yield immense benefits. Among others:
e The main objective of the American economy (and therefore of
American policy) is the oil of the Caspian Sea.
e The existence of a secure American base in the heart of the Arab
world will also enable Washington to bully allthe Arab regimes, lest
they stray from the straight and narrow.
e The new situation will destroy the last remnants of Arab
independence. Even today, almost all the Arab countries are
dependent on America.
A massive American physical presence in their midst will put an end
to any pretense of Arab power and unity.A grandiose, world-
embracing, yet simple and logical design. What does it remind me of?
In the early 80’s, I heard about several plans like this from Ariel
Sharon (which I published at the time). His head was full of grand
designs for restructuring the Middle East, the creation of an Israeli
“security zone” from Pakistan to Central Africa, the overthrow of
regimes and installing others in their stead, moving a whole people
(the Palestinians) and so forth. I can’t help it, but the winds blowing
now in Washington remind me of Sharon. I have absolutely no proof
that the Bushies got their ideas from him, even if all of them seem to
have been mesmerized by him. But the style is the same, a mixture of
megalomania, creativity, arrogance, ignorance and superficiality. An
explosive mixture. Sharon’s grand design floundered, as we know. The
bold flights of imagination and the superficial logic did not help; -
Sharon simply did not understand the real currents of history. I fear
that the band of Bush, Cheney, Rumsfield, Rice, Wolfowitz, Perle and
all the other little Sharons are suffering from the same
syndrome.Sharon may believe that he will be the big winner of such
an American move, though history may show that he brought a
historical disaster on us. He may succeed in exploiting the ensuing
anarchy in order to drive the Palestinians out of the country. But
within a few years Israel could find itself surrounded by a new Middle
EastA region full of hatred, dreaming ofrevenge, driven by religious
and nationalist fanaticism. And in the end, the Americans will go
home. We will be left here alone. But people like Bush and Sharon do
not march to the beat of history. They are listening to a different
drummer.”
Israeli peace activist Uri Avnery, CounterPunch.org, September 10,
2002
“Ever since the Bush administration ordered the CIA to nurture the
exiled Iraqis, nothing happens to them by accident. [Jordanian] Prince
Hassan didn’t just happen to drop in [on a meeting of Iraqi exiles in
London] because he was in town. The Hashemite dynasty has never
given up its dream to revive the Iraqi throne. It could be a great job
for Hassan, whose older brother [the late King Hussein] denied him
the Jordanian kingdom at the last minute. It’s true that restoring a
monarchy in Iraq does not exactly fit the Bush administration’s vision
of a democratic Middle East. But there are signs that it fits some old
dreams of a few of the key strategists around the Bush-Cheney-
Rumsfeld triangle running America's Iraq policy. A few weeks ago,
Richard Perle invited the Pentagon chiefs to a meeting with
researchers from a Washington think tank. According to information
that reached a former top official in the Israeli security services, the
researchers showed two slides to the Pentagon officials. The first was
a depiction of the three goals in the war on terror and the
democratization of the Middle East: Iraq, a tactical goal; Saudi
Arabia, a strategic goal; and Egypt, the great prize. The triangle in the
next slide was no less interesting: Palestine is Israel, Jordan is
Palestine, and Iraq is the Hashemite Kingdom.”
Israeli commentator Akiva Eldar, Haaretz, October 1, 2002
“The summer of 1993 saw the emergence of two contradictory paths
concerning Israel and its place in the Middle East. The signing of the
Oslo agreement raised hopes for Israel’s integration into a web of
political, security and economic cooperation with its Arab neighbors.
At the same time, Harvard Prof. Samuel Huntington published his
essay, The Clash of Civilizations,’ in which he argued that the
conflicts around the world would no longer be over ideology, but over
culture instead. Islam has bloody borders,’ Huntington wrote,
counting Israel as a ‘Western creation’ on the fault lines of the
conflict, along with Kashmir and Bosnia. The idea was accepted
enthusiastically by the Israeli right wing. It also had some supporters
on the left, most noticeably Ehud Barak, who described Israel as a
Western fortress in the region, “a villa in the jungle.’ As of now, it
appears that the argument was settled in favor ofthe clash of
civilizations theory, which has taken over the political and security
establishment in Israel. The appeal of the clash of civilizations theory
is also expressed in the Israeli enthusiasm for the expected American
assault on Iraq, in the hope of showing the Arabs who’s the boss in
the region. Israel is the only country to absolutely support the
American decision, and has urged it to act, and quickly. The
tangible result of the change in consciousness has been deepening
Israel’s dependence on American defense and economic support.
Sharon led that policy. The same Sharon says there are no free
lunches in policy and is now begging for aid from Washington, trying
to point the American cannon in the direction of its next target after
Iraq.”
Israeli correspondent Aluf Benn, Haaretz, November 14, 2002
“The embrace of U.S. President George W. Bush is Ariel Sharon’s chief
asset as he vies for another term of office as prime minister. Sharon is
finding it hard to show any achievements during his 20 months in
power. The only card left in his hand is the diplomatic card, as
personified by Israel's good relations with the White House, and all of
Sharon’s campaign revolves around it. Sharon and his cronies are
now asking the voters for an extended period of grace, and are
promising that next year will be the year that counts. All of their
hopes and expectations are pointed toward Washington: an
American attack on Iraq is seen as the lever which can
extricate Israel from its economic, security and social
quagmire. It is hoped that the removal of Saddam Hussein from
power will set in motion a ‘domino effect,’ will end the Palestinian
Intifada, bring about the end of Yasser Arafat’s regime and eradicate
the threat to Israel from Iran, Syria and Hezbollah.”
Israeli correspondent Aluf Benn, Haaretz, November 18, 2002
“To understand the genesis of this extraordinary [US global]
ambition, it is also necessary to grasp the moral, cultural and
intellectual world of American nationalism in which it has taken
shape. This nationalism existed long before last September, but it has
been inflamed by those attacks and, equally dangerously, it has
become even more entwined with the nationalism of the Israeli Right.
The banal propaganda portrayal of Saddam as a crazed and suicidal
dictator plays well on the American street, but I don’t believe that it is
a view shared by the Administration. Rather, their intention is partly
to retain an absolute certainty of being able to defend the Gulf against
an Iraqi attack, but, more important, to retain for the US and Israel a
free hand for intervention in the Middle East as a whole. From the
point of view of Israel, the Israeli lobby and their representatives in
the Administration, the apparent benefits of such a free hand are
clear enough. For the group around Cheney, the single most
important consideration is guaranteed and unrestricted access to
cheap oil, controlled as far as possible at its source. [A]s alternative
technologies develop, they could become a real threat to the oil lobby,
which, like the Israeli lobby, is deeply intertwined with the Bush
Administration. War with Iraq can therefore be seen as a satisfactory
outcome for both lobbies.[W]hat the Administration hopes is that by
crushing another middle-sized state at minimal military cost, all the
other states in the Muslim world will be terrified into full co-
operation in tracking down and handing over suspected terrorists,
and into forsaking the Palestinian cause.The idea, in other words, is
to scare these states not only into helping with the hunt for al-Qaida,
but into capitulating to the US and, more important, Israeli
agendas in the Middle East.’ The road to Middle East peace lies
through Baghdad’ is a line that's peddled by the Bush Administration
and the Israeli lobby. It is just possible that some members of the
Administration really believe that by destroying Israel’s most
powerful remaining enemy they will gain such credit with Israelis and
the Israeli lobby that they will be able to press compromises on Israel.
But this is certainly not what public statements by members of the
Administration, let alone those of its Likud allies in Israel, suggest.It’s
far more probable, therefore, that most members of the Bush and
Sharon Administrations hope that the crushing of Iraq will so
demoralise the Palestinians, and so reduce wider Arab support for
them, that it will be possible to force them to accept a Bantustan
settlement bearing no resemblance to independent statehood.From
the point of view of the Arab-Israeli conflict, war with Iraq also has
some of the character of a Flucht nach vorn, an ‘escape forwards,’ on
the part of the US Administration. On the one hand, it has become
clear that the conflict is integrally linked to everything else that
happens in the Middle East, and therefore cannot simply be ignored,
as the Bush Administration tried to do during its first year in office.
On the other hand, even those members of the American political elite
who have some understanding of the situation and a concern for
justice are terrified of confronting Israel and the Israeli lobby in the
ways which would be necessary to bring any chance of peace. When
the US demands ‘democracy’ in the Palestinian territories before it
will re-engage in the peace process it is in part, and fairly cynically,
trying to get out of this trap.”Dexter Filkins, New York Times,
December 29, 2002
Anatol Lieven, Senior Associate at the Carnegie Endowment for
International Peace, London Review of Books, December 2002
“If you want to know what the administration has in mind for Iraq,
here’s a hint: It has less to do with weapons of mass destruction than
with implementing an ambitious U.S. vision to redraw the map of the
Middle East. The new map would be drawn with an eye to two main
objectives: controlling the flow of oil and ensuring Israel’s
continued regional military superiority. [Patrick] Clawson [a
policy analyst with the Washington Institute for Near East Policy],
whose institute enjoys close ties with the Bush administration, was
candid during a Capitol Hill forum on a post-Hussein Iraq in 1999:
U.S. oil companies would have an opportunity to make significant
profits,’ he said. ‘We should not be embarrassed about the
commercial advantages that would come from a re-integration of
Iraq into the world economy.”...But taking over Iraq and remaking the
global oil market is not necessarily the endgame. The next steps,
favored by hard-liners determined to elevate Israeli security
above all other U.S. foreign policy goals, would be to destroy any
remaining perceived threat to the Jewish state: namely, the regimes in
Syria and Iran. In 1998, [David] Wurmser, now in the State
Department, told the Jewish newspaper Forward that if [Iraqi
opposition leader] Ahmad Chalabi were in power and extended a no-
fly, no-drive zone in northern Iraq, it would provide the crucial piece
for an anti-Syria, anti-Iran bloc. ‘It puts Scuds out of the range of
Israel and provides the geographic beachhead between Turkey,
Jordan and Israel? he said. “This should anchor the Middle East pro-
Western coalition.’ [Richard] Perle, in the same 1998 article,
told Forward that a coalition of pro-Israeli groups was “at the
forefront with the legislation with regard to Iran. One can only
speculate what it might accomplish ifit decided to focus its attention
on Saddam Hussein.’Now, Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon has
joined the call against Tehran, arguing in a November interview with
the Times of London that the U.S. should shift its focus to Iran ‘the
day after’ the Iraq war ends.[T]he hard-liners in and around the
administration seem to know in their hearts that the battle to carve
up the Middle East would not be won without the blood of Americans
and their allies. ‘One can only hope that we turn the region into a
caldron, and faster, please,’ [Michael] Ledeen preached to the choir
at National Review Online last August. That's our mission in the war
against terror.”
UC Berkeley journalism professor Sandy Tolan, Los Angeles Times,
December 1, 2002
“The immediate and laudatory purpose of a United States military
campaign against Iraq is to stamp out the regime of Saddam Hussein,
the world’s most psychopathic ruler, and to strike a blow against
terrorism and the proliferation of weapons of mass destruction. As
such this is a welcome move from Israel’s standpoint, whatever the
consequences. [T]he American planners, who display considerable
disdain for most of the Muslim and Arab worlds, seem to think that
the forcible removal of Saddam’s evil regime and the consequent
implantation of an American military presence in the wild Middle
East will project a civilizing or liberating influence. They are not
alone; not a few progressive Arab thinkers (and many Israelis)
appear to welcome this American deus ex machina into the region.”
Israeli military/political analyst, Yossi Alpher, bitterlemons.org,
December 23, 2002
“I think that the conquest of Iraq will really create a New Middle East.
Put differently: the Middle East will enter a new age. For the time
being this will happen without us, as long as there's no Palestinian
solution. Many peoples in the region are ruled by frightened dictators
who have to decide whom to fear more, the terrorists or the war
against terrorism. Asad fears for his legitimacy due to the war
against terrorism. Arafat can also lose his legitimacy. The Saudis
gave money for terrorism due to fear. No terrorist-sponsoring
country is democratic. In those countries [that support terrorism]
there will be revolutions. Television will play a role like in the collapse
of the Iron Curtain. This will happen with the Palestinians, too. The
Arab world is ripe for internal revolution like the USSR and China in
the past decade.”
Former Israeli Prime Minister Shimon Peres, bitterlemons.org,
December 23, 2002
“Republican Sen. Chuck Hagel of Nebraska, having just returned from
a week-long fact-finding trip to the Middle East, addressed the
Chicago Council of Foreign Relations Dec. 16 and said out loud what
is whispered on Capitol Hill: The road to Arab-Israeli peace will not
likely go through Baghdad, as some may claim.’ The ‘some’ are led by
Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon. In private conversation with
Hagel and many other members of Congress, the former general
leaves no doubt that the greatest U.S. assistance to Israel would be to
overthrow Saddam Hussein’s Iraqi regime. That view is widely shared
inside the Bush administration, and is a major reason why U.S. forces
today are assembling for war. As the US gets ready for war, its
standing in Islam, even among longtime allies, stands low. Yet, the
Bush administration has tied itself firmly to Gen. Sharon and his
policies. In private conversation, National Security Adviser
Condoleezza Rice has insisted that Hezbollah, not al Qaeda, is the
world’s most dangerous terrorist organization. How could that be,
considering al Qaeda’s global record of mass carnage? In truth,
Hezbollah is the world’s most dangerous terrorist organization from
Israel’s standpoint. While viciously anti-American in rhetoric, the
Lebanon-based Hezbollah is focused on the destruction of Israel.
Thus, Rice’s comments suggest that the U.S. war against terrorism,
accused of being Iraq-centric, actually is Israel-centric. That ties
George W. Bush to Arik Sharon.What is widely perceived as an
indissoluble Bush-Sharon bond creates tension throughout Islam.On
balance, war with Iraq may not be inevitable but is highly probable.
That it looks like Sharon's war disturbs Americans such as Chuck
Hagel, who have no use for Saddam Hussein but worry about the
background of an attack against him.”
Robert Novak, Washington Post, December 26, 2002
“with a scandal chipping away at his government, Prime Minister
Ariel Sharon changed the subject to Iraq this week and found his
country eager to listen.Mr. Sharon’s remarks seemed to strike a chord
with Israeli voters, who are concerned about an Iraqi attack and still
traumatized by the events of 1991, when 39 Iraqi missiles landed in
the country. To some Israeli commentators, the week's events
highlighted the lingering effects of the first war with Iraq, and how
Mr. Sharon, an incumbent prime minister with an unmatched
reputation for toughness, is the likely beneficiary of any debate over a
second one. ‘What happened in 1991 is an unfinished chapter,’ said
Asher Arian, a senior fellow at the Israel Democracy Institute in
Jerusalem. The Israeli public feels it has a score to settle. When
Sharon talks about Iraq, it has enormous resonance. ‘Part of the
explanation for the positive reception of Mr. Sharon is the genuine
fear that many Israelis harbor of an Iraqi attack. The other factor,
commentators here say, is the looming memory of the Persian Gulf
war of 1991. For Israelis, proud of their military successes over the
years, that war was a different experience. At American insistence,
they endured Iraqi missile attacks without fighting back. The gulf
war was the first time in Israel’s history where people had to hide and
run way,’ said Itzhak Galnoor, former commissioner of the Israeli
civil service. ‘For Israelis to be helpless, that was very traumatic.”
Dexter Filkins, New York Times, December 29, 2002
Authors’ note: Given the prevailing atmosphere in the United States for
debate on Israel, the frequency with which critics of Israel are accused
of malicious ethnic motives, and the widespread skittishness about
associating Israel or American Jews with war planning against Iraq, the
following items are of particular interest. The first of these items
reports a clear Jewish effort to suppress any evidence of Jewish
support for war. The second is evidence, from a non-Jewish
perspective, of the effect of the silence imposed on critics of Israel.
“A group of U.S. political consultants has sent pro-Israel leaders a
memo urging them to keep quiet while the Bush administration
pursues a possible war with Iraq. The six-page memo was sent by the
Israel Project, a group funded by American Jewish organizations and
individual donors. Its authors said the main audience was American
Jewish leaders, but much of the memo’s language is directed toward
Israelis. The memo reflects a concern that involvement by Israel in a
U.S.-Iraq confrontation could hurt Israel’s standing in American
public opinion and undermine international support for a hard line
against Iraqi President Saddam Hussein. ‘Let American politicians
fight it out on the floor of Congress and in the media,’ the memo said.
‘Let the nations of the world argue in front of the UN. Your silence
allows everyone to focus on Iraq rather than Israel.’ An Israeli
diplomat in Washington said the Israeli government did not request
or fund the efforts of the Israel Project and that Israeli leaders were
unlikely to follow all the advice. ‘These are professional public
relations people,’ the diplomat said. ‘There’s also a political-
diplomatic side.’ The Iraq memo was issued in the past few weeks and
labeled ‘confidential property of the Israel Project,’ which is led by
Democratic consultant Jennifer Laszlo Mizrahi with help from
Democratic pollster Stan Greenberg and Republican pollsters Neil
Newhouse and Frank Luntz. Several of the consultants have advised
Israeli politicians, and the group aired a pro-Israel ad earlier this
year. If your goal is regime change, you must be much more careful
with your language because of the potential backlash,’ said the
memo, titled ‘Talking About Iraq.’ It added: ‘You do not want
Americans to believe that the war on Iraq is being waged to protect
Israel rather than to protect America.” In particular, the memo urged
Israelis to pipe down about the possibility of Israel responding to an
Iraqi attack. “Such certainty may be Israeli policy, but asserting it
publicly and so overtly will not sit well with a majority of Americans
because it suggests a pre-determined outcome rather than a
measured approach,’ it said.”
Dana Milbank, Washington Post, November 27, 2002
“[We need to] demystify the question of why we have become unable
to discuss our relationship with the current government of Israel.
Whether the actions taken by that government constitute self-defense
or a particularly inclusive form of self-immolation remains an open
question. The question of course has a history.This open question, and
its history, are discussed rationally and with considerable intellectual
subtlety in Jerusalem and Tel Aviv. Where the question is not
discussed rationally, where in fact the question is rarely discussed at
all, since so few of us are willing to see our evenings turn toxic, is in
New York and Washington and in those academic venues where the
attitudes and apprehensions of New York and Washington have taken
hold. The president of Harvard recently warned that criticisms of the
current government of Israel could be construed as “anti-Semitic in
their effect if not their intent.’ The very question of the US relationship
with Israel, in other words, has come to be seen as unraisable,
potentially lethal, the conversational equivalent of an unclaimed bag
on a bus. We take cover. We wait for the entire subject to be defused,
safely insulated behind baffles of invective and counterinvective.
Many opinions are expressed. Few are allowed to develop. Even fewer
change.”
Joan Didion, New York Review of Books, January 16, 2003
Kathleen Christison worked for 16 years as a political analyst with the CIA,
dealing first with Vietnam and then with the Middle East for her last seven
years with the Agency before resigning in 1979. Since leaving the CIA, she has
been a free-lance writer, dealing primarily with the Israeli-Palestinian
conflict. Her book, “Perceptions of Palestine: Their Influence on U.S. Middle
East Policy,” was published by the University of California Press and reissued
in paperback with an update in October 2001. A second book, “The Wound of
Dispossession: Telling the Palestinian Story,” was published in March 2002.
Bill Christison joined the CIA in 1950, and served on the analysis side of the
Agency for 28 years. From the early 1970s he served as National Intelligence
Officer (principal adviser to the Director of Central Intelligence on certain
areas) for, at various times, Southeast Asia, South Asia and Africa. Before he
retired in 1979 he was Director ofthe CIA’s Office of Regional and Political
Analysis, a 250-person unit.
Serving Two Flags: Neo-Cons, Israel and the Bush
Administration
BY STEPHEN GREEN, Counter Punch, February 28/29, 2004
— Reposted on IAK
Since 9-11, asmall group of “neo-conservatives” in the Administration have
effectively gutted-they would say reformed-traditional American foreign
and security policy. Notable features ofthe new Bush doctrine include the
pre-emptive use of unilateral force, and the undermining of the United
Nations and the principle instruments and institutions of international
law....allin the cause of fighting terrorism and promoting homeland
security.
Some skeptics, noting the neo-cons’ past academic and professional
associations, writings and public utterances, have suggested that their
underlying agenda is the alignment of U.S. foreign and security policies
with those of Ariel Sharon and the Israeli right wing. The administration’s
new hard line on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict certainly suggests that, as
perhaps does the destruction, with U.S. soldiers and funds, of the military
capacity of Iraq, and the current belligerent neo-con campaign against the
other two countries which constitute a remaining counterforce to Israeli
military hegemony in the region-Iran and Syria.
Have the neo-conservatives-many of whom are senior officials in the
Defense Department, National Security Council and Office of the Vice
President-had dual agendas, while professing to work for the internal
security of the United States against its terrorist enemies?
A review of the internal security backgrounds of some of the best known
among them strongly suggests the answer.
Dr. Stephen Bryen and Colleagues
In April of 1979, Deputy Assistant Attorney General Robert Keuch
recommended in writing that Bryen, then a staff member of the Senate
Foreign Relations Committee, undergo a grand jury hearing to establish the
basis for a prosecution for espionage. John Davitt, then Chief of the Justice
Department’s Internal Security Division, concurred.
The evidence was strong. Bryen had been overheard in the Madison Hotel
Coffee Shop, offering classified documents to an official of the Israeli
Embassy in the presence of the director of AIPAC, the American-Israel
Public Affairs Committee. It was later determined that the Embassy official
was Zvi Rafiah, the Mossad station chief in Washington. Bryen refused to be
poly-graphed by the FBI on the purpose and details of the meeting; whereas
the person who’d witnessed it agreed to be poly-graphed and passed the
test.
The Bureau also had testimony from a second person, a staff member of the
Foreign Relations Committee, that she had witnessed Bryen in his Senate
office with Rafiah, discussing classified documents that were spread out on
a table in front of an open safe in which the documents were supposed to
be secured. Not long after this second witness came forward, Bryen's
fingerprints were found on classified documents he’d stated in writing to
the FBI he’d never had in his possession....the ones he’d allegedly offered to
Rafiah.
Nevertheless, following the refusal of the Senate Foreign Relations
Committee to grant access by Justice Department officials to files which
were key to the investigation, Keuch's recommendation for a grand jury
hearing, and ultimately the investigation itself, were shut down. This
decision, taken by Philip Heymann, Chief of Justice’s Criminal Division,
was a bitter disappointment to Davitt and to Joel Lisker, the lead
investigator on the case, as expressed to this writer. A complicating factor
in the outcome was that Heymann was a former schoolmate and fellow U.S.
Supreme Court Clerk of Bryen's attorney, Nathan Lewin.
Bryen was asked to resign from his Foreign Relations Committee post
shortly before the investigation was concluded in late 1979. For the
following year and a half, he served as Executive Director of the Jewish
Institute for National Security Affairs (JINSA), and provided consulting
services to AIPAC.
In April, 1981, the FBI received an application by the Defense Department
for a Top Secret security clearance for Dr. Bryen . Richard Perle, who had
just been nominated as Assistant Secretary of Defense for International
Security Policy, was proposing Bryen as his Deputy Assistant Secretary!
Within six months, with Perle pushing hard, Bryen received both Top
Secret-SCI (sensitive compartmented information) and Top
Secret-“NATO/COSMIC” clearances.
Loyalty, Patriotism and Character
The Bryen investigation became in fact the most contentious issue in Perle’s
own confirmation hearings in July, 1981. Under aggressive questioning
from Sen. Jeremiah Denton, Perle held his ground: “I consider Dr. Bryen to
be an individual impeccable integrity....I have the highest confidence in
[his] loyalty, patriotism and character.”
Several years later in early 1988, Israel was in the final stages of
development of a prototype of its ground based “Arrow” anti-ballistic
missile. One element the program lacked was “klystrons”, small microwave
amplifiers which are critical components in the missile's high frequency,
radar-based target acquisition system which locks on to in-coming missiles.
In 1988, klystrons were among the most advanced developments in
American weapons research, and their export was of course strictly
proscribed.
The DOD office involved in control of defense technology exports was the
Defense Technology Security Administration (DTSA) within Richard Perle’s
ISP office. The Director (and founder) of DTSA was Perle’s Deputy, Dr.
Stephen Bryen. In May of 1988, Bryen sent a standard form to Richard
Levine, a Navy tech transfer official, informing him ofintent to approve a
license for Varian Associates, Inc. of Beverly, Massachusetts to export to
Israel four klystrons. This was done without the usual consultations with
the tech transfer officials of the Army and Air Force, or ISA (International
Security Affairs) or DSAA (Defense Security Assistance Agency.
The answer from Levine was “no”. He opposed granting the license, and
asked for a meeting on the matter ofthe appropriate (above listed) offices.
At the meeting, all of the officials present opposed the license. Bryen
responded by suggesting that he go back to the Israelis to ask why these
particular items were needed for their defense. Later, after the Israeli
Government came back with what one DOD staffer described as “a little
bullshit answer”, Bryen simply notified the meeting attendees that an
acceptable answer had been received, the license granted, and the klystrons
released.
By now, however, the dogs were awake. Then Assistant Secretary of
Defense for ISA, (and now Deputy Secretary of State) Richard Armitage sent
Dr. Bryen a letter stating that the State Department (which issues the export
licenses) should be informed of DOD’s “uniformly negative” reaction to the
export of klystrons to Israel. Bryen did as instructed , and the license was
withdrawn.
In July, Varian Associates became the first U.S. corporation formally
precluded from contracting with the Defense Department. Two senior
colleague in DOD who wish to remain anonymous have confirmed that this
attempt by Bryen to obtain klystrons for his friends was not unusual, and
was in fact “standard operating procedure” for him, recalling numerous
instances when U.S. companies were denied licenses to export sensitive
technology, only to learn later that Israeli companies subsequently exported
similar (U.S. derived) weapons and technology to the intended
customers/governments.
In late1988, Bryen resigned from his DOD post, and for a period worked in
the
private sector with a variety of defense technology consulting firms.
Bryen and the China Commission
In 1997, “Defense Week” reported (05/27/97) that, ....” the U.S. Office of
Naval Intelligence reaffirmed that U.S.- derived technology from the
cancelled [Israeli] Lavi fighter project is being used on China’s new F-10
fighter.” The following year, “Jane's Intelligence Review” reported (11/01/98)
the transfer by Israel to China of the Phalcon airborne early warning and
control system, the Python air-combat missile, and the F-10 fighter aircraft,
containing “state-of-the-art U.S. electronics.”
Concern about the continuing transfer of advanced U.S. arms technology to
the burgeoning Chinese military program led, in the last months of the
Clinton Administration, to the creation of a Congressional consultative body
called the United States-China Economic and Security Review Commission.
The charter for the “The China Commission”, as it is commonly known,
states that its purpose is to....”monitor, investigate, and report to the
Congress on the national security implications of the bilateral trade and
economic relationship between the United States and the Peoples Republic
of China.” The charter also reflects an awareness of the problem of “back
door” technology leaks: “The Commission shall also take into account
patterns of trade and transfers through third countries to the extent
practicable.”
It was almost predictable that in the new Bush Administration, Dr. Stephen
Bryen would find his way to the China Commission. In April 2001, with the
support of Deputy Secretary of Defense Paul Wolfowitz and Senator
Richard Shelby (R-Alabama) Bryen was appointed a Member of the
Commission by Speaker of the House Dennis Hastert. Last August, his
appointment was extended through December of 2005.
Informed that Bryen had been appointed to the Commission, the reaction of
one former
senior FBI counter-intelligence official was: “My God, that must mean he
has a “Q
clearance!” (A “Q” clearance, which must be approved by the Department of
Energy, is the designation for a Top Secret codeword clearance to access
nuclear technology.)
Michael Ledeen, Consultant on Chaos
If Stephen Bryen is the military technology guru in the neo-con pantheon,
Michael Ledeen is currently its leading theorist, historian, scholar and
writer. It states in the website of his consulting firm, Benador Associates,
that he is “...one of the world's leading authorities on intelligence,
contemporary history and international affairs” and that....”As Ted Koppel
puts it, Michael Ledeen is a Renaissance man....in the tradition of
Machiavelli.”” Perhaps the following will add some color and texture to this
description.
In 1983, on the recommendation of Richard Perle, Ledeen was hired at the
Department of Defense as a consultant on terrorism. His immediate
supervisor was the Principle Assistant Secretary for International Security
Affairs, Noel Koch. Early in their work together, Koch noticed with concern
Ledeen’s habit of stopping by in his (Koch’s) outer office to read classified
materials. When the two of them took a trip to Italy, Koch learned from the
CIA station there that when Ledeen had lived in Rome previously, as
correspondent for The New Republic, he’d been carried in Agency files as
an agent of influence of a foreign government: Israel.
Some time after their return from the trip, Ledeen approached his boss
with a request for his assistance in obtaining two highly classified CIA
reports which he said were held by the FBI. He’d hand written on a piece of
paper the identifying “alpha numeric designators”. These identifiers were
as highly classified as the reports themselves....which raised in Koch’s mind
the question of who had provided them to Ledeen if he hadn’t the
clearances to obtain them himself. Koch immediately told his executive
assistant that Ledeen was to have no further access to classified materials
in the office, and Ledeen just ceased coming to “work”.
In early 1986, however, Koch learned that Ledeen had joined NSC as a
consultant, and sufficiently concerned about the internal security
implications of the behavior of his former aide, arranged to be interviewed
by two FBI agents on the matter. After a two hour debriefing, Koch was told
that it was only Soviet military intelligence penetration that interested the
Bureau. The follow-on interviews that were promised by the agents just
never occurred.
Koch thought this strange, coming as it did just months after the arrest of
Naval intelligence analyst Jonathan Pollard on charges of espionage for
Israel. Frustrated, Koch wrote up in detail the entire saga of Ledeen’s DOD
consultancy, and sent it to the Office of Senator Charles Grassley, then a
member of the Senate Select Committee on Intelligence, which had
oversight responsibility for, inter alia, the FBI.
A former senior FBI counter-intelligence official was surprised and
somewhat skeptical, when told of Koch's unsuccessful attempts to interest
the Bureau in an investigation of Ledeen, noting that in early 1986, the
Justice Department was in fact already engaged in several on-going,
concurrent investigations of Israeli espionage and theft of American
military technology.
Machiavelli in Tel Aviv
Koch’s belated attempts to draw official attention to his former assistant
were too late, in any event, for within a very few weeks of leaving his DOD
consultancy in late 1984, Ledeen had found gainful (classified) employment
at the National Security Council (NSC). In fact, according to a now
declassified chronology prepared for the Senate/House Iran-
Contra investigation, within calendar 1984 Ledeen was already suggesting
to Oliver North, his new boss at NSC....” that Israeli contacts might be useful
in obtaining release of the U.S. hostages in Lebanon.” Perhaps significantly,
that is the first entry in the “Chronology of Events: U.S.- Iran Dialogue”,
dated November 18,1986, prepared for the Joint House-Senate Hearings in
the Iran-Contra Investigations.
What is so striking about the Ledeen-related documents which are part of
the Iran-Contra Collection of the National Security Archive, is how
thoroughly the judgements of Ledeen’s colleagues at NSC mirrored, and
validated, Noel Koch’s internal security concerns about his consultant.
e on April 9, 1985, NSC Middle East analyst Donald Fortier wrote to
National Security Advisor Robert McFarlane that NSC staffers were
agreed that Ledeen’s role in the scheme should be limited to carrying
messages to Israeli Prime Minister Shimon Peres regarding plans to
cooperate with Israel on the crisis within Iran, and specifically that he
should not be entrusted to ask Peres for detailed operational
information;
e on June 6, 1985, Secretary of State George Shultz wrote to McFarlane
that, “Israel’s record of dealings with Iran since the fall ofthe Shah and
during the hostage crisis [show] that Israel’s agenda is not the same as
ours. Consequently doubt whether an intelligence relationship such as
what Ledeen has in mind would be one which we could fully rely upon
and it could seriously skew our own perception and analysis of the
Iranian scene.”
e on 20 August, 1985, the Office of the Undersecretary of Defense
informed Ledeen by memorandum that his security clearance had been
downgraded from Top Secret-SCI to Secret.
e on 16 January, 1986, Oliver North recommended to John Poindexter “for
[the] security of the Iran initiative” that Ledeen be asked to take periodic
polygraph examinations.
e later in January, on the 24th, North wrote to Poindexter of his suspicion
that Ledeen, along with Adolph Schwimmer and Manucher
Ghorbanifar, might be making money personally on the sale of arms to
Iran, through Israel.
During the June 23-25, 1987 joint hearings of the House and Senate select
committees’ investigation of Iran-Contra, Noel Koch testified that he became
suspicious when he learned that the price which Ledeen had negotiated for
the sale to the Israeli Government of basic TOW missiles was $2,500 each.
Upon inquiring with his DOD colleagues, he learned the lowest price the
U.S. had ever received for the sale of TOWs to a foreign government had
been a previous sale to Israel for $6,800 per copy. Koch, professing in his
testimony that he and his colleagues at DOD were not in favor of the sale to
begin with, determined that he-Koch-should renegotiate the $2,500 price so
that it could be defended by the “defense management system.” In a
clandestine meeting on a Sunday in the first class lounge ofthe TWA section
of National Airport, Koch met over a cup of coffee with an official from the
Israeli purchasing mission in New York, and agreed on a price of $4,500 per
missile, nearly twice what Ledeen had “negotiated” in Israel.
There are two possibilities here-one would be a kickback, as suspected by
his NSC colleagues, and the other would be that Michael Ledeen was
effectively negotiating for Israel, not the U.S.
Like his friend Stephen Bryen (they’ve long served together on the JINSA
Board of Advisors) Ledeen has been out of government service since the
late1980s....until the present Bush Administration. He, like Bryen, is
presently a serving member on the China Commission and, with the
support of DOD Undersecretary for Policy Douglas Feith, he
has since 2001 been employed as a consultant for the Office of Special Plans
OSP). Both involve the handling of classified materials and require high-
level security clearances.
The Principals: Perle, Wolfowitz and Feith
One might wonder how, with security histories like these, Messrs. Bryen
and Ledeen have managed to get second and third chances to return to
government in highly classified positions.
And the explanation is that they, along with other like-minded neo-
conservatives, have in the current Bush Administration friends in very high
places. In particular, Bryen and Ledeen have been repeatedly boosted into
defense/security posts by former Defense Policy Council member and
chairman Richard Perle (he just quietly resigned his position), Deputy
Defense Secretary Paul Wolfowitz, and Under Secretary of Defense for
Policy Douglas Feith.
As previously mentioned, Perle in 1981 as DOD Assistant Secretary for
International Security Policy (ISP) hired Bryen as his Deputy. That same
year, Wolfowitz as head of the State Department Policy Planning Staff hired
Ledeen as a Special Advisor. In 2001 Douglas Feith as DOD Under Secretary
for Policy hired, or approved the hiring of Ledeen as a consultant for the
Office of Special Plans.
The principals have also assisted each other down through the years.
Frequently. In 1973 Richard Perle used his (and Senator Henry “Scoop”
Jackson’s) influence as a senior staff member of the Senate Armed Services
Committee to help Wolfowitz obtain a job with the Arms Control and
Disarmament Agency. In 1982, Perle hired Feith in ISP as his Special
Counsel, and then as Deputy Assistant Secretary for Negotiations Policy. In
2001, DOD Deputy Secretary Wolfowitz helped Feith obtain his appointment
as Undersecretary for Policy. Feith then appointed Perle as Chairman of the
Defense Policy Board. In some cases, this mutual assistance carries risks, as
for instance when Perle’s hiring of Bryen as his Deputy in ISP became an
extremely contentious issue in Perle’s own Senate appointment hearings as
Assistant Secretary.
Every appointment/hiring listed above involved classified work for which
high-level security clearances and associated background checks by the FBI
were required. When the level of the clearance is not above generic Top
Secret, however, the results ofthat background check are only seen by the
hiring authority. And in the event, ifthe appointee were Bryen or Ledeen
and the hiring authority were Perle, Wolfowitz or Feith, the appointee(s)
need not have worried about the findings ofthe background check. In the
case of Perle hiring Bryen as his deputy in 1981, for instance, documents
released in 1983 under the Freedom of Information Act indicate that the
Department provided extraordinarily high clearances for Bryen without
having reviewed more than a small portion of his 1978-79 FBI investigation
file.
Richard Perle: A Habit of Leaking
Perle came to Washington for the first time in early 1969, at the age of 28, to
work for a neo-con think tank called the “Committee to Maintain a Prudent
Defense Policy.” Within months, Senator Henry “Scoop” Jackson offered
Perle a position on his staff, working with the Senate Foreign Relations
Committee. And within months after that-less than a year—Perle was
embroiled in an affair involving the leaking of a classified CIA report on
alleged past Soviet treaty violations.
The leaker (and author of the report) was CIA analyst David Sullivan, and
the leakee was Richard Perle. CIA Director Stansfield Turner was incensed
at the unauthorized disclosure, but before he could fire Sullivan, the latter
quit. Turner urged Sen. Jackson to fire Perle, but he was let off with a
reprimand. Jackson then added insult to injury by immediately hiring
Sullivan to his staff. Sullivan and Perle became close friends and co-
conspirators, and together established an informal right-wing network
which they called “the Madison Group,” after their usual meeting place in—
you might have guessed-the Madison Hotel Coffee Shop.
Perle's second brush with the law occurred a year later in 1970. An FBI
wiretap authorized for the Israeli Embassy picked up Perle discussing with
an Embassy official classified information which he said had been supplied
to by a staff member on the National Security Council. An NSC/FBI
investigation was launched to identify the staff member, and quickly
focused upon Helmut Sonnenfeldt. The latter had been previously
investigated in 1967 while a staff member of the State Department's Bureau
of Intelligence and Research, for suspected unauthorized transmission to an
Israeli Government official of a classified document concerning the
commencement of the 1967 war in the Middle East.
In 1981, shortly before being appointed Assistant Secretary of Defense for
International Security Policy (ISP)-with responsibility, inter alia, for
monitoring of U.S. defense technology exports, Richard Perle was paid a
substantial consulting fee by arms manufacturer Tamares, Ltd. of Israel.
Shortly after assuming that post, Perle wrote a letter to the Secretary of the
Army urging evaluation and purchase of 155 mm. shells manufactured by
Soltam, Ltd. After leaving the ISP job in 1987, he worked for Soltam.
Paul Wolfowitz: A Well Placed Friend
In 1973, in the dying days of the Nixon Administration, Wolfowitz was
recruited to work for the Arms Control and Disarmament Agency (ACDA).
There was a certain irony in the appointment, for in the late 1960’s, as a
graduate student at the University of Chicago, Wolfowitz had been a student
and protege of Albert Wohlstetter, an influential, vehement opponent of
any form of arms control or disarmament, vis a vis the Soviets. Wolfowitz
also brought to ACDA a strong attachment to Israel’s security, and a certain
confusion about his obligation to U.S. national security.
In 1978, he was investigated for providing a classified document on the
proposed sale of U.S. weapons to an Arab government, to an Israel
Government official, through an AIPAC intermediary. An inquiry was
launched and dropped, however, and Wolfowitz continued to work at ACDA
until 1980.
In 1990, after a decade of work with the State Department in Washington
and abroad, Wolfowitz was brought into DoD as Undersecretary for Policy
by then Secretary of Defense Richard Cheney. Two years later, in 1992, the
first Bush Administration launched a broad inter-departmental
investigation into the export of classified technology to China. O particular
concern at the time was the transfer to China by Israel of U.S. Patriot
missiles and/or technology. During that investigation, in a situation very
reminiscent of the Bryen/Varian Associates/klystrons affair two years
earlier, the Pentagon discovered that Wolfowitz’s office was promoting the
export to Israel of advanced AIM-9M air-to-air missiles.
In this instance, the Joint Chiefs of Staff, aware that Israel had already been
caught selling the earlier AIM 9-L version of the missile to China in
violation of a written agreement with the U.S. on arms re-sales, intervened
to cancel the proposed AIM (-M deal. The Chairman of the Joint Chiefs at the
time was General Colin Powell, currently Secretary of State.
Wolfowitz continued to serve as DoD Undersecretary for Policy until 1993,
well into the Clinton Administration. After that, however, like most of the
other prominent neo-conservatives, he was relegated to trying to assist
Israel from the sidelines for the remainder of Clinton’s two terms. In 1998,
Wolfowitz was a co-signer of a public letter to the President organized by
the “Project for the New American Century.” The letter, citing Saddam
Hussein’s continued possession of “weapons of mass destruction,” argued
for military action to achieve regime change and demilitarization of Iraq.
Clinton wasn’t impressed, but a more gullible fellow would soon come
along.
And indeed, when George W. Bush assumed the Presidency in early 2001,
Wolfowitz got his opportunity. Picked as Donald Rumsfeld’s Deputy
Secretary at DoD, he prevailed upon his boss to appoint Douglas Feith as
Undersecretary for Policy. On the day after the destruction of the World
Trade Center, September 12, Rumsfeld and Wolfowitz raised the possibility
of an immediate attack on Iraq during an emergency NSC meeting. The
following day, Wolfowitz conducted the Pentagon press briefing, and
interpreted the
President's statement on “ending states who sponsor terrorism” as a call for
regime change in Iraq. Israel wasn't mentioned.
Douglas Feith: Hardliner, Security Risk
Bush's appointment of Douglas Feith as DoD Undersecretary for Policy in
early 2001 must have come as a surprise, and a harbinger, even to
conservative veterans of the Reagan and George H.W. Bush Administration.
Like Michael Ledeen, Feith is a prolific writer and well-known radical
conservative. Moreover, he was not being hired as a DoD consultant, like
Ledeen, but as the third most senior United States Defense Department
official. Feith was certainly the first, and probably the last high Pentagon
official to have publicly opposed the Biological Weapons Convention (in
1986), the Intermediate Nuclear Forces Treaty (in 1988), the Chemical
Weapons Convention (in 1997), the Anti-Ballistic Missile Treaty (in 2000),
and all of the various Middle East Peace agreements, including Oslo (in
2000).
Even more revealing perhaps, had the transition team known of it, was
Feith's view of “technology cooperation,” as expressed in a 1992
Commentary article: “It is in the interest of U.S. and Israel to remove
needless impediments to technological cooperation between them.
Technologies in the hands of responsible, friendly countries facing military
threats, countries like Israel, serve to deter aggression, enhance regional
stability and promote peace thereby.”
What Douglas Feith had neglected to say, in this last article, was that he
thought that individuals could decide on their own whether the sharing of
classified information was “technical cooperation,” an unauthorized
disclosure, or a violation of U.S. Code 794c, the “Espionage Act.”
Ten years prior to writing the Commentary piece, Feith had made such a
decision on his own. At the time, March of 1972, Feith was a Middle East
analyst in the Near East and South Asian Affairs section of the National
Security Council. Two months before, in January, Judge William Clark had
replaced Richard Allen as National Security Advisor, with the intention to
clean house. A total of nine NSC staff members were fired, including Feith,
who’d only been with the NSC for a year. But Feith was fired because he’d
been the object of an inquiry into whether he’d provided classified material
to an official of the Israeli Embassy in Washington. The FBI had opened the
inquiry. And Clark, who had served in U.S. Army counterintelligence in the
1950’s, took such matters very seriously.....more seriously, apparently, than
had Richard Allen.
Feith did not remain unemployed for long, however. Richard Perle, who
was in 1982 serving in the Pentagon as Assistant secretary for International
Security Policy, hired him on the spot as his “Special Counsel,” and then as
his Deputy. Feith worked at ISP until 1986, when he left government service
to form a small but influential law firm, then based in Israel.
In 2001, Douglas Feith returned to DoD as Donald Rumsfeld’s
Undersecretary for Policy, and it was in his office that “OSP”, the Office of
Special Plans, was created. It was OSP that originated-some say from whole
cloth-much of the intelligence that Bush, Cheney and Rumsfeld have used
to justify the attack on Iraq, to miss-plan the post-war reconstruction there,
and then to point an accusing finger at Iran and Syria.....all to the absolute
delight of Prime Minister Ariel Sharon.
Reason for Concern
Many individuals with strong attachments to foreign countries have served
the U.S. Government with honor and distinction, and will certainly do so in
the future. The highest officials in our executive and legislative branches
should, however, take great care when appointments are made to posts
involving sensitive national security matters. Appointees should be rejected
who have demonstrated, in their previous government service, a
willingness to sacrifice U.S. national security interests for those of another
country, or an inability to distinguish one from the other.
Stephen Green was the author of two meticulously sourced books about Israel
and U.S. policies. Green, who had previously been a field director for Oxfam,
later served in the Vermont legislature. A review of one of Green’s books in
the Naval War College Review stated: “It would seem that since 1965 US
policy in the Mideast has been based on ‘secret covenants clandestinely
executed, with dissembling ever after.”
Richard N. Perle, member of the Defense Policy Board, advisor to the
Pentagon, Assistant Secretary of Defense for Global Strategic Affairs. Perle
spoke about why military action was “necessary” in Iraq. He led a 1996
study group for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu that produced
a report entitled “ A Clean Break: A New Strategy for Securing the Realm,” which called
for damaging and destabilizing Israel's surrounding countries. A 1970 FBI
report Stated that Perle had discussed classified information with Israeli
officials; the information had been supplied to him by someone on the
National Security Council staff; he has never been prosecuted for this.
Commentator in an Israeli newspaper observed that Perle, Feith, and their
fellow strategists were “walking a fine line between their loyalty to
American governments and Israeli interests.” (PHOTO: FP)
Paul Wolfowitz, protege of Richard Perle who then mentored Scooter Libby;
described as “over-the-top crazy when it comes to Israel.” Official positions:
Deputy Secretary of Defense, 2001-05; Under Secretary of Defense for
Policy, 1989-93; Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense for Regional
Programs, 1977-80., (PHOTO: Mother Jones)
i
Lewis “Scooter” Libby, Wolfowitz student who went on to serve in the State
and Defense Departments, become an assistant to Vice President Cheney
and to President Bush. was one of the few who was ofa crime and
served prison time. Libby was Cheney’s closest adviser and a key advocate for war; with
: it WhO was pers: aron. Author Bob Woodward wrote of Libby’s influence:
“Libby had done so much of the preparation for the vice president’s meetings and events, and so much
ofthe hard work. He had been almost part of Cheney’s brain.” Libby was for many years
while Rich made $billions moving Iranian crude oil through a secret pipeline through Israel. Like a
number of others, he was part ofthe ( source)
Dov S. Zakheim, Deputy Undersecretary of Defense, PNAC member, who
held numerous governmental positions, Deputy Under Secretary of Defense for
Planning and Resources in the Office of the Under Secretary of Defense
(Policy) - played an active role in the Departments strategic planning
processes; employed by the National Security and International Affairs
Division of the Congressional Budget Office; Task Force on Defense Reform ;
Defense Science Board task force on “The Impact of DoD Acquisition
Policies on the Health of the Defense Industry”; a senior foreign policy
advisor to then-Governor Bush. Under Secretary of Defense (Comptroller)
and Chief Financial Officer for the Department of Defense; member of the
Commission on Wartime Contracting in Iraq and Afghanistan; retired as a
Senior Vice President of Booz Allen Hamilton. Featured as pundit on news
programs, connected with AIPAC spinoff washington Institute for Mid East Policy. (Son
Reuven, aka Roger, was married in Israel - see below.) (PHOTO: non)
Peter Rodman, assistant secretary of defense, member of pwac who was
mentored by Henry Kissinger, served in five presidential administrations,
closely connected to AIPAC spinoff washington Institute, was a director of the
State Department’s policy planning staff; senior editor at National Review,
director of national security programs at the Nixon Center, senior fellow in
foreign policy at the Brookings Institution. ( source)
U.S. National Security Advisor John Bolton meets with Israeli Prime
Minister Benjamin Netanyahu in Jerusalem, Jan. 6, 2019; an American
Enterprise Institute hawk and Israeli proponent who is said to have been
forced on a reluctant Colin Powell as undersecretary for arms control;
member of Jewish Institute of National Security Affairs (JINSA); Billionaire
Sheldon Adelson (who once said he regretted he had served in the U.S. army
instead of the Israeli military) reportediy recommended him for the national
security adviser position; worked with Netanyahu to sabotage a potential
Trump meeting with Iran’s foreign minister. (PHOTO: jrA)
David Wurmser, special assistant to Dick Cheney, part of the “ Clean Break”
group, was Senior Analyst for the Center for Security Policy, Director for
Research and Studies Program in the U.S. Institute of Peace, Research
Fellow for the American Enterprise Institute, JINSA contributor; husband of
Meyrav Wurmser. (PHOTO: intercept)
3 - The War Party
Meyrav Wurmser, part of the “Clean Break” group; director of the Center
for Middle East Policy at the neoconservative Hudson Institute; with former
Israeli intelligence officers founded the pro-Israel organization MEMRI; in
the BBC documentary on the “neo-conservatives, the small and unelected
group who critics claim hijacked the White House,” said “most of us are
Jewish.” Wife of David Wurmser. (PHOTO: pac)
NGI Near WASHIN
)r
John Hannah speaks at AIPAC spin-off Washington Institute for Near East
Policy (WINEP) event on Lebanon and Syria, March 13, 2009; ran the vice
president’s Office for National Security Affairs, serving as chief foreign
policy advisor to the vice president until the end of the Bush
administration. During the Clinton era, was a senior advisor and
speechwriter to Secretary of State Warren Christopher, playing an
important role in the secretary’s extensive engagement in Middle East
diplomacy. As a senior member ofthe State Department’s Policy Planning
Staff during the presidency of George H. W. Bush, made major
contributions in developing U.S. policy toward the Middle East — including
the first Gulf War; first joined WINEP in 1986 as a researcher focusing on
Soviet policy in the Middle East. Served as deputy director from 1989-1991
and again in 1994. (PHOTO: c-span)
Yi AN
Elliott Abrams pled guilty to withholding information from Congress during
the Iran-contra scandal, son-in-law Of Norman Podhoretz, one of the original
neo-cons and a long-time strident supporter of right-wing Israeli causes as
editor of Commentary magazine; served as foreign policy adviser for
Presidents Ronald Reagan, George W. Bush, and Donald Trump. Abrams is a
lifelong pro-Israel ideologue who has said that all jews must ‘stand apart’ from
the country they live in except Israel. As part of the George W. Bush
administration, enthusiastically supported the U.S. invasion of Iraq in 2003.
Positions: Special Representative for Iran and Venezuela at the Department of
State, deputy assistant to the president and deputy national security advisor
in the administration of President George W. Bush, where he supervised
U.S. policy in the Middle East for the White House, etc. (PHOTO: To1-Cspan)
Thomas Dine, was long-time AIPAC executive director, head of Radio
Liberty, senior policy advisor at Israel Policy Forum (IPF), served as chief
executive officer of the Jewish Community Federation of San Francisco. As
AIPAC head, he was considered “one of the most powerful lobbyists in
Washington and a man whose word can help kill or pass a piece of
legislation or a nomination.” (PHOTO: c-span)
Irving Kristol, originally a Trotskyist, “ sodfather” of the neo-conservative
movement that largely took over Washington’s foreign policy under George
W. Bush..... Kristol’s proteges are seeded through the country’s Republican
establishment”; father of Bill Kristol; co-founder of The Public Interest;
writer for Commentary; “perhaps the most consequential public intellectual of the
latter half of the 20th century”; lifelong supporter of Israel who believed that this
required “fighting ‘dirty little wars’ in remote places”. (PHOTO: Associated
Press)
Gertrude Himmelfarb, aka Bea Kristol, wife of Irving Kristol and mother of
Bill Kristol, “Her scholarship contributed to the intellectual foundation of the
neoconservative movement”; More info here. (PHOTO: T01)
Authors Richard Perle and David Frum on the porch of Mr.
Perle's home in Chevy Chase, MD; 11/12/03
Photo by David Scull
Richard Perle and David Frum co-authored a 2004 book calling for the
invasion of Iran, Syria, Libya, and others. (info on Frum here and here; was
the Canadian speechwriter for Bush whose wife claimed he coined the term
“axis of evil”, Novak reports that Frum was an “uncompromising supporter
of Israel” and “fervent supporter of Ariel Sharon's policies” during his time
in the White House... Frum is more uncompromising in support of Israel
than any other issue, raising the inescapable question of whether this was
the real reason he entered the White House...” Frum opposed the State Dept
and CIA experts who were less supportive of Israel... Claimed, falsely, that
CAIR promotes terrorism - forced to retract accusation...continues to be
active, appears on media as an alleged expert. (PHOTO: Globetrotter)
Israeli newspaper Ha’aretz calls Frank Gaffney “Islamophobe and ‘Great
Friend of Israel”; Perle protégé; founder ofthe Center for Security Policy; has
longstanding ties to the defense and security establishment; “ architect of Trump's
Muslim ban“; connected to JINSA, opposed to the Iran agreement. (PHOTO:
Haaretz)
AS
Former CIA Director James Woolsey has been a member of Israel advocacy
organization the Washington Institute for Near East Policy (WINEP), Jewish
Institute for National Security Affairs (JNSA), NGO Monitor, Project for a
New American Century (PNAC), and chairman of the Foundation for Defense of
Democracies, an Israel-advocacy organization. (PHOTO: asc)
Eugene Rostow speaks at WINEP event, Nov. 23, 1992. Under Secretary of
State for Political Affairs under President Lyndon B. Johnson, dean of Yale
Law School, fervently pro-Israel - supported Israeli settlements, younger
brother, Walt Rostow, served as national security adviser to Presidents John
F. Kennedy and Lyndon B. Johnson. He told Johnson, inaccurately, that the
Israelis had not attacked first in 1967, and then helped broker UN resolution
242. (PHOTO: c-span)
Michael Ledeen, termed by the CIA “an agent of influence of a foreign
government: Israel.’ In 1983, on the recommendation of Richard Perle,
Ledeen was hired at the Department of Defense as a consultant on
terrorism; once wrote that he hoped the U.S. would “turn the region into a
caldron,” and authored a book calling for a multi-generational war. U.S.
colleagues often worried that he was a security risk. Ledeen has held
(often simultaneously) in media, government, academia, and think
tanks since the late 1960s and has been connected to a number of neocon
thinktanks;leading theorist, historian, scholar and writer of the neocon
pantheon; wife and daughter Simone Ledeen (see below) are
also active. (PHOTO: )
Richard Perle, Jeane Kirkpatrick, and (far right) Frank Gaffney speak at
American Enterprise Institute event, Dec. 12, 1987 (third from left is
Christopher DeMuth, AEI president); an analyst wrote: “A visitor from Mars
to the UN headquarters in 1985 would have found it difficult to decide, after
listening to Ambassadors Jeane Kirkpatrick and Binyamin Netanyahu,
which of the two represented the United States and which Israel.” Member
of JINSA advisory board, regularly echoed the Israeli/neocon talking points.
Signatory of 2001 neocon letter calling on Bush to attack Iraq, Syria, and
Iran. (PHOTO: c-span)
Multimillionaire US businessman Irving Moskowitz listens to settler leaders
during a tour ofthe Gaza Strip settlement of Netzarim, 08 April 2005.
Moskowitz and a group of business and religious leaders came to lend
support to the settlers. Moskowitz was notorious for extremist
Israeli settlers. (PHOTO: wic)
STEPHEN BRYEN
Five. DEPUTY UNDERSECRETARY OF DEFENSE Mon.
Stephen Bryen, Deputy Undersecretary for Defense, speaks at American
Enterprise Institute panel composed of Stephen Bryen Douglas Feith, Hillel
Fradkin, Charles Krauthammer, Michael Ledeen, Richard Perle, and David
Wurmser, Nov.6, 2000. Bryen had offered classified documents to an official
of the Israeli Embassy in the presence of the director of AIPAC, but the
investigation was shut down by Philip Heymann, Chief of Justice’s Criminal
Division. Bryen then served as Executive Director of JINSA; provided
consulting services to AIPAC. Perle nominated him to be Assistant Secretary
of Defense for International Security Policy, where he worked to obtain
weaponry for Israel. Additional info here. (PHOTO: c-span)
PHILIP HEYMANN "C-SPAN
Former Deputy Attorney General apan.org
Clinton Administration, 1993-94
Philip Heymann speaks at U.S. Institute of Peace, July 6, 2010. Heymann,
Chief of Justice’s Criminal Division, shut down the investigation into Bryen’s
attempt to give classified info to Israel. Heymann later advocated on behalf
or another Israeli spy, Jonathan Pollard; also co-authored a book with member of
the IDF; signed a letter in support of friend Alan Dershowitz, fervent Israel
advocate who defended billionaire Jeffrey E. Epstein and was himself
accused of having sexual relations with a minor allegedly trafficked by
Epstein. (PHOTO: usip)
Nathan Lewin speaking at Agudath Israel IN 2019. Attorney for Bryen and
another official accused of espionage for Israel. served as Deputy Assistant
Attorney General in the Civil Rights Division of the Department of Justice, as
Deputy Administrator ofthe Bureau of Security and Consular Affairs (the
rank of Deputy Assistant Secretary of State), and Assistant to the Solicitor
General in the Department of Justice. Advocated for a number of cases for
Israel and against Palestinians. Called for executing family members of suicide
bombers, writing that Judaism endorses this: “The Torah commanded the
total eradication - including women and children - of certain nations
(Amalek being a singular illustration) because of the continuing threat its
members presented to the survival of Israel.” His daughter Alyza Doba
works with him, his other daughter Na’ama Batya is a photographer and
professor who promotes Israel; his son-in-law jules Polonetsky has held several
governmental positions. ( Vimeo)
The next generation:
The children of several neocons have now been similarly embedded in the
U.S. government, NGOs and thinktanks, carrying on the pro-Israel agenda:
Roger Zakheim, son of neocon Dov Zakheim, has served as deputy assistant
secretary of Defense, General Counsel and Deputy Staff Director of the U.S.
House Armed Services Committee, where he managed the passage of the
annual National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA), affiliated with jinsa. He
was married in israel to the daughter of Jack Bendheim, an AIPAC official €
head of Israel Policy Forum. (PHOTO: The Hill)
David Feith, son of neocon Douglas Feith (who had been part of the “Clean
Break” group for Netanyahu). David Feith has been U.S. Deputy Assistant
Secretary of State, a member of the Secretary of State’s Policy Planning
Staff, an editorial writer for the Wall Street Journal, an assistant editor at
Foreign Affairs magazine, has consulted for the U.S. Air Force, and
published a book entitled Teaching America: The Case for Civic Education.
While his specialty is China, he also writes about and issues pertaining
to it. (PHOTO: )
Simone Ledeen, daughter of neocon leader Michaael Ledeen, has served in
a multitude of official positions... Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense
(DASD) for Middle East Policy until January 2021, Principal Director to the
Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense for Special Operations and
Combating Terrorism, Senior US Treasury Representative to NATO’s
International Security Assistance Force in Afghanistan; began her
government career in 2003 as an Advisor to the Iraqi Ministry of Finance in
Baghdad, where she served as part of the Coalition Provisional Authority
(from ) A video of her talk at the Jewish Policy Center is . (PHOTO: )
\
THI
HINGTON INSTIT
for Near East
ry
PRESIDENT LYNDON JOHNSON & THE 1967 SIX-DAY WAR
JICHOLAS ROSTOW ILJAMERICAN
HISTORY
C-SPAN2
Colgate University - Charles Evans Hughes
y t& Jurisoruder
Nicholas Rostow speaks on a WINEP panel about the Six Day War, June 1,
2017, that also included Robert Satloff, Dennis Ross, and Michael
Mandelbaum. Rostow, son of Gene Rostow, has been special assistant to
Presidents Reagan and George H.W. Bush for National Security Affairs, legal
adviser to the National Security Council under Colin Powell and Brent
Scowcroft, legal advisor to the U.S. mission at the United Nations, a Senior
Research Scholar at the Yale Law School, and Staff Director, Senate Select
Committee on Intelligence. In 2010, he was a visiting professor at Technion
Israel Institute of Technology. More info here. (PHOTO: c-span)
AN
Jules Polenetsky, son-in-law of Nathan Lewin, speaks at Tel Aviv University
on July 3, 2017. Co-founder of the U.S.-Israel Tech Policy Institute, CEO of the
Future of Privacy Forum, served in the New York State Assembly, was an
aide to Congressmen Charles Schumer and Steve Solarz, Chief Privacy
Officer at AOL, and Consumer Affairs Commissioner for New York City
. (PHOTO: YouTube)
Journalists:
à po!
Judith Miller, close to the neocon network. Her New York Time’s
articles Contained misinformation from sources like Richard Perle, Paul
Wolfowitz, Douglas Feith, and Scooter Libby that played a significant role in
selling the war. Miller is connected to winep. After leaving the NY Times in
disrace after the paper determined that stories she had written about Iraq
were inaccurate, she resurfaced at Fox News. Miller spent 85 days in jail for
temporarily refusing to reveal that her source in revealing the identity of a
CIA agent was Scooter Libby. (PHOTO: Blossomeye)
ALL STAR
= FOX E — dl p”
Jen ERS NETANYAHU SPEECH IMPACT Hh STAR
— — — Ī—n_— ~ann +
RE THAN 260 Ve FOUR-STAR GENERAL AND FMR CIA DIRECTOR
Charles krauthammer was a fervently pro-Israel neocon columnist closely
allied with other neocons. Even Bush considered Kristol and Krauthammer
so eager for war that he mockingly referred to them as as “ the bomber boys.”
(See Kagan-Krauthammer video here.) (PHOTO: Ha'aretz)
RELATED:
e The Men From JINSA and CSP: They want not just a US invasion of Iraq
but “total war” against Arab regimes.
e The Neoconservative War on Terror cannot be understood without
Israel
e Clean Break or Dirty War? Israel’s Foreign Policy Directive to the United
States
e OUR HIJACKED FOREIGN POLICY: Neoconservatives take Washington -
Baghdad is next
e How the Neocons Outfoxed Colin Powell
BOOKS:
e The Transparent Cabal: The Neoconservative Agenda, War in the Middle
East, and the National Interest of Israel
e The Road to Iraq: The Making of a Neoconservative War
VIDEOS:
e How Pro Israel Neocons Pushed for War in Iraq (Alison Weir)
e Pro-Israel officials in the U.S. government pushed war against Iraq -
Dahlia Wasfi
e Gen. Wesley Clark reveals 2001 plan to attack Syria, Lebanon, Libya,
Somalia, Sudan and Iran
Enter your email address below to receive our latest articles right in your
inbox.
===
Full text of "Israel Loyalists Embedded In U.S. Government Pushed U.S. Into Iraq War"
See other formats
www.americanthinker.com /articles/2020/10/trump_a_flawed_champion.html
By Ted Noel : 7-8 minutes
Many pundits suggest that if you haven't made up your mind by now on your choice for
President, you haven't been paying attention. They're largely correct, but there are some (a
minority) who are paying attention and are seeing a riddle wrapped in a mystery inside an
enigma. (Apologies to Winston Churchill) This may be best exemplified by David French's
recent column where he quotes theologian John Piper at length. The upshot of his post is
that a leader's immorality destroys society. To that end, he cites “unrepentant sexual
immorality,” “unrepentant boastfulness,” “unrepentant vulgarity,’ and “unrepentant
factiousness” as key markers of unsuitability in a leader.
French's list is a #NeverTrumper’s transparent slap at Donald Trump. Historically, Trump
was a womanizer. His verbal style is boastful and vulgar. He is accused of being a divider.
For the one who's not paying attention, Joe Biden's claim that this election is about
character seals the deal. Vote Biden! But we have to peel back the layers of this onion.
On the charge of sexual immorality, we must compare Trump's ancient history with Biden's
continuing fondling of women and excuses for his son’s profligate behavior. Recent
revelations point to worse. Joe keeps on keepin’ on, while Donald is notably faithful to
Melania.
We've all heard Donald Trump’s statements about his “tremendous” company, “beautiful”
buildings, and “fantastic” golf courses. Supposedly this is evidence of narcissism, a major
character flaw. But pundits who have grown up near Trump in Queens recognize this a
simply local style. Apparently, many people from Queens speak this way as a daily part of
life. Brooklyn has a different flavor, and Indiana (VP Pence’s home) is radically different.
What about Biden? Are his statements any less dramatic? He claims to have worked
across the aisle to create legislative miracles, but the only one he can cite is the 1994
Crime Bill that put large numbers of black youths in prison for trivial crimes. Trump was
actually able to work across the aisle to begin reversing this evil with the First Step Act.
Biden claims that he was instrumental in negotiating the Paris Climate Accords, from
which Trump withdrew the U.S. But he lied by claiming his counterpart was Deng Xiaoping,
who was already dead. We could go on with Biden's “scholarship” and “degrees,” but you
get the picture.
Vulgarity is one place that Donald Trump seems to have a lead on Joe Biden, but as we
noted earlier, those with personal history in Queens recognize that as a verbal style he
learned growing up. We should compare Trump to many of Biden’s supporters, who make
Trump's language sound like Shakespearean prose.
“Unrepentant factiousness’” is, to put it bluntly, a lie. Anyone who actually works with
Trump finds him to be gracious and willing to work with anyone who will work with him.
But even though many of us saw him as the lesser of two evils in 2016, most have learned
that he fights. And he doesn't pick fights. Rather, he stands up firmly against our enemies
in the Swamp.
Washington, D.C. isn’t called “the Swamp” just because a few blocks of it - Foggy Bottom -
- were originally swampland. Rather, it acts like a swamp, amorphously oozing around your
footsteps, sucking the boots off your feet and then trapping you to be lunch for alligators.
The administrative state has grown so large and powerful that supercomputers
programmed for artificial intelligence are being pressed into service just to sort out the
immense number of conflicting government rules. With such an enormous morass, it’s no
surprise that many thousands of traitors may be hiding in the dark corners.
Of course, every one of those treasonous actors (does the “whistleblower” come to mind?)
has friends and is capable of causing great harm. Fiefdoms have to be safeguarded from
housecleaning. And favors are traded for the protection. Every perceived slight becomes
fodder for some exposé that a compliant media blows up into a “scandal.” After all, they
are part and parcel of the Swamp. They are the Ministry of Propaganda, and every player
scrambles to be the next Joseph Goebbels.
What is Trump's act of division? He actually stands up for America. The Swamp couldn't
care less about America. It cares about itself and where its next victim lies. But Donald
Trump refuses to slaughtered or neutered. Any ordinary person would have wilted under
this unrelenting pressure. But he lives by the maxim that a man is known by his enemies. If
his adversaries are evil, then he is on the side of righteousness.
So in an odd sort of way, Donald Trump is a divider. But his act of division is one of
exposing evil by standing for good. Now we can begin to peel back the layers of the onion.
Are moral flaws disqualifying? Ultimately, the question answers itself. As the Apostle Paul
notes, “All have sinned and fall short of the glory of God.”(Romans 3:23, NAS) Every
president is flawed. Even George Washington, for all his greatness as a general and
president, was a flawed person who owned slaves. John Adams, who was a major force
behind the Declaration of Independence, was incredibly abrasive. He was thrown out of
office for signing the Alien and Sedition Acts, which criminalized speech critical of the
government.
Since every president has had manifest moral flaws, it must be very clear that moral flaws,
by themselves, cannot be disqualifying. John Kennedy, a notorious womanizer, guided us
safely through the Cuban Missile Crisis. Abraham Lincoln, who freed the slaves, did so as
the result of political calculation. Barack Obama, who promised (and almost succeeded)
to “fundamentally change America,” gave the order to take out Osama bin Laden.
The only morally perfect person ever was crucified because he was regarded by the
Swamp of His day as an unacceptable divider. Every president and candidate for president
has flaws. We have to choose based on performance, not on style. And Donald Trump's
performance has been good. His judicial nominees have been excellent. His tax cuts were
wise. His reduction in regulations have unleashed businesses to create wealth for all
America.
Joe Biden's track record, in words even the Left can understand, stinks. At every turn he
has grown the Swamp and taken his vig. Donald Trump went to Washington to make your
life better, while Joe Biden went to Washington to make his life better. Becoming a
multimillionaire without ever holding a productive job is all the evidence we need.
David French and John Piper are wrong. We can't judge our President on public moral
character. We aren't electing a savior. We're electing a champion.
Image: Gage Skidmore
===
==
No comments:
Post a Comment