2024-05-05

The Zionist connection II: 5 Conclusion, Last Word

===
Contents

Introduction
---
PART ONEe*-THE ORIGINAL SIN
I Sixty-seven Words: One Man’s Dream, nother’s Nightmare
Il America Picks Up the Torch
IlI The Creation of Israel Revisited

---
PART TWOe THE COVER-UP
IV Inside Israel
V_ What Palestinians? ©
VI The Jewish Connection: Numbers Don’t Count
VII Whose Congress: Thwarting the National Interest
VII Slanting the Myth-Information
IX Namero Uno: The New York Times
X Terror: The Double Standard

---
PART THREE-~-THE COVER-OVER
XI Exploiting Anti-Semitism
XII The Blitz
XIII The Holocaust: Stoking the Fires
XIV Christians in Bondage
XV_ Soviet Jewry: Blackmail and Barter


---
PART FOUR-POLITICS OR POLICY
XVI The Eisenhower, Kennedy, and Johnson Years
XVII The Attack on Liberty
XVIII Oil on Troubled Waters: The Nixon Years
XIX War Again
XX The Ford Interlude
XXI Exit Henry Kissinger?
XXII Enter Carter—and Then Begin
XXIII Reagan and Still Begin
XXIV The Ultimate Dichotomy: Israel Uber Alles?

----
Part 5
XXV Conclusion: Toward Justice and Then Peace
Last Word

Notes
Index
====


XXV Conclusion: Toward Justice 


and Then Peace 





I shall no longer ask myself if this or that is expedient, but only 
if it is right. I shall do this, not because I am noble or unselfish, 
but because life slips away, and because I need for the rest of my 
journey a star that will not play false to me. . . . a compass that will 
not lie . . . 1 do it because I am no longer able to aspire to the 
highest with one part of myself and deny it with another. 


—Alan Paton, Cry, The Beloved Country 


With sacrifices by al’ parties, the impossible dream of peace in the 
Middle East may yet be achieved before further disaster overruns the 
area and the world. But this depends on the true intent of the Israelis 
and the Arabs, and on banishment of the guile to which the Old 
Testament refers: They speak peace to their neighbors, but mischief 
is in their hearts. (Psalms 28:3.) 

In the course of the Christmas Day luncheon during the 1977 
historic visit of Menachem Begin to Ismailia, the Israeli leader de- 
fended his refusal to grant sovereignty to the Palestinians of the West 
Bank and Gaza with one of his customary history lectures, which traced 
the persecution of Jews from Roman times through the holocaust and 
included the Arab attack on the newly established state in 1948 and the 
1973 “surprise strike.”’ Sadat’s only answer was: “‘No, no, let’s not start 
all that again. That happened before November 19 and my trip to 
Jerusalem.” 

The Egyptian leader ought never have let the record stand as 
Begin recited it and as the myth-informed world accepted it. Sadat 
might have seized the opportunity to cite the “original sin,” the dis- 
possession of the overwhelming majority of the indigenous Arab in- 
habitants of Palestine, which made these innocents pick up the bill in 
expiation for what Hitler and others had done to the Jews of Europe. 


776 





Conclusion: Toward Justice and Then Peace 777 


At the risk of displeasing a guest who was making his first visit to Egypt, 
he also could have quoted Israeli humanist Rabbi Benjamin: 


In the end, we must come out publicly with the truth: that we have no moral 
right whatever to oppose the return of the Arabs to their land. . . . Unul we 
have begun to redeem our sin against the Arab refugees, we have no right to 
continue the in-gathering of the exiles. We have no right to settle in a land that 
has been stolen from others while the owners of it are homeless and miserable. 

We had no right to occupy the house of an Arab if we had not paid for 
it at its value. The same goes for fields, gardens, stores, workshops. We had 
no right to build a settlement and to realize the kind of Zionism with other 
people's property. To do this is robbery. Political conquest cannot abolish 
private property.! 


During the thirty-year step-by-step occupation of Arab Palestine, 
the demand of the dispossessed for their human and political rights 
has never ceased. But in this period Golda Meir’s “‘What Palestinians?”’ 
had only given way to “Why the Palestinians?” Far more needed for 
a lasting Middle East settlement than any Sadat Jerusalem pledge of 
“no more war,” was the Israeli admission: ‘‘We have committed a 
grave wrong to the Palestinians.” The failure to recognize even partial 
guilt for the tragedy militates against hopes of a settlement. Until an 
Israeli head of government makes this declaration, peace can never be 
any more than illusory. For the crux of the bitter Middle East conflict, 
the struggle between the Zionists of Israel and the Arabs of Palestine, 
will have remained unresolved. 

The long years of double-talk engendered by Hitler’s specter 
concealed the true nature of the Zionist state and its purposefulness 
in denying recognition to the Palestinians, who are an independent 
people fully entitled to exercise the right of self-determination in their 
own land. Their existence as an independent nation was provisionally 
recognized by the League of Nations in the 1922 grant of the Palestine 
mandate—long before there was any corresponding international rec- 
ognition of a Zionist state. The same time as the U.N., successor to the 
League, recommended establishment of the Zionist state, it sanctioned 
establishment of a Palestinian state on Palestinian soil. Nothing has 
occurred since 1947 in any way invalidating this title to a national state. 
In population size, in sense of national identity, and in capacity for 
self-government and independence, the Palestinians are fully as well 
qualified for membership at the U.N. as many of the existing member 
states, including Israel. 

The rights of the Palestinian people to exist as an independent 








778 POLITICS OR POLICY 


national entity and the rights of the people of Israel to a secure exis- 
tence are two sides of the same coin. As a man of the Bible who has 
made the quest for human rights the keystone of his administration, 
who better than President Carter could have led the way toward end- 
ing the anguish of Palestinian exile and the hell of Israeli occupation? 
If a sense of justice constitutes the basis for U.S. support of Israel, the 
cake must slice in both directions. Justice must come for those who 
have an equal, if not a superior, legal and moral claim to the same land 
of Palestine. The right of the Palestinian people to statehood and of 
all Palestinians to make their home in their own land ought no longer 
be questioned. 

Staunch American friends of Israel called for the end of the occu- 
pation of the West Bank and Gaza for the benefit of the Israelis them- 
selves: 


It is corrupting to hold and govern another people by force. This is one of the 
arguments mounted against slavery by Thomas Jefferson. Slavery not only 
wronged the slave, it coarsened and brutalized the master.? 


Highly respected Israeli journalist Boaz Evron points to the price 
the occupation was causing his own people: 


... Through the creation of a semi-colonial regime and the rise of a class of 
small omnipotent despots who tyrannize a submissive population by using 
weapons... the ruler is bound to develop all the loathsome traits of arrogance, 
corruption and oblivion of the humanity of the ruled. The ruler may in time 
transfer these conditions to his own people. . .. Oppression of the conquered 
population will turn into interior terror against dissenters among Jews. This 
is an unavoidable process, by which the poison and rot spread. Oppression has 
no limits. 


Presidents Johnson, Nixon, and Ford all failed in their quest for 
the “just and lasting peace” envisaged in Resolution 242 by ignoring 
Palestinian rights and adhering to the false premise that this goal could 
best be achieved by keeping Israel unilaterally stronger than all her 
neighbors combined. Israel has been so militarily endowed by the U.S. 
for two decades, and yet the Arab-Israeli conflict continues. 

Carter seemed to be seeking a more evenhanded approach during 
the early months of his administration by becoming the first U.S. 
President to talk of a ‘Palestinian homeland.” But he continually wav- 
ered, as others before him had, in the face of Zionist pressure and 
power. He abandoned the goal of an overall settlement for the dra- 
matic Israeli-Egyptian version of Kissinger step-by-step diplomacy, 





Conclusion: Toward Justice and Then Peace 779 


leading to the Begin-Dayan plan for the occupied West Bank, in which 
PLO participation was totally ruled out and a mockery was made of 
Palestinian rights. While sharply disagreeing with Begin over the set- 
tlement issue and the necessity of some withdrawal from all occupied 
territories, Carter’s negativeness toward Palestinian statehood for the 
West Bank and Gaza persisted. 

By what right does the U.S., Egypt, Israel, or any other party lay 
down the rules for the self-determination of the Palestinian people and 
decide whether they shall live in a Palestinian state, a Jordanian-Pales- 
tinian federation, a unified Jordanian kingdom, a republic, or other- 
wise? The overwhelming Palestinian sentiment against the Israeh plan 
was expressed by Mayor Mohammed Hassan Milhem of the West Bank 
town of Halhoul: ‘Our people should be given the right of self-deter- 
mination and the full right of an independent state without being 
under the patronage of anybody. We condemn any effort or attempt 
to go around and try to create alternatives.4 As Dr. Walid Khalidi, 
Palestinian professor of political studies at the American University in 
Beirut stated to Anthony Lewis of the New York Times June 15, 1978, 
“the cornerstone” of an acceptable solution is a sovereign state, not 
one with ‘ersatz sovereignty” or an Indian reservation sprinkled with 
“armed archeologists,” but ‘‘only a true state” that could give Pales- 
tinians “‘a national anchorage.” 

Palestinians of the West Bank became increasingly dejected and 
angry as they remained unconsulted and negotiations stalled. From an 
irate Christian in Ramallah came this comment: “Mondays, Wednes- 
days, and Fridays Carter is for the Arabs. Tuesdays, Thursdays, and 
Saturdays he’s for the Israelis, and on Sundays he goes to church.” 
They are convinced ‘‘no one can force Israel to do anything.”’ As a 
businessman told a Washington Post correspondent (January 15, 1978): 
“We want the PLO—warts and all—to represent us.”” Termination of 
occupation is the key demand. 

Ambiguous promises of autonomy under alien supervision and 
control in another Bantustan with the exercise of self-determination 
after five years—and not positively then—is no answer to the Pales- 
tinian claim to nationhood in a national state of their own. While there 
could be no objection to a very brief, temporary, and transitional 
period of international administration to help prepare the way for full 
exercise by the Palestinians of their right of self-determination in an 
orderly representative manner, this was a far cry from Israeli intent. 

The number-one step on any peace agenda is for the U.S. to grant 
immediate and forthright recognition to the PLO as the legitimate 


780 POLITICS OR POLICY 


representatives of the Palestinian people and to lend every possible 
assistance to the establishment of a Palestinian state on the West Bank 
and in Gaza. Such action would be consonant with the inalienable right 
of self-determination, inexorably proclaimed by all American states- 
men. It is for the Palestinians—and the Palestinians alone—to choose 
their own leaders and representatives. However militant and intracta- 
ble they may be, there is little alternative to dealing with the effective 
leaders of a people in revolt. U.N. General Assembly resolutions, the 
Arab states at Rabat, and the 1976 West Bank elections all affirmed the 
PLO leadership. 

Such an act of recognition by the U.S. admittedly would breach 
the once-secret Kissinger covenant given as an inducement to Israel 
to enter into the second disengagement agreement. Not only has the 
situation totally changed with the Sadat initiative, but Israel herself 
violated her agreement with the U.S. by employing American weapons, 
in particular the CBU-72 cluster bombs, during the 1978 invasion of 
Lebanon, contravening the Arms Export Control Act and additional 
pledges of use only in case of full-scale war (such as 1967 and 1973) 
against well-entrenched emplacements.> 

Recognition by the U.S. would place the Palestinian leadership 
under a sense of obligation to Washington, which could be balanced 
against any promissory notes that might be due to Moscow for assist- 
ance rendered in achieving this essential goal. As Arnold Toynbee 
expressed it some years ago: ‘“The question is whether the Arabs are 
going to attain their acceptable objectives with the goodwill and assist- 
ance of the West, or whether they are going to attain their objective, 
in the teeth of Western opposition, thanks to Russian support... . The 
way in which they will win will decide whether they join our or Russia’s 
camp.’’® And this applies particularly to the Palestinians after their 
long struggle. 

As an excuse for its boycott of the PLO, the U.S. points to Begin’s 
assertion that he would negouate anything but Israel’s destruction, 
which he insists is the Palestinian aim. Syrian President Hafez al-Assad 
told Arnaud de Borchgrave, senior foreign correspondent of Newsweek, 
in January 1978: “Let Begin address himself to the PLO. Let him say 
to the PLO executive committee: ‘I want to negotiate with you, but not 
on the destruction of Israel,’ and let him hear their answer.” 

Next in importance, Washington must persuade Israel through 
Jewish-American leadership that the State of Israel must de-Zionize by 
giving up its abnormal nationalism, which extends inchoate citizenship 
to nationals of other countries because they share a common faith. It 





Conclusion: Toward Justice and Then Peace 781 


has been Zionism, never Judaism, that has been the intruder in the area 
and the harbinger of animosity between the two peoples of Palestine. 
It was fear of this political ideology, striving for an exclusivist state, not 
hatred or bias toward Jew qua Jew, that ushered in the awesome con- 
flict. Arabs and Jews lived peacefully together for centuries before the 
advent of Zionism, and they could do so in the future. 

What we today know as anti-Semitism never existed in the Arab 
world. Moses and Abraham, as well as Jesus, are recognized as proph- 
ets in the Islamic faith, the Koran refers to Jews as “people of the 
book,” and one of the holiest places in Islam is the Rock of Jerusalem 
where Abraham was prepared to sacrifice his son Isaac. It is difficult 
for the seeds of bigotry to grow in such an atmosphere. The Jews had 
originally been brought to Babylon (now Iraq) by Nebuchadnezzar 
after the destruction of the Kingdom of Judah. It was there that the 
Babylonian Talmud had been written and the captives had found the 
“peace of the city” prophesized for them by Jeremiah. It was in the 
ensuing great Islamic empires that they served as counselors and ad- 
visers to sultans and pashas, gaining civic prestige and financial posi- 
tion while enjoying for centuries economic and religious freedom. In 
Iraq there had been Jewish finance ministers in various Cabinets, and 
125,000 Jews who attended some sixty synagogues.” 

The situation was the same in Egypt, where the Jews had lived for 
millennia side by side with the followers of Islam. Some of them were 
descendants of ancient Hebrews whom Moses left behind in his exo- 
dus. Others had fled to Egypt following the first destruction of the 
Temple in Jerusalem at the hands of the Babylonians in 250 B.c. Jews 
gained sanctuary in Egypt from Christian persecutions in Spain and 
Portugal in the 15th century, from Soviet excesses at the time of the 
Russian Revolution, and from Hitler’s racial persecutions in the 1940s. 
And the invasion of Egypt by Israel on October 29, 1956, calculatingly 
brought an end to this Egyptian sanctuary for the Jews of the world, 
some of whom I had encountered in the Great Synagogue in the 
middle of Cairo, when as a World War II GI I attended the Rosh 
Hashanah services. 

As one Oriental Jew expressed it: ‘We sang together and wept 
together. It was only after Zionism and Israel appeared on the scene 
that this human structure collapsed. . . ."" Today the Jewish community 
in Iraq numbers less than 1,000 and is even smaller than that in Egypt. 
It was Zionism that brought an end to peaceful coexistence; a well- 
organized Zionist campaign led by agents sent into the country pro- 
duced the trouble between Jews and Muslims, resulting in a most 


782 POLITICS OR POLICY 


reluctant Jewish exodus despite the opposition of Iraq’s chief rabbi, 
Sassoon Kheddoury.® 

The holocaust has caused a total misreading of history and has 
blocked out the reality of the long, intimate relationship under which 
Jews and Judaism thrived in the Arab-Muslim world. Almost totally 
ignored by the U.S. media was the magnanimous act of Yasir Arafat 
in sending food and water to nearly 150 Jewish Lebanese trapped in 
a Beirut synagogue during the Lebanese civil war. Wadi Abu Jamil, the 
Beirut neighborhood that housed many of the city’s 1,500 Jews, had 
been a no-man’s land between the warring Christians and Muslims. 
Acting on a request from attorney Salim al Maghrebi, who heads the 
Jewish community there, the PLO rushed in the necessary aid. Magh- 
rebi was quoted as saying: ‘“The Lebanese Jews are grateful to Mr. 
Arafat. We have no need of any outside protection because no one has 
touched a hair on our heads. We reject Israeli reports that the commu- 
nity is in any danger. We want no outside protectors, Israeli or other- 
wise. We simply plan to go on living as we always have, as Lebanese.’ 
After sending in food for those in need, the Palestinian commandos 
became the guardians of this community during the remainder of the 
strife. 

Jews, Muslims, and with Christians all have an equally deep 
spiritual and emotional attachment to Jerusalem and can share a Holy 
City that is internationalized. This would be consonant with the 1947 
U.N. partition plan, and depoliticizing this most sacred of cities would 
return it to the three monotheistic faiths to whom it justly belongs. 

Five years before Begin came to power, Guardian correspondent 
David Hirst refuted Zionism’s unique claim to Jerusalem: 


They cannot challenge the Arab claim to Jerusalem by the only criterion which 
would count in modern law—centuries of continuous residence and ownership 
of the land; so they have to erect another one in its place, the intensity of the 
sentimental attachment, the strength of the mystic bond which binds them to 
it. The world is asked to have a sense of history and to appreciate what it means 
to the Jews to return to the Holy City from which they were expelled 1900 
years ago. It is asked to find no undue presumption in the recent assertion of 
Ben-Gurion that “Jerusalem has been the Jewish capital for 3000 years since 
King David.’’!0 

For their part, the Arabs must prove that their record of tolerance 
toward Jews is not just past history and that they sincerely intend to 


implement present words regarding coexistence in the area on an 
equal basis with Jews. By not making a mere shibboleth of the deep 





Conclusion: Toward Justice and Then Peace 783 


abyss between Judaism and Zionism, they can do much to overcome 
the deep-seated recent mistrust that has grown up between two Se- 
mitic ‘‘cousins.”” There are many Israelis who would respond positively 
to a resumption of fraternal relations with Arabs. 

What hopes there are for a more reasonable Israeli attitude rest 
in the hands of Israel’s youth and future generations. Many young 
Sabras (the native-born were given this name because their resilience 
makes them resemble the cactus fruit—tough on the outside, sweet on 
the inside) are not afflicted with the Masada complex. What desire they 
may have for a ‘‘Greater Israel’ stems not from support of worldwide 
Jewish nationalism but from overbearing pride in their country, which 
would constitute 10 menace to their neighbors. Prime Minister David 
Ben-Gurion openly admitted that the Eichmann trial had been used 
not only to win world sympathy for the new state but to indoctrinate 
his youngsters with an understanding of the true meaning of Hitler 
and the holocaust. But this new generation of Israelis never developed 
any love of Zionism and, in fact, holds the deepest disdain for nonim- 
migrating Jews living outside. Israeli youth deeply resent the price 
exacted for their insecure living in Israel: the inordinate taxes, ram- 
pant inflation, and the ever-present threat of an Arab attack. They 
cannot help feel the increasing hostility of an outside world in which 
their only real friend and ally, aside from the U.S., is South Africa, with 
its blatant racism and apartheid, and with whom military-economic ties 
have vastly escalated. 

The desire for peace was expressed in the gigantic April !, 1978, 
rally outside Jerusalem's City Hall when more than 30,000 Israelis 
responded to a call by 300 military reservists and university students, 
who had sent a letter to Prime Minister Begin criticizing the govern- 
ment’s conduct of negotiations. Huge placards, “Better Peace in Israel 
than a Greater Israel,” supplied the keynote for the demonstration. 
The pessimistic realism of the youthful strata of Israel is reflected in 
the ever-increasing exodus from their country, including the more 
than 2,000 Israeli taxi drivers on the streets of New York City. 

An independent U.S. policy based on the development of a sound 
framework of evenhanded political relationships with all Middle East 
countries is a prime necessity. This alone can serve vital U.S. interests 
as well as the world community's desire for peace and stability in the 
region. Israel, as President Eisenhower required her to do after the 
1956 aggression, must be made by Washington to give up the occupa- 
tion of all Egyptian, Syrian, and Jordanian territories, save for minor 
border rectifications, in accordance with the most reasonable interpre- 





784 POLITICS OR POLICY 


tation of Resolution 242. The long-extant U.S. guarantee of the terri- 
torial integrity of all nations of the Middle East, flouted since the 1967 
war, should be replaced by a U.S.-U.S.S.R. security pledge, under U.N. 
auspices, to Israel, to the new Palestinian entity, and to the other Arab 
states. 

There is little prospect of Middle East peace, and certainly no 
hope of ending the dangerous and escalating arms race without the 
cooperation of the Kremlin. Between 1973 and 1976 $20 billion in 
armaments were poured into the area; $11 billion from the U.S., $6 
billion from the U.S.S.R., and $3 billion from Britain and France. (On 
his March 1978 visit to Washington, Israel’s Defense Minister Weiz- 
mann sought a long-range arms commitment in excess of $12 billion.) 
It is not in the cards for military establishments to be long in posses- 
sion of such great arsenals without finding some good excuse to use 
them. Israel’s nuclear capability, which the Arab countries were con- 
stantly striving to match, has added to the dangers. Washington must 
both find means other than the sale of instrumentalities of death to 
overcome a portion of its huge deficit balance of payments stemming 
from oil imports and abandon the anomalous use of armaments, such 
as the $4.8 billion jet sale to Saudi Arabia, Egypt, and Israel, as the way 
to peace. 

As for Israel, a genuine peace with its neighbors should prove 
more satisfactory than an amorphous U.S. commitment to its security. 
So long as the Israelis felt they could rely on Washington’s security 
commitment—expressed or implied—they could always reply to a de- 
mand for concessions: “‘We cannot give that territory back. It endan- 
gers our security.” 

Whatever commitment may have been given was certainly in- 
tended by the American people for the people of Israel, not for an 
Israeli state bent on expansionism, be it by conquest or ideology. No 
commitment covering Israel as well as its conquests has ever been 
constitutionally ratified. No President, let alone any number of mem- 
bers of Congress, ever had the right to guarantee the Zionist policy of 
bringing in Jews from all over the world, the ‘‘ingathering of the 
exiles’’ as it is called, or the concomitant establishment of settlements 
in the occupied territories. Why should it still be considered blasphe- 
mous to call for clarification and redefinition by Washington of the 
exact nature of the extant U.S. security commitment to Israel? 

These recommended drastic U.S. foreign policy steps might be 
accompanied by important internal measures. The entire question of 
the Middle East must be taken out of the domestic political arena, a 





Conclusion: Toward Justice and Then Peace 785 


goal for which James Forrestal gave his life, and made part of the 
bipartisan foreign policy Senator Arthur H. Vandenberg first en- 
visaged. Nothing but national harm has been wrought by the continual 
Republican sniping, led by National Committee Chairman William 
Brock and Senator Howard Baker, to which ex-President Ford lent a 
conspicuous hand by addressing a New York meeting of the National 
Council of Young Israel in April 1978 and assailing the Carter adminis- 
tration for insisting on significant Israeli territorial concessions. His 
1976 running mate, Senator Robert J. Dole, made it known that he did 
not intend to “fade away”; he began addressing Zionist rallies, includ- 
ing a large gathering in Jerusalem where he exhorted the Israelis not 
to give up an inch of territory. Sull maintaining his popularity among 
Conservative Republicans, Ronald Reagan, who always had been 
“gung-ho” for Israel, did a weekly column for the Jewish Press of Brook- 
lyn and took intermittent pokes at the Carter administration for not 
doing enough for Israel. 

Bipartisanship could be realized, and the sordid campaigning for 
votes over this issue best brought to an end, through the elimination 
of the Electoral College system and the popular election of the Presi- 
dent and Vice President. This would drastically reduce the reliance of 
any President, or nominee for that office, on the so-called ‘Jewish 
vote,” the wooing of which has so plagued the development of policy 
in the national interest. Such direct elections of the Chief Executive 
would drastically curtail the ability of Zionism and other special inter- 
est groups to gain preferential treatment for themselves and for their 
friends abroad. Several Presidents, including Carter, have submitted 
legislation in this direction, but all have encountered overwhelming 
obstacles to date.!! 

Everyone has played domestic politics with the Arab-Israeli con- 
flict—Republicans, Democrats, and the politicians of other Western 
countries—and have brought only more chaos to the scene. The Arab 
countries competed with one another in being more anti-Israel, the 
Israeli political parties vied as to degree of anti-Arab sentiment. At a 
critical stage in April during the 1978 Middle East negotiations, Sena- 
tor Howard Baker appeared on “Face the Nation” to make political 
capital of Carter’s position by strongly defending Begin against the 
charge of intransigency. In a bid to return to power, former Canadian 
Prime Minister John Diefenbaker visited Israel, planted 750 trees in 
behalf of Canadian Jews, and criticized the Trudeau government for 
not moving its embassy to Jerusalem in recognition of the ‘‘true capital 
of Israel.” 


786 POLITICS OR POLICY 


Next in importance is removal of the word “anti-Semitism” from 
political and public discussion of the Middle East problem. This throt- 
ding label is totally irrelevant to the debate over the rights of two 
Semitic-speaking peoples. A free and open expression of opinion is 
needed so that Americans may understand why their President can 
rarely say “no” to Israel, why their representatives in Washington are 
not serving the totality of American interests, why the media is afraid 
to report the news fairly, and why their sons may one day be forced 
to fight in a new, more horrible Vietnam. The Great Middle East 
Debate, totally untethered and uninhibited, must be permitted to go 
forward to avoid the overwhelming catastrophe that otherwise lies 
ahead. And just as judges disqualify themselves in cases where they 
cannot be impartial because of a conflict of interests, so likewise should 
the many media commentators whose Zionism pervades their outpour- 
ings to millions. 

What is required is that all Americans face the Middle East crisis 
courageously and participate in helping to find a solution. All fear of 
speaking out must be banished. To tell the truth as he sees it, a George 
Ball ought not have to be abjectly apologetic, as in his Foreign Affairs 
article, ‘‘How to Save Israel in Spite of Herself!”’!? Nor should a com- 
petent political-economic observer be forced to employ a pseudonym, 
to turn to Vanity Fair publishers, and then have to resort to the title 
“Goldstein Explains How Jews Control American Policy Toward Is- 
rael”!5 in order to set forth the thesis that international Zionism has 
played on “latent racism and pathological anti-Communism’” to 
achieve its ends in the U.S. The author tellingly puts these words in 
the mouth of his Mr. Goldstein: 


It really upsets us to see that the Palestinians have been as nationalistic as Jews. 
We have a mandate from God and Americans to be so. I never read in any Bible 
about God's having given a similar mandate to the Palestinians. God, are they 
unreasonable bastards! Can you imagine Americans being like that? If Israel 
annexes New York State because it is mostly Jewish owned, Gentiles in Amer- 
ica will never become as unreasonable as the Palestinians and fight the Jews. 
Well, it’s only a hypothetical situation anyway. Why would Israel want only 
New York State when it has all the United States?'4 


The potent American business community, which has a tremen- 
dous stake in the region but has displayed abysmal cowardice to date 
on this issue, must join the struggle for justice. U.S. companies have 
not only refrained from anything but superficial involvement in the 
contest for American public opinion, but have failed to protect even 










787 


their own selfish interests. Large, powerful corporations have coun- 
tenanced the distortion and embellishment of the actual Arab eco- 
nomic boycott of Israel into a ‘“‘shadow boycott’’!5 so as to give all the 
appearances of an Arab “‘anti-Semitic’”’ campaign. This helped spur the 
passage by Congress of antiboycott legislation handcuffing vital U.S. 
trade in the area. 

It is difficult to esumate how many billions of dollars of trade and 
hundreds of thousands of jobs may be lost due to adoption of the 
Stevenson-Rosenthal bill and companion enactments designed to cur- 
tail Arab economic warfare against companies giving economic and 
financial assistance to Israel. As pointed out in the 1976 testimony 
before the House Committee on International Relations by repre- 
sentatives of the Associated General Contractors of America,!® part of 
what was at stake was more than $200 billion in construction programs 
expected over the following five years, of which the American market 
ought to have captured at least 15 percent or $30 billion. (By April 
1978 far more of the top 400 American contracting firms were doing 
business in Saudi Arabia than in any other foreign country.) 

Conceivably, as Congressman Robert H. Michel (Rep.-Ill.) 
warned the House during the 1977 debate over the pending legisla- 
tion, the U.S. could lose “$16 billion in outstanding service and con- 
struction contracts in Saudi Arabia alone this coming year plus another 
$4 billion a year in sales of direct civilian exports, and $9 billion in 
military goods and services.”!7 As many as half a million jobs could be 
lost if all eighteen Arab countries were taken into account, according 
to the study of MIT Professor Richard D. Robinson, cited by Congress- 
man Michel.!8 

The long, tedious, complex, and confusing regulations now re- 
quired for Middle East traders by the Department of Commerce under 
the new legislation have imposed a frightening, restrictive burden, 
particularly on smaller business firms. For many it is better not to 
attempt to do any business rather than to record and justify not only 
transactions but motivations in order to protect themselves against 
unfounded charges and heavy penalties for compliance with the Arab 
boycott. As the U.S. deficit trade balance dangerously mounts, detri- 
mentally affecting the American people and economy, serious thought 
should be given to repealing the crippling antiboycott legislation. The 
Zionist legislators who convinced their colleagues that American con- 
tractors and major business suppliers to the Middle East would sull win 
their share of petrodollars because the U.S. is the ‘‘only country” 
supplying “what the Arab countries need’’!9 unfortunately have been 


788 POLITICS OR POLICY 


proven wrong. The fantastic rise in U.S.-Arab trade since 1973 is 
beginning to reverse itself, and West European and Japanese competi- 
tors are speedily replacing their American counterparts. 

In the past the U.S. has employed economic sanctions and/or 
boycotts against the Soviet Union, China, Cuba, North Vietnam, Cam- 
bodia, North Korea, and Rhodesia. Not to be forgotten was the Zionist 
1946 boycott of Britain, nor their more recent acts of economic war- 
fare: boycotting 970 Japanese companies that preferred to do business 
with twenty Arab countries rather than with Israel, boycotting Mexico 
in 1976 for her vote on the U.N. resolution equating Zionism with 
racism, and France for releasing Palestinian Abu Daoud. 

A heavy price has already been exacted for the failure to heed the 
warning of John F. Kennedy against American partisanship in the 
Arab-Israeli conflict. As Americans continue to view the fast-moving 
Middle East scene through Israeli spectacles and to judge Palestinian 
rights according to the terrorist syndrome, the extent to which the 
security of every American is linked to the attainment of stability in the 
Middle East has been very much kept from public purview. 

Infinitely more necessary than the much-discussed normalization 
of relations between Israel and the Arab states is the normalization of 
U.S.-Israeli relations. An end must be put to the unique relationship, 
unparalleled between two sovereign nations, that has been an alba- 
tross around the U.S. neck in its execution of foreign policy, not to 
mention an incredible burden on the American taxpayer. For example, 
the Israeli government’s 1974-75 budget totaled $8.6 billion, the larg- 
est item of which was $3.8 billion—44 percent—for defense. ‘This was 
almost as much as had been spent during the October war, the bulk 
of which was covered by the special $2.2 billion U.S. military aid bill 
enacted to cover the cost of the arms airlift. 

From the very outset, Uncle Sam had come to the rescue in crucial 
moments in Israel's history. No loan was more vital than the first $135 
million Export-Import Bank loan granted by President Truman in 
1949 when the new state faced instant bankruptcy. But no help had 
been better timed than the gigantic flow of U.S. arms in the midst of 
the 1973 war. The huge Galaxy transports droning in over ‘Tel Aviv’s 
shorefront every hour during the last two weeks of the conflict, deliver- 
ing forty-four tons of armaments, were a visible demonstration of the 
extraordinary American-Israeli relationship. 

In testifying against the special aid bill, Senator James Abourezk 
stated: “It is ludicrous that this Congress should be asked to permit 
the Administration an additional $1.2 billion over and above the $1 








789 


billion costs of the Israeli supply effort for undisclosed ‘impondera- 
bles.’ ” Another view of this extraordinary aid bill for Israel came from 
an American teaching at the University of Beirut: 


$1.5 billion is being planned as capital budget for New York City with its 11 
million population, and now $2.2 billion military aid is given for a country of 
2.5 million. On the basis of that arithmetic, I think it would be much cheaper 
all the way around to transfer all Israelis to New York City. The United States 
would be about a couple millions ahead, and they would live within “safe and 
secure” borders! 


Originally only $1 billion had been declared an outright grant, but 
when President Nixon was in Moscow?® he exercised the discretion 
under the legislation to sign an authorization converting a half-billion 
of the remaining amount to an additional grant. This was done at the 
request of Israeli Defense Minister Shimon Peres, then on a visit to 
Washington seeking an additional $7.5 billion for the ensuing five 
years, almost all in grants rather than “loans” because of Israel’s 
“flagging economy,” according to the New York Times. 

Israel's per capita arms expenditure for 1974 was more than 24% 
times that of any other nation.?! Her expenditure amounted to more 
than $1,110 per person, the nearest comparable per capita figure 
being that of Russia’s $428, with a yearly expenditure of $119 billion. 
The U.S. expenditure was $91 billion, per capita only $390. On an 
absolute dollar basis, only ten other nations spent more for military 
might than Israel.?? The armament expenditures by nine Arab states 
(the United Arab Emirates, Saudi Arabia, Kuwait, Libya, Iraq, Syria, 
Egypt, Jordan, and Lebanon) totaled some $6 billion for a population 
of 71.1 million. Those nine countries spent $84 per capita, 8 percent 
of the Israeli per capita expenditure. 

In the ten years ending in 1974, the Israeli armaments figure 
reached a staggering $15.48 billion, most from government or private 
sources in the U.S. The Zionist state was expending 34.60 percent of 
its G.N.P. on the military, compared to 6 percent by the U.S. Israel’s 
growing war industry, responsible for its Kfir fighters and Chariot 
tanks, was backed by U.S. investments and U.S.-Israeli technology. In 
order to keep its aircraft industry viable, Israel coproduced a portion 
of the F-16s received from the Pentagon and in 1978 was seeking 
authority to manufacture components of U.S. weapons that it did not 
wish to acquire, such as subassemblies of Gruman A-6 tactical bomb- 
ers.23 But Israel continued to draw on American advanced armaments 
and supplies—and billions. 





790 POLITICS OR POLICY 


Half of the development budget of $1.6 billion in 1974 was cov- 
ered by the sale of Israel Bonds abroad, additional sums from Jewry 
in the Diaspora being necessary to cover other foreign loans. Various 
health, education, and social welfare programs were financed in this 
critical postwar year by roughly $1 billion the government received in 
other donations, primarily from United Jewish Appeal and Jewish wel- 
fare funds—all tax deductible to the donor. 

While a handful of objectors fearfully?4 expressed objections to 
the dollar drain for Israeli Bonds, the purchase of large amounts of 
Israel Bonds continued to come from the most curious sources. 

In May 1973 Teamsters President Frank E. Fitzsimmons received 
the Israel Silver Anniversary Award for his efforts in the investment of 
$26 million of Teamster pension and health and welfare funds in Israel 
bonds. According to news reports, present and participating in the 
praise of the Teamster leader was Secretary of the U.S. Treasury 
George Shultz. Fitzsimmons is an Irishman, but the dinner for 2,500 
Teamsters and Teamster employees was declared his ““Bar Mitzvah” 
by Herbert Stein, Chairman of the President's Council of Economic 
Advisers. A telegram from President Nixon was read to the diners. Not 
only did it not seem strange for trust funds of American organized 
labor to be invested in a foreign nation, but two of the administration’s 
top economic advisers, who were otherwise expressing public concern 
over inflation and the credit crunch, apparently gave their approval. 

Israeli Ambassador Simcha Dinitz, substituting for Foreign Minis- 
ter Abba Eban, presented the medal and stated that the Teamsters’ 
investment had made it possible for Israel to ‘‘not only support war, 
but to launch peace.”” What the members of the International Brother- 
hood of Teamsters certainly did not appreciate was that this pension 
fund management, which had brought them $26 million of Israel 54% 
percent Bonds due in twenty years, could have bought at the same time 
the exact number of U.S. bonds, which would have yielded a return of 
6.9 percent for each of the next twenty years. The difference of 1.40 
percent annual return on $26 million is $364,000, or $7.28 million 
over twenty years—the amount the pension funds lost because their 
management had chosen the foreign country of Israel over the U.S. 

American taxpayers continue to pay the piper for Israel on many 
fronts. Under pressure from Speaker Stanley Steingut and Assembly- 
man Irwin J. Landes, the Board of Regents of the State of New York 
appropriated $225,000 as a grant to the Sachler School of Medicine 
in Tel Aviv to pay the tuition for forty New Yorkers to study medicine 
there, and to put ten Israeli students through medical college in the 











Conclusion: Toward Justice and Then Peace 791 


U.S. at no cost.25 The plain fact is that tax-free, tax-deductible monies 
given as charitable dollars are simply a gift to the Israeli national 
budget. When sums needed for various services by an Israeli govern- 
ment agency are provided through American charity, other monies are 
freed to help meet that portion of the Israeli defense budget for which 
there have not been grants or loans. Instead of listing these under 
charitable contributions, they ought to be listed under the category, 
“Taxes Paid to Foreign Governments.” The IRS provides that only 
those contributions that are wholly (not holy) humanitarian, charita- 
ble, or educational are deductible to the donor. U.S. tax-deductible 
funds given for humanitarian purposes have gone into the purchase of 
jets and the manufacture of napalm bombs to subdue the Palestinians 
or to defray the expenses of Moshe Dayan rallies against efforts to win 
increased Israeli flexibility. 

The U.S. has been Israel’s largest trading partner, and private 
investments of American business have played a major factor in the 
Israeli post-1967-war economic boom. U.S. investments approach an 
annual average of 55 percent of the total foreign investments in the 
Israeli economy. 

It is significant that Americans in their relations with Israel lag 
behind other national groups in only one area—immigration. In 1973, 
for example, only 4,393 Americans moved to Israel, while over 35,000 
Soviets immigrated there. Of the 1.5 million who came to Israel be- 
tween 1948 and 1974, only 30,000 Americans remained. The Israelis 
resent their dependence on both the U.S. and American Jews who only 
visit but do not settle in Israel. Despite the continuous urging by 
Zionist leaders to emigrate, American Jews draw the line here. They 
will give money and all else, but to send Jews other than themselves 
to Israel. The contributing nonimmigrating American has frequently 
been the butt of sarcastic jokes. A manager of Jerusalem’s King David 
Hotel used to carry a few bills in his pocket so that, whenever a visiting 
American complained of Israel’s shortcomings, he could thrust the 
note into his hands and say, ‘‘We’re even.’’?6 

The box score on the capital that has poured into the tiny Mediter- 
ranean state from its benefactors, the U.S. government and the Ameri- 
can people, scarcely constitutes a joke. It is staggering: $42 billion or 
$10,700 per Israeli citizen. (See table on next page.) 

Contributions from West Germany to Israel by way of reparations, 
restitutions, and loans reached an additional figure of $4.314 billion, 
which were only made possible by the U.S. forgiveness of $2 billion in 
reparations from Germany. In every way possible, Hitler has done 


792 POLITICS OR POLICY 



U.S. AID TO ISRAEL (IN MILLIONS)?27 





SOURCE FISCAL YEARS 
1948-1975 1976-1977 1978-1981 1948-198] 
U.S Government Assistance $6,562.3 $4,525.0 $10,531.9 $21,619.2 

(Military & Economic) 

Private Institutions     3,363.0 31,013.0 1,987.0 6,363.0 
Private Individuals     12.301.0 1578.0 4] 935.0 4,814.0 
Israel Bonds*             22.611.0 5546.0 1,619.2 4,776.2 
Loans (commercial)     2,060.0 6940.0 5480.0 2,780.0 
Investments                 1,410.0 7139.0 7157.0 1,706.0 
‘VOTALs                     $18.307.3 $7,041.0 $16,710.1 Tt $42,058.4 


(or $10,700 per Israeli citizen) 


1. This figure represents the minimal U.S. 75% of all private individual transfers worldwide. 
2. This figure represents the minimal U.S. 75% of total Israel Bond purchases worldwide. 
3. Principally UJA. According to the Library of Congress research, a spokesman stated these sums 
represented pledges not yet fully collected or transmitted. 
4. Figures supplied by Russell Mishcloff, Near East Bureau A.I1. 
5. According to a spokesman, the U.S. purchases represented 85% of total worldwide sales, which 
figures were set forth in the New York Times, January 9, 1978. 
6. Figures not available ... this represents a minimal based on the average of investments during 
the 1948-1975 period, which is exceedingly low. 
7. Israel Central Bureau, Monthly Bulletin of Statistics, Supplement May 1978 and May 1982. 
*Not subject to the Interest Equalization Tax as are other foreign securities. 
tThis is exclusive of $1.24 billion given to UNRWA, the agency that provides Palestinian refugees 
with a bare minimum of subsistence. And the closure of the Suez Canal cost the U.S. and the 
Free World an estimated $3.4 billion annually from 1967 to 1975. 


more than his share for the State of Israel. 

This accounting does not of course, include other vital benefits to 
Israel given on a scale proportional to her share in financial and mili- 
tary aid, as Harvard’s Nadav Safran pointed out: 


Hundreds of American technicians and Israeli trainees who have been ex- 
changed; dozens of Israeli cultural, educauonal and philanthropic instituuons 
who enjoyed American assistance from counterpart funds. Likewise, the Israeli 
public has been able to buy American cultural and educational material payable 
in Israeli currency at the official rate. In short, Israel has been given the status of 
a most favored nation, and not only in the technical sense in which the word is 
used in international trade. . . . There is scarcely one important educational, 
cultural, social or philanthropic institution in [srael which is not supported to 
some degree by Jewish-American, as well as US Governmentaid. .. .28 


The majority of Israel’s doctors, professors, scientists, and other 
professionals receive part of their training, if not most, in the U.S. At 
the Hebrew University in Jerusalem, sixty-one of the ninety-three visit- 











Conclusion: Toward Justice and Then Peace 793 


ing professors in 1976 were from the U.S., and some 1,400 American 
undergraduates attended courses in 1974, the largest of about fifty 
national groups. 

Not only did the American taxpayer carry the financial burden of 
the 1973 war, but statistics prove that the U.S. emerged the only loser. 
The Arabs gained new confidence and self-respect from their surpris- 
ing near-victory. The Israelis took consolation in the fact that by virtue 
of the American arms lift they managed to pull off a military comeback, 
almost wiping out the Egyptian Third Corps. General Ira C. Eaker, 
who commanded Allied Air Forces in the Mediterranean in World War 
II, pertinently noted that the 1973 war: 


... cost this country at least $4 billion. It used up scarce reserves of weapons 
and supphies and lost the critical Arab oil. General Motors, during the em- 
bargo, laid off 65,000 workers and put 5,700 more on temporary furlough, and 
the entire U.S. economy was affected inasmuch as this move had repercussions 
on GM's 13,000 dealers and 45,000 suppliers. There was hardly a company 
or person in the U.S. who did not suffer in some way from the shortage of 
materials, rising costs or even unemployment stemming from the embargo. 
Completely forgotten, too, was the cost to the United States and Europe of the 
closing of the Canal from 1967 to 1975, well over $10 billion.29 


Losses to the U.S. from its Middle East foreign policy cannot be 
calculated in dollars alone. There has been a vast nonmonetary price 
paid for the government’s inordinate support of Israel, although the 
Zumwalt-Keegan-Churba school of thought vociferously argues that 
the U.S. pays a very small price for having the Zionist state perform 
as our Middle East watchdog, preventing the area from going Commu- 
nist. Retired Admiral Elmo Zumwalt remained Israel’s great champion 
in military circles; in a 1977 speech at Chapel Hill, North Carolina, the 
former Chief of Naval Operations advocated annexing Israel and send- 
ing a large U.S. force to be stationed permanently to defend that 
country if necessary. General George Keegan stated in an interview 
that “for every dollar of support this country has given Israel, we have 
gotten a thousand dollars worth of benefits in return—access to equip- 
ment, access to documents, etc., which prepare us to cope with the 
Soviet forces and equipment around the world. The data is of incalcu- 
lable value.”’3° And Joseph Churba played the same tune whenever and 
wherever he could. 

Such reasoning is a gross perversion of the truth. The gravest 
dangers to U.S. interests in the Middle East have arisen from creation 
of the Israeli state, forcing certain Arab countries to turn to the Soviet 





794 POLITICS OR POLICY 


Union for help against demonstrated Zionist expansionism. 

The many warnings that the creation of a Zionist state in the 
heart of an Arab world against the will of the majority would bring 
the Soviet Union into the area were totally ignored. Russia, which 
had striven for warm water ports and an ‘“‘open sesame’”’ to the re- 
gion as far back as Peter and Catherine the Great, only needed one 
big opportunity. And when America’s “Israel-First”” stance and the 
Arabs’ ‘‘Not-at-all”” policy gave Moscow that big chance, Israelists 
and anti-Communist pundits alike cried out with a perfectly straight 
face: “Communism is threatening us through the Arabs. We must 
give Israel all-out support, military and otherwise, to save the area 
and U.S. interests.” 

This kind of ludicrous reasoning has not only prevailed but has 
rarely been prominently challenged until the appearance of the article 
on the Arab-Israeli military halance, “How Much Is Too Much?” in the 
October 1977 issue of Armed Forces Journal. Written by Anthony H. 
Cordesman, former civilian assistant to Deputy Secretary of Defense 
Robert Ellsworth and Secretary of the Defense Intelligence Board, the 
article claimed that “Israel has become a militaristic state whose mili- 
tary buildup has gone far beyond the requirements of defense.” On 
the other hand, he wrote, the Arabs ‘‘still lack effective air training and 
command, control and communications systems,” and their “‘vast 
amounts of air defense weaponry” have not been organized into an 
effective system. They still “cannot train effectively for armored ma- 
neuver warfare,” and their aircraft generally lacks modern air-to-air 
missles. 

With the emergence of the Likud Begin government, Cordesman 
contended: 


The U.S. may no longer be supplying an Israel whose military struggle would 
lead to Israeli willingness to compromise for peace. It may now find itself 
aiding a country which may use its military strength to take permanent control 
of former Arab territory in direct opposition to U.S. policy, and be locked into 
an indefinite cold war with the Arabs. At worst, the U.S. may find itself tied 
to an ally which will use military force in a pre-emptive attempt to settle the 
PLO problem, or to destroy Arab military forces while they are weak.®! 


The article cited the advice of several of Begin’s senior advisers 
to provoke Syria into war (which Israel nearly accomplished five 
months later during the March invasion of South Lebanon, but Presi- 
dent Assad exercised the greatest restraint, out of respect for Israel’s 
military might) “as an excuse to destroy its improving forces before 





Conclusion: Toward Justice and Then Peace 795 


they became threatening’’?? and to launch “attacks in support of Leba- 
nese Christians against the PLO.” 

Before Cordesman could even prove how remarkably accurate a 
crystal ball he possessed, the Anti-Defamation League charged that he 
had used classified information gained during his employment in the 
Defense Department and that the article contained an anti-Israel and 
anti-Jewish slant; the League called for a Pentagon investigation. Most 
of the five-page ADL press statement contained attempted refutations 
by Keegan and Churba of the Cordesman allegation that “new Israeli 
attitudes threaten the strategic interests of the U.S. and its allies,” 
which could lead to war, oil embargo, and inestimable damage to the 
dollar and the world monetary system. 

What particularly inflamed the Zionists was the article’s careful 
documentation, invaluable military statistical charts, and refutation of 
the large Israeli military requirements for assistance called for by their 
““Matmon B” plan. Cordesman claimed that the U.S. has never taken 
into account the ‘‘qualitative differences between Israeli and Arab 
forces and has chosen instead to set aid requirements based on the 
U.S. view of the future strength of Arab confrontation forces or the 
threat.”” The charts, he maintained, proved that planned US. aid ex- 
ceeded ‘‘far beyond the limit necessary to assure Israel’s security” and 
created an Israel ‘‘which has all of the capabilities necessary to wage 
offensive warfare.” 

The ADL was so exercised by publication of the article that, in 
addition to their demand for a Defense Department investigation, 
which resulted in an ambiguous refutation of the premise on which the 
protest was based, they harassed the editors of Armed Forces Journal into 
accepting a lengthy rebuttal by Churba, in which ‘‘none of the data are 
referenced,’’33 and flooded the magazine with letters. 

Prior to Sadat’s peace initiative, other sources confirmed Israeli 
preparations, in the event of the failure of Carter’s efforts, for a “war 
of annihilation” against the Egyptian and Syrian armies before the Big 
Powers could intervene to bring about a cease-fire as in 1973. Israel 
by the end of 1977 had already “stockpiled enough weapons, ammuni- 
tion, and fuel to fight a three-front conventional war for thirty days 
before needing fresh supplies from the U.S., according to estimated 
American arms exports.34 The idea was to destroy the Arabs militarily 
for seven to twelve years, thus getting through the period when Arab 
oil and money could be used to squeeze concessions from Israel. 
Through its existing eighteen-month, $2 billion military pipeline of 
new equipment, Israel was said by American officials to be in a position 





796 POLITICS OR POLICY 


to do what it wanted. Ona scale of 100 equaling their military capabili- 
ties in 1973, Israel in October 1977 stood at 160, Syria at 100, and 
Egypt at 80 to 90.55 

The basic American fear of Communism and the danger of the 
U.S.S.R. making further inroads into the Middle East has been fully 
exploited by Israel and her friends. 
U.S. policy makers, wittingly or 
unwittingly, have turned their backs on the best possible ally against 
any Communist threat, namely the strong theism of Islam. 
Deep Muslim spirituality is rooted in natural repugnance of a totalitarianism that 
wipes out religion. If the strengthening of anti-Communism is deemed 
to be a primary aim of U.S. foreign policy, then U.S. behavior in the 
Middle East has certainly been totally counterproductive. 

Close American ties to the Free World have invariably been subor- 
dinated to concern for Israel. At the critical moment of the Hungarian 
uprising, which coincided with the 1956 Suez war, U.S. hands were tied 
by “Israel First.’’ With the exception of Portugal, relations with our 
NATO allies were strained almost to the breaking point during the 
1973 airlift by their refusal to allow landing rights for U.S. planes 
carrying arms to Israel. When the oil embargo was imposed, the subse- 
quent energy problems and differences over the solution further mired 
relations with Europe, and with Japan as well. 

Since the early 1960s when the U.S. prodded West Germany to 
serve as an arms supply depot for Israel, differences between Bonn and 
Washington have intensified, the chasm widened by denunciatory full- 
page New York Times ads charging “the bell of danger was tolling in 
Germany for the third time in this century.’’36 Many of the problems 
between Washington and the France of de Gaulle, Pompidou, and 
D’Estaing stemmed from America’s deep obsession over Israel. The 
whipped-up hysteria after the sale of jets to Libya and the Abu Daoud 
affair, scarcely served American national interests. 

The campaigns of Zionism against India and Japan, complicated 
American relations as did Israel’s harmful tourist boycott of Mexico. 
The list could go on and on. There is scarcely a country with whom 
U.S. relations have not been adversely affected over Israel. The U.S. 
no longer had French-U.S. relations; it had French-U.S.-Israeli rela- 
tions. And at the U.N. America virtually isolated itself, frequently 
standing alone in defense of Israeli actions and policies. By 1978 this 
fact further complicated the brand-new problems Washington was 
encountering in the East African region known as the Horn, caused by 
the Somali-Ethiopian strife in which Israel was sending U.S.-made 
weapons to Ethiopia, who was being backed by the Soviet Union and 

797 


Cuba, against assistance being given to the former by the U.S., Egypt, 
and Saudi Arabia. 

Little wonder that by September 1977 President Carter was cau- 
tioning: ‘Dozens of other foreign policy matters have suffered to some 
degree because I’ve expended so much effort on this issue. If our 
efforts fail this year, it will be difficult for us to continue to devote that 
much time and effort to the Mideast.’’37 

There are many other reasons dictating that the U.S. sever the 
unique umbilical cord attaching it to the Zionist state and alienting 
invaluable Arab connections. Propagandists and idealists summarily 
dismiss any consideration given by Washington to her relationship 
with Saudi Arabia as purely an immoral and commercial interest. 
But more objective Americans cannot help feeling how ungrateful the 
Israelis must be to think that the U.S. will be a continuing source of 
infinite remittances and of policies winning enemies and losing friends 
for itself so as to keep the Israelis alive in the style and territory to 
which they have grown accustomed. There is a growing realization that 
we need Arab friendship, too! 

If Israel is to be made an exception to our first President’s admoni- 
tion against “favored nations,” U.S. national interests cry out for an 
equally special relationship with the Saudis (or other oil-rich Arabs), 
however Washington may have committed itself to the security of the 
Israelis. The U.S. 1977 trade deficit was $23.5 billion, and oil imports 
amounted to $41.5 billion. The trade deficit of $4.5 billion for the 
month of February 1978 was the worst in U.S. history. In its 1977 
report the CIA revealed that worldwide oil demands were likely to 
outstrip the supply within five to ten years. The U.S., already importing 
1.2 million barrels of oil daily from Saudi Arabia, was hoping to double 
these imports by 1980. 

The Arab oil-rich states have a minimum of $34 billion in our 
largest banking institutions—Bank of America, Chase, First National, 
and Morgan Guaranty. The Saudis, helping to alleviate the world 
energy crisis, have been producing far more oil than their revenue 
needs, and hence piling up surpluses of investments in the U.S. In the 
heated dispute over the advisability of such investments, Chairman 
Howard G. Blauvelt of Continental Oil Company noted: 


Resistance to Arab investments in the U.S. is understandable, but misquoted. 
There already are thousands of businesses in the U.S. owned or controlled by 
foreigners with an estimated book value of more than $40 billion. On the other 
hand, the book value of American investments overseas is now more than $100 
798 
bilhon. For example, some economists have projected a short-fall of $650 
billion investment capital in the U.S. alone over the next ten years, a gap which 
OPEC investments in this country can in small part help close.38 


The Saudis likewise have been the restraining force in OPEC on 
price increases, and in 1976 when other OPEC nations decided on a 
10 percent increase, they refused (along with the United Arab Emi- 
rates) to raise prices. The condition behind forgoing this increase was, 
as Zaki Yamani expressed it, some “forward movement toward peace,” 
the achievement of which would not preclude the use of American 
pressure on Israel. The Saudis were worried, of course, about the 
rising inflationary costs for the purchase of their imports, which they 
claimed did not match any comparable rise in oil prices. There was an 
admitted reluctance on both sides, the Saudis and the U.S., to exacer- 
bate the differences that already exist. As Carter warned in late May 
1977, failure to act quickly could “mean disaster not only for the 
Middle East, but for the international political and economic order as 
well.” The Saudis wanted peace, no break in their financial and com- 
mercial ties with the U.S., and certainly not another war. However, 
when pressed, they have not hesitated—without specifying the use of 
the oil boycott as a weapon—to talk of using “every effort or every 
capability towards achieving peace,” as phrased by Foreign Minister 
Prince Saud bin Faisal on the CBS show ‘‘Face the Nation” in May 
1977. 

The Saudis and other Gulf states certainly have not forgotten the 
contingency Pentagon plans for an invasion of Arab oil fields. They 
must also realize that in the event of another embargo, their accounts 
would be frozen in this country. Weakened by the death of King Faisal, 
the new Riyadh government has since been striving to unite the Arab 
world as a means of avoiding another ravaging conflict, if for no other 
reason than to protect its own economic well-being. 

If the Sadat initiative should lead not to a general settlement but 
only to another Israel-Egyptian separate agreement, area unrest is 
bound to mount as the PLO and the Palestinians press for their rights. 
In a fifth war Israel is almost certain to emerge victorious. Aside from 
the bloodletting and the risk of the possible use of nonconventional 
weapons, what then? A just, lasting peace would be further away than 
ever, and additional rounds inevitable until justice was done. 

The growing financial power of the Arabs, and the decreasing 
technological gap between them and their enemy, must eventually 
bring them victory. The Arabs can afford to lose another round or two 

799 


—the Israelis cannot afford to lose one. In addition, the support for 
Israel in the international community has been rapidly vanishing. In- 
deed, from the outset this was greatly exaggerated and always minimal. 
The alleged historical connection of the Jewish people did sway the 
U.N. General Assembly in November 1947, only two years after Hit- 
ler’s downfall. But Rabbi Silver’s brilliant rhetoric in his call for ‘‘the 
reconstitution of our national home’’3? would fall totally flat today, 
parucularly after the Koestler disclosure that the “home” for which the 
Zionist has yeained had never indeed been theirs. 

The world never did give its approval to the Palestine partition 
plan in 1947. There were then only fifty-seven member nations in the 
U.N.; thirty-three, or 58 percent, of these voted favorably for the 
resolution while thirteen were opposed, ten abstained, and one was 
absent. There are now 152 members, and a vote on the same resolu- 
tion would scarcely gain ten supporters. As far as world public opinion 
is concerned, today there would be little objection to returning to the 
1948 borders provided there were ironclad international guarantees 
safeguarding the lives of the Israeli people. 

What about the U.S.? Does Israel enjoy the deep-seated support 
among Americans that Zionists claim? The polls show that Americans 
strongly favor Israel over the Arabs, but there is an even more over- 
whelming sentiment against any commitment to Israel involving mih- 
tary forces, and a growing reluctance to provide further military and 
financial support. 

According to an opinion poll conducted for Time magazine by 
Yankelovich, Skelly, and White (March 1975), Americans by two- 
to-one opposed sending arms to either Israel or the Arabs; 41 percent 
favored a cutback while 37 percent backed continued support, and 
only 8 percent favored an increase. An NBC poll January 31, 1975, 
showed 78 percent opposing and only 13 percent approving a U.S. 
guarantee of Israel’s security. The February 1975 issue of U'S News & 
World Report ran opinion research figures showing 57 percent opposi- 
tion to U.S. military aid to Israel with 27 percent in favor. A January 
1976 survey by NBC reported that less than one in five would back a 
move to send troops to Israel. And the Foreign Policy Association 
survey, ‘Great Decisions ’76,” approved the right of Palestinian Arabs 
to an independent state by 66 percent to 19 percent. Even in heavily 
Jewish populated New York City, a Daily News opinion poll in late 
March 1978 registered by 44 to 42 percent disapproval of sending 
more planes to Israel, while 52 percent opted against selling arms or 
aircraft to any Middle East country. 


800 


The Gallup Poll found that Israel was losing considerable ground. 
While the sympathies of 46 percent of a 1500-person sample in the 
previous October before the Sadat initiative had been with Israel, this 
had shrunk to 33 percent in its latest survey of 654 people, according 
to Newsweek, February 27, 1978. Compared to a year ago, 42 percent 
of those questioned stated they were more sympathetic to Egypt and 
20 percent less, while 27 percent admitted to be more sympathetic to 
Israel and 34 percent less. 

Bias has placed the shoe on the wrong foot. As if they had commit- 
ted the original grievance and were the party at fault, it is the PLO from 
whom Israel and the U.S. demand recognition of “the right of Israel 
to exist’”’ as a prior condition for participation in a process aimed to 
produce a mutually acceptable definition of Israel’s permanent fron- 
ters. Itis as if a thief, who has stolen property, refused to return it unul 
his existence as an American citizen was recognized and his great- 
great-grandfather’s residency in the house he had just robbed had 
been confirmed. 

As academician and member of the Palestine National Council Dr, 
Fayez Sayegh expressed it: 


The right of a state to exist cannot be divorced from its location and frontiers. 
France has a right to exist: but does it have a right to exist on Algerian soil? 
Will those who exhort the PLO to “recognize the right of Israel to exist’’ be 
good enough to tell the PLO just where that “right” is supposed to be exer- 
cised? And are they prepared to guarantee that Israel itself will accept that 
territorial stipulation?4° 


Hardly. Zionist expansionist aspirations are limitless. Even during the 
Sadat-Begin negotiations, the cabinet voted to expand the existing 
settlements in Sinai by putting more acreage under cultivation and 
moving in more settlers to Jewish communities near the Rafah salient 
and Sharm el Sheikh. 

Furthermore, the requirement of recognition should be one of 
mutuality. Yet Carter never has demanded that Israel recognize the 
right to existence of an independent Palestinian state, let alone ever 
considered Israel's lack of compliance with that hypothetical demand 
a barrier to U.S. recognition of Israel. Is it not more reasonable to 
consider mutual recognition an end result of a settlement rather than 
an a prion condition for participation in the negotiating process? 

The Western world and the Christian conscience has been asked 
to accept Israel’s existence unreservedly and to force the Palestinians 
to do likewise. ““You cannot turn the clock back” is the stock argument 

 801 


advanced against righting past wrongs. But it is not a question of 
turning the clock back; it is a question of winding the clock up properly 
so that it will work. The Hitler tragedy moved the world in 1948 to turn 
the clock back 2,000 years by establishing in the heart of the Middle 
East a Jewish state where none had existed since 70 a.p. Can it be 
wrong to try to correct a grievous error, thirty years later, if this will 
be beneficial to all peoples concerned? 

In the face of the total dependence of Israel for its viability and 
existence, no U.S. President should hesitate to apply all the necessary 
leverage at his command, both to reach a just settlement and to resist 
efforts to disrupt U.S. relations with Arab countries. It would not be 
unreasonable for Carter to remind Zionists and Israelists in this coun- 
try that rarely has a people so deeply in debt exacted conditions for 
reasonable behavior from its patron and banker, as has the arrogant- 
minded Zionist leadership, supported by a fear-ridden, Masada-com- 
plexed Israeli people. To hear the words of Senators Javits and Jack- 
son, one would imagine the shoe was on the other foot and the U.S. 
was deep in debt to Israel. 

Any close, objective study of the history of the conflict should 
inspire the President to say to the Israelis, as one writer has put it: 


For the U.S. to have aided and abetted the dispossession of the greater part 
of the Palestinian population is an act of barbarism. For American Jews to 
continue to edge the U.S. into the Middle East imbroglio where America has 
everything to lose and nothing to gain is an act of sheer ingratitude to the 
nation which has given them more wealth, freedom and power than any other 
in the long curve of their history. Americans have more constructive and more 
moral things to do than to expend their money, their arms and perhaps their 
lives on a racial dream that is not even their own.*! 


Although the Arab’s congenital incapacity for collaboration constantly 
plagues himself and his friends alike, the many Arab minuses do not 
add up to a Zionist plus in terms of the American national interest. 

If necessary, Carter can carry out the recommendations made to 
President Truman in 1949 by the State Department when the Israelis 
balked at returning territories won by conquest, and refused to do the 
just thing for the new refugees they had created.*? By action that every 
one of his predecessors would have liked to have carried out but lacked 
the intestinal fortitude to accomplish, the man from Georgia could 
make the greatest contribution toward geniune peace in the Middle 
East. 

Any solution of the differences between the Arabs and the Israelis 

802 


must be based not only on the resolutions of the U.N. that created 
Israel, but on the universal demand for a just settlement of a problem 
that had its origins in the Western world. To justify the right of the 
West to gain expiation of the crimes of Hitler at the expense of the 
Arab world remains unconscionable. Justice for Palestine, in the words 
of Professor Toynbee, “requires vindication of people’s rights and the 
righting of wrongs and the least possible suffering of the least possible 
number of people.’’43 

It has been Zionism and its philosophy, not the particular leader- 
ship in power, that has molded Israeli intransigency and inflexibility. 
The fall of Begin (alleged by the Israeli Establishment in March 1978 
to be Carter’s aim) would not solve the basic problem. 

Golda Meir indicated a mentality quite incapable of winning the 
correct Arab response to peace: ‘‘After we have signed peace treaties 
with our neighbors and agreed on the borders, the nature of the State 
of Israel will be Jewish with a large Jewish majority so that we don’t 
have to get up every morning afraid to ask, ‘Who was born last night 
—was it a Jew or an Arab?’ ’44 The entreating Arab phone call for 
which she and other Israeli leaders waited for six years never was 
made. Instead, in October 1973 came the Egyptian and Syrian armies. 

Opposition leader Shimon Peres attacked his successor for inflexi- 
bility on the issue of settlements during the peace talks with Sadat. But 
as Defense Minister in April 1976, he planned “‘to develop a vast area 
of two million dunum (about 800 square miles).”’ He proposed to set 
up “110 settlements in the future in the Ratah-Beersheba-Kadesh 
Barnea triangle.’’45 Before Ezer Weizman wrested an agreement from 
Begin by threatening to resign unless further settlements were sus- 
pended until after the March 1978 talks in Washington, the Israeli 
Defense Minister himself had his own plans for setting up two large 
Jewish urban centers in the West Bank that would plant 100,000 Israe- 
lis in the disputed region within two years.*® Directly after the Israelis 
failed in May to upset the Carter jet plane package deal, Weizman 
proposed that six controversial Israeli settlements on the occupied 
West Bank be expanded into solid urban centers—a move hardly cal- 
culated to clear the atmosphere for a resumption of the stalled peace 
negotiations. While General Sharon emphasized in his plan the neces- 
sity of setting up a wedge of Jewish settlements extending from the 
Golan down to Sharm el-Sheikh, the two generals differed only as to 
detail and timing. UJA funds were to make the settlements possible. 
(The cost of existing settlements in all the occupied territories, made 
possible through UJA tax-deducuible funds, was estimated by Time 





Conclusion: Toward Justice and Then Peace 803 


magazine of June 19, 1978, at $2 billion, the fifty-one West Bank 
communities having alone received half of this amount.) 

To enlarge their settlements, the Israelis moved in 1978 to confis- 
cate further West Bank property owned by Arabs abroad. Bethlehem 
Mayor Elias Freij was informed in April that 80,000 acres around his 
town owned by Arabs living in the U.S., Canada, and Latun America 
would be handed over to the Israeli “custodian of absentee property,” 
which since 1967 has controlled all property owned by persons resid- 
ing in Arab countrics.47 Anthony Lewis of the New York Times reported 
from Ramallah that as many as 11,000 houses were involved, including 
many owned by Arab-Americans. West Bank Palestinians, he noted, 
viewed this latest action as further humiliation designed to make them 
get out and to ease the way for a permanent Israeli hold on the terri- 
tory. A surgeon told the reporter: “By hook or crook they want us to 
leave the country.’"48 

The hour for truth has almost passed us. History will someday 
certainly record that it was far from heretical to have declared that 
there was neither a need for a state for the ‘Jewish people,” and 
certainly little justification for establishing such a state in its present 
locale.*9 Meanwhile, there is little sense in further meaningless talks 
about Israel’s legitimate right to exist unless we define precisely what 
Israel we are talking about. A normal Israel propagating Israeli nation- 
alism in behalf of the people living within its borders could gain coexis- 
tence with a Palestinian state and all other Arab nations in the exact 
same manner in which Arabs and Jews lived together side by side for 
centuries before the advent of Zionism. But an abnormal Israel 
promulgating worldwide Jewish nationalism means only perpetual 
warfare. More than physical boundaries, the limitless nationality base 
of the present Israeli state obstructs all hope of a peaceful tomorrow 
and underlies much of Arab fear. The “‘lebensraum”’ the Zionist state 
requires for its ingatherees poses a perpetual threat of limitless expan- 
sion. 

Contrary to what most people believe, neither the Israeli occupa- 
tion of Arab territory nor even the settlements are the most serious 
obstacle to a solution. These are merely manifestations of an ideology 
that constitutes the greatest hazard to peace. Israel’s abnormality com- 
menced with its self-promulgation on May 15, 1948, as the state not 
of Israeli people living in the territory, but of the ‘Jewish people” 
everywhere. The Law of Return provided a built-in expansionism that 
no boundaries, however they may be drawn at Geneva or elsewhere, 
can ever control. No sanction can be found for this kind of an exclusi- 


804 POLITICS OR POLICY 


vist, racist state upon which the present Israeli leadership insists under 
the pretext of security. The representatives of the thirty-three nations 
who in 1947 recommended Israel’s creation were moved totally by 
humanitarian considerations in giving approval to a small refugee 
state. They never contemplated a nation with an ever-expanding na- 
tionalism depriving the indigenous populace of its rights as well as 
spilling over into the territory of its neighbors. Under the boundaries 
drawn up, the Jewish state was to have had a 42 percent Arab minority, 
and there was no guarantee whatsoever that the original Jewish major- 
ity was to be maintained in the face of the far higher Arab birthrate. 
The international organization thus provided the basis for a binational 
Arab-Israeli state, which was to be joined in economic union with an 
Arab Palestinian state and the holy city of Jerusalem internationalized. 

Is the sovereignty of the Israeli state so sacrosanct that the mere 
suggestion of its dimunition to fit the original U.N. concept is automat- 
ically verboten? Who can deny that the real concern of Americans and 
of the international community is and has always been for the lives of 
the people of Israel rather than for the size or form of the entity in 
which they live. Whether it is called “‘dismantling”’ or ‘‘remantling” of 
the state, what 1s so destructive about Jewish Israelis sharing a whole 
country with the original Palestinian Arab inhabitants? This is the way 
one can reconcile the vast number of Jewish settlements imposed upon 
the Arab-occupied territories. This is how the “original sin” may be 
righted. And this is the only way, rather than through armed might or 
guileful encouragement of Christian forces in furthering the partition 
of Lebanon, to obtain the security about which there has been so much 
loose talk. 

As Israeli Hebrew University professor Avigdor Levontin ex- 
pressed it: 


A secure border—to the extent that such a thing exists in our world—is not 
a “natural” boundary, like a mountain range or a river. That is an anachronis- 
tic conception. Nor is it a border mentioned in signed documents. A border 
is secure when those living on the other side do not have sufficient motivation to infringe on it. No matter how banal this may be, we have to remind ourselves that the roots of security are in the minds of men and that is where the source of insecurity also lies. We have fallen into a vicious circle: since there is no trust in the Arabs’ desire for peace, people emphasize the need for “security” apparently for a substitute, and even say that one really couldn’t rely on the peace agreement with the Arabs even if they agreed to it since it wouldn’t be a “true peace... .” 

I would go on to say about the term “‘secure’’ borders that it has to face ed 

 805 


not only the test of reasonableness, but also the test of the inherent integrity 
of the concept itself. The term ceases to be honest one when you expand 
settlements up to the new border so that in order to make the new line 
“secure” you need still another strip of some tens of kilometers, and in that 
way things are liable to continue in what may perhaps be described as a salami 
method in reverse.5° 


The Zionist movement should not be permitted to exploit indefi- 
nitely the holocaust, its ultimate and final weapon, so as to obstruct the 
final hope of assuring true justice and real security for all peoples of 
the area, of ending the dangerous duality for American and other 
Diaspora Jews, and of removing the number-one threat to world peace. 


====

Last Word 

These words are being written as Israeli bombs from American planes 
are again raining death and destruction on Beirut, its environs and south 
Lebanon. Begin timed the combined air, land and sea invasion to 
coincide with Reagan’s economic summit meeting at Versailles with his 
six industrial partners and his European tour. 

Calling it a reprisal raid against the PLO for the near-fatal shooting 
in London of Israeli Ambassador to the U.K. Shlomo Argov, the media 
(most particularly CBS Newsradio 88) indulged in its customary 
slanting by giving scant attention to either the fact that the assailants 
were Jordanian, Iraqi and Syrian or that the PLO had denied respon- 
sibility from the very outset. Ignored or underplayed by all the media 
was Margaret Thatcher's announcement that a hit list found on the 
assailants included the name of the head of the London PLO office. 

Anticipating (or knowing) the worst, the President immediately 
ordered the evacuation from Beirut of half of American diplomatic 
personnel and dispatched a letter to Begin with Ambassador Habib 
urging moderation. 

After the Security Council twice had called for a cease-fire and 
withdrawal of Israeli forces from Lebanon, which Israel ignored, a third 
resolution demanded that Israel and the Palestinians halt hostilities in 
six hours and said, if they did not, the Council would ‘“‘consider practical 
ways and means” to enforce this proposal approved by the fourteen 
other Council members. 

In his unprecedented speech in Whitehall before a joint session of 
both houses of Parliament, Reagan echoed Israel’s point of view in 
placing the blame for Middle East war on the ‘“‘scourge of terrorism,” 
which, he indicated, had to be ‘‘stamped out .”” He refused to view the 
conflict in its fullest perspective. 

The administration's behavior was further evidence of what one 
Middle East writer has called Washington’s permanent ‘“‘calculated non- 
settlement” policy of not really making an honest effort to resolve the 


806 807 


problem, but simply ‘“‘maneuvering to protect our interests in Middle 
East oil and to assure the well-being of Israel.” 

Only such a non-policy could account for the near-fatal collapse of 
the Palestine autonomy talks, the war in Lebanon, the unrest on the 
West Bank and the nonsensical inconsistencies in the U.S. treatment of 
Iran. Aid was being given to Iranian exiles battling the Ayatollah while 
Israel was permitted in 1981 and 1982 to ship U.S. arms to assist the 
Khomeini regime in its war with Iran. “Tango November,” a chartered 
Argentinian CL 44, carried 360 tons of tank spare parts and ammunition 
to Iran before the plane mysteriously crashed in Soviet Armenia. (Israel 
also sent arms to Argentina during the Falkland Islands war.) 

Washington gave covert approval to Israel’s support of Teheran in 
the long Iraqi-Iranian war and to Tel Aviv’s goal of downing the 
Sadaam Hussein regime until] Washington became alarmed lest an 
impending Iraqi defeat endanger other ‘“‘moderate”’ friendly Arab Gulf 
regimes. 

Public opinion has been swinging toward recognition of Pales- 
tinian rights, some polls indicating that a majority, including a fair 
sampling of Jews, even favor the establishment of a Palestinian state. 
But most sentiment for justice for the indigenous people of Palestine 
still remains very muted with the few illustrious exceptions. 

Visiting the U.N. for sixty-two minutes as a high-light of his 
two-day visit to New York City in October 1979, Pope John Paul II told 
assembled diplomats: 


Any attempt made to settle the conflict would have no value if it did not truly 
represent the first step of a general, overall peace in the area. Peace, being 
necessarily based on equitable recognition of the rights of all, cannot fail to 
include a consideration and just settlement of the Palestinian question. 


The subsequent summer, scarcely noted amidst the heat and the 
national political campaign, was L’Osservatore Romano’s major review 
of the “history and contemporary reality of Jerusalem” whose ‘unique- 
ness requires for all three religions a level of parity without any of them 
feeling subordinate with regard to the others.”’ The voice of the Vatican 
emphasized that all three religions must be “partners in deciding their 
own future.... We cannot reduce the question to mere free access to the 
holy places .... The significance of Jerusalem surpasses the interests of a 
single state.” The viewpoint concluded that what was required was an 
“appropriate juridicial safeguard that does not derive from the will of 
only one of the parties interested.” 

Of course, a George Ball in a Foreign Affairs article or a Zbigniew 

808 

Brzezinski speaking to a small group of Washington reporters might 
urge the U.S. to start dealing with “the reality of the PLO.” But foreign 
policy molders will not stick their chins out lest they be called anti- 
Semitic. John Doe, spellbound by myth-information, still bows to the 
Jewish-Zionist connectors. In the absence of respectable American 
leadership galvinating this sentiment into a broad-based popular 
movement, there is not likely to be any change in U.S. policy, 
particularly in the light of the continuing terrorist PLO image. Who is 
strong enough to remove the gun ever-pointed at the White House by the 
combined hands of supine politicians, the controlled media and the 
Zionist lobby? 

With the April 25 Israeli turn-over to Egypt of the last portion of the 
Sinai, U.S. ground-combat troops for the first time became involved in 
Middle East peace efforts since Lebanon in 1958. Eight-hundred 
paratroops from the 82nd Airborne Division became the heart of the 
2,500 eleven-nation force patrolling the buffer zone between Israel and 
Egypt following the Sinai evacuation and 400 at Eitam Airbase 
headquarters in nothern Sinai as part of the peacekeeping force, MFO. 
These soldiers were ready to be used as part of the U.S. Rapid 
Deployment Force to intervene anywhere in the Gulf area wherever 
needed. 

The U.S. military presence in the Middle East has dangerously 
expanded from the 200 technicians monitoring surveillance stations in 
the Sinai’s Mitla and Gidi passes. Without a miraculous breakthrough, 
the tragedy of nuclear war could envelope this area and the world as the 
arms race continues to dangerously escalate. 

The June 6 Israeli invasion of Lebanon, which fell on the 15th 
anniversary of the 1967 war, brought new dangers and new horrors 
alike—not only the most extensive bombing of Beirut, Tyre and Sidon, 
but the total destruction of small towns, villages and refugee camps. The 
Israeli Army systematically blew up and bulldozed Palestinian homes 
that survived the battle, completely leveling the camp at Ain el-Halweh 
in the same manner as it had fifteen years earlier the Golan Heights 
capital, Quneitra. 

Forty-thousand Palestinians and Lebanese were killed or wounded 
and upwards of 600,000 people were left homeless. The Israelis, 
supported by the Phalangist militia of Beshir Geymayel, laid siege to 
west Beirut, the last Palestinian stronghold, which was subjected to both 
unmerciful and mock air raids to force an unconditional PLO surrender. 

The Israelis were still proclaiming ‘‘Peace for Galilee”’ as their sole 
war goal—the freeing of northern villages from the constant threat of 





LAST WORD 809 


Palestinian guns. ‘‘We do not want an inch of territory” intonated both 
Begin and Sharon who in the quick conquest of Lebanon had once more 
demonstrated his military acumen. 

In the midst of the on-going genocide in Lebanon, Reagan received 
Begin in the Oval Office at the White House. In refusing to rebuke the 
Israeli leader, the President overruled the advice of Vice President 
George Bush, Defense Secretary Weinberger, National Security Advisor 
William Clark and other White House aides, and sided with Secretary of 
State Haig, whose resignation he accepted a few days later. With his 
shameful surrender Reagan was contradicting Begin’s angry response to 
Washington’s suspension of the strategic cooperation agreement: ‘“‘No, 
we are the banana republic. We are your vassal state!” 

At a nationally televised press conference, the President claimed 
‘‘we were not warned or notified of the invasion that was going to take 
place.’’ Despite this denial, there was little doubt that Israel’s uncon- 
scionable use of miliary power, as in the 1967 war, had been carried out 
with the aid and abetment of Washington and the media, under a cover 
of gross deceit that beguiled American public opinion and guaranteed 
support for the continued ruthless suppression of Palestinian rights. 
But it remained to be seen whether, out of the crushing military defeat, 
the political and diplomatic struggle for an independent Palestinian 
state would be advanced. 

At Senate confirmation hearings Secretary of State-designate George 
P. Shultz stated: ‘““The crisis in Lebanon makes painfully clear a central 
reality of the Middle East: the legitimate needs and problems of the 
Palestinian people must be addressed and resolved—urgently and in all 
their dimensions.’’ At the time the Israelis were heightening their 
repression and moving toward annexation of the West Bank and Gaza. 


The sad and tragic realities of the Middle East conflict were further 
exposed at a top-secret summit held by Brezhnev, Reagan and Begin 
with the Lord. The Soviet leader asked God: “Do you think there will 
ever be detente between the Soviet Union and the United States?”’ The 
Lord replied, ‘‘Yes, but not in your lifetime.” 

Then Reagan queried: ‘Do you think it will ever be possible for the 
U.S. to achieve a balanced budget and at the same time maintain a 
defense establishment strong engough to contain the threat of com- 
munism?” The Lord’s response was “Yes, but not in your lifetime.” 

Begin then put this final question to God: ‘Do you think there will 
ever be peace between Arabs and Israelis?”’ To this the Lord answered: 
“Yes, but not in my lifetime.” 


Alfred M. Lilienthal 
New York, July 14, 1982 

===










No comments: