On Democracies and Death Cults: Israel, Hamas and the Future of the West Kindle Edition
by Douglas Murray (Author) Format: Kindle Edition
4.7 4.7 out of 5 stars (2,965)
#1 Best Sellerin Political Commentary & Opinion
See all formats and editions
NO.1 SUNDAY TIMES BESTSELLER
Douglas Murray, international bestselling author and renowned cultural commentator confronts what he views as the most pressing issue of our time: why Western support of the Palestinian cause is ultimately playing into the hands of a much more dangerous force.
Drawing from intensive on-the-ground reporting in Israel, Gaza and Lebanon, Murray presents a compelling case that places the latest violence in its historical context. He takes readers on a harrowing journey through the aftermath of the 7 October 2023 massacre, piecing together exclusive accounts from victims, survivors and even the terrorists responsible for the atrocities.
On Democracies and Death Cults argues that Israel’s commitment to fundamental Western values – capitalism, individual rights, democracy and reason – has made it a beacon of progress in a region dominated by authoritarianism and extremism. Murray contrasts Israel’s principles with the ideology of Hamas, which openly proclaims its love of death over life. If left unchecked, Murray argues, this misplaced Western sympathy could embolden forces that seek to undermine democratic values and perpetuate a culture of violence.
Clear-eyed and deeply reasoned, On Democracies and Death Cults is a gripping and essential read for all who seek to understand the complexities of the Israeli–Palestinian conflict and its implications for the future of democracy – and for the world itself.
Douglas Murray's book 'On Democracies and Death Cults' was a No.1 Sunday Times bestseller w/c 2025-04-07.
Read less
===
Review
Select Guide Rating
About the Author
Douglas Murray is a bestselling author and journalist based in Britain. His books include The Sunday Times No. 1 bestseller The Strange Death of Europe: Immigration, Identity and Islam and The Madness of Crowds: Gender, Race and Identity. He has been Associate Editor at The Spectator magazine since 2012 and has written regularly there, as well as for other publications including The Wall Street Journal, The Times, The Sunday Times, The Sun, The Mail on Sunday and National Review. A regular guest on the BBC and other news channels, he has also spoken at numerous universities, parliaments, the O2 Arena and the White House.
Product details
ASIN : B0DMPXS5GR
Publisher : HarperCollins
Accessibility : Learn more
Publication date : 10 April 2025
Language : English
===
kerry
5.0 out of 5 stars An important, informative and shocking read
Reviewed in Australia on 14 January 2026
Format: KindleVerified Purchase
Reading this book has changed my uninformed and misplaced assumptions. If you want to gain a clearer perspective on the situation read this book.
Helpful
Report
Pigeon
5.0 out of 5 stars If only we knew 30 years ago…
Reviewed in Australia on 28 December 2025
Format: KindleVerified Purchase
Written before the Bondi massacre, read after.
Easy to read. Not so easy to digest. Confronting. Concerning. Compelling. Uncomfortable. Heartbreaking. Sickening.
In Australia no politician even dares to mention radical Islam (is there another sort?). So, here is an interesting and insightful study that holds radical Islam up for examination. Filling the vacuum left because by our society’s ignorance. And it’s not a pretty picture. Is it too late for the West?
Helpful
Report
Darryl Greer
5.0 out of 5 stars POWERFUL AND ACCURATE SENSE OF THE ISRAEL-GAZA CONFLICT
Reviewed in Australia on 24 June 2025
Format: KindleVerified Purchase
Douglas Murray is a 46-year-old-British political commentator, cultural critic, author and journalist. He is currently an associate editor of The Spectator, is a regular contributor to major newspapers in the U.K. and the U.S. and has appeared on numerous broadcast outlets around the world. He is one of the clearest thinkers in the world today. He has written a number of non-fiction books, the latest of which is On Democracies And Death Cults published in April 2025.
When this author and journalist writes about a war, he doesn’t do so from the comfort of a leather chair in his office but he dons a flak jacket and helmet and actually goes there to report from the sharp end of what’s actually going on. He has reported extensively from the front lines in Ukraine and from the thick of battles in Israel, Lebanon and Gaza, even reporting live as rockets rained down on Israel not far from where he was standing.
In On Democracies And Death Cults, he describes in an all too realistic narrative precisely what happened on 07 October 2023 and its aftermath, drawing on interviews with victims, first responders, and even terrorists themselves. It is not a pretty picture and not for the faint-hearted.
He contrasts Israel’s commitment to fundamental Western values with those of Hamas which openly proclaims its love of death over life – provided of course, it is the death of its own civilians, including its women and children, rather than of those leaders orchestrating atrocities from the safety of their life of luxury in Qatar.
His prose is powerful, yet surprisingly lucid and he writes with moral clarity and in great detail. On Democracies And Death Cults is a must-read for those looking to get a better – and accurate – sense of the Israel—Gaza conflict.
3 people found this helpful
Helpful
Report
Inclusivity
5.0 out of 5 stars Definitely worth reading if you want to make sense of social mvts
Reviewed in Australia on 6 December 2025
Verified Purchase
I read this because I wanted to make sense of social movements that have become obvious in the West, and this book does help in this way, very much so. The first half sort of stresses the problems, which I could really have done without - knowing they exist is why I wanted to learn more. The second half of the book, though, is very elucidating, and well constructed (the first half is too forceful). Very much appreciate the work that's gone into this book.
Helpful
Report
Kim Scott Melin Aussie Girl
5.0 out of 5 stars Genius, knowledge, vision Douglas Murray never disappoints.
Reviewed in Australia on 3 October 2025
Verified Purchase
Douglas Murray is an historian of our time. His profound knowledge of his subject, clear thinking and voice of hard facts with logic summations put our politicians to shame. He is a must read to understand the times we live in.
2 people found this helpful
Helpful
Report
Amazon Customer
5.0 out of 5 stars Easy reading - Hard Subject
Reviewed in Australia on 29 April 2025
Format: KindleVerified Purchase
Despite his great intellect, Douglas Murray writes surprisingly clear and simple prose. Most importantly, he writes with great moral clarity about the seemingly endless battle between Islamists and the much maligned champion of Western values, Israel.
5 people found this helpful
Helpful
Report
badman
5.0 out of 5 stars Reality check
Reviewed in Australia on 21 October 2025
Verified Purchase
You have been warned before but have not taken any notice. Read this refreshing update. Life is not as we believe it to be elsewhere in the world.
2 people found this helpful
Helpful
Report
DCOOK
5.0 out of 5 stars A very important book
Reviewed in Australia on 21 August 2025
Verified Purchase
Read this and then make up your mind.
One person found this helpful
Helpful
Report
Debra Holland
5.0 out of 5 stars Excellent book
Reviewed in Australia on 16 June 2025
Format: KindleVerified Purchase
An excellent read - Douglas Murray is one of the great minds of our times
2 people found this helpful
Helpful
Report
Amazon Customer
5.0 out of 5 stars inspiring
Reviewed in Australia on 6 May 2025
Format: KindleVerified Purchase
Murray weaves together, from a deep human perspective and emotion, the choice of choosing life over a death cult , despite the agony involved in the fight.
3 people found this helpful
Helpful
Report
==
From Australia
mjtossell
5.0 out of 5 stars Extraordinary piece of journalism
Reviewed in Australia on 12 May 2025
Format: KindleVerified Purchase
This book by Douglas Murray is an extraordinarily powerful rebuttal of the baseless, foolish points of view being parroted in our spoiled western cultures.
8 people found this helpful
Helpful
Report
Eri Sharp
5.0 out of 5 stars Best book of the year!
Reviewed in Australia on 17 April 2025
Verified Purchase
I am a huge fan of Douglas. He speaks & writes with moral clarity. I thoroughly enjoyed this book. Thank you Douglas for all you do.
Customer image
4 people found this helpful
Helpful
Report
Joel
5.0 out of 5 stars Fantastic
Reviewed in Australia on 30 April 2025
Verified Purchase
Brilliant book, full of inconvenient truths for those blind to who is really driving this conflict and what it is really about.
4 people found this helpful
Helpful
Report
Amazon Customer
5.0 out of 5 stars A must read!
Reviewed in Australia on 16 April 2025
Verified Purchase
A must read!
Murray tells it as it is. No excuses. Very insightful and important.
4 people found this helpful
Helpful
Report
peter williams
1.0 out of 5 stars Misses the most fundamental points!!! Lost in the detail.
Reviewed in Australia on 25 April 2025
Format: KindleVerified Purchase
Douglas Murray gets lost in the detail and his ideology, and misses the most fundamental point(s). It is unacceptable to kill innocent humans. It does not matter what your ideology is. The innocent are innocent, and the rant should stop right there.
Reframing for emphasis, the elite in Hamas AND the elite in Israel (note I use the elite deliberately) are fundamentally wrong.
They both commit Crimes Against Humanity. Where is the International Criminal Court Douglas, who should at least, in theory, make a far more informed determination than yourself? If they do not, if they can't then what is the point of having them?
So yes, an informative book, but misses the most fundamental points!!! Lost in the detail.
14 people found this helpful
Helpful
Report
Chris Alderson
1.0 out of 5 stars Historically unbalanced
Reviewed in Australia on 8 May 2025
Format: KindleVerified Purchase
I had to stop reading. I was looking for insight and all I got was an unbalanced and morally questionable justification for Israel’s current actions. No historical analysis or deeper questioning of why we are where we are today.
7 people found this helpful
Helpful
Report
Lisa Cappe
5.0 out of 5 stars Murray’s Masterful Dissection of Terror and Ideology
Reviewed in Australia on 20 April 2025
Douglas Murray combines clear thinking and outstanding analysis in a gripping account of the October 7 Hamas attacks and their ideological fallout. With sharp insight and firsthand reporting, he exposes the moral confusion of the West in the face of terror.
3 people found this helpful
Helpful
Report
BM
5.0 out of 5 stars Excellent book
Reviewed in Australia on 31 May 2025
Excellent book. So much detail and explanation of these events. Half way through and I'm shocked
One person found this helpful
Helpful
Report
From other countries
Isabelle
5.0 out of 5 stars Outstanding journalist and writer
Reviewed in France on 18 May 2025
Verified Purchase
Dougla Murray has delivered yet another outstanding piece of work. For its journalistic integrity—one would think that’s a given these days, for its courage—because these days stating the facts, common sense, what’s obviously good and evil makes one vulnerable to all kinds of name-calling and violence. I loved this book for what it confirmed, for the discoveries I made—I ordered Vasily Grossman’s and Gregor Von Rezzori’s books, for giving a name and a voice to the victims and survivors who in some parts of the West chose to silence.
Douglas Murray mentioned Oriana Fallaci and that in itself is testament that who came before us, who was at the lieu of the events (she, like Murray, reported from the war zones not from behind a desk and chunky microphone,) should not only be given a platform surrounded by other journalists, photojournalists and experts but also be joined by those who go to the voting booth. This book made me think about countries and leaders and whether their stance (supporting Israel half-way) are worthy to be re-elected.
This is where Murray’s book shines beyond the facts. It's thought-provoking. It made me think of the past and present and of course the future. He manages to do this with each and every one of his books. There is no back cover, in my view, the words stay with me. No last page. If I have only one criticism, it would have been to include a line or two from Fallaci’s Letter to a Child Never Born. Like Douglas Murray’s latest masterpiece, that book too is about LIFE and Fallaci too saw her share of bloodshed. In the midst of evil, Israel, Douglas Murray, the great war correspondents, journalists have celebrated life.
I have also the audible version and I recommend this too as it's beautifully read by the author himself. Not too fast, just right as if I can see the punctuation. Thank you to Douglas Murray, you’re the voice of reason in this mad world, to your courage. Your work will be one that will be referred to in generations to come. Thank you to the publishers for representing him and for publishing his work.
One person found this helpful
Report
Paulo Borges
5.0 out of 5 stars unmissable
Reviewed in Spain on 28 October 2025
Verified Purchase
Not to be missed. Easy to read, well documented and written by those in the know.
Report
==
Craig Wildman
5.0 out of 5 stars As above. A highly prescient and timely read for our times.
Reviewed in Canada on 29 April 2025
Verified Purchase
The depth and often times powerful writing of Murray is as one has come to expect from this superb author, however, the often visceral subject-matter is dealt with in a compassionate, respectful and truly feeling way, thus revealing the humanity of the author and the universality of his actual experiences. A profoundly moving and intellectually rich examination of the very real and present dangers which western civilization faces, dangers which, if left unchecked, will only fester and poison the communities of the western democracies which are not as of yet on the front lines. A real wake-up call to us all...
6 people found this helpful
Report
Cathy A. Elias
5.0 out of 5 stars A MUST read for all university students
Reviewed in the United States on 28 November 2025
Verified Purchase
This book offers an outstanding counterbalance to the biased and sensationalized coverage that has flooded the internet. In a world turned upside down, it provides an honest, sincere, and informed account of the rupture in humanity that occurred on October 7—an event far too many have chosen to ignore. It also presents clear historical context and background, of the complexities of the Middle East, the longstanding challenges surrounding Israel, and the broader struggle over democracy in the region.
10 people found this helpful
Report
Howard MCCLELLAN
5.0 out of 5 stars A superb book Highly recommended.
Reviewed in France on 11 July 2025
Verified Purchase
This book is at once a compulsive and terrifying read. The events since that dreadful 7th October day needed such a book as this and now we have it and by the best man to write it. I simply cannot recommend it highly enough and must thank Douglas Murray for yet another great book.
Report
rcavesta
5.0 out of 5 stars Claridad en las ideas
Reviewed in Spain on 5 June 2025
Verified Purchase
Extraordinario libro con una claridad en las ideas sorprendente. Defiende de manera brillante y con datos clarísimos a un estado liberal y de derecho, pluricultural y plurireligioso, de enorme éxito social y económico para todos sus ciudadanos independientemente de su religión, cultura y afiliación política. Gran lectura para contrarestar las ideas izquierdistas baratas que nos rodean
One person found this helpful
Report
Translate review to English
Gabriel Popovici
5.0 out of 5 stars Best book
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 5 January 2026
Format: HardcoverVerified Purchase
Best book
Report
Annie
5.0 out of 5 stars Eye Opening
Reviewed in Germany on 17 January 2026
Verified Purchase
Douglas Murray has to be one of the most talented political writers around today. His take on Israel’s moderating effect of an outpost surrounded by illiberal Islamic regimes is eye-opening. Whatever your opinion of Israel, you must recognize that the Middle East is overrun with death cults, preaching jihad and importing their ideas to the West via academia and resettlement.
Report
Nosmo King
5.0 out of 5 stars A brutal, brilliant takedown of hypocrisy and hysteria
Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 16 April 2025
Format: HardcoverVerified Purchase
Douglas Murray doesn’t just write—he detonates.
*Democracies and Death Cults* is one of the most important, sickening, and necessary books I’ve ever read. Sickening for the unflinching account of the October 7 massacre—1,200 civilians slaughtered in a frenzy of bloodlust. And even more sickening for what came after: students chanting terrorist slogans, politicians bowing to regimes that hang gay people, and a global Left that suddenly found its voice—because it was *Israel* fighting back.
The hypocrisy exposed here is mind-blowing. Western governments condemning Israel for doing what they themselves do in every military campaign. Activists pretending to care about Palestinians while ignoring every other oppressed people on Earth—because, well, “it’s the Jews, innit?”
This book isn’t polite. It’s angry, it’s sharp, it tells the truth. Murray has walked the battlegrounds, smelt the stench of deathin the desrtroyed kibbutzes, and spoken to people driven to the edge of madness and in some cases beyond by what they endured that day. If you've ever questioned the media narrative, or felt something wasn't adding up—read this book
If you haven't—read it twice.
73 people found this helpful
Report
Ana
5.0 out of 5 stars Excellent read
Reviewed in Spain on 2 January 2026
Verified Purchase
Excellent book. Murray is my hero!
Report
Warlam
5.0 out of 5 stars Erstklassiges Buch
Reviewed in Germany on 23 June 2025
Verified Purchase
Das Buch von Murray ist ebenso gut geschrieben wie recherchiert. Murray trägt nicht nur eine überzeugende Analyse des islamischen Antisemitismus und des politischen Versagens des Westens vor. Er führt auch die Bestialität des Hamas-Pogrom vom 7. Oktober 2023 dem Leser nochmals vor Augen. Journalistische Recherche und Reportage werden hierzu gekonnt mit theoretischen Reflexionen verknüpft. Insgesamt handelt es sich um eine Pflichtlektüre, die, wie zu erwarten war, von den großen deutschen Medien mit Schweigen bedacht wird. Umso wünschenswerte wäre eine zeitnahe Übersetzung von Murrays wichtigem Buch.
18 people found this helpful
Report
Translate review to English
Amazon Customer
5.0 out of 5 stars A great book that you can’t put down
Reviewed in the United States on 31 January 2026
Verified Purchase
This book is absolutely amazing! For anyone who is trying to understand October 7, 2023, without the gory details, this is the book. Douglas presents a detailed multi factorial approach as to why such a heinous massacre could happen in2023. Furthermore, he provides a multigenerational explanation for the reasons for the unbelievable unrest that is occurring all over the world at this time. Without leaning to a particular political party, Douglas able to perhaps answer the reason for such civil unrest all over the world, the reason communism is making a comeback. For the Jewish readers, who have asked: why do so many people hate us because we are Jewish- Douglas offers a possible reason by Vasily Grossman, author of Life and Fate: “ tell me what you accuse the Jews of, I’ll tell you what you believe You are guilty of.”
3 people found this helpful
Report
==
===
On Democracies and Death Cults: Israel and the Future of Civilization
The New York Times bestselling author of The War on the West explains how no less than the future of the Western World is at stake in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.
Douglas Murray, #1 international bestselling author and renowned cultural commentator, confronts arguably the most pressing question of our Why are Western supporters of Palestine unwittingly aligning with an evil empire?
The campus left frames the violent hostilities as white colonialists committing genocide. Yet only a third of Israelis are Ashkenazi Jews of European ancestry. Murray argues that the conflict is not a simple tale of oppressor versus oppressed, but a clash between a thriving multi-racial democracy and a death cult bent on its destruction.
Drawing from intensive on-the-ground reporting in Israel and Gaza, Murray presents a compelling case that places the latest violence in its proper historical context. He takes readers on a harrowing journey through the aftermath of the October 7 massacre, piecing together the exclusive accounts from victims, survivors, and even the terrorists responsible for the atrocities.
On Democracies and Death Cults illustrates how Israel's commitment to fundamental Western values—capitalism, individual rights, democracy, and reason—has made it a beacon of progress in a region dominated by authoritarianism and extremism. Murray contrasts Israel’s principles with the ideology of Hamas, which openly proclaims its love of death over life. If left unchecked, Murray argues, this misplaced Western sympathy could embolden forces that seek to undermine democratic values and perpetuate a culture of violence.
Deeply reasoned, clear-eyed, and grounded in fact, On Democracy and Death Cults is a gripping and essential read for all who seek to understand the complexities of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and its implications for the future of democracy both here and abroad—and for the world itself.
Show more
===========
세진님, 요청하신 더글러스 머리의 <민주주의와 죽음의 숭배: 이스라엘, 하마스, 그리고 서구의 미래>에 대한 요약과 평론입니다. 세진님의 지적 여정에 도움이 되기를 바랍니다.
요약: 서구 문명의 실존적 위기와 도덕적 혼란
1. 10월 7일 사건과 <죽음의 숭배>의 실체
더글러스 머리는 2023년 10월 7일 하마스의 이스라엘 공격을 단순한 군사적 충돌이 아닌, 근본적인 가치관의 충돌로 규정한다. 그는 하마스를 <죽음의 숭배> 집단으로 정의한다. 이들은 삶을 사랑하는 서구적 가치관과 달리, 죽음을 신성시하고 살육을 목적으로 삼는 허무주의적 신학에 기반하고 있다. 머리는 현장에서 목격한 참상을 구체적으로 열거하며, 이것이 서구 민주주의가 직면한 가장 야만적인 도전임을 역설한다.
2. 서구 내부의 도덕적 침식
이 책의 핵심 비판 대상은 하마스뿐만 아니라, 이 사태를 바라보는 서구 내부의 시각이다. 머리는 서구의 대학가와 언론이 가해자와 피해자를 뒤바꾸고, 하마스의 테러를 <저항>으로 미화하는 현상에 경악한다. 그는 이를 <도덕적 부패>로 진단하며, 서구가 자신의 가치(인권, 자유, 법치)를 방어할 의지를 잃었음을 지적한다. 특히 억압자/피억압자라는 이분법적 정체성 정치(Identity Politics)가 테러리즘에 대한 비이성적인 동조를 낳았다고 주장한다.
3. 이스라엘: 민주주의의 전초기지
머리는 이스라엘을 단순히 중동의 한 국가가 아니라, 서구 민주주의 가치를 수호하는 최전선으로 묘사한다. 이스라엘이 무너지면 그다음 타겟은 유럽과 미국이 될 것이라는 경고다. 그는 이스라엘의 대응을 <과잉 진압>이라고 비난하는 목소리에 대해, 국가가 시민을 보호하기 위해 행사해야 할 당연한 권리임을 강조하며 서구 국가들이 이스라엘만큼의 위협에 직면했을 때 과연 더 도덕적으로 행동할 수 있을지 반문한다.
4. 서구의 미래와 문명적 결단
결론적으로 머리는 서구가 선택의 기로에 서 있다고 말한다. 스스로를 증오하며 적대적인 이데올로기에 굴복할 것인지, 아니면 문명의 성취를 당당히 옹호할 것인지 묻는다. 그는 서구가 다시금 자신의 도덕적 명확성(Moral Clarity)을 회복하지 못한다면, 내부에서부터 붕괴할 것이라는 비관적이고도 절박한 전망을 내놓는다.
평론: 명료한 통찰과 위험한 이분법 사이에서
문명 수호자의 날카로운 외침
더글러스 머리의 필치는 거침없고 명확하다. 그는 정치적 올바름(PC)의 장막 뒤에 숨은 위선을 들춰내는 데 탁월한 능력을 보여준다. 특히 테러 집단의 잔혹 행위를 목격하고도 이를 이론적으로 정당화하려는 서구 지식인 사회의 나약함을 꼬집는 대목은 독자에게 강렬한 타격감을 준다. 그는 문명이라는 것이 얼마나 깨지기 쉬운 유리그릇 같은지, 그리고 그것을 지키기 위해 때로는 물리적 힘과 단호한 도덕적 결단이 필요함을 설득력 있게 제시한다.
<민주주의 대 죽음>이라는 프레임의 한계
그러나 이 책은 복잡한 중동의 지정학적 맥락과 역사적 층위를 지나치게 단순화했다는 비판에서 자유롭기 어렵다. 머리는 갈등의 원인을 오직 <가치관의 충돌>로 환원함으로써, 수십 년간 이어진 영토 분쟁, 정착촌 문제, 팔레스타인 민간인이 겪는 구조적 고통을 부차적인 것으로 치부한다. 모든 반대 목소리를 <반유대주의>나 <도덕적 타락>으로 규정하는 그의 논법은 강력한 카타르시스를 주지만, 동시에 합리적인 비판의 공간을 차단하는 폐쇄성을 띤다.
지적 편향성과 선동적 수사
머리의 서사는 철저히 서구 중심적이며 보수주의적 시각에 고착되어 있다. 그는 <우리(서구)>와 <그들(야만)>의 경계를 긋는 데 집중한다. 이러한 이분법은 위기 상황에서 결속력을 높일 수는 있으나, 갈등의 본질적인 해결책보다는 문명 간의 전쟁을 부추기는 결과로 이어질 위험이 있다. 하마스의 잔혹성을 비판하는 것과 이스라엘 정부의 모든 정책을 옹호하는 것은 별개의 문제임에도, 머리는 이 둘을 교묘하게 결합하여 독자의 판단을 유도한다.
결론: 시대의 거울로서의 기록
이 책은 오늘날 서구 사회가 겪고 있는 깊은 분열과 정체성의 혼란을 비추는 가장 선명한 거울이다. 머리의 주장에 동의하든 그렇지 않든, 그가 던지는 질문—<우리는 무엇을 위해 싸우는가?>—은 피할 수 없는 실존적 질문이다. <민주주의와 죽음의 숭배>는 논쟁적인 만큼이나 중요한 기록이다. 서구가 직면한 위기의 본질이 외부의 적 때문인지, 아니면 내부의 확신 결여 때문인지 고민하게 만드는 문제작이다.
더글러스 머리의 다른 저작이나, 이 책과 상반된 시각을 가진 분석이 궁금하시다면 언제든 말씀해 주세요. 상세히 안내해 드리겠습니다.
===
민주주의와 죽음 숭배 집단: 이스라엘, 하마스, 그리고 서구의 미래》
<On Democracies and Death Cults> – <Douglas Murray>
1. 책의 문제의식과 구조
이 책에서 더글러스 머레이는 2023년 10월 7일 <Hamas>의 이스라엘 공격 이후의 상황을 중심으로, 단순한 지역 분쟁이 아니라 “서구 문명 전체의 위기”라는 프레임으로 사건을 해석한다. 그는 이 전쟁을 민주주의 국가와 ‘죽음을 숭배하는 이념 집단’ 사이의 근본적 충돌로 규정한다.
책은 크게 세 축으로 전개된다.
-
10월 7일 공격과 그 잔혹성에 대한 서술
-
<Israel>의 군사적·도덕적 정당성에 대한 옹호
-
서구 사회 내부에서 나타나는 반이스라엘 시위와 도덕적 혼란에 대한 비판
머레이의 핵심 주장은 단순하다.
이스라엘은 생명을 지키려는 민주국가이며, 하마스는 죽음을 미화하는 전체주의 운동이라는 것이다. 그리고 서구가 이 차이를 분명히 인식하지 못하면 스스로를 붕괴시킬 것이라고 경고한다.
2. 하마스에 대한 분석: “죽음 숭배 집단”
머레이는 하마스를 단순한 무장 저항 조직이 아니라 “죽음을 전략적·신학적으로 활용하는 집단”으로 규정한다. 그는 다음과 같은 점을 강조한다.
-
민간인 학살의 의도성
-
인질 납치와 공개적 잔혹행위
-
자국 민간인을 방패로 사용하는 전술
-
순교 이데올로기의 정치적 기능
그는 하마스가 생존보다 상징적 희생을 중시하며, 죽음 자체를 정치적 자산으로 삼는다고 주장한다. 이 점에서 그는 하마스를 나치즘이나 ISIS와 유사한 전체주의적 운동과 비교한다.
3. 이스라엘에 대한 옹호
머레이는 이스라엘을 “서구적 가치의 전초기지”로 묘사한다. 그의 논지는 다음과 같다.
-
중동에서 유일한 자유민주주의
-
언론·사법·선거 제도가 작동하는 국가
-
군사행동에서도 법적 절차와 자제력을 유지하려 노력
그는 이스라엘이 가자지구에서 수행하는 군사작전을 “존재를 위한 전쟁”으로 설명한다.
그의 관점에서 문제의 핵심은 비례성 논쟁이 아니라 생존권이다. 하마스가 존속하는 한 이스라엘은 안전할 수 없으며, 따라서 군사적 제거는 불가피하다고 본다.
4. 서구 사회에 대한 비판
책의 가장 강한 부분은 오히려 서구 비판이다. 머레이는 런던, 파리, 뉴욕 등지에서 벌어진 친팔레스타인 시위를 분석하며 다음을 지적한다.
-
도덕적 상대주의
-
피해자-가해자 구도의 전도
-
탈식민 담론의 자동적 적용
-
서구 내부의 자기혐오
그는 일부 지식인과 학생운동이 이스라엘을 제국주의 국가로 규정하면서, 하마스의 이념적 성격을 의도적으로 축소한다고 주장한다.
그의 메시지는 분명하다.
“민주주의는 스스로를 방어하지 않으면 사라진다.”
5. 사상적 기반
머레이의 논지는 다음 세 가지 전제 위에 서 있다.
-
민주주의는 도덕적으로 우월한 체제다.
-
급진적 이슬람주의는 전체주의적 이념이다.
-
서구는 자기 확신을 회복해야 한다.
그는 다문화주의와 탈식민주의 담론이 도덕적 명료성을 흐렸다고 본다. 따라서 이번 전쟁은 단지 이스라엘의 전쟁이 아니라 “문명적 경계선”이라고 규정한다.
평론
1. 강점
-
명확한 도덕적 구도
머레이는 모호함을 허용하지 않는다. 그의 글은 분명하고 직선적이다. -
이념적 분석의 선명성
하마스의 이데올로기적 성격을 강조함으로써 단순한 민족 분쟁으로 환원하는 시각에 문제를 제기한다. -
서구 내부의 모순에 대한 통찰
자유사회의 자기파괴적 경향에 대한 그의 비판은 일정 부분 설득력이 있다.
2. 한계와 문제점
그러나 이 책에는 분명한 한계가 있다.
① 이분법적 구조
민주주의 대 죽음 숭배 집단이라는 구도는 강력하지만 지나치게 단순하다.
가자지구의 민간인 피해, 봉쇄 정책, 정착촌 문제, 국제법 논쟁 등 복합적 요소가 충분히 분석되지 않는다. 결과적으로 팔레스타인 사회 내부의 다양성도 거의 다뤄지지 않는다.
② 이스라엘 정부 정책에 대한 비판의 부재
머레이는 이스라엘의 구조적 문제, 예컨대 극우 정치의 성장이나 장기 점령 문제를 거의 논의하지 않는다.
그 결과 책은 정책 분석보다는 도덕적 선언에 가깝다.
③ 서구 중심적 시각
그는 서구 문명을 방어의 대상으로 설정한다. 그러나 “서구의 가치”라는 개념 자체가 역사적으로 논쟁적인데, 이에 대한 성찰은 부족하다.
3. 세진님의 문제의식과 연결
세진님은 그동안 이스라엘-팔레스타인 문제에서 도덕적 단선화를 경계하고, “헤게모니적 언어”를 피하는 균형 잡힌 시각을 선호해 오셨다.
이 책은 그런 관점과 긴장 관계에 있다.
머레이는 명확한 편에 선다.
그는 대칭적 언어를 거부한다.
그는 도덕적 우열을 선언한다.
이 점은 책의 힘이자 동시에 약점이다.
4. 종합 평가
이 책은 균형 잡힌 역사 연구서라기보다는 문명 방어론적 에세이다.
-
사상적으로 선명하다.
-
감정적으로 강렬하다.
-
그러나 분석적으로는 선택적이다.
이 책을 읽는 가장 좋은 방식은 “찬반의 문서”로 읽는 것이 아니라,
현재 서구 보수 지성의 한 흐름을 이해하는 자료로 읽는 것이다.
결론
《민주주의와 죽음 숭배 집단》은 전쟁을 통해 드러난 문명적 갈등을 선명하게 제시하는 책이다. 그러나 그것이 제시하는 구도는 갈등을 설명하기에는 충분하지만, 해결을 모색하기에는 부족하다.
머레이는 질문을 던진다.
“민주주의는 스스로를 지킬 것인가?”
그러나 또 다른 질문도 남는다.
“민주주의는 어떻게 자신을 지키면서도 보편적 정의를 유지할 것인가?”
그 질문이 남아 있는 한, 이 책은 논쟁의 출발점이지 종착점은 아니다.
==
No comments:
Post a Comment